Judge clears Microsoft in Xbox patent case against Google
Summary: Microsoft has reason to celebrate being that it just cleared through a patent suit against Google and Motorola Mobility.
In yet another technology patent battle, Microsoft has come out on top against Google and its subsidiary Motorola Mobility in a case related to the Xbox gaming console.
In this particular case, Motorola filed a suit in 2010 with the U.S. International Trade Commission charging that the Redmond, Wash.-based corporation violated its patents related to communication between devices and video decoding.
But ITC Judge David P. Shaw issued a brief but succinct ruling on Friday clearing Microsoft -- at least at this level in the case.
No word if there will be an appeal yet, but a Google spokesperson told Bloomberg that the Mountain View, Calif. company is looking forward to "full Commission’s review."
For now, here is Microsoft's statement regarding today's ruling from David Howard, corporate vice president and deputy general counsel at Microsoft:
We are pleased with the Administrative Law Judge’s finding that Microsoft did not violate Motorola’s patent and are confident that this determination will be affirmed by the Commission. The ITC has already terminated its investigation on the other four patents originally asserted by Motorola against Microsoft.
Here's a copy of Shaw's memo as well:
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
Google is technologically bankrupt.
Owllll1net fanboy
microsoft is one of the companies that should have more patent lawsuits, it copies all
Yeah, right.
WHAT
Dourado fanboy
Google is one of the companies that should have more patent lawsuits, it copies all
You three are being stupid.
This allows them to improve upon what their competition holds.
Whether it's Apple, Samsung, or Microsoft, this must happen in order for them to grow.
Google Caught Bing Stealing Its Search Results
http://gizmodo.com/5748843/google-caught-bing-stealing-its-search-results
http://www.zdnet.com/photos/does-bing-copy-google-search-the-evidence-screenshots/6190648
microsoft copies all
windows copies MacOS
Bing copies Google
Xbox copies Playstation
.Net copies JAVA
MSN Menssanger copies ICQ
WMP copies Winamp
Zune copies Ipod
Windows 8 e WIndows Phone 7 e 8 copia IOS ( sistemas feitos para toque de tela )
bing maps copies google maps
The surface is the latest example of Microsoft's inability to innovate. It's laughable how inept they are at innovation. Google probably comes up with more innovation on any/every given day then MS does in a year. MS only responds to the innovation of others, as they have done for many years. They copy and replicate everyone around them, but by the time they do, it's already old news. Things are different now. They are still the biggest boy on the playground, but their 3rd grade approach isn't cutting it with the high school crowd anymore and everybody can see that the 3rd grader might be a little slow in the head. Microsoft reminds me of the Brady movie where every design by Mike Brady was the same 70's look regardless of place or time. Only the Brady movie was funny, MS is just a pathetic factory of sadness. It's like someone stupid has been who keeps trying to get the crowd going on a joke that was only funny 20 years ago. Sad and pathetic.
.net copies Java
Ms have truly created it's own technologies. Like every inventor, they were influenced by the moment's trend but Ms is clean.
gbouchard99 .. you're right
There ya go, all your ducks in a row now.
.net
Someone did there homework
Owlnet, with all respect...
:)
Google, the saint, bless them :-)
WOW
Google
The H264/MP4 Patent?
Motorola asked for 5% of the total sales for all products using a standard essential patents. What do you expect Microsoft to do?
Duh
Lets be fair here
Sounds like the deal Google wants from Apple as well.
Google does not believe any licensing fee paid to use Android is fair.