NBN may not be completed: Turnbull

NBN may not be completed: Turnbull

Summary: Shadow Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull warned late last week that the National Broadband Network (NBN) may not end up being fully constructed due to "the crippling costs of the project" and the likelihood that the Australian Labor Party might lose government in a future election.


Shadow Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull warned late last week that the National Broadband Network (NBN) may not end up being fully constructed due to "the crippling costs of the project" and the likelihood that the Australian Labor Party might lose government in a future election.

The Liberal MP's comments came after Telstra last week revealed that it had been forced to delay putting a vote to shareholders regarding whether it should go ahead with its $11 billion deal to transfer customers onto the NBN as the new fibre monopoly rolls out its infrastructure around the nation. NBN Co subsequently stated that the deal could affect the timing of the next stage of its fibre roll-out plans.

Turnbull said in a blog post that the delay could be assumed to be the consequence of Telstra's management taking "great care" to ensure that its shareholders were protected in what would be "a very large and very complex transaction".

"No doubt central to the negotiations is the very high probability that the NBN is never completed," Turnbull added. "Most people in the industry I talk to are of the view that even if the Labor Party were to stay in government the crippling costs of the project will cause it to be abandoned, at least in the form it has been announced."

Turnbull himself has previously confirmed that should the Coalition form government in Canberra at a future date, it would stop the construction of the NBN, quickly conduct a cost-benefit analysis into the infrastructure roll-out and identify those elements in the infrastructure that should be maintained and integrated, "perhaps into the new separated network company". The Coalition would also examine and prioritise any areas around the nation that have poor broadband coverage.

Last week, Turnbull added that if partial completion of the NBN was "a real risk", Telstra would insist in the negotiations that the cost of the risk be borne by the Federal Government. "One suspects that this issue is one of the reasons for the delay," he said.

Ultimately, the shadow communications minister saw the delay in terms of a contrast with Julia Gillard's Labor Government.

"Telstra is taking its time to make sure that the deal is properly analysed and documented and in a form which will be of advantage to its shareholders," he said. "The government on the other hand paid scant regard to the interests of its shareholders — taxpayers — and rushed headlong into the deal without any proper analysis, let alone any consideration, of whether the objective of universal fast broadband could be achieved at a lower cost."

Turnbull's comments come at a critical legislative time for the NBN roll-out; the Senate is slated to start debate this morning on legislation associated with the project. Both Bills passed the House of Representatives several weeks ago with only one minor amendment.

A Senate committee looking into the Bills last week said the legislation should be passed with just one amendment: that NBN Co be subject to freedom of information laws. The Coalition subsequently released its own statement calling for additional amendments to prevent NBN Co from creeping into the retail service provider market.

Communications Day reported this morning that Greens Communications Spokesperson, Scott Ludlam, had not yet taken a voting proposition to his party room. The Greens hold the balance of power in the Senate with five senators, and Ludlam is reported to still be concerned about issues such as cherry picking of NBN infrastructure, scope creep and volume discounting for certain telcos.

Topics: Government, Broadband, Government AU, Telcos, Telstra, NBN

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Perhaps Telstra is delaying the process in the hope that there will be a change of government that might lead to them getting their national network monopoly handed back to them.

    Which would probably be bad luck for all the non-cherry-picked areas of Australia. Like most of it.
  • "the crippling costs of the project"

    lol good one Malcolm. So this is the phrase of the month the Liberal party decided to go with at their zoo crew meeting for March? just lol.
    Hubert Cumberdale
  • Another good reason not to vote for the coalition of the stupid.
  • In the eventuality that a half-constructed infrastructure project is canned by a new government, surely any charges of waste should be leveled at the new government and not the one committed to seeing the project through.
  • When are you techophiles going to get it? The $50B plus (God alone knows what the final cost would be) that crazy Conroy and his mad ALP mates propose spending on this pink batts on steriods scheme called the NBN is a complete waste of taxpayer funds. Of course we need a a fibre backbone right around the country but we do not need fibre down nearly every back steet of Australia. This time next week NSW will have a coalition government and then NSW residents will have the oportunity to opt in only if they really want it. Most will not. Read this piece in this ZDNet mail: CSIRO aims for 50Mbps TV, Wi-Fi link - wireless technology is racing ahead and by the time the NBN rolls out it will be totally outdated. Who will cop the bill? Us poor old taxpayers of course!

    Go figure
  • Another one of Turnbull's "Godwin Grech" ploys?
  • Csiro's Ngara wireless is a joke. This is obvious to anyone who works with modern RF systems. NBNCo are only meeting with them because they have whipped up so much media interest that it is politically difficult not to meet with them.