Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

Summary: Azaleos' Tim Harrington examines four commonly cited concerns about VoIP’s ability to deliver "ready for prime time" voice services and whether they are fact or fiction today.

SHARE:

Ever since the first VoIP calls were made in 1973, the industry predicted that packetized voice would replace traditional voice technology in enterprise networks. Are Cisco, Microsoft Lync, and others now capable of replacing PBX platforms? The answer is “yes” and “no”. That’s because most organizations today are looking to move to one Unified Communications (UC) platform that supports all their communications needs – email, instant messaging, audio and video conferencing – not just voice. Let’s examine four commonly cited concerns about VoIP’s ability to deliver "ready for prime time" voice services and whether they are fact or fiction today. We’ll use the Lync Server UC system as a reference.

Myth #1: “Lync does not provide all of the features that my current PBX has.”
Yes, Lync does not “check-off” every feature box available with traditional PBX systems, primarily because Lync is a software-powered PBX. As a result, Lync’s foundation is very flexible and can be modified to fit almost any business need. It provides 90 percent of the features found in a traditional PBX, but also includes advanced telephony features like “true” E911, Call Admission Control, QoS, least cost routing, etc. Lync also offers branch office survivability, rich endpoints, and media bypass for voice components. Where Lync comes up short against PBX platforms is with large call center capabilities (Lync does include small call center functionality with Response Groups), paging, and shared lines. For most enterprises, these capabilities are not required, and if they are, can be addressed through third party partners.

Myth #2: “Lync is proprietary and hard to interoperate with.”
Lync is a part of the UCIF (Unified Communications Interoperability Forum www.ucif.org), whose sole purpose is to advance unified communications standards that enable interoperability across all vendor solutions. This is the same path that was travelled by the circuit switched technology vendors in the early days of that industry. More and more vendors are becoming UCIF members and solutions and standards that all vendors can utilize are surfacing every day. For example, Lync can natively interoperate with Polycom video endpoints without the use of any “middle” transcoding gateway. Also, generic SIP phones are becoming more common in Lync environments by utilizing partner solutions from NET and Audiocodes. Finally, Lync can interoperate with any PBX or PSTN connection with either a direct SIP connection (SIP trunk) or through a media gateway.

Myth #3: “Lync with Enterprise Voice introduces too much complexity.”
To the contrary, Lync reduces infrastructure complexity. By supporting virtualization for all workloads, Lync allows enterprises to implement a full “PBX” solution using as little as one server. A simple one server implementation can include the Front-End server with collocated Mediation server, and a SIP trunk to connect to an ITSP (Internet Telephony Service Provider). Also, since Lync uses Active Directory for authentication and directory services, there’s no need to maintain separate authentication databases and address lists for voice services. However, management complexity, which exists for both traditional PBX platforms and Lync, remains the same.

Myth #4: “Lync’s choices of endpoint devices are limited.”
Not anymore. Lync now supports a virtually unlimited number of devices, since basically any accessory with a microphone and speaker can be used as a phone. Microsoft has also created an official certification program for devices that are optimized to be true plug and play compatible with Lync and require little to no user configuration. This program currently has over 70 devices from 12 different vendors ranging from IP phones, USB, Bluetooth, Conferencing, and video devices. Lync Server and other unified communications platforms have matured to the point where they match the PBX capabilities required by most enterprises, while exceeding what voice-only systems can accomplish. These technologies are not your father’s VoIP. Since Lync and others support virtualization and can interoperate with existing PBXes, these new generation UC solutions can be easily taken for a test drive with full functionality under a trial license.

biography
Tim Harrington is an expert on VoIP and other unified communications technology. He is a Lync Architect for Azaleos Corporation.

Topics: Collaboration, Networking, Telcos, Unified Comms

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

11 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

    IS THIS AN AD???
    davidmpaul
    • Maybe not an Ad, but

      @davidmpaul
      Since he DOES list himself as a Lynk expert in his bio, you could make a case for this being an article were the author sticks to what he knows.
      On the other hand, I would certainly been happier if he had added some information about Cisco or Nortel UC products, or any other brand for that matter.

      So maybe not an actual AD, but an article with poor research at the very least.
      VBJackson
    • RE: Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

      @davidmpaul

      Certainly reads like one, don't it?
      fairportfan
  • RE: Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

    Open Source solutions abound that provide all the knobs and whistles of the traditional PBX plus many more, including very effective call centre applications. Just look at the new FreePBX distro of asterisk, it knocks Cisco and Nortel offerings into a cocked hat and the great thing is its free!
    stone_t
  • RE: Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

    Yeah - I'd say the summary statement that he "examines four commonly cited concerns" is accurate, but incomplete, and thus potentially misleading. Not a good job at all.
    Willnott
  • VoIP is better for small business and home users but not large scale

    Where VoIP can replace PBX or not really depends on the user. Like he states VoIP supports many of the common features of PBX but not all of them... Thus if you are a business that is feature dependent VoIP is not for you.

    However on the infrastructure side VoIP is alot easier to implement than PBX simply because of server costs and maintenance.

    It should be noted that in general VoIP is good for small scale businesses not large ones. Large scale will work, however it will require a great deal more complexity and initial cost to setup.

    Overall I'm for VoIP for use in small business and home use. For big business however I would still recommend PBX.
    mikegonzalez2k
  • baratas ghd planchas

    <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">GHD Espa??a</a></strong> - comprar el m??s barato planchas ghd rosa en el Espa??a.Use Comparar ghd para encontrar el mayor ahorro de ghd mk4 iv rosa, planchas ghd, <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/-c-.html">GHD IV Styler</a></strong> y planchas ghd pelo pink.Cheap <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">ghd planchas</a></strong> para el pelo del Reino Unido encontr?? aqu??. El nuevo set de edici??n limitada de GHD regalo precioso incorpora esta tendencia con un reluciente color negro y plata barroco styler que rezuma opulencia, me gusta alisadores de pelo, as?? que usted estar?? en la tendencia cada vez que su estilo de pelo. Ver m??s sobre <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">plancha de pelo ghd</a></strong> muy baratos por ghdsplanchastyler.es tienda en l??nea en busca de mejores alisadores de pelo de hierro <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">comprar ghd planchas</a></strong>.

    Los alisadores de pelo <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">GHD planchas</a></strong> hermosa se venden en diferentes precios en diferentes lugares, pero la compra es de algunos grandes sitios y recomend?? puede beneficiarte con descuentos ofrecen. Es bastante obvio para elegir la edici??n de GHD envidia Verde de Nueva Ghd 2011, ya que es marca de la declaraci??n de cabello y estilo. Otro patr??n tiene un d??ficit de <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/ghd-diamond-uk-flag-p-1.html">GHD Diamond UK Flag</a></strong>, GHD 2010 Pink Styler, <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/ghd-red-lust-p-9.html">GHD Red Lust</a></strong>, <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/ghd-styler-styling-set-p-27.html">GHD Styler Styling Set</a></strong>, si usted consulte con su pelo Styler, estoy seguro de que no voy a negar conseguir esta pieza a casa verde! Hay muchos otros colores disponibles en la pieza de la misma marca, como el rojo, azul y verde.
    Esta edici??n de los modelos de GHD es bastante limitado en cierta medida, como toda la oferta de paquetes de regalo set se venden en el primer d??a de libertad en s??. A pesar de que est??n dispuestos a comprar este set de regalo precioso entonces usted tiene que darse prisa! Este GHD Gold IV Styler <strong><a href="http://www.ghdsplanchastyler.es/">plancha de pelo ghd</a></strong> plano es barato en el precio y viene con asas personalizadas y secadora, junto con un caso para la colocaci??n de la plancha.
    baratas ghd planchas
  • RE: Can VoIP replace traditional voice services: Myth or fact?

    Virtual working environment using state-of-the-art technology, many companies today are indeed expanding their business operations with collaborated technology tools to virtually improve numbers in terms of workforce efficiency, minimizing traveling expenditures and most importantly lower infrastructure investments.

    http://conferencediary.wordpress.com/2011/10/06/virtual-work-environment/
    blogs4bytes
  • maccosmeticswholesalexo

    Every woman dreams of looking beautiful; and what can be a better to beautify yourself other than buying cosmetics? <a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=???<a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=???<a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein <a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeti cosmeti wholesale???><a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein <a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeti cosmeti wholesale</a> wholesale???><a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=???<a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein <a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeti cosmeti wholesale???><a href=???http://www.<a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeticosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein <a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeti cosmeti wholesale</a> wholesale</a> brand was first established in Toronto, Canada in the year 1985 and since then beauty conscious folks swear by its value and affordability. <a href=???http://www.maccosmeticswholesalexo.com/??? title=??? sales forein mac cosmeti cosmetic wholesale products are not only quite reasonably priced but they also come in superior quality.
    SEMY2
  • supra shoes for man

    If you with the <a href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net">supra tk society</a> shoes put yourself into the location who is worth to believe, you will find that you are the person who has the trust to have the confidence to believe. That means you are a person who is worth to believe.Do not put yourelf into the condition to cheat others and get others trust.
    When I has the wonderful <a href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net/product_list-Supra-Thunder-Shoes-c_37.html">cheap Supra Thunder</a> shoes on my
    workplace.Believe that you are the person who has the different feelings in the emotions. Trust that you are the person who has the responsible for others.
    Do not make yourself become the high-hat person who likes to wear the <a href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net/product_list-Supra-Muska-Skytop-Shoes-
    c_26.html">cheap Supra Muska Skytop</a> shoes.If you have the good emotions fro yourself in the life, you will fel very happy and become that you are the happy person.
    I am so sad that now <a href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net">cheap supra shoes</a> I am falling into the terrible feelings in the family conditions. I
    hope that I can change the conditions in my power, but I always fall into the fail conditions. I have <a href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net/product_list-
    Kids-Supra-Skytop-c_39.html">buy Kids Supra Skytop</a> tried to do my bset to change the conditions, but I <a
    href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net/product_list-Supra-Pilot-Shoes-c_25.html">cheap Supra Cuttler</a> always fall into the <a
    href="http://www.cheapsupraonline.net/product_show-Supra-Vaider-white-yellow-shoes-c_295.html">Supra Vaider white</a> fail.
    fxmstart
  • Finding Business VoIP Service

    We are starting to offer our customers Business VoIP service, so we'd like to tell your website/article visitors about our new VoIP finder service:
    http://broadbandbuyer.com/VoIP-for-Business/small-business-voip.htm

    Thank you,
    BroadBandBuyer.com
    BroadBandBuyer.com