Price not too high for iPad pedagogy

Price not too high for iPad pedagogy

Summary: A school down the road from my old house has created a national debate over the use of iPads in the classroom.


A school down the road from my old house has created a national debate over the use of iPads in the classroom.

Orewa College wants to make it compulsory for its students to use a "one-to-one computer device" such as a laptop, tablet or notebook, and has expressed a preference for iPads.

Since these cost upwards of NZ$799, there has been an almighty row over the cost, even though Orewa is a most pleasant and prosperous seaside suburb of Auckland, where virtually all parents should be able to find the money, especially since the college has given them months of warning and, thus, months to save up.

The arguments over money entirely miss the purpose of having such devices in class — that is, of giving the kids a better and more relevant education.

At first, I had some misgivings over iPads as opposed to a traditional laptop. I doubted that iPads would be robust enough for schoolbags; I wondered whether there would be sufficient software packages available; and if we are preparing kids for work, well, the workplace is still a world of PCs and laptops. And it is still mainly a Microsoft world. It seems to be mostly graphic designers who are the main Mac users.

However, supporters say that iPads have their uses: they're light, quick to start up, have a long battery life, have few moving parts to break and (I like this one) are impossible to hide behind!

Already, iPads are being used in American and Australian classrooms, and advice is available for those wanting to take this route.

There remains much debate about their use, but supporters say that iPads could re-invent the textbook — and could cost less than buying physical books.

Furthermore, since kids are already using smartphones, classrooms are ready for them. More tablet devices are becoming available, and there is the software to make them competitive.

It certainly looks as though the case for iPads is now clear, despite my initial concerns.

I wish Orewa College well in convincing parents who seem more concerned about their back pockets than the education of their children. However, in some cases, parents might be genuinely struggling, in which case schools will have to find a way to help, by staging fundraising events and getting good rental or leasing deals from vendors. Government and charities could also help.

As they say, where there's a will, there's a way.

Topics: Apple, Government, Government AU, iPad

Darren Greenwood

About Darren Greenwood

Darren Greenwood has been in journalism, not all of it IT, since the days of typewriters and long before the web spun its way around the world.

Coming from Yorkshire, he can be blunt, and though having resided in New Zealand, as well as Australia, for quite some time, he insists he is not one of the 'sheeple!'

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • How does the "light, quick to start up, have a long battery life" provide a "better and more relevant education" ? The education department is failing students by falling for the "i" marketing. There are a multitude of educational software that the iPad will not run, they need to look at other tablets that run Silverlight and Flash plugins. Limiting access to educational software is downright irresponsible, at least the school my kids go to standardised on the MacBook (although I am a windows fan) which runs Silverlight and Flash.
  • iPads provide a "standardised" environment. One current model, one current OS with broad compatibility with previous versions, software that must pass examination by Apple and a lot of application support would be driven by Apple if chosen as the tablet platform. Android tablets, as an example, have many models from a plethora of vendors, numerous in-flight OS versions, software that undergoes little or no scrutiny and support would need to be negotiated with multiple hardware and software vendors. The iPad route makes sense.
    I have an iPad and a Tosh Android tablet. I know which I'd choose for a school environment today. Maybe Windows 8 will be a game changer in this area?
  • I guess the schools will need to make it simple, if only for their staff!
    Hence, iPads will be better than say Android devices with a plethora of software.
    Schools will also need to consider the use of such devices in 'the real world.'
    This was why my first thoughts were about Windows and laptops.
    Darren Greenwood