Republic Wireless and Motorola Defy XT are a solid combo for just $19/month (review)

Republic Wireless and Motorola Defy XT are a solid combo for just $19/month (review)

Summary: The fees for service from the top four US wireless carriers keep rising and MVNO options are getting more and more attractive. Republic Wireless offers a solid alternative with a decent Android smartphone for $19 per month.

SHARE:

 |  Image 3 of 11

  • Thumbnail 1
  • Thumbnail 2
  • Thumbnail 3
  • Thumbnail 4
  • Thumbnail 5
  • Thumbnail 6
  • Thumbnail 7
  • Thumbnail 8
  • Thumbnail 9
  • Thumbnail 10
  • Thumbnail 11
  • Opening up the Motorola Defy XT retail package

    The front is mostly taken up by the 3.7 inch display with four hardware capacitive buttons (Menu, Home, Back, and Search) below the display and above a grid area. The 3.5mm headset jack (with rubber plug to keep it free from dust) and the power button are found on the top. A volume button is on the right with the standard microUSB port (again with a rubber cover) on the lower left. There is nothing on the bottom. On the back you will find a unique design that helps with the in-hand comfort. The camera and flash are up near the left top of the back. Centered at the bottom of the back is a lock switch that helps add an additional securing mechanism to keeping the back cover in place if you happen to drop the phone. This lock is one piece of the rugged outfitting with the Gorilla Glass display and port covers helping to keep the device safe from some elements.

    The phone does not work via GSM so you cannot use it outside of the US unless you use it just to connect via WiFi. It doesn't connect to Sprint's new LTE network or older WiMAX network so is limited to CDMA connectivity when not connected via WiFi. Unfortunately, I get fairly poor Sprint coverage so my connectivity wasn't the best with the device. However, as you can read in my experiences below when I was connected I found the call quality and data to be decent.

    Republic Wireless service

    Republic Wireless has deals setup with Sprint to use their network when you are not connected via a WiFi access point. The service is designed to primarily make connections via WiFi and when you do so you will see the green Republic Wireless arc symbol appear in the top notification area. The arc turns gray when connected via Sprint's cellular network and cellular is really the secondary means of connectivity. I found other MVNOs to offer unlimited, but actually have "limits" in place. For example, with Straight Talk I quickly found they have a 2GB data limit and don't keep folks around that regularly exceed this level. Republic Wireless states the following on their website:

    It really is just $19 for truly unlimited talk, text, and data with no contract. But nobody likes a data hog and we rely on the honor system. As long as you play nice, and try to use Wi-Fi as much as you can, we'll keep on doing what we do and can continue to offer you great wireless service on a network built for you.

    Republic Wireless uses something similar to T-Mobile's WiFi Calling service to support calls made over the Internet when connected to a WiFi hotspot. This is different than the previous T-Mobile technology where UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) was used to properly hand off WiFi calls to the cellular network and thus when you leave a WiFi hotspot your call will drop. It is unlikely that Republic Wireless can do much about this network transfer since handsets have to be UMA-compatible and the network has to fully support it. Republic leases their network access from Sprint so they don't have this network control either. Their service does support handing off cellular to WiFi calls so when you come home the connection should transfer.

    There are some limitations with Republic Wireless service at this time, including MMS (not that popular anyway), SMS over WiFi (works just fine over cellular), and 911 over WiFi. I understand that SMS and 911 over WiFi will be coming in an OTA update.

    Experiences and closing thoughts

    While the Motorola Defy XT isn't the highest end Android smartphone, it is a solid device. I liked the feel in my hand and the rugged aspects of the device. Android performed well and I was able to get all of my email, use social networking, browse the Internet, and more on the Defy XT. Phone calls sounded great over WiFi and the Sprint cellular network. Republic Wireless makes connecting to WiFi for calls easy and the green arc symbol in the top bar is a handy way to check WiFi connectivity. As WiFi networks continue to populate malls, airports, restaurants, and cities around us, the ability to use WiFi for mobile phone service is becoming more practical.

    The minimum monthly fee for wireless service with unlimited voice, messaging, and data from most major carriers is $90+ and this still requires at least a two year contract. This makes the $19 monthly fee from Republic Wireless quite a compelling alternative for those looking to save money. We can't say for sure if Republic Wireless will be around in a few months with such a low cost model, but without a contract the only risk to you is the initial cost of the Defy XT. If you consider that three months of service on the major carriers covers the price of the Defy XT it seems there is little risk in giving Republic Wireless a try if you want to save a considerable amount of money on wireless service.

  • Motorola Defy XT package contents

  • The Defy XT feels great in my hand

Topics: Mobility, Android, Google, Reviews, Smartphones

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Related Stories

Talkback

18 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • What is MVNO?

    Please include a definition of MVNO
    ebhb2004@...
  • What is MVNO?

    Mobile Virtual Network Operator. Essentially a company that rents access to the cell towers from their owners in order to provide their users access to it.
    RyuDarragh
  • What's the coverage?

    Can you please provide a link to the coverage map?
    dave@...
    • Basically

      anywhere you have WiFi coverage and Sprint's network, apparently.

      The phone uses WiFi when you have access, and Sprint when you don't.
      fairportfan
    • Network

      It is on Sprint's 3G.
      Don't get this if you live in a rural area because otherwise you'll have no coverage anywhere.
      Ahbud Dactun
      • Actually many "rural" based customers can

        "Rural" based customers have commented that they have no cell coverage, from any company, where they live. Republic allows them to make calls their own WIFI network at home or work, and use Sprint 3G everywhere else. It is a perfect solution for them. You seem to just resent "rural" people.
        Jaguar6cy
  • Battery is removable?

    I recently bought several phones from AT&T (iPhone 4S, HTC One X, Nokia Lumia 900) and none have a removable battery! I should also add that none of these phones' battery lives is all that impressive, which is why I'd like to be able to replace the battery at some point.
    krisoccer
    • Re: Battery is removeable?

      Yes, the battery is removable. (I have used the service since it first started up)
      Michael Fagerstrom
  • Lack of 3G is a glaring oversight

    There is one very glaring shortcoming of this deal - the phone has NO 3G/4G capability.

    So what you end up with is a basic cell phone and android tablet in one. I wonder how many people will jump on this, and then wonder why they have no Internet connection everywhere?
    Alan Maier
    • Phone has 3G

      Phone has 3G
      RanaKabir
    • WHAT?!

      The phone has 3G!
      IT'S A SMARTPHONE! Do your research before you make up a random comment.
      Ahbud Dactun
    • as rural as it gets

      I live in Fair Play SC, in the sticks and I have signal and internet almost everywhere I go. My phone displays 3G 90% of the time.
      Lillian Lusk
  • not true

    It does have 3G capability. As one of the other commenters pointed out, it uses WiFi by default but when not in range of WiFi it will connect to Sprint's 3G network where available. Some of my friends bought this phone and have been using the service for almost a month now and it works great.
    stevechri@...
  • RW

    I have republic wireless and I haven't had a problem.
    The only problem I've had is that Sprint doesn't have the best 3G in my area so it takes a while to download apps. Otherwise, browsing social media and surfing the web have not been a problem.
    There is an extremely annoying thing, though.
    1) There is no pic messaging (but I'm pretty sure pic messaging will be enabled with the OTA update)
    2) whenever someone sends you a message over 160 characters it arrives out of order and broken in segments.

    Anyways, that's all.
    But for $19/month with unlimited everything no one should hesitate.
    Ahbud Dactun
  • I recommend it.

    I have had Republic Wireless for 8 months now, and I would recommend the phone, the service and the price to anyone. Unbeatable.
    Jaguar6cy
    • motorola defy xt

      I have had the service for a month now and it's awesome. later this year I do hope to upgrade to a better 4g phone like a nexus if republic can offer one-I hear 3 phones will be made available in the fall.
      Brian Hyde
  • I like the service

    I've recently started the service. Like it so far.

    If you're ordering Republic Wireless, use the link:

    http://referrals.republicwireless.com/a/clk/57Yqv8

    to get $19 off. Enjoy folks!
    jumbo1234
  • Republic works great for me

    Most of the time, I am in a wi-fi covered area, so this plan is great!. jumbo was so generous to give you a link to "save" $19. Of course, this is a referral program, and he benefits with a $19 credit as well. At least I am being up front about it. BTW, my name is Gary. Here is my link if you feel so inclined! Thanks

    http://referrals.republicwireless.com/a/clk/2Hnf5
    reizoku