Samsung may dump Windows-like Magazine UI, downplay custom apps

Samsung may dump Windows-like Magazine UI, downplay custom apps

Summary: Samsung and Google work towards an agreement on what Android should look like.

The Magazine UI on the NotePro. Image: Sarah Tew/CNET

Google may have twisted Samsung's arm into ditching its new Windows 8-like Android UI, called Magazine, due to fears it too much of a departure from the vanilla version of the OS.

Magazine is Samsung's new widget-centric successor to the TouchWiz UI that it showed off at this year's CES conference, when it debuted on the company's 12.1-inch Galaxy NotePro tablet.

Early reviews of the NotePro by CNET highlighted that Magazine UI was such a departure from the pure Android seen in Nexus devices that it was difficult to tell the NotePro was running Android 4.4. Instead, the UI seemed to lean on graphical elements, such as live tiles, which are more familiar to Windows 8.1 and Flipboard.

According to Re/code's unnamed sources, Google execs were so dismayed by the new interface that they've been locked in negotiations with Samsung ever since CES in a bid to rein in the Korean company's skinned version of Android, in favour of something more consistent with its own vision for the OS.

It's not clear exactly what parts of Magazine UX Google objected to, but it's not hard to imagine Android as a whole suffering if its most dominant player is pushing an interface that is unrecognisable as Android.

It looks as if Google's objections have hit their target: Re/code's sources said Samsung may abandon the Magazine UI altogether or make adjustments to it. Sources told the site there had been "a huge change, a sea change in the last few weeks" between the companies.

The report follows a cross-licensing patent deal the pair announced on Sunday and comes as Google prepares to sell the hardware side of Motorola Mobility to Lenovo for $2.91bn. Google will retain Motorola's patents and its Advanced Technologies and Projects Group.   

According to the report, Samsung will also bury its line of home-made apps that divert users away from Google's content to Samsung's own, such as ChatOn and WatchOn. Newer Samsung devices for example will instead highlight Google Play apps leading to movies and music.

ZDNet has asked Samsung and Google for comment and will update the story if it receives any.

More on Android

Topics: Mobility, Android, Samsung

Liam Tung

About Liam Tung

Liam Tung is an Australian business technology journalist living a few too many Swedish miles north of Stockholm for his liking. He gained a bachelors degree in economics and arts (cultural studies) at Sydney's Macquarie University, but hacked (without Norse or malicious code for that matter) his way into a career as an enterprise tech, security and telecommunications journalist with ZDNet Australia. These days Liam is a full time freelance technology journalist who writes for several publications.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • None of that is useful to users

    unless Samsung improves the speed with which it released Android upgrades. KitKat was released so many months ago and yet there is still not upgrade for most Samsung devices.
  • Google Feels Threatened Again?

    With Samsung making Windows Phone devices, Google is just trying to make any application ports to Windows Phone harder for Samsung. The more barriers to entry into the market that Google can make for Microsoft the better in Google's eyes.
    • Agreed.

      They seem to feel threatened every time they turn around, anymore.

      I imagine that Page comes into the office every morning, then cowers in the corner wondering who's out to get him today.

  • Only thing like Metro...

    ...was that the elements were square or rectangular. The Metro start screen is customizable with resizable tiles that can be grouped and groups can be named.

    What Samsung put on these tablets was more akin to that FaceBook Android launcher a while back.
    Rann Xeroxx
    • Very true

      Felt the same way..
  • Actually that is a good thing for Samsung

    Because their ham fisted implementation of those apps and so called "services" had me looking for a different manufacturer and considering Windows Phone (well for 2 minutes anyhow) as a way to get out of the Samsung non-removable and very intrusive application harrassment.