Upp fuel cell review: Off-grid gadget power, at a price

Upp fuel cell review: Off-grid gadget power, at a price

Summary: Fuel cells are now a feasible option for powering smartphones and tablets when there's no access to mains power. We look at a UK-developed product that can keep you charged wherever you may roam.

SHARE:
upp-fuel-cell-thumb
Upp: no mains, no sunshine required. Image: Intelligent Energy

The post-PC world is all about mobile technology, which means that people are increasingly concerned about keeping their various portable devices charged throughout the day. Most of the time, you'll be able to recharge your smartphone or tablet from a convenient source of mains power, but when you're properly off-grid, an alternative solution must be found. Many people carry a mains-rechargeable battery, and solar-powered chargers are also available. However, in areas where it's not feasible to use such devices, the Upp fuel cell is an interesting option. Developed by UK-based power technology specialist Intelligent Energy, the Upp was launched initially in Africa in November 2013, and is planned to be available worldwide in due course. In the UK, sales via the beupp.com store are expected to begin in June, where a fuel cell/fuel cartridge kit will cost £149 (inc. VAT).

How it works

The Upp is a PEM (Proton Exchange Membrane) fuel cell comprising two parts: the cartridge containing the hydrogen fuel, stored in high-density metal hydride form; and the fuel cell block containing stacked bipolar plates (combined anodes and cathodes) and fans to draw in air and expel the water vapour created by the electrochemical reaction between hydrogen and oxygen. The fuel cell block measures 119.5mm by 40mm by 48mm and weighs 235g, while the Upp cartridge is 29mm shorter at 90.5mm and 150g heavier at 385g. The two units snap together magnetically with a satisfying 'thunk' to form a device weighing 620g — something you'll definitely notice in your travel bag.

upp-fuel-cell-parts
The Upp fuel cartridge (above left), fuel cell (above right) and dust cap (above). Image: Charles McLellan/ZDNet

There's also a magnetic dust cap adapter for protecting the hydrogen inlet on the fuel cell when the two parts are disconnected (as they should be when the device is not in use). Some sort of tether for this dust cap might be an idea, as it could easily get misplaced or lost. The dust cap adapter also houses a Micro-USB port for charging the fuel cell's internal battery, should it become flat (after a prolonged period of storage, for example); this port is protected by a rubber plug, which is also untethered.

What can you charge with an Upp fuel cell? The brief answer is, anything you can charge via USB — there's a full-size USB Type A socket on the end of the fuel cell. In practice, that means feature phones, smartphones and iOS or Android tablets. According to the spec sheet, the 25Wh Upp fuel cell can fully charge a typical smartphone five times from a single cartridge. Tablets, which have bigger batteries, will generally only get one full charge from the device (the iPad Air, for example, has a 32.4Wh battery).

Upp in use

When you're ready to use the Upp device, you attach the two parts and press-and-hold the power button on the fuel cell portion for one second, whereupon, if all is well, a green LED should glow continuously. If it pulses green, the cartridge has less than 10 percent of its fuel remaining; a continuous amber glow means the Upp's firmware needs updating, while pulsing amber means the cartridge is out of fuel; anything red means you have a problem (continuous red for a cartridge authentication failure, pulsing red for an unrecognised firmware image).

According to Intelligent Energy, Upp charges as fast as the mains, and we found this to be a reasonable claim in our testing. Built-in battery protection software shuts down the Upp automatically once your battery is fully charged.

upp-fuel-cell-app-0
The Upp mobile app (running here on an Android smartphone) tells you how much charge remains on your mobile device and, when connected, the fuel level in your Upp cartridge. Images: Charles McLellan/ZDNet

A key feature of the Upp is its companion app, which is available for iOS and Android devices. The Upp app will report the estimated usage time remaining on your mobile device (see above) and, when connected to the Upp, the fuel level remaining in the cartridge plus the voltage and current being delivered by the fuel cell. Other configurable features include a Fast Charge mode that disables communication with the mobile device and an EcoMode setting that terminates charging when your battery reaches a user-configurable level (the default is 85 percent).

upp-fuel-cell-app-1
Fuel cell settings and charging statistics are available on the Upp mobile app. Images: Charles McLellan/ZDNet

When it's time to replace the cartridge, the app will even use your mobile device's GPS (if present and activated) to show you the nearest replacement cartridge distributor. At the time of writing, the pushpins on the Find Fuel map were merely placeholders saying "Upp Partners coming soon", but we're assured that these will soon carry real information. Swapping a spent cartridge for a fresh one will cost £10, while a spare cartridge will cost you £45.

upp-fuel-cell-app-2
An Upp cartridge will charge a typical smartphone around five times. The Upp app uses your phone's GPS to locate replacement cartridge distributors. Images: Charles McLellan/ZDNet

Conclusion

If you want to be sure of a power top-up anywhere, anytime, the Upp fuel cell works well — although it's on the pricey side at £149 and £10 to recharge a spent cartridge. Having said that, it compares well to competition like the 4-5Wh myFC PowerTrekk, which costs from €199 (around £160). As well as the price, be aware that the Upp adds a significant 620g weight to your travel kit. It also remains to be seen how extensive and efficient the cartridge distributor network turns out to be.

Specifications

Voltage  5V
Maximum output current  1A
Rated power  5W
Electrical interface  USB
Fuel cell type  Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM)
Cartridge capacity  25Wh
Fuel type  Hydrogen
Storage medium  Metal hydride
Dimensions  119.5 x 40 x 48mm (fuel cell), 90.5x 40 x 48mm (cartridge)
Weight  235g (fuel cell), 385g (cartridge)

Topics: Mobility, Emerging Tech, Reviews, Innovation

About

Charles has been in tech publishing since the late 1980s, starting with Reed's Practical Computing, then moving to Ziff-Davis to help launch the UK version of PC Magazine in 1992. ZDNet came looking for a Reviews Editor in 2000, and he's been here ever since.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

7 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Or for 730 grams you can

    get a 100 Wh li-ion battery pack and recharge your iphone 20 times or your iPad 3 times.
    baggins_z
  • I stopped reading

    When the phrase "post-pc" was used.
    happyharry_z
  • Daft fuel to use for people who are no where near an exchange .

    With five charges per cartridge, which areas of the world would you be able to travel to, use the phone as gps/navigation etc and reach a refill location that would not also be able to recharge a large rechargeable battery - many of which could also be charged by solar means. For an emergency device, would be even better if it could use fuels that an explorer may carry.
    richardhx
  • Soon to be replaced by Graphene based batteries

    For a fraction of the cost.
    TheSaint777
  • Or a hand-crank charger that doesn't need fuel, or a wall socket.

    There are hand-crank chargers that don't need fuel, or a wall socket, and are much
    more likely to be useful for seriously off-road environments. These devices have a light, a weather radio, and a USB charge port. All you need to charge up its internal battery is some
    human to spin the crank a while. Then you have light, emergency weather radio, and
    can charge all of those nifty USB toys. Most of these hand-cranks cost less than
    the replacement cartridge of this fuel cell eco-tech novelty.
    Iozone
  • Certified for Use on Aircraft?

    Are these approved for use or transport on commercial aircraft?
    randycpu
    • Use on aircraft

      According to this 29 April press release, "Carriage on aircraft is subject to local safety and security procedures":
      http://www.beupp.com/media-centre/latest-news/upp-portable-fuel-cell-the-clean-energy-alternative-for-powering-usb-devices-receives-industry-certification/
      Charles McLellan