Kindle's identity crisis

February 10, 2009, 4:57pm PST | Length: 00:02:39
ZDNet senior editor Sam Diaz briefs correspondent Sumi Das on the newest version of Amazon's electronic reader: what's changed, what hasn't, and just what exactly the online giant is trying to achieve with Kindle 2.

Transcript

Kindle's identity crisis

Sound effect

^M00:00:04

Sumi Das: Hello, I'm Sumi Das for ZDNet, here with our senior editor, Sam Diaz. Sam, thank you for being with us.

Sam Diaz: Sure. Thank you for having me.

Sumi Das: So Amazon has introduced the lasted version of their electronic reader, the Kindle. This is version 2.0. Tell us how it improves upon the original. At least, it should improve upon the original, right?

Sam Diaz: Well, let's just talk the specs right out of the gate here, the technical specs. So a better screen, more internal memory, although they did take out the ability to add flash memory, like and SD card. So they did take that out. They've redesigned the buttons, the navigationers, so it's supposed to be a little bit easier to navigate through and use those buttons so you're not accidentally pushing stuff. And --

Sumi Das: I had a problem with that because you'd hit the page turn button accidentally because that's where you naturally want to hold it.

Sam Diaz: Right. On thing that didn't change was the price.

Sumi Das: Mm-hmm. So it's still about 300 bucks?

Sam Diaz: $359.00 to be exact.

Sumi Das: That's a lot of money.

Sam Diaz: It is a lot of money, and given what's happened with consumer spending, with the economy overall, it really feels overpriced.

Sumi Das: Why didn't they drop the price?

Sam Diaz: Well, you know, that's an interesting question. Some of the critics out there who really had expected the price to come down are really criticizing Amazon for really holding onto the device itself. Now, you look at the Apple model, where they build both the software and the hardware. The critics out there are saying maybe Amazon should have outsourced this to, you know, manufacturers who are already making mobile devices. They could have done some really cool stuff with it, you know? Color screen, touchscreen, different sort of buttons and navigation, all sort of different features they could have done for something like this, but instead Amazon's holding onto that.

Sumi Das: So what's Amazon's goal with this device? Are they trying to create a good electronic reader or a good mobile device?

Sam Diaz: Well, that is a big question, actually, because people are debating this.

Sumi Das: Mobile computer.

Sam Diaz: Yeah. People are debating this, you know. For $359.00, is this a book or is it a computer? Personally, I think it should be a computer. I think it should have a Wi-Fi chip in it. I think I should be able to do a bunch of different things with it. I mean, really, when you compare it to other devices out there, especially --

Sumi Das: That may cost less.

Sam Diaz: That may cost less than $359.00. You know, you look at the iPod Touch, the iPhone, all the apps that go with it.

Sumi Das: And have greater capabilities.

Sam Diaz: That's right. I mean, you know, just the sort of touchscreen, and to be able to slide your finger across the screen, those sort of things are really attractive. I don't know that -- I mean the Kindle -- the Kindle seems like a great product, but really, I think it just needs to do more.

Sumi Das: Okay. All right. So maybe they'll fix all of these issues in version three.

Sam Diaz: I think version three may just be an iPhone app.

Sumi Das: All right. We'll have to wait and see.

Sam Diaz: All right.

Sumi Das: Sam, thank you so much.

Sam Diaz: Sure. Thank you.

Sumi Das: For more on the latest version of the Amazon Kindle, and anything else happening in the tech world, head to blogs.zdnet.com.

^M00:02:35

Sound effect

IDC predicts top tech for 2010 IT recovery

IDC predicts top tech for 2010 IT recovery

Senior editor Sam Diaz talks to IDC Chief Analyst Frank Gens about the technologies he believes...

Tech predictions for 2010

Tech predictions for 2010

Is 2010 the year we’ll see the long awaited Apple "iTablet?" What will be the big trends that...

The year in review: Top 5 stories of 2009

The year in review: Top 5 stories of 2009

What were the top five stories that shaped 2009? From the launch of Microsoft's Windows 7 OS, to...

The month ahead: Will Droid do damage to the iPhone's mojo?

The month ahead: Will Droid do damage to the iPhone's mojo?

ZDNet correspondent Sumi Das and senior editor Sam Diaz discuss the new Droid phone set to...

The month ahead: Can Windows 7 close the Vista flop chapter?

The month ahead: Can Windows 7 close the Vista flop chapter?

ZDNet correspondent Sumi Das and senior editor Sam Diaz share the early word on the highly...

The month ahead: Partnerships and products expected

The month ahead: Partnerships and products expected

The kids are back at school, conventions are back on the calendar, and tech companies are laying...

Is the Apple rumor mill getting out of control?

Is the Apple rumor mill getting out of control?

ZDNet Senior Editor Sam Diaz shares his thoughts on the constant rumors surrounding Apple’s...

Apple's app flap: Don't blame AT&T

Apple's app flap: Don't blame AT&T

ZDNet Senior Editor Sam Diaz shares his views on the recent iPhone related controversy--Apple’s...

Talkback Most Recent of 6 Talkback(s)

  • I Disagree: It's About the Screen
    I think overall you were very harsh on the Kindle, but the key feature or Niche the kindle is supposed to fill is for health. More specifically the health of your eyes. We stare at LCD screens all day this is a great alternative. I prefer not to look at LCDs all the time. If they had to sacrifice the screen for color or anything else it would be pointless. It also takes less energy. I also agree the price is too high. It should come in black.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    worldnick
    11th Feb 2009
  • It's like ZDNet employees can't grasp that concept
    The concept of an easy to read screen simply goes over their heads... :\
    ZDNet Gravatar
    T1Oracle
    21st Feb 2009
  • No, it goes deeper than that
    These buzzards are simply cheap buggers, period. Paying $360 for a Kindle is just incomprehensible to ZDNet and CNET "editors", therefore they complain about any and all aspects of the device. They don't understand that Amazon doesn't see themselves having to copy the PS3/360 business model, where the 'software' is supposed to be the moneymaker, not the hardware.

    Hell ZDNet, if you can't afford the thing then don't buy it. Simple as that. The "tech" press' continual whining is pathetic to an extreme.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    flatliner
    15th Mar 2009
  • RE: Kindle's identity crisis
    It's a book and document reader. It's not a computer and should not be a computer. My golf
    GPS gives me yardage to the green -- I don't want it to search the internet while I'm putting. Every device does not have to be an everthing device.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    jeroethel@...
    12th Feb 2009
  • ZDNet Gravatar
    LifeSizeActionFigure
    22nd Mar 2009
  • This is an incredibly bad bit of reporting
    Oh boy. Maybe Sam should have actually done a bit of research. The whole point of the Kindle is its liquid ink screen technology, which limits its use as a general purpose device. This is an incredibly bad bit of reporting. Maybe ZDNET needs to find a new senior editor.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    IT-NUT
    26th Mar 2009

Talkback - Tell Us What You Think

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources

Facebook Activity