Five years ago: Tests show limits of virus scanners

Antivirus specialist journal Virus Bulletin claims that only one antivirus package it tested in a recent examination discovered 100 per cent of viruses currently in the wild
Written by Martin Veitch, Contributor

First published 15 January, 1997

In a recent examination, the only package that spotted every single virus was the Norwegian software Norman Virus Control. Virus Bulletin conducts the tests every six months and last time out two packages - Esass Thunderbyte and Frisk Software's F-Prot - scored 100 per cent. The tests are independent and requires no fee from the software vendor.

"We were really surprised," said Megan Skinner, assistant editor of the Abingdon, Oxon.-based journal. "But there are so many new viruses and the increase in macro viruses has been amazing."

However, Skinner said the results were not cause for alarm. "What's encouraging is that every single one we tested scored over 90 per cent and antivirus vendors seem to be working harder than ever to get the new viruses."

Two big guns had close to perfect scores: Symantec Norton AntiVirus scored 99.8 per cent while Dr Solomon's recorded 98.7 per cent.

However, Dr. Solomon's senior technology consultant David Emm said that the regular monthly updates issued by most antivirus vendors made it impossible to test perfectly. "It's down to version numbers," Em said. "Our test was on a product that was just about to be updated. Any virus worth its salt should detect viruses in the wild."

Editorial standards