Wireless execs: We hate spectrum sales!

Motorola and Nokia chiefs blast expensive wireless spectrum sales

The heads of two of the world's top wireless-technology providers made pleas Wednesday to government regulators in Europe and the United States to change the way the wireless spectrum is being sold.

Regulators have been auctioning only a small number of the available radio frequencies needed for the high-speed, mobile Internet-access services that network operators want to offer and on which companies such as Nokia, Ericsson and Motorola are predicating new handset technology.

Motorola's chief executive, Chris Galvin, told an audience Wednesday at the Cellular Telecommunications and Internet Association (CTIA) annual wireless convention that telecommunications companies have already spent what they thought it would take to launch a third-generation phone system on the spectrum rights alone.

"We have to find a new set of rules," Galvin said. "Often in history, regulation has helped determine the success of industry."

Nokia chief executive Jorma Olilla was more blunt. "There has to be a rethinking," he said.

For example, in Europe, telecommunications companies have spent an estimated $100bn to buy the spectrum. In the United States, an untapped market being coveted by most of the world's carriers, government regulators have continued to delay the auctions, hoping to drive up prices. One recent auction garnered $18bn in fees from carriers such as Verizon Wireless.

The result has been a chaotic financial situation for the carriers hoping to offer third-generation, or 3G, phone services. The more money spent on auctions by telecommunications companies means the less they will have to launch a 3G network, a predicament that often requires them to solicit loans. At the same time, banks are more reluctant to issue those types of loans in the current economic climate.

Further complicating the issue is that the US military also uses some of the same spectrum for its operations. Even US president George W Bush has weighed in on the issue. In his recent budget sent to the US Congress, he opened a window for the Federal Communications Commission to delay the US spectrum auction again and garner more funds.

Ericsson's president, Kurt Hellstrom, was also to have spoken on the issue at the CTIA show -- instead he appeared via a tape replay of comments. Nokia's Olilla appeared live via satellite.

Hellstrom said that as a result of the changing telecommunications climate, equipment providers and the network operators they serve have to adjust the manner in which they do business. "We have to share the risks and benefits together," he said.

While long on complaints, the wireless executives offered just a few alternatives for the predicament facing their industry. Galvin said companies buying the spectrum should be allowed to enter into a payment plan. Perhaps regulators should make the spectrums available for free, he said. He drew an analogy to the railroad build outs of the mid-1800s, during which land was given to the railway companies for free.

"Imagine what would have happened to the building of the United States if railways would have had to pay for the land," he said. "The United States would have stopped at Chicago."

Olilla and Galvin are not alone in their views. A day earlier, Michael Powell, the head of the FCC, called for a national policy for managing airwaves used by government agencies.

The problem will only get worse, if the predictions Olilla and Galvin made Wednesday about the growth of the wireless Web come true.

Galvin said he expects that half of all voice mails will be accessed using a wireless device, a huge jump from present levels of 10 to 12 percent. Nearly 70 percent of all cars will be wired as well, he said. "We need huge amounts of new spectrum."

Spectrum woes make up just some of the latest bad news for handset makers, who started the year with predictions of glory only to experience dropping sales, missed financial projections and layoffs.

Motorola has missed earnings estimates and laid off thousands of workers to try and right its struggling ship. Ericsson announced a quarterly loss last week.

Only Nokia, the market share leader, seems to have fared any better. The company hit its financial numbers for the last quarter, but lowered its own mobile phone sales projections.

Take me to the ZDNet Road to 3G News Special.

Have your say instantly, and see what others have said. Click on the TalkBack button and go to the ZDNet News forum.

Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom. And read what others have said.