Microsoft Surface Studio review: An appealing all-in-one for creatives, but the price is high

Microsoft has been making much of the running in laptop design in recent years, thanks to the success of its Surface tablet-laptop hybrids, yet this solitary desktop member of the Surface range has had a curiously low profile since its launch just over a year ago. And, in some ways, the Surface Studio all-in-one still seems more like a proof-of-concept design, rather than a genuine attempt to bring the Surface range to a desktop environment.

Microsoft has always been top dog in the business market, but the Surface Studio is clearly an attempt to prove that Windows devices can appeal to creative users as well -- the very people who have traditionally been Apple's most loyal users. With that in mind, the Surface Studio makes a striking first impression with its 28-inch display, which provides an attractively bright and colourful image with '4.5K' resolution of 4,500 by 3,000 pixels (192dpi). The display also supports sRGB and DCI-P3 colour space standards, making it suitable for a wide range of graphics and design applications, as well as professional-level video editing.

Microsoft claims to have chosen the size and resolution for the display to match the 3:2 aspect ratio of a traditional graphics drawing board. The display is also touch-sensitive, and Microsoft bundles its Surface Pen stylus, for sketching and note-taking. And, to take the drawing-board metaphor even further, the display is mounted on a 'zero-gravity' hinge that can quickly be adjusted with just light finger-tip pressure, to lower the screen right down to desktop level.

The stylus is included in the price, but Microsoft also introduced a new type of input device for the Surface Studio, called the Surface Dial, which must be bought as an optional extra for £89.99 (inc. VAT; £74.99 ex. VAT, or $99.99). The Dial can sit on the desktop, alongside a conventional mouse, and can be used to quickly cycle through menus and other options in graphics and design software ( it's compatible with the Surface laptop range as well). However, it can also be placed directly on the screen and used together with the Pen stylus, providing additional controls such as the ability to act as a colour picker, or rotating 3D objects on screen. Adobe has added support for the Surface Dial to recent versions of Photoshop, and claims that it allows designers to work 'without looking away from the canvas' -- which would seem to be an endorsement of the Surface Studio's design approach.

In other respects, though, the Surface Studio is a more conventional desktop all-in-one system -- and a rather expensive one, at that. Microsoft's website only refers rather vaguely to '6th generation Core i5 or i7' processors, but a number of reports indicate that the entry-level model is based on a Core i5-6440HQ processor, along with 8GB of RAM, a 1TB hybrid drive and an Nvidia GeForce GTX 965M GPU with 2GB of video memory, priced at £2,999 (inc. VAT; £2,500 ex. VAT, or $2999).

We tested the top-of-the-range model, which costs £4,249 (inc. VAT; £3,540.17 ex. VAT, or $4,199) and steps up to a Core i7-6820HQ running at 2.7GHz (3.6GHz with TurboBoost) along with 32GB of RAM, a 2TB hybrid drive and an Nvidia GeForce GTX 980M GPU with 4GB of video memory.

Top ZDNET Reviews

Dell Latitude 11 5179

7.9

Apple iPhone 7 Plus

9.3

Amazon Echo

9.0

Google Pixel XL

8.0

That configuration provides strong performance, and the Surface Studio will certainly be a good choice for graphics and design work. Even so, its performance is hardly exceptional when compared to other high-end all-in-one systems. Geekbench 4 recorded scores of 4,300 and 13,775 for single- and multi-core CPU performance respectively, and 102.5fps for graphics performance under Cinebench R15. Those are certainly respectable scores, but Dell's Precision Workstation AIO 5720 delivers comparable performance -- stronger in the case of Cinebench -- for barely half the price.

The 2TB hybrid drive isn't a bad performer, with write and read performance of 544MB/s and 1,332MB/s respectively -- but at this price you're entitled to expect a dedicated solid-state drive. There are no Thunderbolt ports either, simply four USB 3.0 ports, Gigabit Ethernet and a Mini-DisplayPort, so the Surface Studio's upgrade potential is fairly limited. Having said that, iFixit's teardown analysis suggests that it's not too difficult to open the unit up if you need to do a few repairs.

Conclusions

The distinctive 'drawing-board-display' is clearly the outstanding feature of the Surface Studio, and -- along with the optional Surface Dial -- could well have some appeal for creative users. But you're paying quite a premium for that versatile display, and the Surface Studio will need a serious price reduction if it's to compete with the latest high-end AIOs on the market.

RECENT AND RELATED CONTENT

Apple iMac Pro (late 2017) review: An AIO for the Pro crowd
It's seriously expensive, but Apple has finally released an iMac that can handle VR and other high-end content-creation tasks.

Dell Precision Workstation AIO 5720 review: A professional-level all-in-one with excellent GPU performance
The Precision AIO 5720's high-end graphics performance makes it well suited to tasks such as photography, design and illustration work. It's also competitively priced.

Linux all-in-one: Slimbook Curve comes with your distro of choice pre-installedLinux users can pick which of 10 Linux distros the Slimbook Curve 24-inch screen all-in-one one is delivered with.

HP launches sanitizable healthcare notebook, all-in-one PC, and displayHP's portfolio is aimed at clinicians who have to log in 70 times a day and sanitize IT gear repeatedly.

HP unveils Core X options for Z4 workstation, 'pro' MR headsetWith a VR focus, HP's best-selling workstation gains Core X processors for the first time.

Windows 10 Spring Creators Update: A cheat sheet (TechRepublic)Everything you need to know about the latest major feature update to Windows 10, including the features for home users and businesses, how to get it now and how to delay it.

Read more AIO reviews

• Apple iMac Pro (late 2017) review: An AIO for the Pro crowd
• Dell Precision Workstation AIO 5720 review: A professional-level all-in-one with excellent GPU performance
• HP EliteOne 1000: A 34-inch curved all-in-one monster
• Lenovo ThinkCentre M910z AIO review: Unassuming design, strong performance for the price