After backlash Yahoo's Tumblr quietly restores adult, NSFW blogs

After backlash Yahoo's Tumblr quietly restores adult, NSFW blogs

Summary: When it was revealed that Yahoo's Tumblr had removed adult blogs from every kind of search possible, online backlash prompted the company to quickly, quietly restore search indexing to its adult blogs.

SHARE:
11

Tumblr users with "Adult" and "NSFW" blogs can breathe a sigh of relief as Tumblr has moved quickly to restore its adult and NSFW blogs to both internal and external search, now under one "NSFW" category.

Friday, it was revealed that Yahoo's Tumblr brand had exiled its "Adult" blogs separately from its "NSFW" blogs into a non-searchable ghetto where they were de-indexed from both internal and external search - making an estimated 12.5 million blogs unfindable.

Screen shot 2013-07-21 at 1.10.30 PM

Within 24 hours Tumblr has quietly returned the blogs back to internal and external search, and folded its "Adult" blogs into the wider "NSFW" category. When reached for a statement, Tumblr's Head of Communications told ZDNet,

The two options ("NSFW" and "Adult") were clearly causing confusion, so we’ve dropped the extra option.

If your blog contains anything too sexy for the average workplace, simply check "Flag this blog as NSFW" so people in Safe Mode can avoid it.

Your blog will still be indexed by third-party search engines.

Before the sale, Tumblr was seen as a place where such content would be monitored but left alone - and its new owners suggested to press that this "hands-off" approach would continue.

When news of the blog banishing and other unfriendly changes such as the removal of Tumblr's "Erotica" category and blacklisting of tag search for terms like #gay and #lesbian were learnt by users and public, the reaction was overwhelmingly and loudly furious.

The re-classification of naughty blogs into one category has been confirmed by adult Tumblr blog operators. This reporter's list of eighty formerly "Adult" now "NSFW" Tumblrs confirms the disabling of robots.txt to allow the blogs to again be indexed and searchable by Google, DuckDuckGo, Bing, Yahoo and other search engines.

What's more, Tumblr told ZDNet that the amount of porn blogs engaging in spammy behavior are actually a very low number - not the bulk of its adult userbase.

According to Tumblr's representative, the spammy porn blogs amount to less than one percent of its "Adult" blogs (estimated at 10% of Tumblr's total userbase of 125 million) - meaning that with the former search exile on "Adult" blogs, the "Adult" baby was being thrown out with the bathwater.

Tumblr explained to ZDNet via email today that this is no longer the case:

For the roughly 124k blogs that have been hidden from search engines for harmful behavior like bulk linking to/from commercial porn sites, Tumblr's Trust & Safety team reviews all reports from anyone who believes they've been incorrectly flagged.

The number of false positives remains extremely low, but our team takes these reports very seriously and is actively adjusting any relevant automatic flags.

This is the list that an additional 46k blogs had effectively opted-in to by flagging their blog "adult" before we removed that option on Friday.

Tumblr made sure to say that their team is taking care to parse the adult blogs that had opted-in to being "Adult" before the change to avoid false flags.

By Saturday evening, Tumblr had silently restored all its "Adult" blogs to search by external search engines, and the blogs were under the "NSFW" banner.

Tumblr former Adult and NSFW policy
Tumblr's former "Adult" and "NSFW" policy.

 

Tumblr's new "NSFW" policy includes its "Adult" blogs.
Tumblr's new "NSFW" policy includes its "Adult" blogs.

 

Founder David Karp had quickly responded to the outrage on the Tumblr Staff Blog, but his Saturday statement raised more questions than the answers it sought to provide.

Adult Tumblr owners saw it as a non-apology. This is likely because Karp's statement failed to inform readers of the restoration of "Adult" blogs to internal and third-party search (Tumblr has not acknowledged public observation of its de-indexing practices), and did not state that Tumblr had simply combined the two categories.

Tumblr's Karp did say it restored all its racy blogs to Tumblr search:

As some of you have pointed out, disabling Safe Mode still wasn’t allowing search results from all blogs to appear. This has been fixed.

Karp went on to explain that the banning of tags #gay, #lesbian and #bisexual on "some of [its] mobile apps" was in place to prevent search returns for adult content, and Karp admitted this was not ideal. Indeed, as LGBT Tumblr users have angrily responded with comments such as 'my existence is not porn.'

Karp stated that Tumblr was working to find a 'smarter' solution - but unfortunately the tag ban is in place until Tumblr figures it out.

He did not explicitly state why Tumblr has begun its mobile LGBT filtering, but it appears that the clumsy solution is to comply with Apple's strict rules against adult material.

The ways in which Apple's unevenly enforced sex-negative policy chills art, information and speech in the sphere of mobile apps is a post for another day.

Tumblr moved fast to make its changes, although a lot of drama could have been avoided if Tumblr had been more clear.

But this is a lesson in growing up, a lesson that other companies should pay close attention to, as well as the new fact that large companies can no longer mess with adult content and expect that no one cares, that no one will notice, or that no one will publicly object.

Tumblr has moved the conversation forward. While there are some things left to be desired, NSFW (formerly "Adult") Tumblr users now have founder Karp's assurance that their blogs are back in the community and will now continue to be visible to search engines and internal search (with "Safe Mode" off, of course).

The upside is that unlike other companies, Tumblr is listening to its userbase. Let's hope this is allowed to continue under Yahoo's stweardship.

Topics: Censorship, Apple, Mobile OS

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

11 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Does this address de-listed sites?

    I checked several sites' robots.txt and it's fortunate they've made them searchable again. Though from my tests, I will still way to see if they are fully crawled (aside from the private

    But some tumblr sites have appeared to be previously de-listed from what Karp himself mentioned:

    "Earlier this year, in an effort to discourage some not-so-nice people from using Tumblr as free hosting for spammy commercial porn sites, we started delisting this tiny subset of blogs from search engines like Google. This was never intended to be an opt-in flag, but for some reason could be enabled after checking off NSFW → Adult in your blog settings. "

    There are a few whose tumblr site name turns up nothing, presumably from this kind of de-listing. For example: lipwrapped (+ tumblr.com)
    still turns up no hits. Will these sites be submitted or re-listed for indexing again? Or do they need to be?

    Also some of tumblr's generated sitemaps.xml seem to be missing many pages for several day old posts (assuming they are generated in chronological order) as if they were randomly skipped
    npcompletion
    • Good post

      just as Larry responded I'm alarmed that a single mom can make ($)7030 in 1 month on the internet. did you read this web link... c­a­n9­9.ℂ­ℴ­M
      BrendaBarajas
  • Apple or Yahoo!

    "He did not explicitly state why Tumblr has begun its mobile LGBT filtering, but it appears that the clumsy solution is to comply with Apple's strict rules against adult material.

    The ways in which Apple's unevenly enforced sex-negative policy chills art, information and speech in the sphere of mobile apps is a post for another day."

    Huh? Who owns Tumblr, Apple or Yahoo!?
    madfry
    • Yahoo own Tumblr

      Apple have strict rules regarding content available through its apps which means the Tumblr app was in danger of being banned from the app store due to content.
      badrabbit
  • Yahoo has a habit of doing this sort of thing

    I dumped Yahoo a half-dozen years ago over the Callahan/allah flap.

    This latest incident confirms the wisdom of my decision.

    I hate Yahoo and its censorious philosophy.
    FlyingKahuna
  • We won't de-list, we'll just terminate

    Sorry, confused here. Was this "in an effort to discourage some not-so-nice people from using Tumblr as free hosting for spammy commercial porn sites ... " or was the standard for de-indexing simply any tumblog they felt was engaging in "harmful behavior like bulk linking to/from commercial porn sites?"

    Hosting images is one thing, but now Tumblr admits de-listing for linking to the content source -- the copyright owner?

    That has to be the stupidest effing thing I've heard from David Karp on this subject yet. And that's actually saying quite a bit.

    What he doesn't say in his public statements is how many of those estimated 12 million adult/nsfw tumblogs they've terminated in the last few months. If Tumblr wants to change it's community standards to ban adult content, that's what they should do. It only affects 10% of their total users, right?
    Jenny Allen
  • Tumblr Terminating Adult Blogs

    For the past couple weeks Tumblr has aggressively been terminating adult blogs without giving reason. When your account is terminated, you see a message that your account was terminated and a link to contact them to find out why. When you do contact them, they NEVER respond; even if you keep contacting them.
    Bluenitro
  • Time to migrate to nsfwtumblr.com

    Just use nsfwtumblr.com you can even import your old tumblr and post anything you want, its even a bit more powerful than tumblr

    that way you dont have to worry about yahoo anymore! yay.
    tumblrnsfw
  • tumbler

    I'm assuming Ms. Meyer approved the change?
    preferred user
  • Zdnet

    This is really very interesting topic, i like it and i will use it
    escortmanchesteruk
  • Usually at Old Trafford it is the actualthe particular away

    Border Patrol says it has arrested greater than 100 people from Haiti for allegedly entering Vermont illegally from Canada since an enormous earthquake devastated the Caribbean nation. "Other items put up for sale on eBay by Leicestershire police included cellphones, a replica second world war German motorcycle and sidecar, military toys and a volume called The particular Book of Muscle: the World's Most Authoritative Guide to Building The body. That makes cloud servers easier to control, but for database-intensive applications, it can result in the allocation of approximately 20 times as much hardware as needs to be necessary. He was seated alongside Sir Bruce Forsyth as well as Stephen Fry. 5m in 2012. President Barack Obama said Saturday that the particular U. Each banner marks a line of glass-covered orbs that stretches down a mile . 5 into the ice, like beads on a frozen string. "I think all of it's a pity frankly, I really do – the way that creative integrity has been devalued towards commercialism and reality television. And so is his race, which has struck a chord in a country with all the world's second-largest black population, after Nigeria. ” Now that the shuttle program is actually officially retired, how might the role of the U . s . astronaut change. "We didn't play well enough to should have anything. '"The virtuoso argues it is not her job to persuade children to adore classical music, or even to create the stars for the future. “There are big questions that we nonetheless haven't answered, all centered around this little particle. Confusion is not an unpleasant failure but a chance for adventure and learning. I'm finding it hard not to take awe of Bailey. 2 billion or more in payments to wash up and compensate people affected by the massive oil spill in the Gulf coast of florida. No it's not, says atheist "pastor" Sanderson Jones. Then join us for live coverage associated with USA vs Cuba on Saturday, and return on Monday morning with faces filled with rueful experience as we review just what we should learned this weekend (just don't expect us to possess learnt how to spell "Wondolowski"…)All kick-off occasions are listed as ETPhiladelphia Union vs Chivas USAFri 7. Collegiate council votes to take over union's hq, but student activists say they'll fight programs 'to the end'Students have threatened to stage sit-ins and a demonstration so as to overturn a decision to close the College of London Union, the largest student association of its type in Europe. Indeed, they found that the jump in conductivity nonetheless occurred. The bride is an assistant professor of English and fine arts in the Virginia Military Institute; the groom is an assistant commonwealth lawyer in Virginia. This restored big-screen version shouldn't be overlooked: it's a colossus of the analogue-epic period, and the high point of Elizabeth Taylor's worldwide celebrity, when her prestige was hardly less towering than that with the actual queen of the Nile. He talked with MIT News about a number of his favorite moments as a space shuttle service astronaut. Jonathan Quick earned his first shutout with the season with 27 saves, Tyler Toffoli scored his first NHL goal over a power play in only his second game with La and the Kings beat the Phoenix Coyotes 4-0 about Monday night. Finally, evaporated molybdenum is fired at the area, where it forms the gate, tightly squeezed between the two other electrodes, del Alamo says. "BarcelonaAndrés IniestaChampions LeagueEuropean club footballguardian. Its hollow tubular structure would make it great for throwing and wielding as a weapon, but does its rigid nature means it might more often shatter on impact with a difficult surface. The MIT researchers are now looking for other aspects of the pathway that connects glial calcium amounts to neuronal hyperactivity, which could lead to the discovery regarding other potential drug targets. But then, Fred Turner points out, "he's also had a lifetime of arranging. Lest we forget, university tuition fees trebled last year. Thank god he didn't let us lower. "We have been here nearly three seasons and you may see there is a plan, players understand the way we want in order to play, " said Poyet. It's not perfect, but we need to plan based on the forward vision, instead of only looking backward. "Legal or illegal, I will do it, " he said. Even under Beddington's admirably plural model, there are still implicit hierarchies between professions, which aren't properly explained or written lower. A second pair of brothers Bassam Karrar, 33, and Mohammed Karrar, 38, were also given life sentences. How did he cheat hypothermia. However, since then the government has not mentioned whether it supports such moves. Could the magnetization of Vesta's rocks happen to be caused by anything other than a dynamo. To label proteins with biotin, the researchers first designed a new enzyme they will dubbed APEX. KHALED EL-HAGARThe film director who returned from your UK in time to film the wave. This is no fault of Richard McCabe, who plays Wilson with a nice pawky humour. The accounts show that GFH, which has had financial difficulties during the home and financial market slumps, recorded in 2011-12 a modest profit regarding $10m (£7m). Maduro government accuses US of being powering post-election violence and insists Tracy was plotting in order to destabilise VenezuelaVenezuela's government has rejected comments by Barack Obama in regards to the country's political crisis and the arrest of the US film-maker, accusing Washington of being behind violence which includes followed the recent presidential election. By becoming a public advocate for cyberpunks implicated in major computer crimes, however, Brown was in extremely shaky legal area. $26 For a brief, shining moment, the world stood together, and Gordon Brown was its voice. Diehard fans are reading t' riot behave With Peter Jackson's Hobbit trilogy already set to equal the box-office success from the Kiwi film-maker's Lord of the Rings triptych and Game of Thrones storming the tiny screen, it ought to be a golden grow older for swords and sorcery. What an archetypal story does is expose you to a central character – the protagonist – and invite one to identify with them; effectively they become your avatar in the actual drama. 'Twig does funny things like packing twelve pairs of pants for starters day. I used to work next to a building having an MRI scanner in it, and it was always covered with parrots. Then Sunshine goes missing. Yet Shakespeare had died in 1616, and Florio was hard up: a pension promised to him by James I needed failed to materialise. But the MIT researchers showed that, remarkably, this simple, repetitive process of adding edges and rebalancing will converge about the solution of the graph Laplacian. However, a new federal study may stir items up further, even though the bottom , says the microthruster design stands out among satellite propellant systems because of its size and low power consumption. • Centre committed foul on Simone Favaro inside Six Nations• O'Driscoll will miss Leinster's Amlin Challenge Cup quarter-finalBrian O'Driscoll continues to be given a three‑week suspension for his seal of approval on Italy's Simone Favaro in Ireland's 6 Nations defeat in Rome. To that end, we are discontinuing support for our more mature apps: TweetDeck AIR, TweetDeck for Android and TweetDeck for apple iphone. 17 percent in November. Bryan Bickell scored twice in the first period and Patrick Kane added a target in the third as Chicago remained the fghtes56 sole team in the NHL without a loss in regulation time this year: 23 games. For many she was the first writer to create sense of the worldTiger Eyes, my favourite of Judy Blume's books, has been made into a film which finally includes a US release date. Adapted from the novel by Jonathan Lethem, the show will play at the Dallas Theater Center before arriving at the Public Theater in New York. In the past few years we have observed startling progress towards reinventing the language associated with life. "I miss my classmates from Pakistan very much but I am looking towards meeting my teachers and making new friends within Birmingham, " she said. "Every week Washington is creating some sort of manmade political crisis so they can worry about, " he said. She was the runner-up in the B Division with the Hatch Brown Trophy and the A Division from the New England Dinghy Championship, finished tied for second in the A Division from the Eckerd Intersectional, was third in the B Division from the Danmark Trophy, ranked fourth in the B Division with the Moody Trophy, and claimed fifth place in the A Division from the Hood Trophy and the B Division from the Navy Fall Intersectional. But what is most enduring about Cummings' military experience is it fueled her desire to improve how humans and computers can function together in complex technical systems. The first trick is to book any "Group Save 4" ticket, which brings the family price down to be able to £64. , begins with a rugged task: selling the kids on a holiday near to home. As the spacecraft orbited the planet, an onboard X-ray spectrometer measured the X-ray rays generated by Mercury's surface. 5km course from Châtel-Guyon to Brioude. We were led to believe that in extreme circumstances they'd come midweek, but that's not been the case. I can't remember what I sent. The issue at a glanceAfter doubts on the safety of the MMR vaccine in any now discredited scientific paper in 1998, vaccination rates fell as some parents lost confidence from the vaccine. ' People socialise on Facebook because where can you go to loiter in New York any longer. A rep for John Kerry said that doctors have figured the secretary of state's wife suffered the seizure on Sunday. Why he has said that I don't know. 19I have never made a hat prior to. The £200m deal affected 500, 000 households, and included customers of BE broadband, acquired by O2 last year. He was lean, a nonsmoker and had healthy blood stress, although his cholesterol levels hovered just previously mentioned normal. Plenette Pierson scored 9 of her 22 points within the fourth quarter as the host Liberty recovered after stopping nearly all of a 19-point lead inside the third quarter and beat the Seattle Surprise. When TalkTalk took over AOL and Tiscali it resulted in billing problems and number of disputes with customers over promises produced by the previous company. In the first randomized trial to address whether individuals with diabetes benefit from restricting fruit, researchers found that avoiding fruit may not need benefits for those with Type 2 diabetes. Williams, 31, was rarely troubled throughout her 6-3, 6-2 victory but credit must also navigate to the French teenager Garcia, who on this evidence should have a bright future within the game. The move marks a rare step in to the spotlight for Lee, who is known for keeping a low profile for this kind of household name, living quietly in a tiny town within the deep south of America and eschewing virtually all media requests. Reloadable cards are becoming more widely used but they need not carry federal deposit insurance. As so many times this season, the former Rotherham striker came off the bench at Fulham – a job with which he has become increasingly disappointed. "RepublicansUS elections 2016Obama inaugurationInternetSocial mediaUnited StatesEd Pilkingtonguardian. Gross. "We definitely come back stronger. You probably gleaned the facts of life from your giggling friend or a hastily passed around bit of paper, or if you were born after Madonna released Just like a Virgin, from the internet. In the case of CFCs, the real reason they were able to become phased out "was because of us, " Solomon said. 6 percent after a 6 percent decrease Monday. When we get sick we bring one another food. Andy Palmer, Nissan executive vice-president and the most powerful Briton in the Japanese company, said northeast production of the Leaf would certainly begin on 28 March. Navy seniors Angela Myers and Cassie Consedine were the initial to embrace at center court following a 47-40 victory over American inside the Patriot League final Saturday at Alumni Hallway. “Normally, propulsion systems have significant infrastructure associated along with propellant feed lines, valves [and] complex power conditioning systems, ” says Graves, who was not involved in the investigation. To me, it was so important and exciting. Here are a few of the a lot more entertaining reactions "Barça's Víctor Valdés has been banned with regard to four matches by La Liga suits for that red card he received for telling the referee he "cr@pped himself" during Barcelona's clásico defeat. "And he still couldn't play bass any time he died, I mean, fucking hell. The surgical spirit should sit on the surface of the kiwi mixture, and in this top layer some whitened cloudy stuff will form. "Goodman's method is a form of item divination. Women faculty are much less likely being on these boards. The video includes paper cut-outs of Obama and also Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announcing their nation's "unbreakable alliance" before retiring to Netanyahu's business office. Determine how the cooperative nature of microbial growth in beta-lactam antibiotics influences the direction of selection and conditions that cause the spread of more resistant mutants. President Obama brought 47 world leaders towards the White House this spring to discuss nuclear hands control. 3, at 6 p. “What's exciting is that novel technologies and also data collection strategies are giving citizens and scholars a better ability to monitor and study the investments made by their governments than previously. Goldwasser has had tremendous impact on the particular development of cryptography and complexity theory. He captained all the age grades that amazed me because he was so peaceful. "It does not change his attitude. Here's why. Where the underlying limestone layer is thicker and rainfall heavy, vast underground caverns and subterranean rivers have produced sinkholes of dimensions which make what's happened in Florida or Essex seem positively insignificant: the Xiaozhai tiankeng ("heavenly pit") within Chongqing, China, is 662m deep; the Dashiwei tiankeng in  Guangxi 613m. South American leaders planned to send a difficult message to Washington on Friday over accusations of U. “Holography works, it's beautiful, nothing can touch its quality, ” says Douglas Lanman, a postdoc at the Media Lab and one of many new paper's co-authors. The hideous conditions, complete with horizontal rain, did not allow for fully flowing rugby, and on the odd occasion before the break when England looked able to going over, both Carling and Webb ignored the presence of Oti around the wing, leaving English fans screaming in frustration. Leather. He was lean, a nonsmoker and had healthy blood stress, although his cholesterol levels hovered just previously mentioned normal. Tom Wheeler has invested in start-up technologies and communications companies, and advised the Federal Communications Commission upon technology issues. Anabolic steroids are powerful drugs which have got significant, and rapid, effects.
    ordode