Apple censors Lawrence Lessig over warranty information; iOS 7 mess grows

Apple censors Lawrence Lessig over warranty information; iOS 7 mess grows

Summary: The man behind Creative Commons was twice censored by Apple in its Community forums when he tried to share warranty information with users who lost Wi-Fi after the iOS 7 update.

TOPICS: iOS, Apple, Mobile OS

A significant number of Apple users have lost Wi-Fi functions after its glitch-ridden iOS 7 update. Ignored since September, Apple Support Communities members are now watching their solutions be deleted by Apple.

And according to Lawrence Lessig, Apple is also preventing its users from posting innocent questions about the deletions.

Mr Lessig personally experienced Apple's censors today, when two of his comments were disallowed — with one removed for forum violation — when he joined the growing throngs of iOS 7 upgrade failure victims.

ios7 lessig censorship

The man behind Creative Commons, and friend and lawyer to Aaron Swartz, Lessig is now part of an angry mob in Apple's forums who upgraded to iOS 7 and lost Wi-Fi connectivity.

When a warranty return solution was posted in the forum, Lessig witnessed firsthand that Apple is deleting this information — and more — from its support boards.

Mr Lessig first experienced Apple's censorship when he was prevented from posting a comment asking whether Apple removed comments.

Frustrated at this, along with Apple's lack of response in its forums, and the non-trivial difficulty in restoring any device to a pre-iOS 7 state, he had also taken particular notice of a UK commenter who found a last-ditch solution in returning their device under UK warranty laws.

But when Lessig blinked, the comment was gone.

Lessig reposted the comment, which explained to the growing mass of iOS 7 vanished-Wi-Fi victims that in the EU, if an iOS update breaks your phone, you can return it due to warranty protections and get a new one.

Lessig's own comment was deleted — and Apple admonished him for posting inappropriate content to its forums.

Apple told Mr Lessig,

We understand the desire to share experiences in your topic, "Re: Wi-Fi greyed out after update to iOS 7," but because these posts are not allowed on our forums, we have removed it.

Lessig responded in a blog post detailing the experience, Wow, or from the When-Apple-Became-the-Borg Department,

OK, so what precisely is the valid objection here? Sure, the community site is intended for technical issues. That was what the thread began with — a technical issue.

When there was no corporate response to that technical issue, some started to offer advice to other customers about what they could do to deal with that issue.

When did it become inappropriate to inform people about legally protected rights related to technical issues? Is talking about legal rights the new porn?

Lessig had at first thought that the UK warranty comment — though informative — seemed a touch paranoid in its mention that Apple was deleting helpful iOS 7 comments from Apple forum users.

Having saved a copy of the comment, Mr Lessig reposted it, noting that the comment was a repost but contained essential information for UK Apple users.

He remarked that UK users were lucky to have this solution available (US users have no such legal protections with Apple products).

Lessig's "Borg" post detailing his "Support" experience circled the larger problems at hand, which prompted the comment in the first place — namely, the serious technical problems in the iOS 7 rollout, and Apple's refusal to answer legitimate user questions in its forums.

I upgraded my iPhone ("what, you have an iPhone" — OK, you win, sin #1) to iOS 7.0.3. It killed Wi-Fi. I went to the Apple discussion site to see what the community had to say about it.

Seems there are lots of people who had the same problem.

... This link is a great example: link.

As you read through it, you'll see that it's fairly clear there's a bug which is causing significant trouble; clear that there's been no response from Apple; and clear that the troops are getting angry.

Lessig is now watching — and recording — Apple's active removal of legitimate Support Communities queries, such as his new post, the slaughter continues — Apple's latest deleted comment.

Currently, the Apple Support Communities post, Wi-Fi greyed out after update to iOS 7, has 4,806 views and only 25 comments — but as Mr Lessig discovered, the comment number is higher and unknown, due to Apple's active removal of legitimate comments about the problem.

The Wi-Fi issue is only one of nearly two dozen of the many known, serious bugs in Apple's seventh major release of the iOS mobile operating system.

Today, iOS 7 users are reporting a new glitch in the calendar's daylight savings time function.

Apple's policy to remove comments that lend legitimate help is little more than a display of censorship for the internet thought leader, who clearly understands that it is Apple's right to censor its forum users.

But it shows that Apple is well aware of the problem and the critical mass being reached over iOS 7's serious technical problems — and is both refusing to help and actively removing solutions it simply doesn't like.

ZDNet has reached out to Apple for comment and will update this post if it responds.

Topics: iOS, Apple, Mobile OS

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • A related question

    For all tech users. Why does US law not recognize a software upgrade that breaks functionality as a valid warranty issue?
    • A related answer

      because the US is run by and for Corporations....
    • Why, oh, why?

      Why Microsoft is allowed to chose its own punishment for monopoly abuse. Apple does not have to pay Samsung for patent violation. Google does not have to honour your privacy. Should I go on?
      Maybe it has to do with the political system in US?
      • You mean the political system where... vote for your representatives and other elected officials?
        • Don't be naive, they all lie you, the USA is ruled by others ;)

          Don't be naive, they all lie you, the USA is ruled by others ;)
          Proofs: lie about mass destruction weapons in Iraq>> murders of the USA and EU soldiers
          Lies about surveillance
          Search "US Concentration Camps FEMA & REX 84 Programs"
          Prepared for the martial law to remove people who want a change after a crisis that is coming
          Etc etc etc
        • there are votes, and there are votes that count

          remember that SCOTUS has ruled, led by corporatist judges, that money is speech.
      • same bs

        move to china and then talk to me
        Timothy Kane
    • Warranty Length

      I'm guessing because US warranty is 12 months, and Europe tends to enforce a longer warranty whether the manufacturer likes it or not. Since this is a software upgrade, likely most users are out of official warranty and are into statutory warranty.
    • Or contract...

      Let alone a contract violation, since most iPhone users are locked into a 2-year and stuck with a device that no-longer matches what they bought.
  • So it...

    ...I go into an Apple store, knock over a display table and something unintentionally gets broken no one is going to say, "You broke it, you bought it"?

    Just askin...
    • not only they are not goning to say that

      they'll be very polite and ask if you are ok and then will offer you a discount of a freebie so that you don't sue them for endangering their customers
  • iOS 7 mess

    I owned all the iPhones ever released in the market. After i discovered Apple would not allow downgrade to iOS6 i sold it and joined the Android smartphone bandwagon. After two weeks of usage, i am very satisfied. For sure it is not an Apple OS in many aspects, but i have no dizziness or headaches now.

    Apple should listen to its customers, not the other way around. How can they NOT allow a customer to downgrade to iOS6? It is preposterous!!!

    I even put the iOS7 on my iPad, but nothing i can do on that one now. But on the iPad i can just about tolerate the OS. However, on my wife's iPad mini, we will NEVER be updating to iOS7.
    Paris Hilarion
    • iOS7 Mess

      Don't worry, Apple is acting alot like Microsoft now days with their "overlord" ways with their Operating Systems. Seems that Microsoft went rogue on Windows 8.x and didn't go to their user base for discernment. Apple has done the same thing with iOS7 and the US Government has done the same thing with OBummerCare 1.x
  • Censor is nothing new

    I wrote an email in their forum awhile back about how it was a mistake to wait another year to release a 4G phone. That it would give too much of an advantage to Android. That they did this because AT&T wasn't ready for 4G and the IPhone, at that time had few Verizon customers. Apple immediately pulled this comment off their forum telling me it was inappropriate. They are babies. They can't take even a little constructive criticism.
    • Say what you will about Microsoft

      but in their Answers and MSDN forums, this almost never happens. Lots of people there ranting about Windows 8, problems with their software, etc. in a way that puts Microsoft in a non flattering light.

      Apple would do well to follow the example.
    • Wrong forum

      If you posted that to the Support forum, then you used the wrong outlet for your rant.
  • LOL! Anyone else find it ironic ZDNet just censored posts from an...

    ...article about censoring posts?
    • Sure do.

    • re: Pathetic is what it is

      Apple fans sure are thin skinned, but then most cult members get real upset when you question the dogma that they fight so hard to maintain belief in against all objective evidence.
      Sir Name
  • typical

    I was dumped when I complained a few years ago re the inApps scam that Apple profited in re toddlers, etc...
    Felt great when the courts went against them..