iPhone - first reviews

Looks like the embargo's off in the US; the first reviews are coming in. Check out Crunchgear for a round-up; they're still up in the US, so there may be more tomorrow.

Looks like the embargo's off in the US; the first reviews are coming in. Check out Crunchgear for a round-up; they're still up in the US, so there may be more tomorrow. Right now, it's the NY Times and the WSJ. The NYT has a 'video diary', which doesn't seem quite sure whether it's an advert or not but is fun to watch anyway.

Plus points: screen fabulous, web browsing ditto (via WiFi), interface for graphics and webbery works very well, various user interface elements ditto. Voice mail/email integration excellent.

Ho-hum points: entering text via touchscreen not as good as using real keys. No MMS or video capture. Battery life five hours or so use. Internal camera... not brilliant.

Bad points: no Java, Flash, memory slot, GPS, replaceable battery (back to Apple after two years), EDGE only (and on AT&T's excreable network too - minutes to load web pages). Making a phone call is a five-step process,

It's clearly going to get GPS, Java and Flash (it so is) and 3G (it SO is). A two year irreplacable battery life - well, it never killed the iPod, which is by now my longest-owned pocket device (I replaced the irreplacable battery. My last Nokia had a replaceable battery, which cost more than a new phone. Huh).

But bad at making phone calls and text messages?

Mmm. Bold.

(OK - one update before I turn in. Walt Mossberg, the WSJ's tech bod, has his review up here outside the WSJ's paywall. He's keen, got nearer the 8 hour battery life promised, and says the keyboard's a non-issue once you get past three days of pain. But there's no cut and paste, entering punctuation is a bit messy, and navigating within documents outside the web browser is clearly not so grand. I'm not sure that ditching the iPod's music interface for a big scrolly list of album covers is a good thing either, although there may be more to it than these early reviews have said)

Newsletters

You have been successfully signed up. To sign up for more newsletters or to manage your account, visit the Newsletter Subscription Center.
See All
See All