ME Bank picks 'cheaper' Microsoft stack over Linux
Summary: ME Bank has claimed that the long term cost of using Windows Server 2012 and SQL Server 2012 will be over AU$100,000 cheaper than the Linux alternative.
Members Equity Bank has claimed that the long term cost of using Windows Server 2012 and SQL Server 2012 will be cheaper than a Linux alternative, which the company claims would cost AU$100,000 more.
The bank, which is one of Australia's smaller banks with 250,000 customers, does not have any bank branches. It is currently undertaking an AU$57 million technology transformation program.
In late 2012, ME Bank picked the Temenos T24 CRM and product lifecycle-management software platform for its core banking platform, switching from the Windows-SQL-based NTBS and Solaris-based Ultratracs, which the bank had in place for close to a decade. The Temenos software was platform agnostic, meaning that the bank could have gone with either Windows or Linux for its server operating systems.
ME Bank's enterprise architect Jem Richards said that after the bank examined the costs between the two platforms, including the cost of providing tech support, ultimately decided that the Windows Server 2012 and SQL Server 2012 option would be cheaper.
"Although the alternative Linux-based platform is essentially free to deploy, based on our past experience, we knew that it would cost more to support than Windows. This made the overall costs of the two operating systems approximately the same," he said in a statement.
"In addition, Microsoft and Windows community specialists were readily available to help us configure Temenos T24, whereas finding the relevant skills for the alternative platform with Temenos was proving to be a lot more difficult."
The company would not confirm which Linux platform it was considering deploying.
Richards said that the unnamed Linux platform would cost AU$100,000 more to upgrade, while the Microsoft licence would require no additional cost over five years.
"It was clear that if we deployed our core banking systems on Windows-SQL, the total cost of ownership would be substantially less than if we chose the alternative.”
Richards said that the decision would allow ME Bank to "consolidate internal IT skills on a single technology", and through the decommissioning of its legacy core banking system, it will save tens of thousands of dollars each year by requiring fewer external consultants to maintain the systems.
In March, ME Bank announced that it has begun rolling out its virtual teller systems with a focus on contact centres, starting with Telstra's Melbourne contact centre.
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
seriously?
After a few years ...
Why, sure.
what's with this whole "ransome" thing?
Indispensable managers!?!
Well ...
Linux + N staff can typically be replaced by Windows + M < N staff, which is why Windows often wins out in procurement decisions. Finding a standardised product that will allow you to reduce the number of managers is more difficult – though there probably are some products that at least help with it.
Funny how 80% of notarios stock exchange market see things in pretty....
And of course: 91% of top 500 supercomputers are running on Linux too. (only 1% with Windows).
What about statistics showing that Linux needs 12% less electric than Windows or this one:
https://joinup.ec.europa.eu/community/osor/news/spains-open-source-centre-publishes-model-desktop-cost-savings
“Switching a basic government desktop PC configuration to open source, for example, will save some 5000 euro per desktop per year, Cenatic’s model shows. The calculation can be tweaked by changing the figures for migration costs, downtime, maintenance, consultancy and the prices paid for proprietary software licences.The results are shown as graphs, displaying the costs over a five-year period.”
Seriously
No operating system is perfect. Linux your programmers could fix, Windows your programmers can't. But sure Linux sux because skilled people could fix your problems for you. Windows rocks because skilled programmers can't fix what is broken.
You are the problem I think.
The article is (unintentionally) deceiving
Temenos
It was mentioned in the article that Microsoft and community will configure TemenosT24 for them
This probably swing it to MS platform
Did you know
The Vanguard Group, Inc.
Did you know
I have red plenty of articles showing how badly Aussies are...
A $100'000 difference in a $57'000'000 project ...
Good one!
It's a "rounding error" only if...
Bad news for linux team
Not really
I think you will find The NYSE and LSE booted out Windows in favor of Linux as it wasn't up to the job.
Anyhow the bank may regret their decision in the future just as the NYSE and LSE did.
Basic economics
ME Bank picks 'cheaper' Microsoft stack over Linux