Video: Road testing two Bluetooth-based speakerphones -- the VR3 and the Aura

Video: Road testing two Bluetooth-based speakerphones -- the VR3 and the Aura

Summary: These days, you can't go out in public without bumping into someone that's got some Bluetooth-based gear on their head. You may look funny when appearing to talk into thin air, but the convenience of being able to talk on the phone or listen to music while the phone or music player is still on your belt or in your pocket is liberating.

SHARE:
TOPICS: Mobility
3

These days, you can't go out in public without bumping into someone that's got some Bluetooth-based gear on their head. You may look funny when appearing to talk into thin air, but the convenience of being able to talk on the phone or listen to music while the phone or music player is still on your belt or in your pocket is liberating. A lot of people also use hands-free headgear in their cars. But what they may not know is that it's often possible to pair their phones with more than one device and then pick which of those devices is the one they want to use at any given time. In the car for example, instead of using Bluetooth headgear, you might want to try using a Bluetooth-based speakerphone.

After gathering up two such devices -- Spracht's $150 Aura Mobile BT and Roadmaster's $70 VR3 -- I decided to take both for a road test. Not only did I test them in the car, we rolled video tape so you could experience the same thing I did. In addition took a bunch of pictures of both devices and loaded them into a ZDNet image gallery to allow for a more intimate look at some of their features and their user interfaces.


  See our video review of the Roadmaster VR3 and Spracht Aura Mobile BT: To get a better idea of how both Bluetooth speakerphones worked, David took to the road in his car and gave both a try and we caught it all on tape. Check out the video to see how things went.  Image Gallery: Want images? Have we got images. We took In addition to the video, we've prepared a gallery of images that shows the two devices up close and personal.  

With such a disparity in price (the Aura Mobile BT is more than twice the price of the Roadmaster VR3), you'd think that the Aura must, hands down, be the better of the two. The Aura was in fact more flexible than the VR3 since it can be used as a speakerphone for VoIP-applications like Skype.It comes with the jacks and cables necessary for attaching it to your computer as well as two power source options (one for the plug in the wall, the other for your car's lighter). Technically, the VR3 could be used as a desktop speakerphone as long as your computer supports the hands-free profile of Bluetooth (many don't) and the VR3's battery is fully charged (although in our tests, it did accept a charge from a AC-power-based Motorola cell phone charger). But that's really stretching the purpose of the VR3. If you want a speakerphone solution for Skype or some other VoIP app, the Aura (pictured right) is the better choice of the two (and you pay a lot more for that flexibility).

In the video review, you'll see that I focus on four basic review criteria:

  • How distracting is either device in terms of driver safety.
  • Degree of Bluetooth support
  • Audio quality (to both the caller and the person on the other end)
  • Other features that might attract you to one device over the other

Perhaps the most obvious difference between the two devices is the fact that the VR3 (pictured left) has an LED display and the Aura has none. Given that the hands-free profile of Bluetooth supports the transmission of information (eg: caller ID) that can be used on a display like the VR3's, you'll see how, in the video, the VR3 turns up the winner in Bluetooth support. 

While the video shows me using both devices to place a phone call to a friend who was on a cell phone in New York City, it's really hard for a recording of what's coming out of another speaker to give you a feel of which device sounds better. To be honest, neither device was loud enough for me. If road noise easily penetrates the passenger compartment of your car, you'll find yourself maxing out the volume on both devices and wishing they could go louder. I'm not sure why this is always a problem (not just with these devices, but with many cell phones too). I get the feeling that the devices could go louder if they used better components and it often has me wondering if they were simply looking for a way to save money.

Both devices have rechargeable batteries and both can be mounted to the visor in your car (although the Aura's visor mount, as can be seen in the image gallery, is retractable). If you're in your car, chances are you'll want to always take advantage of the capability of both to receive a charge from the included cigarette lighter adapter (in other words, not run it on the battery since you don't want to have to fidget with power cords while your driving if the battery on either device starts to run low). In this category, the Aura is slightly better because the power jack is on the end of the device that is closest to the windshield when mounted on your visor. In either case, an unsightly wire must be stretched from the lighter up to the unit on the visor. But with the VR3, that wire pokes out the front (facing the driver) rather than the back.

Well, that gives you a taste of my findings. For the rest of the gory details, be sure to check out the video below (which we encourage you to publish on your own web sites and blogs) and the image gallery. To get the embed codes to publish the video on your own site, you can find them on the bottom right hand corner of this Webshots page.

Topic: Mobility

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

3 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • not impressed with bluetooth audio products

    I have not encountered a bluetooth headset that I like yet. This report makes me believe bluetooth speakerphone support is also not ready for primetime .. at least not for me. Maybe too much focus on bluetooth and not enough on better product design?
    gary@...
  • Great review.

    I am getting ready to go to a PDA phone and i will be buying a car hands free and an ear piece hands free. I will keep this product in mind.

    As for the review, i like the video, i think it adds so much more understanding to what exactly your talking about when do talk about each product. I would like to see more reviews done this way. As they say, a picture is worth a 1000 words. Maybe they should say now, video is worth a million.
    Been_Done_Before
  • try the parrot minikit

    I have been using the parrot hands fess minikit for 6 months and am very happy with it. The normal user interface is very good, although the set up interface is a bit odd. I wish it did not need to be trained for voice dialing, but once trained it works very well. Sound quality is good and the battery lasts a long time between charges. Your video did not show voice dialing. The additional safety added by voice dialing from the speakerphone without touching your cell phone is important enough I was surprised your video did not mention if either unit reviewed support it.
    timfl