Acta: EU suspends treaty approval

Acta: EU suspends treaty approval

Summary: The controversial Acta bill is to be taken to Europe's highest court.


The European Commisson has stalled approval of the controverisal anti-piracy Acta treaty in light of virulent opposition to the legislation.

Acta, instead, will be taken to Europe's highest court to determine whether implementing and enforcing the agreement in its current state would violate fundamental EU rights.

The decision to suspend the anti-piracy and counterfeit bill, arguably, was already taken out of the EC's hands.

Several countries have already rejected the bill in its current form, including Germany, the Netherlands and Poland. Due to this, the agreement could not be enforced, as it would require every European country to both approve it and sign i in order to adhere to the treaty.

Not only has the treaty faced opposition from country leaders, its ramifications are understood by the general public; who have protested online as well as taking part in street demonstrations to express their displeasure. Protesters have marched against Acta across Europe; from London and Helsinki, Paris to Vienna.

On the heels of the SOPA and PIPA acts, it was unlikely to be met with open arms.

Karel De Gucht, the EU trade commissioner, said that taking the treaty to the European court of justice would clear the "fog of misinformation" surrounding Acta, as well as assessing the compatibility of the treaty with standing EU rights and freedom.

"This debate must be based upon facts and not upon the misinformation or rumour that has dominated social media sites and blogs in recent weeks," De Gucht said. "Acta will not censor websites or shut them down; Acta will not hinder freedom of the internet or freedom of speech."

However, opposers of the treaty fear that Acta will lead to censorship and further governmental control of the Internet. Taking the agreement further to gain approval of the UCJ has not dispelled these concerns. Jeremie Zimmermann, co-founder of the Internet advocacy group La Quadrature du Net stated:

"No legal debate can fix ACTA or give it a legitimacy that by design it cannot have."

The agreement has collected the signatures of 22 European member states so far, and is set to be debated in Parliament in June this year.

Image credit: AnonOps


Topics: Enterprise Software, Piracy, Security

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Acta: EU suspends treaty approval

    I've written both my senators and my (democrat) rep about rolling back ACTA in the U.S. Not a peep out of any of them. Is our country going to be shamed as being the only one subject to this fascist legislation?
  • RE: Acta: EU suspends treaty approval

    @nikacat - you're not alone. The UK has fallen. Not much of a turnout to the anti-ACTA protests. Also, you should note that while the US is a signatory and it was the US who was behind ACTA from inception, ACTA will never be 'legally binding' in the US, so will actually favour already established US corporations (it will be easier for US firms to sue EU citizens, but not vice versa).

    Regardless of ACTA's compatibility with EU law, if the EU ratifies this ludicrous treaty, it will lose the ability to shape or reform its copyright and intellectual property laws in the future. ACTA will be shaped and modified by the ACTA committee.

    Also, things in the EU will become much more expensive because companies (especially US companies) will use the mechanisms within ACTA to turn 'alternative generic products' into 'counterfeit products'. This will especially be the case for pharmaceutical products, and it will result in things like the NHS (National Health Service) in the UK being much more expensive to run.