ie8 fix

Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Apple's iPad 2: An incremental upgrade enough to kill the competition

By | March 2, 2011, 11:35am PST

Summary: Apple CEO Steve Jobs unveiled the iPad 2 and boxed in the competition for potentially the next two product cycles.

Apple CEO Steve Jobs unveiled the iPad 2 on Wednesday and the festivities went about as expected. The iPad got two cameras, dropped some girth and introduced some snazzy new covers.

Missing from the equation was a USB port and a new display.

But when you add up all the moving parts, Jobs had every right to be cocky and kick around the competition, notably Android, Samsung, Motorola and RIM. Sure, you could argue that Jobs lowered himself by calling out rivals by name, but the message was received: Apple just ensured that the other tablets are dead on arrival.

“We think 2011 is going to be the year of the iPad 2,” said Jobs.

More: Apple statements on iPad 2, iOS 4.3, our live analysis, Gallery, iPad 2 specs, 33 percent thinner, all incoming on Apple and iPad 2

No argument here, Steve.

Simply put, iPad 2 may be more 1.5 to some folks, but it’s more than enough to put the rivals to rest. Why? Most tablets—all preannounced by the way—aren’t going to hit the market before the iPad 2 launches. The iPad 2 will hit the U.S. market March 11 and global markets March 26. The iPad 2 “will be everywhere,” said Jobs.

That fact means it’s going to be very hard for rivals to come close to competing with Apple. The Art of War goes like this:

  • Apple’s iPad 2 will hit stores before rivals.
  • Most of the performance talk from Android rivals will be negated.
  • Apple left just enough features out of the iPad 2 to convince some folks that iPad 3 will be coming later.
  • The space between iPad 2 and iPad 3 is enough to convince most consumers to freeze thoughts of other tablets. Consumers may go Apple now—or later. Either way Apple wins.

As my colleague Jason Perlow noted: The competition is “mega screwed.”

Here’s the fallout:

Motorola Xoom: Jobs made a point to note that Apple only had one model over $799. That quip could have been directly addressed to Motorola Mobility CEO Sanjay Jha. The big bet for Motorola is that 4G—something lacking on the iPad—will be enough to woo business users. On the floors of Best Buy, iPad 2 is likely to win the day hands down. The Xoom will have to come down in price quickly. The Xoom has its merits, but it will be tough to unseat Apple.

Samsung and the Android army: These Honeycomb Android tablets will have their merits, but they will have to compete on price. The commoditization of Android tablets will be fast and furious. It’s unlikely that Samsung or others can win that game with Apple owning the supply chain.

Research in Motion:
If Apple didn’t announce the iPad 2, there would be significant questions about RIM’s PlayBook. As Perlow noted, battery life, thermal management, the software and email tethering are all question marks. And oh yeah, RIM doesn’t have a price tag either. Advantage Apple.

Hewlett-Packard: HP showed off its WebOS tablet and got into the game. The problem is that we don’t know when HP’s tablet is coming or the price. Toss in the fact that the app situation is unclear and you have no reason to pause a purchase to see what HP cooks up.

Bottom line: Apple just forced the hand of tablet rivals. Jobs bravado looks justified. The year of the iPad will be 2011 too.

More coverage:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic.

Disclosure

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan has nothing to disclose. He doesn’t hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic. He was most recently Executive Editor of News and Blogs at ZDNet. Prior to that he was executive news editor at eWeek and news editor at Baseline. He also served as the East Coast news editor and finance editor at CNET News.com. Larry has covered the technology and financial services industry since 1995, publishing articles in WallStreetWeek.com, Inter@ctive Week, The New York Times, and Financial Planning magazine. He's a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism and the University of Delaware.

For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.

296
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Apple's iPad 2: An incremental upgrade enough to kill the competition
user202 17th Sep
hen you add up all the moving parts, Jobs had every right to be cocky and kick around the competition, notably Android, Samsung, Motorola and RIM. Sure, you could argue that Jobs lowered himself by calling out rivals by name, but the message was received: Apple just ensured that the other tablets are dead on arrival. beauty and cosmetology careers
You mention that it launches on the 26th. I thought it was in the US on the 11th and other countries around the 26th.
0 Votes
+ -
you are correct
Snooki_smoosh_smoosh 2nd Mar 2011
@Bookmark71
@Snooki_smoosh_smoosh: it is true.

LTE is in just 1% of territory, so it is pointless as "advantage" of competitors. SD card and HDMI are accessible in iPad with small adapter -- though most people do not care since Apple has AirPlay technology and access cloud-based services. There is simply no need to even deal with physical connectors for most of people.

Also, 65000 tablet apps against 100 -- huge advantage.
0 Votes
+ -
NOT
Peter Perry 2nd Mar 2011
@denisrs it isn't pointless if you are in those areas and it isn't .1% that is an outrit lie, 4G LTE will be in quite a few major markets within 3 months and I happen to be in one of those markets so I will take the future proof technology without walls thanks!
0 Votes
+ -
@denisrs LTE coverage is quite good and expanding. The real issue is that the Xoom is 3G only for now, 4G is coming later and you will have to send your tablet back to moto to get it upgraded.
@Peter Perry, @otaddy: .. that LTE testing mode, which will not actually unfold in good scale until two-three years will pass.

So, most of the time, LTE is useless for now. The only area where is can be useful is when you are stuck in some traffic jam within the city. If you are in the jam while trying to approach the city from your suburban home, then you are out of luck because LTE is out of coverage there and it will not improve, as I said, before two-three years will pass.

So it is not worthy to disregard iPad 2 advantages over being lab rat with that LTE signal. And when LTE *will* improve, Apple will, of course, release updated iPad. But now it is not the time; user experience is too spotty and pricy for now and the nearest time.

Taking into consideration level of iPad's sales, LTE mode will be killed under the load and everyone would be frustrated.
  • Flagged
@denisrs you need to show something to back that up because verizon assures me Tampa will be covered.
@denisrs I have an LTE modem now and average around 20Mbps. Ive traveled the midwest and Chicago, Detroit and Cleveland are pretty well covered now. I've had no trouble using it in the airports or in the downtown areas.

Sorry, but your unfounded criticisms of 4g just dont cut it. Not sure what you mean by test mode either.
@otaddy LTE will be big in 1 or 2 years from now. At that time iPad 3 already launching. Who need LTE while you cannot use it anytime anywhere ?
0 Votes
+ -
Dunno about you guys
Uralbas 2nd Mar 2011
But T Mobile's 4G (Harley) is considerably faster than ATTs 4G (bicycle) or Verizon's 3G (tricycle).

The LG Slate is priced similarly as iPad 2 and its similar in size and weight. Plus the additional dock and keyboard.

65K apps that Apple has that are expensive compared to over 160K apps for Android is no comparison Android wins.

But above all.. you can use REAL Multitasking with Android or a crippled version with an iPad 2/iPad.

And in six months, iPads will cost the same while Android tablets will go down in price and increase in capabilities.

Choose what you guys want, I and many other users that relate to things we do will purchase Honeycomb tablets (and its not peanuts like a 1000 units). We are just waiting for the right time, hardware and software maturity that will come within the next six months.
  • Flagged
@otaddy

LTE is really not much off an advantage at this very point. By the time iPad 3 gets here is when LTE map will start to really grow.
@denisrs, @dave95

Please read my initial reply, I clearly state that 4G isnt an advantage for the Xoom since you have to get it upgraded to support it at a later date.

I fully expect apple to outsell xoom. That said, I live and travel in areas already well covered by LTE and it works really well.
@denisrs SD card and HDMI are accessible in iPad with small adapter

Ahh small but pricey. If that's important to have, it just narrowed the margin on price.
@Bagered - USB/SD card combo adapters start at $20.00 - HDMI adapters start at $30.00. Oh...so pricey!
What's up with ZDNET ramping up the confrontational headlines? Do you guys actually ENJOY reading the kind of crap Talkback these baiting tactics generate? I'm getting tired of wading through all the fanboy nonsense to winnow out the thoughtful responses, which are becoming fewer and fewer as you drive intelligent comments away.
If this is the future of ZDNET, you can count me out!
@radleym You can't really complain when Apple does the same thing.
@Aerowind

Nice catch.
@radleym

Agreed. ZDNET is sinking fast.
@radleym
Agree with you in principle, though there is also the possibility that you will find fanboyz and trolls in even the most innocuous of ZDNet reports. The increase in these could also be attributed to culture and society and not necessarily the level of controversy in the headlines.

The net effect is a reduction in the readability of the threads and enjoyment of the site.
0 Votes
+ -
so true
FADS_z 3rd Mar 2011
@radleym
zdnet used be tech-talk, now is all about fanboy devices.
@radleym

Here, here!
@radleym

I started reading the old PC Magazine in 1985 and, yes, for sure, the trend you note is one that has gripped ZDNet and ZD publications in recent years.

They're struggling -- thrashing like a man who can't swim suddenly thrown in the water.

And that will never be pretty.

Or enlightening.
@radleym I agree, but fanbois will flock to any article discussing their ilk
@Bookmark71 correct and fixed
@Bookmark71
Don't you think there are far too many tablets to choose from, and now the iPad 2 is released can you imagine how many more will come out - it's mind boggling!!

David
http://webbgear.co.uk/gis_a_job.html
@Bookmark71 Who cares about pads anyway. The entire "IT press" is going berserk as usual haha; we are bracing for another apple-gasm on how we must buy ipads or dare being "uncool"...
0 Votes
+ -
# of apps = VASTLY overrated statistic
richard.a.davis@... 3rd Mar 2011
Not really germane to the release date; just some venting on my part...

100 apps, 1,000 apps a million or more; the number doesn't matter.

Theoretically, there are about 8 billion butts that can "interoperate" with the seats of my car. The only 4 that matter are my wife, my kids and me.

I believe that similar scale-down of numbers is necessary when talking about apps. Most folks will only care enough to download a handful, the rest just make it difficult to find the gems.
@Bookmark71 Read the article, it does mention 3.11.11 as the US launch date. If it weren't for the size of the iPad I would jump on it immediately. I wish Apple would have something like the iPad Jr. Seven inches would be perfect for lots of folks.
hen you add up all the moving parts, Jobs had every right to be cocky and kick around the competition, notably Android, Samsung, Motorola and RIM. Sure, you could argue that Jobs lowered himself by calling out rivals by name, but the message was received: Apple just ensured that the other tablets are dead on arrival. beauty and cosmetology careers
It is far from "enough to kill the competition". It is merely an upgrade which brings it up to par with other devices in 2010. 3G & Camera are so 2010. And do we really care about the 33% slash in thickness? (like the iTouch vs iPhone??) the HDMI cable alike has been available on eBay for a while now.... and the cable just look retarded. Apple TV and airplay is the way to go. This release is a real disappointment, evolution rather than revolution. Apple will face real competitions in 2011 in the tablet segment.
0 Votes
+ -
you wouldn't be happy with it unless
Snooki_smoosh_smoosh 2nd Mar 2011
@domlee2010... it washed your dishes, and wiped your @55.

I don't think anyone really thought this was going to be anything more than an evolutionary upgrade.
Then go ahead and blame it on Apple marketing, or consumer stupidity, or whatever strawman salves your ego when iPad 2 wipes the floor with all other tablets in sales.
0 Votes
+ -
@domlee2010
Think about it - all those iPad 1 owners will want the thinner form fator, so I predict 7.5 million sales in the next 3 months.

Bank on it.
@Will Farrell
Doubtful.
What will be interesting is who has a 1 and upgrades to a 2. I suspect overall new customer growth will be less than projected.

Looking more like iphone vs Android all over again - at the tablet level.

popcorn.... happy
0 Votes
+ -
Your logic is flawed...
Snooki_smoosh_smoosh 2nd Mar 2011
@Will Farrell... There are likely a few tech enthusiasts that with will buy the new one to replace the old, but my guess is that is actually a very small percentage. I think there are a lot of people who like me, based on Apple's release cycle new that v2 would be a better device, especially after the iPhone 4 announcement.

You are probably correct or close on your estimate of 7.5 million.

I have been interested in getting an iPad since their first announcement last year, but I have held off for the v2.
@zenwalker Looking more like iphone vs Android all over again - at the tablet level.

Apart from your complete bias, what exactly lead you to make that statement?
@Will Farrell
My first iPhone is an iPhone 4, I bought it because it is really a great product. I've never set my eyes on any of its predecessor, why? becoz they were sub-par... Apple knows iFans will buy their product no matter what, so they only do incremental upgrade-- take the iphone as an example. from 2G, to 3G, then added (software activated bluetooh), then Camera, then Facetime.... generations after generations....while all those features have been widely available in other brands. FaceTime in 2010, really? video calling has been around for years... what's so special about being able to do it on a phone, thru WIFI only (w/o jailbreak) ? Guess what, next thing apple will do is to enable FaceTime over 3G and 4G and say "this changes everything. Again x 2"

Apple has a great OS, and its user expereince is truly second to none. I love my iPhone4, didn't like iPad when it first came out, and am disappointed at the no-surprise spec for iPad2 (yes, not much better than an iPhone. A Duo core on a tablet and 9x graphics, with the screen unchanged? really? i'd rather stick to my PS3 and LED TV for gaming)

Some people will blindly welcome whatever apple makes. Some people will question the value of their products. You may be happy with the saving in a fraction of an inch or a pound that you can measure but can't feel. You may be happy becoz u get an iPad2 becoz u feel yours has a "2" in it and the fact that its Apple and it makes you feel superior or that you're catching up... whatever floats your boat. I just don't see how it can "KILL" its competition. When clearly Apple lost 20% of market share when its competitors emerge....

don't forget... Apple started out with its iPhone with few fans and people were paying attention to it. And it just growed becoz its phone is getting better and better. If Apple wants to keep its champian title in the tablet market, it has got to do better
@domlee2010 My first iPhone was the 3G - I had gone from a WM based PPC-6700 device on Sprint to the iPhone on AT&T and it was worlds apart as far as the experience. WM 6 was extremely buggy, had memory leaks like you would not believe, and sure it has multitasking because one could not simply close an app - once opened it ran in the background. Internet browsing sucked out loud.

Going from iPhone 3G to 3Gs (which I did not) was at best an incremental upgrade... sure it had some decent features and larger on board storage but nothing I felt worth upgrading for. I upgraded to the iPhone 4 in November and THAT was indeed a worthy upgrade!
@Will Farrell Exactly, it's the same stupid people buying Apple products over and over again. I'm sure 90% of iPad buyers last year were people who had iPhones. And the majority of people buying iPad 2 will be iPad 1 users. Apple is fleecing these morons over and over. Amazing.
Given the dual core processor, much faster graphics, the competition is toast.
@DonnieBoy
almost true, except that the Xoom has an even faster processor and better graphics and more RAM and is 4G and can run Flash content and has a better screen resolution and has USB connectors and has better resolution cameras and ...
those are hard facts backed by numbers, no need to reply.
0 Votes
+ -
Goodbye, Honeycomb
Will Farrell 2nd Mar 2011
@DonnieBoy
we barely knew you.
0 Votes
+ -
And to think
use_what_works_4_U Updated - 2nd Mar 2011
@Samiup
And just think ...
You get all those features, PLUS a 2 year monthly bill with Verizon for only $100 More than the starting price of the iPad2!

Or you could cough up an additional $200 and not have the contract. Interestingly, if you get the contract, it comes complete with a $350 early termination fee. Contract and $350 ETF, or no contract and a $200 premium. What the h311 are they thinking?

Sorry, but the Xoom has a huge battle ahead at best. At worst, it's stillborn.
@DonnieBoy okay, so by toast you mean it is 75% of what the XOOM already gave us?

The Xoom is
Widescreen with true 720P playback on the device
4G Ready
Has more RAM than most business computers had 4 years ago
Dual Core
Features an Nvidia GPU (much better than Power VR)
32 Gigs internal and an SD Slot on the device
It also features built in HDMI not some funky port with a $40 dongle
And the Xoom has a micro USB port
Oh and it charges in half the time of the original I pad.
@DonnieBoy
almost true, except that the Xoom has an even faster processor and better graphics and more RAM and is 4G and can run Flash content and has a better screen resolution and has USB connectors and has better resolution cameras and ...
those are hard facts backed by numbers, no need to reply.


And many people aren't gonna care about any of that. Unless you care to declare the iPad 2 a complete sales flop.
@samiup Another set of facts backed up by the numbers is that the Xoom is MORE expensive than the highest priced iPad not including the cost of the required 2 year data plan... the iPad has never been subject to a mandatory 2 year data plan with the 3G capable models but one can purchase a month of 3G when needed or wanted without a contract.

No need to reply... LOL
@athynz

But you're putting that money into more hardware power and expandability options as opposed to.... what, style and a bit more fixed storage that's soldered onto the board and which you would have no means of expanding whatsoever? Seeing that the cost of flash memory is dropping and the size of an SD card just keeps getting larger, I would say that the Xoom is a better deal over the long run.
@domlee2010 "It is merely an upgrade which brings it up to par with other devices in 2010." Ya sure it does, you mean all 50,000 or so that sold?
@Monkeypox he isn't lying... this has one advantage over the galaxy tab hardware (dual core CPU) and the GPU is rumored to be the same one that Samsung used.

I know, the screen is bigger on the apple but that is completely subjective as some want the smaller screen for portability.
@domlee2010... "It is merely an upgrade which brings it up to par with other devices in 2010."
WHAT!!??
You're kidding!
As an honest Android owner, it's two months into 2011 and I still haven't handled an android tablet which operates better than an iPad. It seems like whenever I try to show-off my Android device, someone else with an iPad steals my thunder with their device which seems to do everything better. Will I jump ship?? Probably. Android has yet to compete in an area which they should have been in the lead.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix