Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

AT&T revamps data plan pricing, adds iPhone tethering

By | June 2, 2010, 2:54am PDT

Summary: AT&T revamped its data plan pricing structure in a move that could force rivals to follow. Unlimited plans are gone, but most customers should make out on the deal.

AT&T on Wednesday carried out sweeping changes to its data plan pricing structure in a move that could force rivals to follow.

AT&T’s move (statement) comes as analysts come around to the realization that the U.S. wireless subscriber market is saturated. The game is to keep the subscribers you have happy and that means better pricing and long-awaited perks like tethering.

Among the major changes from AT&T:

  • An entry data plan for $15 a month capped at 200 MB of data. AT&T says 65 percent of its users could get by with the $15 a month plan and cut their costs in half. Should you exceed your 200 MB cap then you get another 200 MB for $15.
  • A plan for $25 a month for 2 GB of data. This “DataPro” plan allows for an extra 1 GB of data for $10 should you go over the cap. AT&T said that 98 percent of its customers use less than 2 GB of data a month. That cap is hard to top.
  • Tethering will arrive on the iPhone and any other smartphone for $20 a month on top of a DataPro plan. Generally speaking, this set-up means a 2 GB plan with tethering for $45 a month total.
  • iPad customers will see their $29.99 unlimited plan replaced with the $25 a month DataPro plan. You still prepay without a contract.

As noted by Engadget most customers will make out on the new pricing model, which will be effective June 7. Some folks are mourning the passing of unlimited data plans, but frankly they were a bit academic. It’s hard to surpass the targets the wireless carriers are setting and even if you do pass the caps, the charges are predictable.

Bottom line: Consumers aren’t going to sweat unlimited plans if they can save a few bucks every month.

There’s also a simplicity message here. AT&T’s pricing is easier to follow now relative to what was there before even though service caps have a lower tier. Consider the new AT&T pricing compared to this mess:

It should be interesting to see what rivals come back with.

Related:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic.

Disclosure

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan has nothing to disclose. He doesn’t hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic. He was most recently Executive Editor of News and Blogs at ZDNet. Prior to that he was executive news editor at eWeek and news editor at Baseline. He also served as the East Coast news editor and finance editor at CNET News.com. Larry has covered the technology and financial services industry since 1995, publishing articles in WallStreetWeek.com, Inter@ctive Week, The New York Times, and Financial Planning magazine. He's a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism and the University of Delaware.

For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.

95
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: AT&T revamps data plan pricing, adds iPhone tethering
jackson1984-24316069205748857739440257893812 11th Oct
Truly nfl jerseys usa cherished this brief short article submit.Severely thanks! Great.
Finally. A reasonable solution that allows the average user to pay less and the advanced users to get the features they so desperately want. Well done, AT&T ... better late than never!
0 Votes
+ -
Do they pay you for this or?
SpectreWriter 2nd Jun 2010
@scottb@... Gotta wonder if AT&T pays you for this hyperbole. This is a HORRIBLE idea, because it's not an option, on the iPad situation.

Let's translate it to "AT&T screws over people who spent $700+ on an iPad to get unlimited data."
0 Votes
+ -
@SpectreWriter The term for this is referred to as "bait-and-switch". This sleight of hand is part of the magic if the iPud. Rumplestiltskin would have loved to have owned the rights to it.
@SpectreWriter
Verizon is also forcing you to use and pay for a Data plan you dont want . Reminds me of the electric company's "Delivery Charge" cost what a joke.
@SpectreWriter ... agreed. Unlimited data on the iPhone is a bit of a luxary. I assume the specs on data usage in the article are accurate and it shows unlimited data is really unnecessary. However, on an iPad... thats really the sole function. I'd understand if they started charging a little more for the unlimited data plan and had an optional cheaper limited plan, but this is just bogus. I don't have to worry, I'm not a 3g data user of any kind. Portland, OR has enough hot spots I can get free access every 15 feet or so. The worst? Starbucks still charges for their internet. How archaic! I suppose they probably have better transfer though. I rarely notice. Small communal style cafes are the best.
@SpectreWriter Move your iPad to T-Mobile or another carrier. If they're locked to AT&T, then jail break them!

It's really a rip off announcing after millions sold! ....just had to be in the plans!
@scottb@...
I don't know that this would make sense in 5 years time. It probably makes sense for most people right now given the functionality of cell phones. But as technology advances, we could be using cell phones for drastically different purposes. By setting a precedence in pricing, we could be preprogramming ourselves that a limited data plan is ok.

The tethering per month is obscene. Why you should pay extra each month for tethering is beyond me. You already paid for the data. Why are you paying for it a second time? Thats essentially what you are paying for, moving the data from your phone to your device.

Glad I have a palm pre and a one time $10 software that lets me tether to my laptops.
@scottb@... A friend of mine has a laptop with internet through t-mobile and just with regular surfing they pass that every month. T-mobile is planning on doing the same thing but in my contract it states that i have unlimited internet so if they change it they are in breach of contract, and i will guarantee you I take action to make sure it stays that way.
@dougogd@...
Betcha you lose.

Betcha there's fine print that pretty much says they can do whatever they like in this regard and you can go pound sand.

This is why you shouldn't lock yourself into one and two year plans to get a phone you can't afford to buy outright.
@dougogd@... "guarantee you I take action to make sure it stays that way." Bold statement, more likely you'll be able to exit without incurring an early termination fee, if it applies.
@scottb@... I just hope they do not screw up the unlimited plan that some of us have now. If they do then I will be looking elswhere for one.
@murp6566@...
do a search for t-mobile unlimited data 5GB and you will find that ALL carriers have a 5GB cap on their "unlimited data" plans, sprint added a $10 fee to the HTC Evo that removes the 5GB cap, I believe that verizon drops your bandwidth as you go over (ie the more you use the lower the bandwidth you receive) this I also got by doing a web search. this is the only article I have read on this topic that does not link you to the previous articles stating that all carriers had gone to 5GB as the cap for "unlimited" AT&T used to offer a 10GB cap service for $480 per month, your can web search for that one too...
0 Votes
+ -
@alellenon... My Verizon is unlimited and I've never seen a drop in my bandwidth even though I use my Droid tethered to my Mac Book Pro every day when I'm out and about. I far exceed 5GB each month. In fact, as of today, my current data usage is 7,482,433.61KB and we're just 14 days into this month's billing cycle.

And no, I didn't look this up on the web. It's what I'm actually using and paying.
I've been tethering my Blackberry for 2 years on T Mob for free with the BlackBerry Data plan of $20 a month. Is this some new revolution in I(diot)Phone technology? When I go camping I pull gigs of data over a week in the woods, usually on a carrier like ATT when we are not in range of T Mob towers (funny how tethering on an ATT tower works great as long as you are not an ATT customer). I also like to listen to streaming audio both tethered and on the phone itself. 4-5 hours of that can really add up. This entire pricing plan will have everyone by the short hairs in a few years. We left ATT after many many years over this tethering CRAP.

And seriously, you must either work for ATT or ........
@scottb@... iphones do not support tethering. it is not built in the hardware, unless itunes has a tethering software that i do not know about.
Well, we will see.

I doubt it will be good. Even if it works, it will be SLOW!
We have two iPhones and two AT&T phones for my in-laws. We want them to have cell phones even though they only use about three minutes a month. They would use more if they could get the old person friendly "Jitterbug."

As soon as the iPhone is available on Verizon, we are GONE! My wife and I will have Verizon iPhones, and the inlaws will have Jitterbugs. That is what they need and AT&T stupidly doesn't give us that option.

Don't get me started on AT&T's lousy coverage, which they took away from us at our home. We used to have nine bars out of nine, now we have no bars. AT&T SUCKS!
0 Votes
+ -
I hope this doesn't come to Verizon
soulquarian Updated - 2nd Jun 2010
because I use my Omnia II as a wireless router via WMWifiRouter. My data plan is $5 more than DataPro plan so it's really not that serious. I regularly surpass 3 GB a month and would hate to be charged with high penalty fees.

Don't get me wrong, I believe this new data plan system will benefit a lot of low to moderate data users and I'm happy for them. But if this plan does influence the other major networks, as you are suggesting, then it's going to be a pain in the wallet for heavy users.
0 Votes
+ -
Lol while TMob increases caps and reduces price
Uralbas Updated - 2nd Jun 2010
ATT does the opposite. It is getting to be cost effective to dump ATT for any other company. T Mob offers the best price if you live in a Metropolitan area. 10Gb unlimited everything (even internet just slows to 50kbps after 10Gb). for under 90 after taxes, including calls to landlines unlike Sprint. And T Mob offers the best speed if you live in metropolitan area true 3G 2.2 Mpbs average peaks of 4Mpbs.

All those of you, when you discover the benefits of tethering you will be hurt by the new pricing as your laptop will need a larger bandwidth. 10GB barely is adequate to replace your DSL line, but I have.
0 Votes
+ -
How AT&T will empty your pocket
TristanThomas 2nd Jun 2010
@Uralbas


Im with you on that one. I use my G1 as the sole internet provider for me and my room mate. Its handy and no matter what my internet charges are a flat $30 rate.

For all of you who think ATT is doing a good thing (essentially you iPhone users) read this article :

http://getyourgadgetsgoing.com/2010/06/03/how-att-will-empty-your-pocket/

it breaks down how ATT is trying to trap you with statistics that mislead and device. Its true that i am an Android user but i hate to see companies take our hard earned money so this isn;t even about the whole Android-iPhone war. This is just be looking after my fellow consumers...so just check out the article the reply to me with thoughts
0 Votes
+ -
Interesting
Pete "athynz" Athens 2nd Jun 2010
I'd be more impressed if they had a lower price for the tethering/ data bundle or allowed one to use tethering with the entry level plan. It is a step in the right direction though.
0 Votes
+ -
Called AT&T...
BubbaJones_ Updated - 2nd Jun 2010
the CS rep. was most helpful. She lowered my data plan to the $15. My highest monthly data usage was 161 MB so, this for me was a good thing. Though it does start June 7, she set it to kick in then.

Oh, I have an old voice plan of 1,500 minutes for $50 a month; does not include carryover. A few years ago as a Christmas special AT&T offered that voice package.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: AT&T revamps data plan pricing, adds iPhone tethering
murp6566@... Updated - 2nd Jun 2010
@RicD_ Heck I use my laptop at work. I work offshore so this will hurt me if they try to change my current unlimited plan. I have had the same plan for several years now and use a wireless modem (I do not tether my phone), I pass 5 gigs on most days just with E-Mail and gaming.
@murp6566@...
Wow, 5 GB in one day! I cannot imagine that much data in a day. As I read it those of us that have the original unlimited plan still can keep it; you should be good to go.

Most all my data is over WiFi which does not count. My highest 161 MB would have been much higher if WiFi was included. That is the reason I switched to the $15 plan.
0 Votes
+ -
Many will be hurt by this
tshanno 2nd Jun 2010
Do you have any idea how many gigabytes of data come down to an iPad during a single 4 hour radio broadcast? It will eat up that 2 gigabyte data plan in a little more than one session.

We buy these things so we can access media. That takes band width. They're going to kill that aspect of the machine and make it far less useful.
@tshanno

Although I agree the iPad users are being burned here since the device is far more capable.

Radio is 6 - 8 KBps or 2 - 3 MB /hr give or take
youtube for the iphone is about 300Kbps or about 13 MB /hr assuming you watch a straight hour

One the first month of my iphone. I even tethered and watched some trailers in 720p I used 213MB. I doubt I would use more than that regularly.
@someitguy79
If you were to watch one single true HD movie streamed to your ipad.....there goes your 1 gig.....before the movie is half over.
0 Votes
+ -
My Math come out like this...
arminw 2nd Jun 2010
@tshanno
12.8Kilobytes/sec *3600sec/hr * 4 Hrs = 184,320 Kilobytes/1000 = 184.32 Megabytes. 2Gigbytes/184.32 Megabytes = 10850.69sec/3600sec/hr * 4hrs = 12 hrs of listening on a 2GB data plan. Get yourself a real radio.
0 Votes
+ -
Bad Math
Regulator1956 2nd Jun 2010
Internet speed is measured in Bits. Data in Bytes. You're off by a factor of 8, assuming everything else you wrote is correct.
@tshanno

I use my Droid heavily for data all day, plus I listen to Pandora radio on both commutes. I come in at about 1gb of data for the month. I realize I'm on Verizon, but it's just an example that a 2gb cap isn't that bad. I'm sure I could get by easy, and save $5 a month.
0 Votes
+ -
@WindowWasher - simply downloading an average week's updates from MS or Apple will set you back 500MB - and that's before you've even watched one episode of American Idol (couldn't resist). I also depend on updates to a couple of active development environments and I easily eat up multiple GB sessions in an evening. And that's with no Starcraft or Netflix.

For some of us, being tethered to the equivalent of a T-1+ in our phones is a great reason to bypass cable or DSL modems and save a few bucks.
@tshanno .... and so much for watching video on the iPad.... this will drive iPad users back to wifi hotspots.
@tshanno - a 1hr audio podcast is 25MB - 50MB depending on quality. Streaming radio is probably not much more, reset your meter and test it.
As my use can vary (my iPhone is linked to my work exchange server) I took a look at my actaul usage.
Note: I am including wifi as whenever possible I try to use wifi. Its not that fast but it is faster and usually more consistent than 3G data.

3G data - ranges from 0.3gb to 2.4gb
WiFi data - ranges from 0.7gb to 3.1gb

This means my average monthly data download ranges from 1.0gb to 5.5gb
If I add tethering to that... ouch!

I also looked at my sons use - he has a Samsung Propel - and his use entails almost all 3G as he is always on the go. He is also a fairly big You Tube viewer.
3G data - 0.2gb to 1.4gb

Based on my usage, and can only see it increasing as the devices bcome more sophisticated and then next gen networks roll out, I forsee a serious data issue.
This will nake me think long and hard on my options and likely push me away from upgrading or adding new devices to my account.
And at the time when ATT and others are supposedly upgrading their networks to allow greater data access and speeds.

Talk about shooting yourself in the foot!
And where is the "you are about to exceed your limit" notices?

Ouch!
@zenwalker
ugh Does anybody know the difference between a bit and a byte and mega and giga. This supposed to be a site for IT professionals after all.

>3G data - ranges from 0.3gb to 2.4gb
>WiFi data - ranges from 0.7gb to 3.1gb

those should be (assuming those are accurate numbers)
0.3 Mb (megabit) to 2.4 Mb.
or .04MB (megabyte) to .3MB per second.

2GB is a ton of data for mobile devices.
0 Votes
+ -
@someitguy79 I know the difference, and I know that I use well over 2GB a month on my iphone, what irks me is the fact that we have to pay extra for tethering, seeing as we are already paying for the data connection it shouldnt make a difference if stop that data on the phone or if we forward it to a laptop, its not like we are using that much more bandwidth either way. and all this talk about "unlimited" data plans is a joke, there has never been an unlimited data plan on the iphone, its always been capped at 5GB, they just assume that no one will ever reach that much so they call it unlimited. what a crock...
0 Votes
+ -
@zenwalker What do you do on an iphone to generate 2GB in traffic. Ever heard of wifi?

Nonetheless I agree at the high end its worse for those users. Don't forget you are grandfathered in. Personally I am pleased that I can half my data bill. I understand if someone is an intense user. Kinda of hard to be since the nearest 3g is 50 miles away.

You are right unlimited is nonsense.
@someitguy79 I can watch a streamed movie with my N900...
@larryarms737

Ok. I can watch streamed video on my iphone. Its not something I prefer to do that often though. My points are.

One people are confusing bits and bytes. I personally have wifi access home, parents, inlaws, and work. I use generally very moderate data use on my iphone. This is a blessing to me, but not to those who rely on the data plans.
0 Votes
+ -
I like it but I was wondering...
mr1972 2nd Jun 2010
All of this actually sound pretty good and I hate to sound ungrateful because I am not ungrateful but on top of these plans I would like some friendly messaging from the carriers that warn you when you are getting close to your cap.

My data usage is all over the place. On a business trip I am usually over my cap, at home, never. So it would help to have a friendly little reminder saying that I am getting close to my data usage cap. This would allow me to make more informed decisions on buying more data for that month or not.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: AT&T revamps data plan pricing, adds iPhone tethering
mike_devlin@... Updated - 2nd Jun 2010
@mr1972 You should see free text messages when you reach certain usage intervals.
0 Votes
+ -
It should be free!
GORGUTS 2nd Jun 2010
I don't get it. You're still limited to a set amount of data, just from a different device. It's like the txt messaging scam. It costs carriers absolutely nothing to allow txt messaging, yet they charge for it anyway. It should be a free perk.
@chris.srt@...
exactly. text message pricing used to be like a nickel or free way way back. Then they realize it was a gold mine and bumped the prices up. Same business model for tethering. They are hoping people won't understand what is happening and won't argue with the montly charge. Since verizon started doing that with palm pre plus they figure they will do the same. But its a slap in the face of users if the users knew that they already paid for the data.
@chris.srt@...

jailbreak it and download pdanet.
0 Votes
+ -
Death of mobile internet...
ICU Doc NY 2nd Jun 2010
...will be the lack of unlimited access plans. The internet did not explode until the original ISPs went to unlimited plans from their hourly limits. Yet these Wireless companies think they will succeed where the Modem ISPs did not. They are wrong. People do not like being nickel and dimed. As soon as people get hit with overage charges they will start to scream as their monthly fees increase, not decrease.

We should be hoping for ALL unlimited plans - and if Verizon goes for this I will be sunk because I routinely go over these limits with my Storm 2.
0 Votes
+ -
A sad day...
sanderson@... 2nd Jun 2010
I know the rational behind it, but it is still a sad day. For the current idea of a smart phone I can see some logic in these plans (even though bandwidth availibility in most area is still very poor). However this could have a huge impact on future services for the general consumer that will (or might have been) offered that take advantage of more data. Consider things like using VOIP for calls instead of leacy cellular protocals or HD video on demand for mobile devices (iPad, HTC, Droid, tablets, etc). This doesn't even take into account enterprise applications that are being deployed for mobile and portal devices.

It is my hope that ATT&T recognizes the error of its ways and bring it back -- if not, I think this will open up a golden opportunity for some of the other vendors out there. Especially when you look at Sprint moving full steam ahead on the roll out of 4G which makes the current ATT&T network look old indeed.
0 Votes
+ -
ALREADY?!!!
SpectreWriter 2nd Jun 2010
When Apple announced the iPad data package, I was thrilled. FINALLY a plan that I wouldn't have to worry about. To me, THAT is the perk -- a flat amount, no surprises or changes. The iPad is only out about a month and they're "helping" us by replacing the plan with a lesser one? Personally, I'm furious! One month after the thing comes out, and they're changing the deal already!

Typical AT&T tactic. They cannot be trusted. I had been factoring an iPad into my mobile data plans for the next year. Now it's out, all bets are off, and I have little reason to buy the iPad. Way to kill a deal, AT&T! Way to screw people over, Apple, by letting 'em get away with it!
What about rollover? I don't like throwing away something I paid for.
Already, I'm pissed off when I'm hit with absolutely ridiculous, disproportionate charges for going "over" some arbitrary limit.... bringing my $45 for a certain number of minutes up to a $200 phone bill when I didn't even use that many extra minutes, for example.

Now, we've got the same scenario brewing here.

I don't want to feel on-edge, wondering, itching, stressing, paranoid that "maybe I'm close to going over", and at 201 megabytes of data being charged $15 for that extra megabyte.

Give me a megabyte meter! They never will, they WANT you to go over. They don't want $15 data customers, they want $30 data customers... maybe $45 data customers.

This is absolutely NOT "looking out for the customer". It's discouragement from using a mobile device, except for emergencies. And it's profiting off customers who want to enjoy using their mobile devices.
0 Votes
+ -
@geolemon someone will write an app that will keep track of voice and data use. Apple could have included that already.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: AT&T revamps data plan pricing, adds iPhone tethering
jackson1984-24316069205748857739440257893812 11th Oct
Truly nfl jerseys usa cherished this brief short article submit.Severely thanks! Great.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix