British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
Summary: British PM David Cameron moots social media bans for those involved in rioting, that has plagued the British streets for nearly a week.
British Prime Minister David Cameron, in a statement to the House of Commons earlier today, made reference to and mooted the possibility that social media could be 'disrupted' or turned off if riots continue.
Services such as Facebook, Twitter and crucially BlackBerry Messenger -- which has been used by rioters and looters to organise disruption across the British capital and other cities in England -- could be restricted in a bid to prevent further violence; present day or in future warranted situations.
(Image via Flickr)
Speaking in the House of Commons, David Cameron said: "The free flow of information can be used for good. But it can also be used for ill".
"So, we are working with the police, the intelligence services and industry to look at whether it would be right to stop people communicating via these websites and services when we know they are plotting violence, disorder and criminality".
This comes on the same day that two men from Lancashire in the north of England have been charged over inciting others to commit violence over Facebook.
Home Secretary Theresa May is also to speak to the industry -- including Facebook, Twitter and the BlackBerry maker Research in Motion -- regarding social media's usage and responsibilities during the riots. She will discuss with Cabinet colleagues whether the police need "any other new powers" to deal with ongoing or future riots and widespread disorder.
Many MPs for the Liberal Democrats, the party in coalition with the current Conservative-majority government, are sceptical over the standing of civil rights and liberties if social media is disrupted.
Liberal Democrat Julian Huppert MP said that "clamping down" on networks could have serious effects, while David Cameron responded by noting that BlackBerrys and closed networks "needed to be looked at".
The Guardian discusses this further. Speaking to Jim Killock of the Open Rights Group, the prime minister "risked attacking the fundamental rights of free speech".
Conservative Tobias Ellwood MP said in Parliament that police should be given the option to switch off cell network masts "and other social networks" used to co-ordinate trouble, violence and disorder.
David Cameron's words may come as a surprise, considering it was Britain who was first to condemn the use of limiting social media in Egypt during the uprising earlier this year.
Related content:
- If technology is not to blame for the London riots, what or who is?
- BlackBerry Messenger 'used to perpetuate riots' in London
- CBS News: British riots exposing social media's dark side?
- CNET: RIM blog hacked in warning over London unrest
- ZDNet UK: Cameron hints at social media crackdown
- London riots: Understanding technology’s role in the thick of it
- RIM’s dilemma: BlackBerry fueled riots put core privacy principles at risk
- Facebook used to organize UK riots, clean them up
- Hacking becomes latest weapon in London riots (updated)
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
Perfect way to breed more rioters
I mean really. What was this idiot thinking? Oh, right, he wasn't...
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
What counrty do you know that allows people to incite riots through any means? I do think they should hunt them down and bring the full force of the law on them. no need to shut down the whole network.
PS
And they should get there butts outside and protest not be couch quaterbacks.
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
You forgot a little [i]detail[/i] ...
In the countries you are referring to (such as Iran), it was the government forces who were vandalizing cars and shops to portrait peaceful demonstrators as rioters and looters. You can find plenty of amateur videos on YouTube proving exactly that.
The whole clamp down on social media was not to prevent the so called "riots", but to prevent those damning news and evidence to get out and go public.
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
Yes, but...
...public order still has to be maintained. It's one thing to allow peaceful demonstrations; it's quite another to allow people's homes and businesses to be looted and destroyed.
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
Then we should not be criticising other countries for using those exact same measure he is considering bringing into this country.
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
Taking down any form of communication will not help maintain order. It's like trying to quench a riot by taking down the phone system.... I only see it fueling discontent.
Uh well how did that work out for Egypt...
He may have no choice
Agreed
I do not believe in punishing 99% of the innocent who use social networking just because 1% are criminals.
Those who are rioting are not exercising their civil liberties; they are violating the rights of others. I have no qualms about what Cameron and the British government do to punish the guilty, just as long as they punish them severely.
From what I've heard, punishing them at all would be a good start. The current state of affairs is what happens when a soft liberal government gets permissive with low-life.
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
Again, there is a difference...
Don't be shy ...
and don't avoid mentioning Iran. Isn't that the whole purpose of your comments? After all, the Iranian government has been the only government openly supporting rioters by calling them "peaceful protesters".
Am I the only one who sees the [i]harmony[/i] here?
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots
RE: British PM considers turning off social networks amid further riots