CES 2012: Who will connect your future television? With Smart TV, LG fails to break from pack

CES 2012: Who will connect your future television? With Smart TV, LG fails to break from pack

Summary: CES 2012: LG adds Google TV to the mix, but the Internet-connected television isn't any easier to digest. Who will be the first to offer a truly turnkey solution?

TOPICS: Hardware, Mobility

LAS VEGAS -- It's still too early to call the connected television wars in favor of one company or the other, but after LG's press conference this morning here at the 2012 Consumer Electronics Show, it's clear that there's no single path to the "third screen."

But it's getting better. Slowly.

The Korean manufacturer this morning expectedly announced several new models of televisions, including drool-worthy "Cinema Screen" models that offer bezels less than 5 millimeters in width. That's a welcome hardware innovation to be sure -- I love the bezel-less look on electronics as much as a Beverly Hills homeowner loves his infinity edge pool -- but the real question is which company will take the lead on presenting the connected television as a simple, one-step upgrade.

This isn't a trivial issue. As Internet-connected content consumption moves to the screen it's most suited for, there remains a dizzying array of different ways to get the Internet on your TV, none terribly intuitive. The most popular involves a third-party add-on: either a Roku (or similar) box or a gaming console such as Microsoft's Xbox 360 piping connectivity into an otherwise passive television. Manufacturers have been making connected TVs for awhile now, but only for the models with the highest price points. As with 3D, the trickle down effect of features is not yet complete.

In LG's case, the company is still selling five models of Blu-ray players, effectively pursuing two paths: insist that a consumer upgrade their television to be Internet-capable (via its Smart TV models), or offer a retrofit option through a Blu-ray player.

Too many hardware choices? That's problem number one. The second: there are too many ecosystems, too. With so many players (none truly dominant) in the TV space, it's becoming challenging for a consumer (and developer) to pick one with confidence. There's a serious need for natural selection to occur in the space.

Who will connect your future television: Microsoft, Google, Roku and Apple? Or LG, Samsung, Panasonic and Sony? Or some combination of both? As televisions and computers converge, there will be winners, losers and a dark horse or two -- just like in the smartphone and tablet space. (HTC, anyone?) That sorting is only beginning to occur, leaving developers in a lurch. The good news: it is occurring, and LG today joined Sony in throwing its weight behind Google TV.

Hopefully that decision will solve problem number three for LG, which is the unfortunate reality that there's little changed from last year's software offerings. LG's ecosystem is evolving as slowly as the hardware.

My CNET colleague Matthew Moskovciak elaborates:

When CNET was briefed on LG's 2012 home theater plans, we were told there would be little changes to LG's Smart TV platform in terms of services supported or the look of the interface. You'll be able to customize the main dashboard more, but otherwise it will look pretty close to last year's Smart TV portal. That's not necessarily a bad thing, since LG had the best overall streaming-content portal in 2011, but it's disappointing that LG hasn't put effort toward creating a better cross-platform content-browsing and -searching solution for the Smart TV platform.

We still have yet to hear from Panasonic, Samsung and Sony, who will make their CES 2012 announcements later today. Nonetheless, my hope is that this all sorts out sooner rather than later so that customers, developers and investors can waste less time backing a failed candidate and more time accelerating development of a winner. Fewer accounts to manage, fewer gadgets to tuck beneath the TV stand, fewer puzzle pieces to fit together: that's a connected TV that everyone will love.

Topics: Hardware, Mobility

Andrew Nusca

About Andrew Nusca

Andrew Nusca is a former writer-editor for ZDNet and contributor to CNET. During his tenure, he was the editor of SmartPlanet, ZDNet's sister site about innovation.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • If you get a google tv be prepared to get malware and get pwnd

    And plan on watching the Superbowl at someone else's house because that be a prime target time for them to get you. Probably ask for your credit card number to get it back.
    Johnny Vegas
    • Apple fan boy huh

      Google TV is actually pretty slick I probably prefer just the stock LG but it is getting better in huge steps not just ripping of other peoples things and patenting them like apple.

      I don't think active 3D can keep selling for much longer so LGs smart TVs will probably get a big push.
  • RE: CES 2012: Who will connect your future television? With Smart TV, LG fails to break from pack

    I have the LG Smart TV box. It is okay but nothing to rave about. Still a long way to go here. We just need a TV with the box build in for wireless and HDMI wired ethernet plugin and a blue ray mouse to control it all on the TV screen.
  • upgrade

    This is actually my first Smart TV. I upgraded from an LG 3D TV to a LG Smart TV with 3D capability. However, I am loving it so far. The operating system runs very smoothly and the image quality is very good.
    Alekzandra John