Does Your CEO Trust You?

Does Your CEO Trust You?

Summary: The Bain & Co. "Management Tools and Trends 2005" survey asks some rather pointed questions of IT and business managers regarding the relationship between these two groups.


The Bain & Co. "Management Tools and Trends 2005" survey asks some rather pointed questions of IT and business managers regarding the relationship between these two groups.  There are some surprising results, according to an article by Ed Cone in CIO Insight.  For example, 60% said that IT spending was completely aligned with business objectives.  I think that number would be considerably lower if the question had been about outcomes rather than spending.  Over and over in the survey, it was clear that business managers thought IT was important, but many didn't think their IT department was up to the task.   The question in my mind is "If you don't have an IT department that can deliver, whose fault is that?" The subtitle for my blog, Technometria,  is "Organizations Get the IT They Deserve" and this story seems to bear that out. 

This cuts both ways.  Sometimes the IT department isn't up to the task and other times they haven't been given the resources necessary to meet management's objectives.  I've seen cases where replacing the CIO, had dramatic effects on the ability of IT to deliver.  In one case the person being replaced wasn't up to the task, in the other the management team had simply lost confidence in an otherwise good CIO.  In any event, the first step is to admit there's a problem and second step is going through the hard work of making the replacement.

On the other hand, if your company's been through CIO after CIO and nothing seems to change, consider that it might not be a leadership problem so much as the context within which the CIO is forced to work.   Management may say they "believe in IT" but not really understand enough about it to create a business climate and funding model that allows it to work.  The CIO's talking, but the message isn't getting through because the CEO is distrustful of anything IT says.  In that situation, maybe it's time for the board to find another CEO.

Topic: CXO

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


1 comment
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • CIO sweepstakes won at Company "F"

    We had many problems with CIOs over the years. This was mostly because CIOs were chosen from fields that we NOT IT - in our case, finance! After suffering through a Mickey-Mouse(TM) reject CIO that believed in the "software factory" concept (doesn't work - maintenance costs are VERY high), and a corporate-guy from finance (PROFIT centers - NOT cost centers!), our IT was in SHAMBLES. Morale was low, turnover was high as were costs.

    We were then lucky enough to get a TRUE IT guy to be CIO. As much as I loathe upper management's CLUELESS decision-making, this guy has YET to come out with a policy that I disagree with (after 3 years). Although I didn't like the idea of jumping in bed with Big Blue, there was just NO other vendor that could deliver on a dual UNIX/Linux strategy out there. Anywho, we got a good one, and IT has a bright future here.
    Roger Ramjet