Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Facebook flaw allows access to private photos

By | December 6, 2011, 7:07am PST

Summary: A flaw in Facebook allows users to access private photos that are hidden from view, through no less than the social network’s own image reporting tool.

Update: Facebook acknowledges the flaw, and fixes the bug.

‘Report abuse’ features in Facebook give users access to personal, private and hidden photos that would normally be hidden from view.

The flaw, spotted by members of a body building forum, no less, allows Facebook users to access photos revealed by the report abuse tool.

Only a handful of images are presented to the user as part of the ‘report’ feature, which is used by Facebook to maintain decency and remove harmful images, posts or content.

Here’s how it works:

Users are able to report “inappropriate profile photos” on a user’s profile. By checking the box ”nudity or pornography,” the user is granted an opportunity to help Facebook “take action by selecting additional photos to include with your report.”  Facebook will then display a number of additional photos that are not otherwise publicly available to the user.

Photos (such as the one below) were taken directly from Mark Zuckerberg’s private photo collection on his profile and posted. Ed note: We debated the photo selection and whether to run one at all. We initially posted the Obama-Zuckerberg and then went with a dinner party. We flipped back to the picture with the most public figures. Ultimately, we decided running the picture made sense.


(Source: “Mark Zuckerberg”, Facebook)

This flaw appears to expose private photos of any person on Facebook. We tried this out for ourselves: Sometimes,  private photos were exposed; others times they weren’t.

Members of the forum also posted onto an image sharing website some of of Zuckerberg’s private Facebook photos, which are normally inaccessible from public viewing.

The forum explored a number of the flaw’s details. For example, private photos that are hidden or inaccessible to people who are friends, can not only be accessed but can be enlarged to their full scale.

Some browsers restrict this flaw.

One thing to note: Exploiting this flaw requires reporting a Facebook member.

But this flaw is open for anyone to use — and abuse. While Facebook anonymises the data that it gets through this reporting tool, the user whose profile pictures can be viewed will  not know that their privacy has been invaded.

Update: Facebook issued this statement a short time ago:

“Earlier today, we discovered a bug in one of our reporting flows that allows people to report multiple instances of inappropriate content simultaneously.

The bug, was a result of one of our most recent code pushes and was live for a limited period of time. Not all content was accessible, rather a small number of one’s photos. Upon discovering the bug, we immediately disabled the system, and will only return functionality once we can confirm the bug has been fixed.”

Facebook added that the privacy of our user’s data is a top priority for the company, and Facebook invests lots of resources in protecting our site and the people who use it.

Related:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Zack Whittaker, a criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, Canterbury, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

Disclosure

Zack Whittaker

I worked briefly with Microsoft UK in 2006 but no longer have any connection with the company. Regardless, I remain impartial and unbiased in my views.

I don't hold any stock or shares, investments or industrial secrets in any company, but have signed confidentiality agreements with a number of UK and U.S. organisations, whose names I am not at liberty to disclose.

I was involved with Kent Union, the University of Kent's student union, undertaking voluntary, non-salaried, elected positions between early 2009 and mid-2010.

No other company, body, government department, non-governmental organisation or third sector organisation employs me or pays me a salary in any capacity whatsoever.

As a freelance journalist, whenever expenses are given and taken by a company that is not CBS Interactive, these will be disclosed in each relevant post to ensure transparency.

I currently work with a UK law enforcement unit, but this is an entirely separate position which bears no connection to other work.

(Updated: 23rd October 2011)

Biography

Zack Whittaker

Zack Whittaker, criminologist who studied at the University of Kent, UK, is a journalist, writer and broadcaster.

After studying criminology at university, though still in his early-20's, he has already had a series unconventional work and voluntary positions. He has worked with researchers studying neurological illnesses like Tourette's syndrome (which he suffers from), has given lectures on the nature of disabilities in the public community, and occasionally ends up speaking on television and radio discussing the events of the day.

He first had academic work published at the age of 22, then still an undergraduate, and has been cited by a wide range of publications: from CNN, the Huffington Post, AllThingsDigital, The Atlantic Wire and CBS News.

Talkback Most Recent of 12 Talkback(s)

  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    I've never uploaded any pictures other than my profile one (I link to external galleries on more trusted services), and certainly wouldn't leave trust anything remotely private to FB.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    hoop1a
    6th Dec
  • What else is new?
    So much for FB privacy improvements and settling of complaints against them!!!!!

    So much for the saying "keep your enemies closer"?? When they can file a false complaint to gain access to your private photos,etc.. anyhow??

    YET ANOTHER REASON NOT TO POST ANYTHING YOU CONSIDER PERSONAL/PRIVATE ON ANY WEBSITE!!!!!
    ZDNet Gravatar
    jasonemmg
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    @jasonemmg
    In case you didn't knew, posting private matters is the whole purpose of facebook :-p When you don't want that, don't sign up.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    belli_bettens@...
    7th Dec
  • AND....
    I never post photos of myself or family on FB..

    Every time I am asked by a friend to post a recent photo of my kids my answer is always "I do not trust FB or any other sites privacy settings" and I send the photos to his or her personal e-mail or phone directly !!!
    ZDNet Gravatar
    jasonemmg
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    @jasonemmg Unless you encrypt the images, email is completely public when in transit.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    mattack1
    7th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    BWAHAHAHAHA. Keep those facebroke pages rolling folks!
    ZDNet Gravatar
    smashandgrab
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    That is a White House photo, from their flickr feed. How is it private?

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/5454952553/
    ZDNet Gravatar
    bobrkenyon
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    Facebook is so stuffy about photos. It is ridiculous to think that they would allow this to even happen, just for the purpose of censorship. I have seen the photos that people have complained about. It sickens me that people would "like" a page KNOWING it had adult humor on it. Only to report said page after somehow being offended. Facebook always caters to these prudes and deems ANYTHING someone whines about a "violation". Makes me sick. I wish there was a decent alternative to FB besides lame Twitter.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    landonthegr8
    6th Dec
  • Facebook, schmacebook
    The name of the website sez it all. Face up. FB is not intended for privacy. [Sound of violins/] FB is meant for sharing [/end violins]
    ZDNet Gravatar
    fjpoblam
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    Facebook is a cult. But the odd thing is that no-one else seems to have noticed that Zuck's own presentations are all backed by that hexagon style symbol. It's always up on the screen whenever the poisonous anointed one speaks and he's even got it inside his hoodie! We're talking demonic, secret society style stuff here. All that's missing is the blood, horned creatures and chanting. Oh, they do the chanting already!

    Facebook is a force for really bad things, not least allowing the many tentacles of so-called 'authority' to pry even further into our lives. This photo thing almost exactly mirrors the policies of the Stasi, where ordinary citizens were encouraged to report on others. It's insidious.
    ZDNet Gravatar
    Graham Ellison
    6th Dec
  • RE: Facebook flaw allows access to private photos
    @Graham Ellison How's your tinfoil hat fitting lately?
    ZDNet Gravatar
    mattack1
    7th Dec
  • In the Words of Zuckerberg himself...
    You are a "dumb f%#k" to submit your personal information to my site (Facebook). -- Zuckerberg
    ZDNet Gravatar
    edelbrp
    7th Dec

Talkback - Tell Us What You Think

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources