Facebook's election data: some insight, but too limited to be credible

Facebook's election data: some insight, but too limited to be credible

Summary: Facebook had the potential to show itself as a greater gauge of how voters were turning out or even how they were voting - but it missed the opportunity this time around. There's always the next election, though.

SHARE:
4

I tend to be a bit of a data nut sometimes, looking for trends and stories within the results of surveys and so on. That's why I was excited to see a running tally of Facebook members who had voted on Election Day in the U.S. - as well as my friends who had proudly clicked the "I voted" button for an "I voted" badge on their walls. I just knew Facebook would be tallying some numbers and share the trends it had seen.

And they've done just that. But I'm not terribly confident of the accuracy of the data. Based on my wife's own experience on Election Night, I quickly discredited the Facebook tally as being nothing more than just fun.

You see, my wife couldn't get to our neighborhood polling place until the end of her work day. But that blasted Facebook popup window about voting kept appearing on the screen during the day. At some point during the day, she closed that window, not realizing that once she dismissed it, it would never come back - and she would never be allowed to display her "I voted" badge.

She hit the polling place around 6 p.m. and logged into Facebook when she got home - ready to proudly "wear" her badge like many of her friends had already done. (Plus, she had been encouraging people to remember to vote so she wanted to show that she had also gone to the polls.)

But she couldn't get the badge window back. She searched the Facebook Help forums but the only thing that came up were other badges created by Facebook groups - not the official one. She searched the wall posts of other users to see if anyone knew how to find the badge but all she came up with was inquiries from other people who were in the exact same boat. She even did a general Web search on how to restore this Facebook badge - but it was just more of the same.

In the end, she typed "I voted" into her status and let it go.

When it comes to elections, there's nothing really scientific about the TV exit polls because they're based on a small sampling of people and they're biased based on who was asked and where the person was asked. I'm sure that a 23-year-old student at University of California, Berkeley probably voted different than a retiree in rural Kentucky.

But Facebook, with a membership base of 500 million people - some of whom are obviously not eligible to vote - had the potential to more accurately gauge the potential results because the demographics and geographies of people on Facebook are so diverse.

Instead, what we got was some interesting insight, but nothing I would report as fact. How skewed was the data? How many people closed the "I Voted" window and couldn't back to it when they finally cast their votes? How many searches for "Facebook's I Voted button" were conducted?

Sure, Facebook's insight was still probably better than anything being offered by network television - but it had the potential to be so much more. Oh well, lessons learned, right? Maybe Facebook can take this input, rethink how the site can offer a greater snapshot of trends around key issues and come back during the next election as the ultimate exit poll data provider.

It had the potential this year - but just fell short.

Oh, in case you are interested in some of Facebook's data, the company has put up a post with some anecdotal data - such as voter turnout among San Francisco Giants fans versus Texas Rangers fans.

I bet that's a question that CNN wasn't asking on Election Night.

Topic: Social Enterprise

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

4 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Facebook's election data: some insight, but too limited to be credible

    "But Facebook, with a membership base of 500,000 people"?

    I think it's closer to "500,000,000". :-P
    jcpt928
    • RE: Facebook's election data: some insight, but too limited to be credible

      @jcpt928@... excellent catch. thanks much.
      sldiaz
  • RE: Facebook's election data: some insight, but too limited to be credible

    Great topic @ Sam Diaz , If Mark Elliot Zuckerberg was a ZDNet member he would of seen the Connect 8 blog by Christopher Dawson. ;) I know exactly how frustrating something like that can be , it is very aggravating searching an searching for something that should of been a simple query.In my opinion facebook couldn't handle data from a election . Social networking websites are to timid for political warfare. Besides one wrong call an it's Flori-duh 2000 again .I agree election data was sagging via the television. NBR PBS an the huffingtonpost.com had the best results IMO
    cybursoft
  • good idea about facebook

    A good post. Do you know tattoo? It is quite amazing. We supply kinds of tattoo kits, tattoo machines, tattoo needles, tattoo ink and so on. Please buy<a href="http://www.dealingway.com/Wholesale-tattoos-and-body-art_c80">tattoo accessories</a>at wholesale price from us.c9kED
    gavin.chan