Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

Summary: Microsoft has launched a formal complaint against Motorola Mobility due to Standard Essential Patent 'abuse'.


This morning, Microsoft filed formal competition law charges with the European Commission against Motorola Mobility in relation to its 'abuse' of Standard Essential Patents, on the heels of Apple's EU Antitrust complaint against the company.

The Standard Essential Patents issue has been discussed in great detail in light of the announcements by the U.S. Justice Department and European Commission regarding the Google/Motorola Mobility transaction, and now that two industry leaders have lodged complaints, the matter is unlikely to be taken lightly.

It is reasonable to assume that a formal investigation into the issue is looking more certain.

Microsoft has taken this step as 'Motorola is attempting to block sales of Windows PCs, the Xbox game console and other products' -- the offence in itself being that these products allow users to view videos on the Internet and connect wirelessly through industry standards.

As much as technology users may take this common access for granted, it was made possible due to industry leaders collating to define common technical standards that every firm can implement and develop within their individual product lines for both video and WiFi connectivity.

However, patent issues were likely to lurk on the horizon due to this agreement. Therefore, according to Dave Heiner, Vice President & Deputy General Counsel, Corporate Standards & Antitrust Group, Microsoft:

"Motorola and all the other firms that contributed to these standards also made a promise to one another: that if they had any patents essential to the standards, they would make their patents available on fair and reasonable terms, and would not use them to block competitors from shipping their products.

Motorola has broken its promise. Motorola is on a path to use standard essential patents to kill video on the Web, and Google as its new owner doesn’t seem to be willing to change course."

If every industry leader took the same line, it can be assumed that industry standards and the wireless technology we have come to expect within our devices could become a thing of the past -- expensive or restricted patents rendering intellectual property operable by a limited amount of companies.

Motorola is currently demanding that Microsoft takes its products off the market; citing that the 'standards-based ability' to play video and connect wirelessly belongs to it through its patented technology.

The European Commission and the U.S. Department of Justice are now involved. Apple's complaint has begun the process, Microsoft's has the potential to compel the authorities to launch a formal inquiry.

Whereas Microsoft, Apple and Cisco have stated that they will not seek injunctions against other firms on the basis of standard-essential products, Google has not done so.

According to Foss Patents, Joaquin Almunia, the European Union’s Competition Commissioner, said:

"I can assure you that the Commission will take further action if warranted to ensure that the use of standard essential patents by all players in the sector is fully compliant with EU competition law and with the FRAND commitments given to standard setting organisations."

If FRAND terms are rejected, and corporations including Google chose not to enter the discussion concerning such patent worries, the 'everywhere, anytime' connectivity we have become used to may be in jeopardy.


Topics: Security, Microsoft, Mobility, Wi-Fi

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

    Kudos to Microsoft. However I don't expect the complaint to get very far since it is the EU and they have a grudge against Microsoft.
    Loverock Davidson-
    • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

      @Loverock Davidson-

      They have a grudge against any business that doesn't cut them a check.

      Google doesn't cut them a check so expect an investigation
    • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

      @Loverock Davidson-
      The EC is very pro-standards, and anything that seems to undermine the value of broad standards adoption in the marketplace is going to be a lightning rod for the regulators. GOOG is already regarded with considerable concern in the EU, and they keep making it worse by their "your laws don't apply to us" attitude.

      MS went through a lot of pain to learn this lesson. Google (and Apple) are still in the learning phase.

      Remember that while US antitrust law is designed to protect competitors, EU competition law is designed to protect consumers. They are related, but not the same.
  • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

    My friends told me about---onenightcupid.c/0/m---. They told me it is the best place to seek casual fun and no strings attached relationship. I have tried. It is fantastic! Hundreds of thousands sexy women and handsome guys are active there. Come in and give it a shot, you will find someone you like there. Have fun! +_+
  • M$ and apple are pandering to the EC

    when M$ and apple fail in the market place, they file bogus lawsuits and instigate the EU bureaucrats against google and FOSS who's eating their lunch.<br>This has to stop and M$ and apple should be investigated for patent abuse.
    The Linux Geek
    • Lame even by your troll standards. This is about pcs and xbox.

      MS has not failed in these markets. Nor has apple in its chosen markets. Time for you to put away your dolls and go upstairs and ask your mom whats for dinner.
      Johnny Vegas
  • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility

    If you want to solve the standards thing - ALL patented ideas to be considered for inclusion in a standard should be transferred into the public domain - royalty free.
    • Yeah standards bodies need to reject patented tech and find alternatives

      Best way to avoid this.
      Johnny Vegas
    • RE: Microsoft next in line to file EU complaint against Motorola Mobility


      So you feel that inventors should have their ideas taken from them?
  • Seriously though what did everyone expect from google once they got control

    of motorola? Their do no evil has been a huge joke from day one. It was a huge failure for both the US and EU to allow the takeover without making this a condition in the first place.
    Johnny Vegas