ie8 fix
Click Here

Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Ready to ditch paper? Here are the 10 best e-readers

By | September 27, 2010, 3:00am PDT

Summary: Since the sales of ebooks and the use of e-readers are exploding, we’ve put together this list of the top 10 e-readers, along with a companion photo gallery.

According to Amazon, ebook sales have already surpassed hardback book sales and will surpass paperbacks sometime in 2011, and then both hardback and paperback combined sometime shortly thereafter. That’s a much faster timeline than most of us expected and it speaks to how fast the e-reader market is accelerating.

With that in mind, we’d like to help TechRepublic readers in selecting an e-reader, since many of you are using them not just for reading books but business documents as well. Take a look at our photo gallery of the top 10 e-readers. You can also read the list in text format below.

1. Apple iPad

The premier e-reading device is the Apple iPad, for two reasons: 1.) Its high-quality full color screen, and 2.) It’s ability to handle everything from ebooks (from multiple ebook stores and in multiple formats), magazines, PDFs, newspapers, web pages, emails, and many other electronic files. It’s the information omnivore’s device. If you just want to read books, there are better options.

2. Amazon Kindle

If you’re only interested in books and newspapers and don’t want the distraction and expense of all that other stuff on the iPad, then the Amazon Kindle is the best choice. The third generation Kindle was just released in August and it is smaller, thinner, and less expensive than ever. And, the Kindle ecosystem is bigger than ever, with Kindle apps on iPhone, iPad, Android, BlackBerry, PCs, and Macs so that you can read and sync your Kindle ebooks across lots of different devices.

3. Barnes & Noble Nook

Brick and mortar bookseller Barnes & Noble has gotten into the e-reader mix with the Nook. You can try one out at a kiosk in one of its book stores. The device itself has a much more clunky experience than the Kindle or the iPad, but it offers the largest ebook library with over a million titles (Amazon offers 700,000).

4. Apple iPhone

Not to be overlooked as an e-reader is the iPhone. You can read Kindle and Barnes & Noble ebooks on it as well as lots of news sources via apps and web pages. You may not want to sit down and read on it for hours, it’s great for reading when standing in lines, waiting at the doctor’s office, and traveling, for example. You’d be surprised at how much reading you can get done just by using these short snatches of time.

5. Borders Kobo

The Kobo is Borders’ answer to its chief rivals Amazon and Barnes & Noble in the e-reader race. It’s a lightweight, low-cost device that does a good job of syncing with a PC and reading ebook files that can be loaded from your PC (including ones from the Borders ebook store) but doesn’t offer wireless book buying like Amazon and Barnes & Nobile. It also doesn’t do highlighting or note-taking.

6. Sony Reader, Touch Edition (PRS-650)

Possibly the most elegant e-reader is the Sony Reader Touch, with its metal exterior, ultra-slim form factor, and integrated touchscreen. Like the Kobo you’ll have to transfer ePub and PDF files to the Sony Reader Touch from a PC. But, the Sony includes annotation ability, even freehand drawing notes on the touchscreen using the included stylus.

7. Amazon Kindle DX

Amazon’s oversized Kindle, the DX, is made for people who read larger format books or simply want more screen space to read regular books. You’ll pay for that extra space since the Kindle DX is over twice as much as the smaller standard Kindle. This is a niche product aimed primarily at textbooks for students.

8. HTC EVO 4G

Just as we talked about the iPhone as an e-reader, we also have to keep in mind that Android phones can be effectively used as e-readers as well. Like the iPhone, the three major ebook stores — Kindle, Nook, and Kobo — all have apps for Android. The best of the Android phones, in my opinion, is the HTC EVO 4G and its large 4.3-inch screen make a great e-reader as well. Other top Android choices for e-reading: Samsung Vibrant and Motorola Droid X.

9. Spring Design Alex

The Alex is an e-reader that runs Android. It looks fairly similar to the B&N Nook (and Spring Design has sued B&N over that) in that it combines an e-ink screen for reading and a touchscreen at the bottom. But, the Alex is a little more sophisticated, not nearly as sluggish as the Nook, and a lot more expensive. It’s an interesting experiment in e-reading nonetheless.

10. Pandigital Novel

Another interesting e-reader that we’re starting to see in a lot more retail stores is the Pandigital Novel. At first glance, it actually bears some resemblance to the iPad — although it has a lot more plastic and the screen size is only 7-inches (vs. 10 inches on the iPad). Like the Alex, it’s based on Android. It’s not nearly as polished of an experience as the iPad, but it’s much cheaper and it’s still an attractive touchscreen e-reader with a lot of future potential.

Honorable mentions: Copia Ocean and Bookeen Cybook

This article was originally published on TechRepublic.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic. He writes about the products, people, and ideas that are revolutionizing business with technology.

Disclosure

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner has nothing to disclose. He doesn't hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Jason Hiner

Jason Hiner is the Editor in Chief of TechRepublic, an online trade publication and peer-to-peer community for IT leaders. He is an award-winning journalist who examines the latest trends and asks the big questions about the technology industry. He previously worked as an IT manager in the health care industry.

You can also find him on Twitter, , Facebook, and at JasonHiner.com.

57
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Ready to ditch paper? Here are the 10 best e-readers
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Alright! Thanks! lv ******** on sale I frequently sought after to generate on my internet site a person matter like that. Can I use a part of your respective piece of writing to my web site web page?
0 Votes
+ -
How did the Kobo rank above the Sony?
happyharry_z 27th Sep 2010
Was it price alone? The Kobo feels cheap so I was wondering about the rank.
0 Votes
+ -
Apple at number one?
trickytom3 27th Sep 2010
Seriously, a reading device that only works well indoors made number one? Are you clinically insane?
0 Votes
+ -
@trickytom3 Or are you just disappointed/annoyed that an Apple product is number one? Jason gave sound reasons why he placed the iPad at number one. If your read the entire blog post, you'd have seen him say that kindle is actually better for reading books, but for the shear amount of formats supported and the fact that it has a color screen (can be handy), iPad is number one. Is that really hard to comprehend, or as a fanboi, can you not get beyond your hate?
@webmaster@... I do not get his order either, his statement @ the end of the iPad indicates it is not the best e-reader "If you just want to read books, there are better options."
0 Votes
+ -
Master Joe Says...Context
MasterJoe 27th Sep 2010
@webmaster@... This is an article about e-readers. Anything else that the iPad can do is completely unnecessary in this context. So, if the iPad is not the best e-Reader, then it should nto be listed at #1. Personally, I'm not a huge fan of the Kindle, and do think the color screen is a big deal. I am legally blind, and the e-ink displays just don't work well for me, even on enlarged font sizes. But, I'm in the minority there, and see the Kindle as being ahead of the iPad as an e-reader, and JUST an e-reader. If you factor in the other stuff the iPad can do, then you are talking tablets, and comparing the Kindle to a tablet is apples to oranges. Then, the Dell Streek and other TABLETS would have to come into the mix. But, notice that the iPad is the ONLY multi-purpose device on a list of dedicated e-readers? That is what I think the above poster's point was, and I agree with him.

--Master Joe
0 Votes
+ -
If you read the title...
trickytom3 Updated - 27th Sep 2010
@webmaster@...

The article aims to find the best e-reader; not the best "all-around" device. It's like saying that Chevrolet makes the best air-conditioner because you can also drive it around town.

The iPad can't be read outdoors, which is a pretty big flaw for an e-reader.
@webmaster@... your right. Since this article is about e-readers alone. The other features of the iPad are irrelevant. Also I want to know how the iPhone has a better rank than the evo 4g. Because it has a bigger screen, more storage, the same apps for reading (if anything the evo might support more formats), and has multitasking, so you can do other thing while you are reading.
0 Votes
+ -
I agree...
ryork272 27th Sep 2010
@trickytom3
The iPad is an eReader in same regard as my computer or Droid X. Its a multi-purpose device, not an eReader.

Clearly the Kindle should be number one with its flexibility to locate on virtually any device (PC, iPhone, Andoid, Kindle eReader, etc.). The Amazon Kindle store is amazing in its ease-of-use, speed on *FREE* 3G connectivity and super easy to set up Wifi. It hits it out of the park on all fronts. Its truly a "suite" of components that make it very unique in the industry.

There is nothing else like the Kindle and its a shame the author displays his bias toward Apple to anoint the iPad the best eReader when clearly it is nothing more than a small PC.
@ryork272 - The Kindle does hit a lot of home runs, but strikes out on 3 pitches regarding ePub books. Until I can use a Kindle to check out books from my local library (which uses both PDF and ePub formats) I won't get one. My current reader is a Sony personal edition, which has MANY faults but can use ePub books. BTW, Sony still has not fixed the firmware issue that causes books to be temporarily locked when going back and forth between PDF and ePub books.
@ryork272 its actually lacking too much to be considered a small pc. It's actually an oversized ipod touch.
@barwell
Kindle 3 can be used to read PDFs, though the format does not allow for text flowing to fit the display as eBook versions do.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Ready to ditch paper? Here are the 10 best e-readers
luxsphinx@... Updated - 28th Sep 2010
@ryork272
If those are your reasons, then the nook should be up there. It has PC, iPhone, iPad, Android, etc. apps as well. It has an amazing store as well, boasting more book choices and ease of use. It runs on "*FREE*" 3G and had wifi first. And to add on top of that, it can also read more formats - the most important of which is epub, allowing the use of local libraries/other ebook stores and better formatting options than PDFs. Basically, the nook matches the Kindle on those items and then adds more, such as free in-store reading and book lending.

The Kindle is good, but not always the best. The iPad definitely should not have been on the top either way though, since this is about e-readers and not multi-purpose devices. If that was the case, I'd say my laptop with multiple operating systems, reading programs, production software, and unhindered internet use would be up there.
@webmaster - as you say, read -- in this case the headline. This is supposed to be about e-readers, not all the other things it might do, assuming you want them. Kindle has never been intended to be about anything but reading. Not better or worse, just different.
Nook has a clumsy interface ???? Have you ever tried it and a Kindle talk about clunky. Also the Nook supports multiple formats. At least with the Nook you get page numbers(Kindle NO) also it has a go to page feature.
0 Votes
+ -
Why is little thought or discussion put into what readers preferred before ebooks arrived? Most readers went for fairly plain and small books, especially while traveling; certainly you never saw coffee-table monstrosities, which were primarily for flipping through in your living room. People wanted cheap and conveniently small. They still do.
@geneven Speak for yourself! I love coffee table books and books that offer me more than the written word. Sure that is fine when reading fiction, but when I'm reading a book on gardening or a cookbook I want lot's of pictures to spark my imagination and help me to understand the possibilities of doing something a certain way. When a reader comes out that can do all of this, then I will buy it in a heartbeat...until then, will wait...
0 Votes
+ -
The Pandigital Novel has more features than what is stated here. First it has a colorful scree instead of the dull black/white, as most e-readers have. It is also a MP3 player, a picture viewer and a web browser. So you can have more fun besides reading ......
0 Votes
+ -
And so is the iPad ...
mwagner@... 27th Sep 2010
@johnnychow8@ ... the difference is the price-points. Dedicated devices can be easier for the consumer to use. Non-dedicated devices offer the more sophisticated consumer more choices. Readers of this blog are in the latter group.

The vendor who wins is the one who can deliver a rock-solid dedicated device at a reasonable price (soon to be ~$100) for the entry-level consumer and who can also deliver their code to more sophisticated devices. Right now, that's Amazon, Apple, and Sony. And maybe the nook.

Whether any of the others are around in a year remains to be seen.
0 Votes
+ -
4.3-inch LCDs are a game changer
paul613 27th Sep 2010
I borrowed a Droid X for a couple minutes and found book reading practical and pleasant. For many of us, the 4.3-inch screen found on the X and other new smartphones has eliminated the most compelling argument for "needing" a tablet.
Doesn't the iTouch work as well as the iPhone as an ebook reader? Cheaper -- but not necessarily always with you, since it isn't a phone...
0 Votes
+ -
This reminds me of cassettes killing vinyl, or a later analogy, iTunes killing CD's. This time, though, I think the results will be positive (those other two were both very bad for music).

Ebooks are so much more compact and portable. The Kindle 3 feels lighter than a magazine, and the print is extremely clear. I've read a few very long books from an iPhone (3G). It can be tedious, but it works. I have just started a long one on my Samsung Galaxy S (Captivate), and it much better than the iPhone (bigger screen). By the way, you should use the generic Galaxy S versus a particular re-branded name.
0 Votes
+ -
Ipad First?
timbrady1124@... 27th Sep 2010
Ipad has some serious limitations re: viewing in certain light. I think the Nook does a better job IF you just want to read ... if you want to do other things, get the IPad ... if you can afford it.
0 Votes
+ -
Android Phone
timbrady1124@... Updated - 27th Sep 2010
My phone makes a very capable reader using Nook ... and it didn't cost anything!
0 Votes
+ -
Kindle?
Mike106132000@... 27th Sep 2010
I was going to buy a Kindle, but all your can read on it apparently is their format - no PDFs - so No Sale.
@Mike106132000@... Look again the Kindle will take PDF
0 Votes
+ -
From my experience ...
mwagner@... 27th Sep 2010
@Mike106132000@ ... Kindle handles PDFs better than Apple's iBook application.
0 Votes
+ -
@Mike106132000@...
PDFs are spatially fixed, meaning that unless the device can display a whole page legibly, crude panning is required.

eBook formats allow text to flow to fit the display, thus optimising usability.
reading a book using all those devices with minute screens is for these for whom carying something that weighs very little, like the kindle, is much too tiring. just like reading us magazine is for people who do not have enough concentration to read people magazine.
what is this world coming to?
0 Votes
+ -
Struggling to get what you are saying!
Patanjali 27th Sep 2010
@erglazier
Please eloborate.
I returned my Pandigital Novel after MANY system freezes and lockups and got the Nook instead. What a difference!!! The Novel is also VERY slow to respond to any input.
0 Votes
+ -
Kindel DX and Older Readers
WBAdairJr 27th Sep 2010
Note that by older readers I mean the jelly wear holding the e-book reader. Larger fonts make any of the already cramped smaller readers significantly less usable. For reading technical materials the smaller formats are also much less desirable. Students are not the only ones reading technical material. Indeed, many of the readers of ZDNet just might be reading a lot of technical material. As a degreed and licensed professional engineer, a degreed scientist and a self taught software professional I read a LOT of technical material of considerable variation. And, yes, to be all of those things it does sort of imply that I am an "older reader". So the Kindel DX fits my "niche" market as well as that of young students. I think the "niche" is much bigger than just students.
Come on, I know some of you guys have to post a certain amount of pro-Apple posts to keep your quota up, but to say the iPad is a better reader than a dedicated e-reader is nothing short of retarded.

The iPad is a good device for videos, games etc but not for reading books. I really don't think I would like to read a whole book on an LCD with a shiny glare screen!
0 Votes
+ -
Who cares?
CMS100 27th Sep 2010
Does anyone really care about the devices? No doubt, the iPad is the sexiest device out there and newspapers and magazines look great, but books are lame. The real topic is on distribution and flexibility. I bought a Kindle. Why? Because I can read my Amazon Book on my Kindle, iPad, iPhone, and laptop. They even synch pages and notes to one another. And my family members can read the same books at the same time. In my humble opinion, the race is for distribution and digital rights privileges. The devices are disposable.
0 Votes
+ -
I've already ditched paper ...
mwagner@... 27th Sep 2010
The more interesting question is how many of these ten devices will still be be around in twelve months? I predict that the following devices/applications will survive:

1) iPad/iPod Touch/iPhone
2) Kindle/Kindle DX
3) Nook
4) Kobo
5) Sony

... and, of course, any device to which any of these five vendors choose to port their code.

Anything else will be irrelevant in a year!
I would have to say that the reason the Nook beat out the Kindle is : Simple really - availability ! At least to ME, that is true. I have never laid hands on a kindle, but have seen, held, operated, and fell in love with the Nook ! I love the free 3g, wifi, ability to loan books, borrow books, etc. I honestly do not know that much about the kindle, other than some of my favorite authors do not have their material on the Kindle, but they DO have them on the Nook. No brainer for me then happy
0 Votes
+ -
I have the Sony reader and I would say don't get it. The touch screen ads glare which forces you to have to angle the thing in weird ways and causes eye strain. The software it comes with to sync with your PC is horrible and for $300 you can get 2 Kindles.
I have ereader software for Borders/Amazon/Barnes&Noble on my Android phone. What is the diff between this and the iTouch/iPhone? Further it has games thanks to the Android OS. This should be #2, maybe #1, as it is lighter than the iPad and as the Kindle ad suggests can be read in the sun (similar eInk display).

Not only is the Nook availabe catalog of books larger than the kindle but you can lend a purchased book to a friend and read for FREE public library books!!
0 Votes
+ -
Clunky?
kwabinalars 27th Sep 2010
Are we still using this word in tech? It's like someone on the food network saying, "Mmm." It's so nondescript that it is meaningless.
Another thought - I notice a lot of ZD Net writers enjoy using this negatively-non-description for just about anything running Android.
0 Votes
+ -
Any not tethered to a store?
justthisguyyouknow 27th Sep 2010
Do any of these work without having to buy e-books? There are tons of books out there that are in the public domain, but it's tough to tell if any of these will allow you to download public domain books.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Ready to ditch paper? Here are the 10 best e-readers
luxsphinx@... Updated - 28th Sep 2010
@justthisguyyouknow

Yep, I know that the nook allows them for sure. The Kindle will work only if its a PDF. Basically, if it offers epub, then the public domain epub books are fair game. I have over one hundred public domain books on my nook. Kindle locks you to Amazon. Nook links you up to B&N anywhere, but its an option not a mandate.
0 Votes
+ -
From the MeAndMyKindle blog: So what happens if you ask how many "printed books" Amazon sold, instead of using the smaller number of "hardcover books"? Following the same ratio, Amazon would be selling approximately 334 paperbacks for every 100 hardcover books -- or a total of 434 printed books for every 180 ebooks. That would mean over 70% of the books Amazon sells are still printed books -- 180 out of 614 -- with ebooks accounting for just 29.3% of all the books that Amazon sells.
0 Votes
+ -
iPhone over the Evo?
faxmonkey 27th Sep 2010
Evo has a bigger screen. At best it should be a tie.
This whole "iPad isn't an e-reader so Kindle should be first" argument is retarded. I've used both. Reading magazines, journals, textbooks, or basically ANYTHING with color illustrations is infinitely more pleasant on an iPad. Reading virtually any web-based content is also much more pleasant on an iPad. In fact, there is ONE situation where the Kindle is a superior reading experience. That's reading black and white books outdoors in bright sunlight, which the vast majority of us rarely ever do. The vast majority of my reading is done indoors, in dimly lit rooms, and rarely is it books-only. Unless you spend your entire life reading black and white books on a beach (lucky you), the iPad most definitely ranks above the Kindle.
0 Votes
+ -
@BillDem
Different people, different uses. As a student, I have a lot of reading to do and use any free minute to get it done. This includes standing outside waiting for the campus bus, enjoying the outdoors between classes in stuffy rooms, etc. I loaded all the journal articles and most of my textbooks (which are almost entirely black-and-white text) onto my nook and was good to go. No paper wasted printing articles, less to carry, and a lot lower cost than the physical books.

Considering this article's title says it is about "e-readers" I think it is fair to question the iPad's presence since it isn't actually an e-reader. It just happens to be able to read ebooks. Also, don't the iPad and iPhone run the same iOS4? It seems like they're basically the same thing except for screen size when it comes to ebooks (though there are difference that don't concern ereading). Kind of a tricky way to claim two spots.
0 Votes
+ -
The iPod Touch works for me!
xrayangiodoc 27th Sep 2010
Stanza on the iPod Touch has been a fantastic free ebook reader for me. The accompanying PC program will accept just about any format document and allow the Stanza iPod Touch App to download it onto the iPod. My most used App.
0 Votes
+ -
Kindle vs. Nook libraries -
Danariel 27th Sep 2010
Just wanted to chime in here - The B&N library is artificially inflated with Google's public domain books. The Kindle can read these, as well as stuff from Project Gutenberg and any number of free book sites. So oranges to oranges, Amazon's library is a LOT bigger than "700,000 vs. over 1 million."

As far as multi-format support goes, I can convert my ebooks (I most often find them in .lit format) in Calibre. The Kindle accepts .azw (Amazon's proprietary, DRM'd format) .mobi, .prc, .txt, .pdf, as well as .doc and .rtf via Amazon's conversion.

I must admit, I'm waiting for the day everyone decides on a "standard" format that anyone can play (like .mp3) but until then, Kindle is the #1 ereader in spite of no .epub support.
0 Votes
+ -
A factual error in your report
Thad McIlroy, The Future of Publishing Updated - 28th Sep 2010
You write: "According to Amazon, ebook sales have already surpassed hardback book sales and will surpass paperbacks sometime in 2011, and then both hardback and paperback combined sometime shortly thereafter."

No, according to Amazon, ebook sales AT AMAZON USING THE KINDLE FORMAT have already surpassed hardback book sales and will surpass paperbacks sometime in 2011...

Amazon is if course pleased that the confusing verbiage in its original press release has led to many reporters making this same error. But Amazon does NOT equal the entire world of publishing. In that world e-books have not yet overtaken hardback book sales and are nowhere close to surpassing paperback sales.

I'm not diminishing the rapid growth in justifiable popularity of the e-book format. I'm just interested in keeping the record straight. See http://thefutureofpublishing.com/blog/?s=Amazon+Kindle+sales
0 Votes
+ -
Jason - are you an Apple fanboy or what? My Nook is easy to read in direct sunlight. Try that with a backlit screen!
I've been researching the option to add an online version of a magazine published by a non-profit Historical Society.

I have thee questions perhaps someone would care to comment on.

1. I see that some readers have issues displaying certain formats, PDF's included. Do you notice these formatting issues when viewing a publication, and on which devices?
2. I see several places where you can publish material. Some sites make the material available to only certain readers and some advertise that multiple readers can download material from their site. So where?s the best place to publish content that will be available to the widest range of readers?
3. Which readers have limitations displaying photos?
Best e Readers, the glossy screen iPad that's a pain to read in bright light?? If you said the best pad computers so far I could accept that but since your atricle specifically focusses on e readers I have to ask, are you nuts of just a fanboi??
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Ready to ditch paper? Here are the 10 best e-readers
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
Alright! Thanks! lv ******** on sale I frequently sought after to generate on my internet site a person matter like that. Can I use a part of your respective piece of writing to my web site web page?

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix