ie8 fix

Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Steve Jobs: Thinking through his CEO legacy

By | August 24, 2011, 4:52pm PDT

Summary: What were Steve Jobs’ crowning moments as Apple CEO? The iPod? The iPad? The iPhone? The Mac?

Apple’s Steve Jobs has resigned as CEO, but the imprint he left on the company will last for decades to come.

When you think of Jobs you think of four products—the Mac, the iPod, the iPhone and the iPad—industrial design, control and the idea that integration and ecosystem matters. Some folks would say Jobs was a control freak. Most geniuses are.

I view Jobs tenure as CEO in two acts. There’s the Steve Jobs that created the Mac and was a computing pioneer. That Jobs was kicked out of Apple for a few years. All Jobs did in that down time was grow Pixar and start Next, which was later acquired by Apple.

And then there’s the modern day Jobs. This Jobs created the iPod, the iPhone and then leveraged those ecosystems to create the iPad. The iPad pricing was so on point that Apple grabbed more than a year head start. The iPad was Jobs’ crowning achievement. In many respects, the iPad is delivering on the promise of the Mac—a computing device that just works.

What’s the difference between Jobs Act I and Jobs Act II? Technology and timing. Jobs’ concept of devices that just work was always there. What changed is the technology. Jobs Apple II was designed to be a hermetically sealed computing device. The problem was that the technology was too immature. The chips, the storage, the software and the networking weren’t ready for prime time.

More: Steve Jobs resigns: Now Apple’s succession plan to be put to test

Fast forward to the modern day. Storage and speedy processors can be packed into a tight device. Software is very visual. There’s touch navigation. And you can offload video, music and apps into iTunes and the cloud. In other words, all the stars lined up for Jobs’ vision.

Without Jobs, the tech sector may be stagnant. After all, phones have copied the iPhone. And now tablet rivals are copying the iPad. Jobs was the catalyst for copycats.

What’s Jobs’ legacy?

When it comes to Jobs’ legacy as CEO there is no one right answer. Personally, I think Jobs’ legacy may be forging two kick-ass companies—Apple and Pixar.

But most folks associate Jobs with Apple. Old timers would argue that the Mac was Jobs’ legacy. The Mac was the linchpin of Apple and funded the development of related products designed to create the fabled halo effect.

The Mac taught us what a computer could be. However, now the Mac is a bit of an afterthought. The Mac started the revolution, but by itself isn’t revolutionary.

There’s a solid argument that the iPod was pure genius. Jobs reinvented the MP3 player and the music industry. The iPod with iTunes riding shotgun started the entire ecosystem that led to the iPhone and iPad. However, the iPod was missing a key element—the full leveraging of the Internet.

Enter the iPhone. The iPhone captured imaginations, took its share of hits early on and became the device that inspired hundreds of similar efforts. Jobs also introduced us to apps potentially by accident. Remember that Jobs was touting Safari as the best mobile browser. After developers screamed, Jobs gave them a software developer kit. The rest is App Store history.

Jobs took what appeared to be a tired category—mobile phones—and reinvented it. He also single-handedly put the U.S. on the mobile map. Before the iPhone, all Americans would here is how the phones and networks were so much better in Europe and Asia. You don’t hear that argument anymore. Thank Jobs.

The iPad on the surface is basically a big iPhone. That thinking only lasted a few minutes. In retrospect, the iPad turned out to be the computing paradigm Jobs always wanted. The iPod is a hassle free conduit to the world. With the iPad, Jobs reinvented computing. The form factor of the future is the tablet.

And Jobs was determined to own the tablet category. The real notable point with the iPad was the pricing. Jobs came out with aggressive pricing that rivals simply couldn’t beat for two years. Apparently hardware and software integration has its advantages. The supply chain angle is also critical: Apple’s scale with the iPod allowed it to procure components for the iPhone and iPad.

Add it up and the iPad has staying power, but needed the iPhone to create the ecosystem. And the iPhone needed the iPod. Jobs formulated a product relay race.

Will the Jobs management style live on via Apple?

The true test of Jobs legacy may come in the years after he’s gone. Has Jobs’ management DNA been instilled at Apple? Tim Cook has shown he’s very capable and can run Apple well. Meanwhile, Apple’s management bench is deep. The challenge for Cook and the Apple management team will be to keep the company rolling and deliver new innovations going forward.

We won’t know how that tale plays out for years. Apple has built a big moat around its business via its app ecosystem that it would take years of mismanagement for the company to stumble. And Cook isn’t the mismanagement type.

What’s unclear is whether the Jobs drive and design knowhow carries on within Apple. It’s possible that Apple will slip without Jobs’ eye for design.

Poll

What was Steve Jobs' most important moment as a technology and business leader?

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic.

Disclosure

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan has nothing to disclose. He doesn’t hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic. He was most recently Executive Editor of News and Blogs at ZDNet. Prior to that he was executive news editor at eWeek and news editor at Baseline. He also served as the East Coast news editor and finance editor at CNET News.com. Larry has covered the technology and financial services industry since 1995, publishing articles in WallStreetWeek.com, Inter@ctive Week, The New York Times, and Financial Planning magazine. He's a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism and the University of Delaware.

For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.

151
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

anyone get the humor in this article?
gonzobrains 5th Sep
okay, besides claiming that the iMac was the first computer designed for the Internet (probably secretly co-designed with Al Gore), I think it's funny that an article that is supposed to pay tribute to Steve Jobs has Flash videos that can't even be viewed on his own products!
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
crizCraig Updated - 25th Aug
Will I am not an apply fanboy by any means, I will admit Steve Jobs did a lot to shape the digital media player spectrum, i.e. ipod and really kickstarted the tablet field with the ipad.
@ffries@...
I bought my first Mac Mini Saturday morning after my PC unexpectedly had a fatal hardware failure. I thought it was time to finally try what all that zealots have been talking about. I've had my MCSE since 1997 so it's safe to say my economic livelihood is embedded in Microsoft but I am really happy with what I have seen in my new Mini. Windows 7 is awesome but I understand now why people are so committed to OSX.

I wish him good health and congratulate on a career well done.
0 Votes
+ -
@Bookmark71 You are very representative of a new wave of computer users: smart enough to think for yourself, despite years of indoctrination. You and your words are very welcome.
0 Votes
+ -
@Bookmark71 I agree. I own a Macbook Pro since last year. i never regretted a second for making this investment and parting away from Windows which i am still forced to use at work.
@ffries@... Ditto. I own a Mac, iPhone, and iPad 2, along with numerous Windows PCs, servers, laptops, etc. I'm not an Apple (or Windows) zealot. I just use the best tool for each task. That said, I recognize that Apple is one of the best industrial design firms in the world. They take existing tech or ideas and mold them into something beautiful, functional, and usable. This has set them apart for years and is largely due to the clear vision provided by Jobs. While I have rarely agreed with Jobs on the selected product features (Remember no native apps, no MMS, and no cut/paste on iPhone 1?), I do hope Apple continues to realize that a single coherent vision is critical to their long-term success.
@BillDem Well said...+100
Forgot the other legacy of Steve Jobs... the bogus lawsuits.
0 Votes
+ -
Really?...
Mcleary316 24th Aug
@CLHatch
Can't we just focus on the good for now?
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
o_p_i Updated - 25th Aug
  • Flagged
@CLHatch : Jobs worked at SCO?
@CLHatch Idiot. This isn't the 90s anymore. Apple will not allow it's intellectual property to be lifted wholesale from it's products and pasted onto third rate competitors. Apple declared years ago that it was intent on protecting it's IP and it has done just that. Whether the software patent system is broken or not is another discussion entirely. As it stands right now, Apple is fully within it's rights to drag the imitators into court and punish them for stealing Apple's ideas.
0 Votes
+ -
@His_Shadow: You used the word(s) it's three times in your email. For the future you should know that the form it's has only ONE meaning: it is! it's Not a possessive form!
docjay
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Steve Jobs: Thinking through his CEO legacy
ceokoro@... Updated - 26th Aug
@His_Shadow tone it down with CLHatch. Indeed, Jobs begining with Apple and his going out is a true play out of the Biblical Job, the end of Steve Jobs has touch IT as the Biblical Job has touch faith, and the World stage needs more of such actors to make here a better place.
@CLHatch Yeah him and all the other tech companies. C'mon this is about celebrating a guy who had vision in re-shaping technology. Put the axe away. I tell you there's always one in the bunch...
Very, very few people have the legacy of Steve Jobs in the corporate world. He created new industries and basically remolded the music industry. Whatever other companies have come up with to emulate Job's creations have been faint copies at best. The iPad will probably lead the way forward in personal computing.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Steve Jobs: Thinking through his CEO legacy
P Nandakumar Updated - 24th Aug
It is an unrepairable loss to Apple
@P Nandakumar No, it isn't. The sky is not falling and the Earth isn't going to open up and swallow Apple. Did the Touchpad suddenly become more attractive because Jobs isn't CEO? Not even a little bit.
So he must be dying again, huh. Oh well, death comes to all.
Thank him for the iPad, bc without it I would not have bought the Motorola Xoom.
@Violetw

Bitter Apple-haters... Go somewhere else!!!
0 Votes
+ -
Seriously
Mcleary316 24th Aug
@costart It drives me crazy. They just try to stir sh*t up.
  • Flagged
@costart
It's easy to dismiss anybody not celebrating Apple/Steve Jobs as Apple haters. Ever thought about some real worries like the undisguised control freak nature and closed universe business models of Apple? For me, worse than Microsoft ever was.
0 Votes
+ -
@Violetw You are an unfeeling nasty *****.
0 Votes
+ -
@Violetw True, because they would never have built it...
@Violetw Yeah, who wants a feature complete finished product.

Hows that 4G mail-in thing working out for you?
0 Votes
+ -
@Violetw
So you dislike Apple. May that's because you never used anything made by Apple?
Why bother to degrade yourself. You're the dummy
0 Votes
+ -
1) The Apple II
2) The Mac *WITH* OS/X
3) The iPod which led to iTunes, iPhone and iPad.
0 Votes
+ -
Don't forget NeXTStep
matthew_maurice 24th Aug
@mktpostal@... Steve Jobs' interregnum was far from Wilderness Years. Between stints at Apple he assembled the team that brought Object Oriented programming and integrated development environments into the mainstream.
@mktpostal@... Jobs didn't make the Apple ][... That was Wazniak. Jobs is the one that abandoned the Apple ][ for the Mac.
0 Votes
+ -
@CLHatch
Job and Woz both hatched the Apple II. But Jobs saw it was a dead-end system and wanted Apple to push the Mac more. Sculley thot otherwise and the Apple board chose Sculley.
I don't think it's the "eye for design" that is Jobs' legacy. It is his ability to keep improving a company that is absolutely firing on all 8 cylinders, at the top of its game, and avoid complacency. Apple is relentless, and they believe in their product, because it is part of their vision. Vision AND relentless, paranoiac, pursuit of excellence. That is a legacy that no one has matched. But the culture at Apple is in place, Steve walking the corridors or no.
0 Votes
+ -
Agreed
Mcleary316 24th Aug
@beart0e I think that Jobs has set up an environment and an expectation by consumers that will force Apple to keep doing what its doing whether Jobs is there or not.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Steve Jobs: Thinking through his CEO legacy
KBabcock75 Updated - 25th Aug
@beart0e
Very true, the man defined visionary. Besides creating great new technology he had a way of taking technology that other companies had failed at and gave it a whole new life...smartphones, tablets ect. This is a guy who just gets it. He new what the average person wanted and delivered. He did not care about specifications that so many techs get so caught up with and instead focused on the user experience. He is truly a genius in many area, even with his short comings. Windows, Android and so many other technologies can trace their roots to this man's vision. Best of luck to him and his family.
"Jobs Apple II was designed to be a heretically sealed computing device."
A heretically sealed computing device is a concept that takes some thinking about.
@Pak3141 Hilarious! Nice catch.

Pretty sure the author meant, "hermetically sealed". Proofreading fail!
@wazungu I guess the author didn't realize that the Apple II series, including all but the first version of the IIc, were all user-upgradable on the inside. I still remember putting the RAM chips into my IIc+'s RAM upgrade card myself; I also had a lot of friends when I was a kid with massively upgraded IIe and IIGS systems (audio adapters, SCSI, video boards, PC emulator cards, and so on...) Saying the II was a closed system is a joke.
@Champ_Kind I was one of them kids. I had a fully loaded Apple IIgs and it blew away everything on the PC side up until the mid 90's. 3.5MB RAM BABY!!! Oh yeah!
0 Votes
+ -
Actually Heretically is right of it means open the Apple II as designed by WOZ not Jobs is the most open box ever
@Pak3141 Given the atmosphere around crackable, modifiable PCs, "heretically" sealed fits.
0 Votes
+ -
I don't like him ...
zaq.hack 24th Aug
But his impact has been undeniable. I am not a fan of the "tight design" that cuts out customer choices; but Apple's choices have been smart more often than not when Jobs was running the ship. Hats off to him.
Its funny that you list it like that...the iPod, the iPad, the iPhone...their all basically the same device in different form factors.
0 Votes
+ -
And none of them created by Jobs
toddybottom 24th Aug
@timotim
Not one of them.
@toddybottom Thanks for the insight, Captain Obvious.
0 Votes
+ -
@toddybottom
Yeah, he just has his name attached to a couple hundred iPod, iPhone, iPad and iOS patents.
@timotim but, just like stairs, one doesn't get you very high. The changes from one generation to the next were indeed significant.
"He also single-handedly put the U.S. on the mobile map"

Really? Wow. Single-handedly? Wow.

Steve Jobs was a figurehead at Apple. Nothing more. He was the man who sat on the couch with the device that others created and said "one more thing". He is a sitcom character with a catchphrase.

Wozniak deserves far more credit for Apple. Tim Cook deserves far more credit for Apple. Ives deserves far more credit for Apple. Rubinstein deserves far more credit for Apple. These were the people responsible for the Mac, the iPod, the iPhone, the iPad. Not Jobs.

Bye bye Jobs, you won't be missed, certainly not by the handicapped at Apple:
http://www.cultofmac.com/steve-jobs-still-parking-in-handicapped-spaces-the-pictures/2613
0 Votes
+ -
@toddybottom Just about every member of the original Mac team talk about how it was Steve Jobs who kept the project moving forward. Yes, it's true he wasn't coding QuickDraw, but Bill Atkinson and Andy Hertzfeld, who did, have both said that without Steve Jobs it never would have happened.

So yes, Steve didn't create the iPod, iPhone or iPad with his one hands, but if you think he didn't create the environment that facilitated them, the motivation the instigated them, the critical evaluations that improved them, and the corporate arrangements that protected them, you're even dumber that it appears.
@matthew_maurice own?
@toddybottom

You're full of hate today, aren't you?

I guess by your thinking neither Eisenhower nor Churchill had anything to do with winning WWII. After all, neither fired a shot.

Iacocca didn't really save Chrysler in the '80s. He never designed a car.

Edison didn't really invent the light bulb. He had assistants who did the work.
@msalzberg Not to put too fine a point to it, but Lee did participate in the design of several significant automobiles. He was an engineer by trade. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lee_Iacocca#Career_at_Ford
0 Votes
+ -
okay, besides claiming that the iMac was the first computer designed for the Internet (probably secretly co-designed with Al Gore), I think it's funny that an article that is supposed to pay tribute to Steve Jobs has Flash videos that can't even be viewed on his own products!

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix