Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Tablets will displace PC units; Time to pick winners and losers

By | November 29, 2010, 8:24am PST

Summary: Gartner revised its global PC shipment estimate largely because of tablets. Specifically, Gartner projected 352.4 million PC units in 2010, up 14.3 percent from 2009. The problem: Gartner was expecting growth of 17.9 percent in September.

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to pretend that tablets aren’t hurting PC sales.

Gartner on Monday revised its global PC shipment estimate largely because of tablets. Specifically, Gartner projected 352.4 million PC units in 2010, up 14.3 percent from 2009. The problem: Gartner was expecting growth of 17.9 percent in September.

What happened? The iPad happened. Gartner also projected 2011 PC shipments of 409 million units, up 15.9 percent from 2010. That projection is also down from Gartner’s previous estimate for growth of 18.1 percent.

In a statement, Gartner said:

Over the longer term, media tablets are expected to displace around 10 percent of PC units by 2014.

The PC isn’t dead yet, but smartphones, tablets and mobile computing are becoming more popular. Gartner said that these mobile devices will be more complements to PCs, but will cannibalize some sales.

George Shiffer, an analyst at Gartner, painted the picture.

PCs are still seen as necessities, but the PC industry’s inability to significantly innovate and its overreliance on a business model predicated on driving volume through price declines are finally impacting the industry’s ability to induce new replacement cycles. As the PC market slows, vendors that differentiate themselves through services and technology innovation rather than unit volume and price will dictate the future. Even then, leading vendors will be challenged to keep PCs from losing the device ‘limelight’ to more innovative products that offer better dedicated compute capabilities.

That point is notable. The big challenge is predicting winners and losers. A quick initial scorecard:

Winners:

  • Apple: Early lead with iPad and competition isn’t up to snuff yet.
  • Google: Android will power tablets and give it more of a monetization play in computing devices.
  • Motorola, Samsung and HTC: These players could become PC replacements and tackle a larger market.

Losers:

  • Dell: The company has some focus on tablets and mobile devices, but lacks a hit and the DNA for design.
  • Hewlett-Packard: Can the company grow tablets fast enough to offset potential losses in its PC business? Still awaiting the master plan for tablets and HP’s Palm business.
  • Acer: The company will be a tablet player, but it’s hard to ignore that it is tied to the PC business.

On the bubble:

  • Microsoft: A mixed bag here. First, Microsoft lacks an iPad killer and dominant mobile operating system. However, Microsoft does know touch well and could play in tablets. Can the Windows playbook last? In addition, Microsoft is growing its services effort.
  • Research in Motion: The fate here largely depends on how the PlayBook does.
  • Intel: Does it have an answer for tablets yet? If not, Intel is tethered to the PC market as rivals like Qualcomm and Nvidia eye tablets.

Related:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic.

Disclosure

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan has nothing to disclose. He doesn’t hold investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Larry Dignan

Larry Dignan is Editor in Chief of ZDNet and SmartPlanet as well as Editorial Director of ZDNet's sister site TechRepublic. He was most recently Executive Editor of News and Blogs at ZDNet. Prior to that he was executive news editor at eWeek and news editor at Baseline. He also served as the East Coast news editor and finance editor at CNET News.com. Larry has covered the technology and financial services industry since 1995, publishing articles in WallStreetWeek.com, Inter@ctive Week, The New York Times, and Financial Planning magazine. He's a graduate of the Columbia School of Journalism and the University of Delaware.

For daily updates, follow Larry on Twitter.

85
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Tablets will displace PC units; Time to pick winners and losers
birumut Updated - 19th Jun
Well done! Thank you very much for professional templates and community edition
sesli sohbet sesli chat
0 Votes
+ -
We have to cut loose the old baggage from the last century sooner of later.
0 Votes
+ -
Sure, DonniBoy, sure.
John Zern 29th Nov 2010
same old tired line you've been saying for the last 5 years?
LOL!
clinging to the Win32/64 OS monopoly, and MS Office, but, you can see from the stock price that MS is still in trouble.
0 Votes
+ -
Good thing I have Apple stock, too then
John Zern Updated - 29th Nov 2010
DB, but then again, when backed into a corner you go and start talking about things way above your level of understanding. It only makse you look even more foolish.

Same old thing you've been doing for the last 5 years.


(BTW: 8 posts already on the same subject DB? Desparate much?)

LOL!
clearly what we mean by MS stock being in the toilet.
@Donnieboy - you just don't have a clue.
0 Votes
+ -
Guys
Cylon Centurion 29th Nov 2010
Quit giving him the time of day.
all tablets will run Win32 and MS Office within the month.
0 Votes
+ -
Dell?
HP?
Acer?

lol.... grin Why am I not surprised...

It's 21st century, boys. 1998 was a long time ago...
@DonnieBoy The reason I ask is that you don't seem to quite get it that this is not really about Microsoft. If Gartner is correct (which I doubt) then tablets are just as much of a hit on OSX as they are on Windows. iPad is iOS (I mean the Apple OS with it's name stolen from Cisco not the original iOS found in Cisco devices) not OSX - you knew that, right?
not understand??? And, iOS is OSX for smart phones. They renamed the version for smart phones iOS later. When Steve Jobs introduced iPhone, he said it ran OSX. But the important thing here is the proliferation of platforms that do not do Win32/64, and do not run MS Office.
@cornpie - you are 100% correct and he will be chirping the same thing in 10 years still from his parents house. But your right - he just doesn't get it.
0 Votes
+ -
Hey, cornpie . . .
JLHenry 29th Nov 2010
have you noticed that he was saying Win32, until a bunch of pointed out that people were migrating to the 64 bit environment, now all of a sudden he's saying Win32/64???
@DonnieBoy - Any chance we can cut you lose too? You're constantly banging the same old drum and truly it's annoying.

ZDNET! How about an "ignore this poster" button so that your website does the filtering for me?
@PollyProteus You know the funny thing is he posts, and he can't even get attention for this Alter he has in his mother's basement to Google, so you think he can move the needle for some sad argument about 32/64bit processing. He obviously does not work in IT - fry cook maybe?
0 Votes
+ -
@DonnieBoy

Yep Linux and BSD Unix (OS/X, iOS), those tired old 20C OSs. I agree Donnie, time to let them go.

Ooooh Ooooh. You're now including Win 64 - nice to see you up with the latest tech despite your love of antiques wink
@DonnieBoy you guys are all the same... backing a company that doesnt care what their customers want and has no idea it is about to get left behind... lets face it, Jobs is making the same mistakes he made more than 20 years ago only this time, there will not be a shot at redemption.
@DonnieBoy oh and for the record, MS made almost the same amount of cash as Apple and that will top that total in 2011... oh and if I am not mistaken it was Microsoft that surpassed expectations and Apple that failed to meet them.
@Peter Perry

Actually Microsoft profits are larger than Apple.
One point the article left out is units like Apple's Mac "Air" type "laptops". With it's flash memory and speed it's a real game changer in the information and Mobil computing age.
0 Votes
+ -
@DonnieBoy Poor deluded Boy... just can't see the forest for the trees. No matter what your opinion is Windows and Microsoft Office will be around for a long, long time - there are too many big businesses that utilize both on a daily basis. The fact that YOU do not use them or use them rarely is irrelevant.
Office is coming. iPad shows that Win32/64 is not so important anymore.
@DonnieBoy

Don't underestimate the power of legacy software. The need for it lingers for a long LONG time. Management types will not accept that they have to port their company's custom software to another platform without a long hard battle. To them it's an unjustified cost.
Win32 stores based on WineLib. Software venders could recompile and test against WineLib. Then you could serve up Win32 applications in a terminal from the cloud, and also run them locally in a special sandbox. Google should make ChromeOS the safest way to run Win32 applications in a special sand box.
0 Votes
+ -
@DonnieBoy
Does iOS use Winelib?
Oh, it is WineLib, not WineLab. I think that a Win32 store would be a great for the transition.
0 Votes
+ -
Do it no where as good.
osreinstall 29th Nov 2010
@DonnieBoy

Just what I want to do. Type a spreadsheet or a document on anything less that 1024x768 resolution that was 90s tech. Netbook's 1024x600 resolution I would do in the field in an emergency.

It would be like going from talking on the telephone and going back to the telegraph with Morse code.
history about 20 years. All of those great options to format for and printing on 8.5x11 paper. Soooo cool.
0 Votes
+ -
Tablets are appliances, not PCs.
osreinstall 29th Nov 2010
@donnieboy

When I look at net computing or Unix or its copycats, it is like going back to the late 60s with teletype, green flickering screens and hard drives the size of home ACs. Now they are trying to entice us into small screens, data hostage, high rents with expensive contract early termination fees and no security of the hostage data. There is a reason why this business model failed. IT SUCKS! Now they are trying to bamboozle a generation that never experienced Unix heyday. Once they find out it is a raw deal those services will taper off.
@osreinstall Don't forget that wonderful infrastructure connection we have around ooops, just lost your connection....still some flaws in Donnies world - among other things.
@osreinstall And he things Google Doc's spreadsheet and documents is cool - Wow the child needs some help.
@ItsTheBottomLine

I have a friend that gets on her Facebook with a phone. It takes about a minute and I go huh! I told her to come over and load Facebook on my PC. About 2 sec. tops. Now she can't wait to get her PC hooked up to broadband. These cloudsters are hoping that the new folks or older ones that find a PC too confusing to be their revenue stream.
@DonnieBoy :... I do believe DonnieBoy is right--about Windows. Windows has been on tablets for over ten years now, and the iPad alone has sold more units than all of the competing brands running that 'Tablet Edition' of Windows in less than 8 months. No, WP7, maybe; Android, maybe; but not a desktop version of Windows.

On the other hand, I think I can disagree with DonnieBoy about Office--up to a point. With the tablet designed and intended to be a desktop supplemental device, really a full version of Office for the tablet is simply gross overkill! As a supplemental device, the tablet may have the need to do minor text editing or minor layout adjustments, but it certainly doesn't need all the bells, whistles and overall bloat. I'm not just talking about iPad, here.

Yes, maybe 70% or so of all computers will still run Windows by the end of this decade, but the remainder will be using something else--something easier to manipulate when you're away from your desktop.
0 Votes
+ -
you would be wrong sir...
Peter Perry 29th Nov 2010
@vulpine@... Windows NT was on the Fujitsu tablets 13 years ago qnd they sold more than 8 Million Tablets.

Here is the difference between the iPad and the Windows Tablets... Windows has business in mind and iOS has entertainment first and business second (this works because it gives them numbers to impress the business end)... MS Windows took off because of the gaming potential and Balmer and Company seem to have forgotten that.
0 Votes
+ -
Would I?
vulpine@... 1st Dec 2010
@Peter Perry:
Microsoft took off because they tied themselves to IBM's apron strings into the enterprise, then offered the OS to anybody who wanted to build to that platform. To be quite blunt, without that bit of marketing genius by Gates, Microsoft and Apple would probably be neck-and-neck today.

Your analysis of the differences is in error, too, because if a full Windows tablet were really what people wanted, you'd see far more of them in consumers' hands today. I won't deny that Windows was on tablets so long ago--I've said so myself--but I'd like to see proof that a single brand sold that many that long ago without making a much bigger splash in the market. I could see that 8 million in 10-13 years, but even then, Apple has managed it in what, 8 months?
0 Votes
+ -
seriously?
Peter Perry 29th Nov 2010
@DonnieBoy Have you checked the latest sales of office? I guarantee you they are a lot higher than iWork and even Office 2008 is higher than that office platform.
It?s becoming increasingly difficult to pretend that tablets aren?t hurting PC sales.

No its not. I don't see tablets becoming the major players that ZDNet and Gartner thinks it is. PCs are used as input devices and calculations. A tablet was not designed to do such things. Really ZDNet is the only one hyping tablets, the rest of the world doesn't see them as being a must have gadget or replacing any other computers.
0 Votes
+ -
Hi Loverock
CowLauncher 29th Nov 2010
The thing is that many many consumers don't really need a full blown PC and used to be this was the only choice they had for doing email and surfing the web.
0 Votes
+ -
Then the iPad isn't the right device
NonZealot 29th Nov 2010
@CowLauncher
many consumers don't really need a full blown PC

You need a full blown PC to use an iPad so right there, it is a fail. Something like the Windows 7 powered HP Slate is far better since it isn't tied to a full blown PC!
  • Flagged
one Win32/64 computer, and the rest will be tablets running Android or larger computers running ChromeOS. Those Win32/64 computers will start gathering a lot of dust. Well, let us not forget the iPad, and other Apple all-in-one computers that will be getting a lot more popular.
@NonZealot

"You need a full blown PC to use an iPad so right there, it is a fail."

To use an iPad or to activate an iPad, which can be done at an Apple store now. I see that you're pushing the Win Slate pretty hard now. wink
0 Votes
+ -
ChromeOS is vaporware
Cylon Centurion 29th Nov 2010
Why do you constantly talk about it?
@NonZealot
That's the iPad. Android on the other hand, can be used without a PC, especially if the device supports SD Cards.
If you are CowLauncher you should remember when it was Longhorn!!
@Donnieboy - your betting a lot ... well never mind just your reputation ... on a company that pulls software out left and right, releases products (Think GoogleTV which you were getting wood over ) and so far it's a flop, on a copy to get into the OS market. Time will tell but historically Google's software offerings (their internal) are not very good, and rest in Beta - for years. It will be interesting...you have a enough babels out there that someone will call you on the carpet if (which appears to be good at this point) it fails. Now for a kid in high school or failed graduate I can see how Chrome would appeal...but for the enterprise, well that is funny.
@Loverock Davidson Yes, it is..and that's the main reason you fail on every post here. Stay in the 20th century, the rest of us are moving ahead.
@Loverock Davidson
And a phone was never designed to play 3D games ether. Now look where we are! Derp.
@Loverock Davidson

Donnie can learn by the way. I've been telling him about Win 64 and now he includes it in all his rants.

You can also tell he hasn't used ANY tablet, let alone an iPad. If he had, he'd be wondering what to do with this expensive drink coaster. Here's some suggestions:

an iPad is great for:

Getting your heart rate up when you see it has slowed down or dropped WiFi again.

Acting as a large mirror if you need to check your look outside.

Preventing you from using any website that actually has Flash on it.

Helping you tone your arms by carrying around all that weight.

Letting you see what low resolution looked like.

Identifying you as an Apple user with more money than sense.

Spreading disease with the greatest of ease (wash your hands before you touch my pad!)

Causing neck aches from looking at a horizontal screen.

Letting you play specific games, unless in a game you need to see the screen, rather than your hand and fingerprint oils.

As an oversized consumer media player, which is the real extent of its usefulness.

Yes I did have one for a week, but sent it back because I couldn't really think of any other uses for it.

I'm waiting for PC glasses and virtual keyboards so we can leave all this touch nonsense behind (or at least confine it to phones and kiosks wink
@Loverock Davidson
As usual, you are missing the point. While it is true that PCs with a keyboard are better for content creation whereas tablets were designed for content consumption. However, the ratio of users who consume content vs those who create it is at least 10:1 so that should tell you that number of PC's will go down and number of tablets will go up...
0 Votes
+ -
very true
Peter Perry 29th Nov 2010
@Loverock Davidson I have to agree, I know more than a dozen people at work alone who own the iPad but you know, none of them use it for business so it really is not the picture that Zdnet paints in the real world.
Well done! Thank you very much for professional templates and community edition
sesli sohbet sesli chat

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix