Between the Lines

Larry Dignan, Andrew Nusca and Rachel King

Verizon, Sprint tops in wireless customer service, survey says

By | August 2, 2011, 6:57am PDT

Summary: Verizon and Sprint topped AT&T and T-Mobile in phone-based customer service in the previous three months, according to a new study.

Another mobile phone customer service study shows how quickly the tides can turn.

Verizon and Sprint topped AT&T and T-Mobile in customer service in the previous three months, according to a study of phone-based customer service quality conducted by Vocal Laboratories.

Here’s how the numbers looked after the company conducted telephone interviews with 6,377 customers immediately after service calls they placed in April, May and June of this year:

  1. 66% of Verizon customers were ”very satisfied”
  2. 64% of Sprint customers were ”very satisfied”
  3. 60% of T-Mobile customers were ”very satisfied”
  4. 56% of AT&T customers were “very satisfied”

Vocal made an effort to point out that Sprint is sliding back on its gains in 2010, when it equaled Verizon’s top ranking.

But it looks to me as if this data is simply too finely cut for utility — that is, the equivalent of trying to rank Ivy League schools. (Who cares who’s best? They’re all fine choices.) When I look at this list, I see the reverse numbers:

  1. 34% of Verizon customers were less than completely satisfied.
  2. 36% of Sprint customers were the same.
  3. 40% of T-Mobile customers were the same.
  4. 44% of AT&T customers were the same.

Crudely averaged — crude because I’m not taking into account the varied sizes of each company’s customer base —  about 39 percent of wireless customers in the United States are less than completely satisfied with their mobile service.

Compared to a utility or cable company, that’s just peachy. Compared to another industry, well…there’s some room for improvement.

And that’s not even considering the in-store experience, which I’ve found to be — especially in crowded urban centers — a soul-stifling adventure. (”Satisfied” doesn’t begin to describe it. “Outrageously incompetent” does.)

But you tell me: how do these figures stack up with your own experience with your mobile carrier? Consumer or enterprise — I’m interested in both.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Andrew J. Nusca is associate editor of ZDNet and editor of SmartPlanet.

Disclosure

Andrew Nusca

Andrew J. Nusca does not hold any investments in the technology companies he covers.

Biography

Andrew Nusca

Editor

Andrew J. Nusca is an associate editor at ZDNet and editor of SmartPlanet. As a journalist based in New York City, he has written for Popular Mechanics and Men's Vogue and his byline has appeared in New York magazine, The Huffington Post, New York Daily News, Editor & Publisher, New York Press and many others. He also writes The Editorialiste, a media criticism blog.

He is a New York University graduate and former news editor and columnist of the Washington Square News. He is a graduate of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism. He has been named "Howard Kurtz, Jr." by film critic John Lichman despite having no relation to him. He lives in his native Philadelphia with his wife, cat and Boston Terrier.

Follow him on Twitter.

25
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Flipped experience
XenophonJones 24th Aug
I've been on AT&T as a consumer for six years now, but I administered a multi-phone Verizon plan for my job a couple years ago.

I think it's very important to note that there's a distinction between the service provided and the customer service. The service provided is the coverage and the quality of the signal. Customer service is the courtesy and quality of interpersonal communication you experience when trying to address an issue with the company providing the service. I think a lot of respondents don't understand this in the least. A corner diner can have inferior food offerings but prompt, friendly service, and a pricey restaurant can have amazing cuisine but slow, snotty waiters.

I acknowledge that Verizon's voice service is generally superior to AT&T's. Living in a major metropolitan area, I don't notice much of a difference. Verizon's 3G is slower than AT&T's 3G on their best days. All in all, I haven't felt like I've missed much being on AT&T, and I've chosen to remain on AT&T given its vastly superior international prices, service, and coverage.

So, that being said, while Verizon has a vaguely better product, I was absolutely shocked by how difficult it was to get through to a representative with Verizon over the phone. Their phone tree was absolutely designed to keep you from dealing with a human being. I'm a smart guy and know when I don't need to talk directly to a person - I actually prefer to deal with things myself either online or through automated systems. But every so often you've got a quirky need that automated systems just weren't designed to address. Verizon's system was a massive time-waster. Maybe that's changed in the three years since I had to work with them, but it didn't even compare to my experiences I've had with AT&T's customer service over the years.

With AT&T, it's always been fast and direct to get a human being on the line, and they've always been helpful and friendly - at least in my experience. If you're calling AT&T expecting the customer service rep to personally build a new transmitting tower in a matter of 24 hours near where you feel your coverage is lacking, well, sorry. That's even harder for them to accomplish than it would be for the server at that corner hamburger joint to get you the finest beluga caviar off-menu on a moment's notice. But you can't fault the rep if they were easy to reach and nice with you.

That's been my experience.
0 Votes
+ -
AT&T Once Again SUCKS
BallmerFail 2nd Aug
Can't wait until fall, Verizon here I come!!!
0 Votes
+ -
Verizon SUCKS
blind obedience 2nd Aug
After 5 years of being nickled & dimed, it's time for Sprint!
I have never had a carrier other than Verizon, unless you count GTE who became part of Verizon, so I can't compare VZ with others, but I have one of the "very satisfied" VZ customers.

My wife, 2 children and I share a family plan with 2 Android phones and 2 regular feature phones.

Every 3 months, VZ sends me a package showing what I am paying and offering suggestions on plans which might be more competitive.

I have done business with 2 VZ stores in the SF Bay Area of CA and have gotten great service both times. The ultimate was when I wanted a netbook for my father and asked if they could let him pick it up at a Verizon store near him. Instead, they gave me a box with prepaid shipping tags at no cost to me so I could load it with software before sending it to him.

As I said, I don't know whether other carriers are just as good, but Verizon has given me no reason to find out.
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
bfriskey Updated - 2nd Aug
@bfriskey You're surrounded by idiots, and yet YOU capitalize everything...
Don't agree about Verizon, but others okay. I like Sprint's customer service so far, very professional. When talking to Verizon, all I feel is greed, greed, greed from them. And I can easily see why AT&T didn't make the list, greed, greed, greed.
@ITOdeed - I'm an AT&T employee. Can you explain what you mean by "greed, greed, greed"? Are you referring to the anticipated T-Mobile merger? Thanks.
@JohniPhoneLover That along with the fact that their rates are comparable to Verizon in terms of being outrageously OVER-priced.

I've talked with friends who are with AT&T and they can't STAND their service or rates. Many of them have also talked about moving to other providers. I also talk with Sprint, Verizon, and AT&T Customer Care on a regular basis; none of them are worth a damn, IMHO.

I'm a T-Mobile customer and I have had nothing but incredible experiences with customer service and the stores. Frankly, I am praying the AT&T merger does NOT happen.
@JohniPhoneLover
I tend to agree that AT&T plans are overpriced - they (like Verizono) want to nickel and dime you to death.

I moved my family plan from AT&T to Sprint. I am paying $250 ( taxes included) a month for five (5) EVO 4G lines, everything is unlimited (text, data, mobile-to-mobile).
Note: no, I am not a Rockfeller, my kids pay me back their share.

Can I get the same pricing on either Verizon or AT&T?
You think AT&T is bad now, if the the take-over of T-Mobile is allowed to go through (with enough under the table political donations) tech support will end up with "Peggy" in his little shack!
0 Votes
+ -
Peggy
jaybyrd 2nd Aug
@rverhelst I thought 'Peggy' was pretty 'hot', the boss too...lol
Sprint? Worst system out there. Slow outside the major urban areas it services, doesn't work inside buildings, shll I continue. Of course that means they have to try and be nice to their customers.
@Romas27
dont know where you live. Sprint works fine in buildings in Atlanta. AT&T wont even work here if you are standing next to a window.
@Romas27 Strange... I have been using mine Sprint phones inside buildings everyday for 11 years... They always work. In fact, Sprint and Verizon are both great... but we have plenty of AT&T users here who have trouble constantly with dropped calls..

Don't know why it was flagged as Spam? I just typed this in... WEIRD. ok.. it isn't anymore... ZDNET.. Fix spam filters!
Sprint has the worst customer service in the history of customer service... and ATT is worse ? OUCH !

Glad I went to Verizon happy
@gtatransam@... Agreed. I stick with Sprint for the sole reason that it feels to me like the lesser of two (three?) evils. I made the moronic mistake to upgrade the four phones on my business plan last year and sign another two year contract. Of course, NOTHING about the order was fulfilled properly which cost me a total of 16 hours phone time trying to resolve it, getting bounced from one person in "customer service" to another. And not one of them giving me the same story as to the cause of the problem and the solution.


If they are rated better than AT&T and on par with Verizon, that just shows you how bad the customer service end of a service industry is and how Americans are fools (including me) for accepting it.

God, I feel dirty now.
0 Votes
+ -
Verizon was a NIGHTMARE
mtelesha 2nd Aug
Sprint = Cheapest Data Plan. Service has always been nice even when I am in total disagreement with a policy and they do things to keep me as a customer.

Verizon was the worst customer service I have ever had and they cost TOO MUCH MONEY! I went from Nextel to Verizon on a shared planned and they made an error. It was that we had zero minutes so every minute was at full rate. My first $400 bill was a little shocking and funny. After an hour I was told we are all fine. Then after 4 months of it I was done. I was called a liar by a Verizon rep who told me he would not help me since they are not in error but me. Then when we had a death in the family and went 150 minutes over they got us for $100 and nothing to help us.
0 Votes
+ -
Since they're so big...
blind obedience Updated - 2nd Aug
...they take their customers for granted. And get away with it, too.

I hope you went with another carrier.
I have to say that I was very very happy to say goodbye to AT&T a few months ago! Overpriced, nickle & dime you to death fee's, terrible customer service with more dropped calls in the last few years then I have ever experienced in the 6 plus years prior I was with them. Switched to Sprint and so far have been very happy with call quality, data speeds on 3g & 4g have been great! Only dealt with customer service once and they were great!
hahaha this is TRUE of SPRINT. They are best phone provider now and great plans UNLIMITTED yup i said it not like crappy tmobile which you be lucky get a signal and ATT cutting off unlimitted and will be charging now hahahaha also verizon will be doing that too
I've been happy with Sprint for most of my time with them. But even they are trying to get more money from us. I have a Palm Centro and I'm told that if I activate a new Centro (like if mine dies and I buy from eBay), I'll be charged an additional $10/month smartphone fee.
My experiences with both ATT and VZW are mediocre at best.

I have to use mobile broadband where I live. I had unlimited data with ATT, and they switched my plan to 5 gig a month. When I called, customer service said, "Ooops, our mistake, but you did not call us soon enough to tell us about our mistake, so, tough luck". I was leaving anyway so I did not pursue the issue. In my area, ATT mobile broadband switched between 2g and 3g.

I switched to VZW for the data connection. Recently I upgraded to a Droid X2. The unit "spontaneously rebooted" 4-5 times a day. I called support after 17 days to ask for a new unit. VZW said, "Too bad, you are 3 days over the replacement period". They offered to send a "like new" (used) replacement. After several frustrating conversations with customer (no)service, I connected with a tech rep who agreed that changing from a 30 day to a 14 day return policy was not very customer friendly. She called, my local store, talked to the manager, and I picked up a new replacement that day. It was a happy ending, but it was still a headache.
My experiences with both ATT and VZW are mediocre at best.

I have to use mobile broadband where I live. I had unlimited data with ATT, and they switched my plan to 5 gig a month. When I called, customer service said, "Ooops, our mistake, but you did not call us soon enough to tell us about our mistake, so, tough luck". I was leaving anyway so I did not pursue the issue. In my area, ATT mobile broadband switched between 2g and 3g.

I switched to VZW for the data connection. Recently, I upgraded to a Droid X2. The unit "spontaneously rebooted" 4-5 times a day. I called support after 17 days to ask for a new unit. VZW said, "Too bad, you are 3 days over the replacement period". They offered to send a "like new" (used) replacement. After several frustrating conversations with customer (no)service, I connected with a tech rep who agreed that changing from a 30 day to a 14 day return policy was not very customer friendly. She called, my local store, talked to the manager, and I picked up a new replacement that day. It was a happy ending, but it was still a headache.
For a wireless company I think its a conspiracy that they keep you on the phone for hours when you want to solve a simple issue. I'm with AT&T, my mom with Sprint, and my dad with T-Mobile and honestly, its a lose lose situation. I took AT&T's customer service survey and made sure to tell them, in detail, how horrible they are at customer support. I doubt the merger will change things but I'm ready to move on without them.
0 Votes
+ -
Flipped experience
XenophonJones 24th Aug
I've been on AT&T as a consumer for six years now, but I administered a multi-phone Verizon plan for my job a couple years ago.

I think it's very important to note that there's a distinction between the service provided and the customer service. The service provided is the coverage and the quality of the signal. Customer service is the courtesy and quality of interpersonal communication you experience when trying to address an issue with the company providing the service. I think a lot of respondents don't understand this in the least. A corner diner can have inferior food offerings but prompt, friendly service, and a pricey restaurant can have amazing cuisine but slow, snotty waiters.

I acknowledge that Verizon's voice service is generally superior to AT&T's. Living in a major metropolitan area, I don't notice much of a difference. Verizon's 3G is slower than AT&T's 3G on their best days. All in all, I haven't felt like I've missed much being on AT&T, and I've chosen to remain on AT&T given its vastly superior international prices, service, and coverage.

So, that being said, while Verizon has a vaguely better product, I was absolutely shocked by how difficult it was to get through to a representative with Verizon over the phone. Their phone tree was absolutely designed to keep you from dealing with a human being. I'm a smart guy and know when I don't need to talk directly to a person - I actually prefer to deal with things myself either online or through automated systems. But every so often you've got a quirky need that automated systems just weren't designed to address. Verizon's system was a massive time-waster. Maybe that's changed in the three years since I had to work with them, but it didn't even compare to my experiences I've had with AT&T's customer service over the years.

With AT&T, it's always been fast and direct to get a human being on the line, and they've always been helpful and friendly - at least in my experience. If you're calling AT&T expecting the customer service rep to personally build a new transmitting tower in a matter of 24 hours near where you feel your coverage is lacking, well, sorry. That's even harder for them to accomplish than it would be for the server at that corner hamburger joint to get you the finest beluga caviar off-menu on a moment's notice. But you can't fault the rep if they were easy to reach and nice with you.

That's been my experience.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix