iPhone 4S, Nokia N8, Lumia 900, N9, and HTC One X camera phone shootout

iPhone 4S, Nokia N8, Lumia 900, N9, and HTC One X camera phone shootout

Summary: The cameras on phones just keep getting better and better and the great thing is that most of the higher end models compare well with each other too.

SHARE:
20

I took a basic look at the cameras on four smartphones last October and my results were pretty close. I have several smartphones in my possession at this time so I decided to compare the Apple iPhone 4S, Nokia N8, Nokia Lumia 900, Nokia N9, and HTC One X in a few typical scenarios. It was very tough to judge the differences in a couple shots and in the end it turns out four of the five were about the same with only one clear loser in the bunch.

As you can see in my image gallery I captured the following photos to compare the camera on each smartphone:

  • Potted flowers in sun
  • Typical shot of the yard
  • Outside day shot of my truck and trailer
  • Macro shot of flowers
  • Macro shot in complete darkness


Image Gallery: Check out several sample photos taken with these five smartphones in various situations. Image Gallery: 5 candidate smartphones Image Gallery: Close up with the Nokia Lumia 900

Some phones have a ton of settings and some have hardly any (look at the Apple iPhone 4S), but to conduct a comparison of a typical smartphone user I left everything in auto mode, except for the two macro shots. Most people never mess with the ISO, white balance, and other settings available, but if you take the time you can improve your shots on most phones. The photos were unaltered, except to be resized to fit our ZDNet gallery dimensions.

I ranked each photo from 1 to 5 in a direct comparison to each other and present the totals of my rankings in the table below with 1 being the 1st place phone so that the lowest total score is the winner in my comparison. Some were very tough to decide and I gave out a tie. As you can see in the end the winner could have been any of the phones, but the Nokia N9. I went into this shootout thinking the HTC One X would blow out the competition and the Nokia Lumia 900 would lag behind most others. Keep in mind though that this was a limited test of some real world situations and the judging was up to my personal ability to discern differences in the photos. We also have different inherent bias in what we thing a good photo is. For example, some prefer more detail while others prefer more vibrant colors, so your judgement of the photos is likely different than mine. Also some devices excel in certain areas while others do a fair job overall. Read on below to find out how my ratings shook out and take a look at the photos yourself to see if you agree.

The Competitors

Apple iPhone 4S

The iPhone 4S has the best camera that Apple has ever had in an iPhone with an upgrade to 8 megapixels, f/2.4 aperture, face detection, and pinch to zoom. The iPhone 4S is very responsive in going from capturing a picture to being ready for the next one, but others are even faster today as you can see on the HTC One X. You can open the camera right from the lock screen by simply pressing the Home button twice and then sliding the camera icon up.

You will notice that the iPhone 4S camera software is the most basic of all of these device with very few options for you to change. The thing is, the majority of people don't want to mess with settings and just want to be able to point and shoot. Apple's camera software still takes decent macro shots or low light shots without any manual change in settings. It doesn't do that well at focusing in dark conditions though. You can toggle the flash on and off (no red eye mode), toggle the grid, and toggle HDR mode. That's it for any settings in the software.

To zoom you pinch and zoom on the display. To focus on something other than what the software picks up you can tap on the display to do so. You can also perform editing of your photos on the iPhone 4S.

You can capture video in 1080p high resolution on the iPhone 4S, but I didn't compare video in this article.

Nokia N8 Symbian device

The Nokia N8 has been out for more than a year and has served in the role as the leader of all camera phones with its 12 megapixel camera, Carl Zeiss lens, f/2.8 aperture, and Xenon lens. There are a LOT of things you can do with the Nokia N8, in terms of manual settings and taking advantage of the hardware in the camera and if you search online you will find many fantastic photos taken with the device. When I travel I still take along the N8 as my point and shoot and have been very happy with it.

The camera software in the N8 has been improved over the last year and even though things such as panorama and HDR are not in the default software, that's all I am using for this comparison, you can find 3rd party apps to enable these functions. There is full 12 megapixel mode and 9 megapixel wide screen 16:9 mode.

There are several settings in the N8 software so take some time scrolling through the menus. Modes include the following:

  • Automatic
  • Custom
  • Close-up
  • Portrait
  • Landscape
  • Sport
  • Night
  • Night portrait

You will also find red-eye flash mode on the N8 and the Xenon flash really cannot be beat by any LED flash camera phone, just check the pitch black shot in my image gallery. Video is also captured 720p high resolution.

Like the Nokia Lumia 900 there is a physical capture button on the Nokia N8. You cannot launch it from a locked device though.

Nokia Lumia 900 Windows Phone device

The Nokia Lumia 900 just launched a few weeks ago on AT&T and as I stated in my recent article I purchased a white one for myself. Windows Phone is setup to help you take photos quickly and easily with a requirement for a physical capture button and ability to take photos without having to unlock the phone.

The camera on the Lumia 900 has a f/2.2 aperture and Carl Zeiss optics and it actually works quite well. I have seen much better on other Nokia devices in the past and wonder if the Microsoft software is limiting what Nokia can do on the Lumia 900.

There are several settings in the Nokia Lumia 800's software so take some time scrolling through the menus. Scenes include the following:

  • Beach
  • Candlelight
  • Macro
  • Landscape
  • Night
  • Portrait
  • Snow
  • Sports
  • Sunset

You will also find settings for white balance, exposure value, ISO, metering mode, effects, contrast, saturation, focus mode, resolution, and flicker reduction. Video is captured in 720p high resolution.

I highly recommend you check out this article regarding how to optimize your camera usage on the Lumia 900. I tried setting the Focus Mode to Macro for all shots and am seeing better camera performance too.

Nokia N9 MeeGo device

The Nokia N9 is the second, the N950 launched in limited quantities for developers, MeeGo powered device coming from Nokia. It launched in a few select countries and unfortunately we won't see it here in the U.S. from Nokia directly. I included it here since it is one of the newest devices to hit the streets and given that Nokia excels in camera phones I thought it worthy of a look. Make sure to check out this article where Damian Dinning discusses the N9 camera he helped create.

The Nokia N9 comes with an 8 megapixel camera with Carl Zeiss optics, f/2.2 aperture (matches that of the latest devices), and some amazing features detailed in the Nokia Conversations article.

I recommend you use auto for taking macro shots as the macro mode doesn't bring objects into focus very well. Settings and modes on the N9 include the following:

  • Automatic
  • Macro
  • Landscape
  • Portrait
  • Night
  • Sports

You will also find a red-eye flash, different aspect ratios, face detection and much more in the settings. Nokia includes editing software on both the N9 and the N8.

HTC One X Android device

It's great to see HTC improving the optics on their devices and the HTC One X on AT&T is a fantastic device with a ton of camera enhancements and options. I chose it as the first place contender in my typical shots, but had it scoring in the middle of the pack for macro shots. It is a very good camera phone and with all of the different modes, you can really optimize it for your shooting needs.

You will find the following scene modes on the HTC One X, along with dedicated camera and video recording buttons, a flash button, advanced settings button, and an Instagram-like filter button,:

  • Auto mode
  • HDR
  • Panorama
  • Portrait
  • Group portrait
  • Landscape
  • Whiteboard
  • Close up
  • Low light

The HTC One X, and the One S, integrate HTC's new camera technology that allows you to take photos in rapid succession. In addition, you can even capture still images while recording video at the same time. Other settings include choosing the camera (you can take stills with the front facing camera if you like), setting the time, selection resolution, making image adjustments in regards to exposure, contrast and saturation, white balance, continuous shooting toggle, face detection toggle, auto smile, widescreen, geo-tag, and upload frequency.

You can also shoot slow motion video with the HTC One X. Video is capable of being recored at 1080p.

Summary table and my pick for best camera phone »

Comparison Table

Here you can see my selection of first through fifth place in each of the five situations that I took photos. The lower the score the higher the ranking as it was simply a 1 through 5 rating scale between all five phones.
Apple iPhone 4S Nokia N8 Nokia Lumia 900 Nokia N9 HTC One X
Outside flower pot 2 1 2 3 3
Typical yard shot 2 3 4 5 1
Truck and trailer shot 1 3 2 4 1
Macro of flowers 2 4 1 5 3
Pitch black macro mode 4 1 2 5 3
Total 11 12 11 22 11

Is there a clear winner?

As you can see the results were very close with three devices tied at 11 points, one at 12 points, and the Nokia N9 at 23 points. You should be able to take fine photos with any of them so I don't think the camera is really the major differentiator when selecting from one of these. The Nokia Lumia 900 did much better than I thought it would while the N9 really didn't show up as well in this particular comparison. The Nokia N8 easily beats others when used with the Xenon flash, but other cameras are catching up to it and even beating it in everyday usage scenarios.

Look through the photos in my image gallery and let me know what phone you think is the best at taking photos.

[poll id="42"]

Back to the beginning »

Topics: iPhone, Hardware, HTC, Mobility, Nokia

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

20 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • What is funny about this...

    The One X is using the same camera as the Rezound and I have been saying for months the Rezound is overall superior to the iPhone 4s for overall image quality, speed and sound quality.
    slickjim
  • Put that can't be possible. DeRSSS, where are you?

    iPhone has 5 lenses and IR filters and, and, and, um, no glue between the vector gpu.

    I recently had a little discussion with a certain bilbo baggins who swore that when DeRSSS spouted his little spec sheet straight from the Apple PR department, he only did it to explain why iPhone was better in real life. So iPhone wasn't better because it has 5 lenses, iPhone was better because it took noticeably better pictures and the reason it took better pictures was because it had 5 lenses and an IR filter.

    Bilbo and DeRSSS, you have just been proven wrong. Note that I'm not saying the iPhone 4S has a bad camera (and neither is Matthew). It is now proven though that iPhone 4S, with its 5 lenses and IR filter and all the rest of its camera related bullet point specification items, isn't actually better than any of the others.

    Still, all of these blow away the camera on my iPhone 4 and I think my iPhone 4 takes good pictures.
    toddbottom3
    • Where I was proven wrong?

      Are you dreaming?
      DDERSSS
      • You're wrong for the same reason many here are...

        You don't worship Microsoft, thus you must be wrong. I personally hate WP 7 (and would give up using a phone, before buying one). But on ZDNet, you're not allowed to speak out against Microsoft products. Even when they suck!

        Edit:I expect the Microsoft employees will vote this into oblivion, because the truth hurts!
        Jumpin Jack Flash
      • To Jumpin Jack Flash

        Contrary to "I expect the Microsoft employees will vote this into oblivion, because the truth hurts!", I submit that people - in general - vote your comments into 'oblivion' because your comments are prejudiced and don't contribute to an objective discussion on the articles' themes. If this wasn't a virtual group discussion, everyone would realize this after you've made a few comments and would be physically turning their backs to you when you decided to say something - which is essentially what's happening with the negative voting to the point that you're comments are collapsed.
        achilles heal
    • And yet every objective review states..

      The Lumia series cameras are not as good as other 8 megapixel smartphone cameras. So they all must be wrong, because the resident Microsoft fanboy says the Lumia camera is the best? Face it this whole article was written at Microsoft's request, to hype the crappy Lumia phones. The Pitch black macro mode, has the Lumia having a yellowish cast to it. But since Mr. Microsoft is doing the test he changes the numbers to suit his own Agenda. Falsely promoting the inferior phone (Nokia Lumia 900) as the "best thing since sliced bread"
      Jumpin Jack Flash
      • Which article did you read?

        [i]the resident Microsoft fanboy says the Lumia camera is the best[/i]

        Matthew put the Lumia camera in last place, along with the iPhone 4S. The N9 was ranked #1.

        [i]this whole article was written at Microsoft's request[/i]

        MS requested that the Lumia camera come in last place and that the Linux powered phone comes in 1st? Can you explain to the class why MS would do that?
        toddbottom3
      • Can't you read Trollboy?

        What part of "[b]The lower the score the higher the ranking[/b] as it was simply a 1 through 5 rating scale between all five phones." escapes your comprehension? Miller reminds me of another Microsoft Shill that used to post distorted articles on ZNet, George Ou. George would "Cherry pick stats" and distort the truth to fit his [b]Pro-Microsoft[/b] agenda.
        Jumpin Jack Flash
      • Jack: I will admit when I am wrong

        I misread the rankings. I therefore apologize to both DeRSSS and to you.

        The iPhone 4S did come in first, tied with the Lumia 900 and the HTC One X. I will still claim a small victory since the iPhone 4S, with its 5 lenses, IR filter, non glued vector arithmetic duel cpu core gpu couldn't beat the Lumia 900, a phone that is far less expensive and has, according to DeRSSS, really cheap parts in it. Even so, even with the Lumia 900's cheap parts and the iPhone 4S's fantastically superior parts, the iPhone 4S still can't take better pictures.

        So while I was wrong in the way I read the chart, I am still right about DeRSSS being proved wrong. And since you are wrong about Matthew being an MS shill, I guess that means all of us are wrong. Shame.
        toddbottom3
      • We cannot objectively measure

        When the originals are not used. For all we know the images were "adjusted" using Photoshop. I have read about many issues with the Lumia's camera, but you will never hear about those issues, or really any issues at all with Microsoft flagship products.
        Jumpin Jack Flash
  • I have HTC Titan II in addition to iPhone 4S and Nokia Lumia 900

    I find Titan II excels in a lot of areas in imaging, of course Titan II is a proven.
    Ram U
    • Yes, Titan II is very good too

      I don't have one to test with, but when I was using it I found it to be a very good camera as well. Like I said in my article, most of the high end devices turn out good photos and the lines between them are getting less distinguishable. You can pretty much replace a point and shoot with a high end camera phone, but DLSR is best for dedicated photography.
      palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)
    • Titan II has even better apperture than iPhone, so it should be here for ..

      ... comparison.

      However, without access to original resolution photos, it is hard to decide anything.

      Optically, the best here is Nokia N8 since it is cameraphone -- weak as smartphone, but better at camera comparing to all-purpose universal smartphones as all the others devices in the list.

      On the second place in optics, it is iPhone 4S thans to additional lens that prevent blurring around the corners. IR filter is an advantage for low light situations only.

      Other aspects depend on what could be seen on original resolution photos, which are inaccessible in this comparison.
      DDERSSS
      • Nope, you don't get to do that

        [i]On the second place in optics, it is iPhone 4S[/i]

        iPhone 4S did not come in 2nd, it came in last. That [b]despite[/b] having 5 lenses and an IR filter that you seem to have personally designed since you have the inside scoop on how fantastic it is. Wait, you aren't simply repeating Apple's marketing spec sheet when you talk about it being the best IR filter, are you?

        At worst, iPhone came in last. At best, it came in 3rd. This despite you going on and on about how superior the 5 lenses, IR filter, gpu vector glue layered IPS screen regurgitation of Apple press releases.
        toddbottom3
      • According to even those specific results which can not be checked

        @toddbottom3: ... there is no better phone camera than in iPhone by overall marks.
        DDERSSS
  • Calculations are wrong, Apple iPhone 4S is #1!

    I do not have an opinion on which is best because I prefer a hands-on approach to determining what is best. The problem I have is your calculations. The first and third categories are ranked incorrect. If you have 3 cameras ranked better than the 4th and 5th cameras, how can the 4th and 5th cameras have a 3rd place ranking? iPhone 4S (11), N8 (13), Lumia (12), N9 (24), and HTC (12).
    trojandave
    • Because it would require him to be objective

      Rather than promote his favorite Brand/OS combination. This a blog, where no actual facts need be present.
      Jumpin Jack Flash
  • All I know is that...

    I don't miss any pictures on my WP7 when it is locked since all I need to do is hit the camera button and I don't have to lose time by typing in my code, loading an app etc..

    As for quality, what you see here is only as good as your monitor, the pics taken and your own eyes.

    Overall, I'll take a WP7 any day over any Android or iPhone (owned them both and hated them)
    omdguy
  • iPhone 4S Reveiw

    It may be that the most compelling new feature of the iPhone 4S isn???t iOS 5 or the A5 processor, but the new camera. I???ve given phone cameras a lot of guff for the generally poor image quality that results from a small sensor and bad glass, but this really is a problem that camera-makers have been trying to alleviate.
    Jane Nelson
  • ??

    For me,I don't know which one is better.I wanna try Cell Phone Accessories on sale visit at http://www.ok-buy.org/
    okbuyorg