ie8 fix
madison

Microsoft and Nokia announce my dream partnership so why aren't you all happy?

By | February 11, 2011, 2:08am PST

Summary: Microsoft and Nokia announced they are partnering to bring Windows Phone 7 smartphones and services to the world. I must be dreaming and cannot think of a better strategy for both companies at this time.

I am probably one of the very few people in the entire world that have a passion and love for both Windows Phone 7 and Nokia smartphones. In the past I have taken criticism from parties in both camps for my choices, yet today my dream came true (I still have to pinch myself) and Microsoft and Nokia announced a strategic partnership where we will eventually see Nokia hardware running Windows Phone 7.

I know that fans of both these camps will say I am an idiot and this whole idea is stupid and won’t lead to anything fruitful. They will say it is a desperate act of two long time smartphone companies trying to figure out some way to compete with Android and iOS. You might picture Microsoft and Nokia as two old retired super heroes huddled over in the corner with their wrinkled capes on trying to figure out how to best fight the bad guys while iOS and Android lead the group to victory. Well, I think those two old super heroes just put together their wonder twin powers and will join the Justice League when the first Nokia WP7 device launches.

As you may know I am the editor of the Nokia Experts website and write there as a venue to express my passion for Nokia products. I seriously considered giving up that site at the end of 2010 after attending Nokia World and not seeing much innovation or forward thinking coming out of Nokia. Symbian^3 fixes some UI issues in the Symbian OS, but as Stephen Elop even said it doesn’t even come close to competing what we see in iOS and Android. It is very customizable and like other Nokia fans I tried to justify its existence beyond what it really deserves. I purchased an orange Nokia N8 and the hardware is fantastic with innovations in it not seen on any other device, but the UI is not competitive with the latest and greatest smartphones.

Windows Phone 7 is relatively new to the smartphone world and if you read in nearly every review on the Internet the author’s generally love the operating system. It is fun, fast, stable, and unique. It is not perfect, but neither is any other smartphone operating system. Developers are actively rolling out applications at a rate exceeding 400 apps a week in the Marketplace so this OS is going places. The current hardware is a bit lame with HTC and Samsung basically just adding the OS to existing devices. As I just wrote, Dell has a great device in the Venue Pro, but earlier builds seemed to have issues.

Here is my breakdown of what each company brings to the partnership and why I am so excited:

  • All cameras in Microsoft’s smartphones have sucked, but Nokia rules the world with Carl Zeiss optics and imaging technology that rivals high end dedicated cameras
  • Nokia has the ONLY penta-band smartphones so it doesn’t matter who your GSM carrier is you can get 3G data support (this includes T-Mobile’s special 1700 MHz band)
  • Nokia brings hardware with aluminum colored bodies, Gorilla Glass, HDMI out, USB on-the-go, amazing RF reception and call quality, long battery life, and more
  • Windows Phone 7 is amazingly fast and responsive while also being unique
  • Windows Phone 7 is rock solid stable and after using it since July 2010 I can confirm it is the MOST stable mobile operating system I have ever used
  • Windows Phone 7 gaming rocks, Zune is fantastic, multiple Exchange support is solid, Office integration is great, and developers are building apps
  • Email on Symbian blows, but on Windows Phone 7 it absolutely rocks and I prefer to use my WP7 smartphone for email handling over even my Outlook desktop client

If Nokia and Microsoft can combine all of these great things that each brings to the table, please explain to me how this can be a bad thing.

According to the press release, this is what the proposed partnership consists of:

  • Nokia would adopt Windows Phone as its principal smartphone strategy, innovating on top of the platform in areas such as imaging, where Nokia is a market leader.
  • Nokia would help drive the future of Windows Phone. Nokia would contribute its expertise on hardware design, language support, and help bring Windows Phone to a larger range of price points, market segments and geographies.
  • Nokia and Microsoft would closely collaborate on joint marketing initiatives and a shared development roadmap to align on the future evolution of mobile products.
  • Bing would power Nokia’s search services across Nokia devices and services, giving customers access to Bing’s next generation search capabilities. Microsoft adCenter would provide search advertising services on Nokia’s line of devices and services.
  • Nokia Maps would be a core part of Microsoft’s mapping services. For example, Maps would be integrated with Microsoft’s Bing search engine and adCenter advertising platform to form a unique local search and advertising experience
  • Nokia’s extensive operator billing agreements would make it easier for consumers to purchase Nokia Windows Phone services in countries where credit-card use is low.
  • Microsoft development tools would be used to create applications to run on Nokia Windows Phones, allowing developers to easily leverage the ecosystem’s global reach.
  • Nokia’s content and application store would be integrated with Microsoft Marketplace for a more compelling consumer experience.

So, as you can see there are some positive aspects of Symbian that will be adopted in Windows Phone 7, including the fantastic Ovi Maps capability. Nokia will also help with services, which is excellent because right now there is a fragmented Windows Phone 7 service experience that needs to be addressed to have a global impact with Windows Phone 7.

HTC and Samsung have shown that you can succeed with multiple platforms so I don’t know why people think this kills off Nokia and other platforms they want to support. I also think this deal helps push HTC, Samsung, and others to step up the game for quality Windows Phone 7 devices.

Microsoft and Nokia just saved me lots of money as I no longer see any reason for me personally to buy an iOS, BlackBerry, webOS, or Android smartphone since a Nokia Windows Phone 7 device will meet and exceed all of my needs and desires. I will still test out these other platforms, but I can’t see them offering anything this partnership platform won’t. Apple and Google may not be nervous about this announcement, but HP and RIM might want to think hard about their future plans.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Matthew Miller started using a Pilot 1000 in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since.

Disclosure

Matthew Miller

Matthew is a professional naval architect by day and a mobile gadget freak at all other times. He purchases his own devices and then sells them on eBay or Craigslist to buy more. Many other devices are sent for review on a 30-day loaner basis and then returned to the carrier or manufacturer. If any are provided as “long term loaner units” this will be clearly disclosed in his reviews.

Biography

Matthew Miller

Matthew Miller started using a mobile devices in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since. He is a co-host with GigaOM's Kevin Tofel on the MobileTechRoundup podcast and an author of three Wiley Companion series books. Matthew started using mobile devices with a US Robotics Pilot 1000 and has owned over 125 different devices running Palm, Linux, Symbian, Newton, BlackBerry, iOS, Android, webOS, Windows Mobile, and Windows Phone operating systems. His current collection includes an HTC Radar 4G, Dell Venue Pro, Apple iPad 2, HTC Flyer, Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Nokia N9, Apple iPhone 4S, MacBook Pro, and many more, along with tons of accessories and classic devices like the Apple Newton MessagePad 2100 and Sony CLIE UX50. Matthew can be found on various discussion forums under the user name of "palmsolo".
77
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Microsoft and Nokia announce my dream partnership so why aren't you all happy?
tomlin21-24319035676893835085146735905770 11th Oct
I take pleasure in you sharing this internet site content.A large nfl jersey number of many thanks However once more. Sustain making.
0 Votes
+ -
Completely Agree...
C#2010 Updated - 12th Feb 2011
This is a perfect merger. WP7 OS on nokia harware will definetly shake up the mobile landscape. And as more people try the WP7 OS they will realize what a gem it is! The current WP7 harware lineup is lame, including the Dell Venue Pro (crappy camera, and 256MB of RAM). I'm really looking forward to the first crop of devices...

8-12MP Carl Zeiss Camera
HDMI out
Amoled screen
Best 3g radio of any phone period
Colored aluminum case
Windows Phone 7 OS

!ABSOLUTE GOODNESS!

Note: For those who keep saying Nokia should have gone with Andriod... WP7 just has more to offer in the short and long term.
phones. The big question is if it will stop the slide for Nokia, or if it will even increase the slide. In Europe (and other places), Microsoft is not very popular, so, it could HURT Nokia in Europe.

You can bet that they broke out the Champaign at Apple today. This is a huge plus for Apple.
@DonnieBoy - truthfully, Microsoft is very popular in Europe. More so than any other company. Macs are less popular in Europe than windows PC's. As a matter of fact the windows live suite and social network on MSN are more popular in Europe that in USA. Check you facts.
fooling anyone but yourself.

Did you notice that Apple moved up there exclusitivty deal with AT&T a year earlier then signed on, so as to get the iPhone on Verizon? Is it a coincidence that it was done right after the release date of WP7? This is the last thing that Apple wanted.

And guess what? MS is popular:

http://www.dirjournal.com/business-journal/the-most-powerful-brands-in-the-world/

http://top-10-list.org/2010/07/20/top-ten-most-powerful-brands/

So it's only going to help Nokia, and Google was desparate/worried enough to offer Nokia tons of money, too. Google wouldn't even care to do that unless they felt Nokia/WP7 would hurt Android sales.

The only thing for certain is that Apple is neutral, while Page and Brin are throwing chairs around their offices.
@DonnieBoy
Check your facts... Ms is very popular in europe. And why would Apple be happy the competition just got alot stiffer?
0 Votes
+ -
@C#2010

I could not stop laughing after hearing the news and you are making me continue the laugh. 2 desperate failed companies trying to regain the top spot and they need 2 years for the merger to be any fruitful! Yeah good luck with that and the next memo would say, our competitors in Google and Apple have so advanced systems and how did we sleep and allow this. Enjoy!
@browser.
Companies with resources such as Microsoft and Nokia in a "desperate (as you termed it)" position are a very real threat to market leaders. Google and Apple better stay on top of their game, or they will get passed by (it would not be the first time MS has surpassed a market leader and won't be the last time)
@browser.
Yes, it is foolish to think that MS could crack an existing market, why with its puny resources and short-term outlook. Just ask Apple, Novell, Netscape, Sony & Nintendo, ... should I continue, troll?
@C#2010

Dream Team for me too!

I think I the future of my next cellphone has just been unveiled. Have always loved Nokia hardware, and combined with WP7 I will be all over that at the end of my next contract.
@SlithyTove WP7 was not selling well, even with the huge investment in design and public relations. Maybe they can sell thanks to Nokia. Maybe Nokia will find out that versions with other OS'es sell better. It is not exclusive, I understand.
Before they can start selling however the effect of the announcement will long be gone. And, I think everybody must admit Apple is much better in creating a hype. Hopefully they do not start selling it like Windows is sold to private persons, practically having the alternatives blocked.
@C#2010
Donnie, Europe is more than UK. Do you know why did EU went after Microsoft. Please stop talking about things that you don't know. Please. Also DT claims WP7 phones are selling excellent in Germany.
0 Votes
+ -
Buying market share
lektron 11th Feb 2011
@Rama.NET It's always possible to buy market share like with the Xbox which has a negative price.
@C#2010

At least Android, MeeGo, and Symbian are open source, WP7 and iOS not so. Open source looses with this deal sad
@vingjr It is not a sign of strength. People reunite if they feel week. Either Nokia and the mobile department of MS can see some burning if they look good. Losing the mobile market may threaten the MS monopoly on the private user market.

But cooperating may make them somewhat stronger. But both have a week image about innovation. What will be the combined image?
0 Votes
+ -
Yep ! Android will be the new WinMo.
jinishans 11th Feb 2011
@C#2010 MS + NOKIA for Mobile = MS + IBM for PCs. As happened for PC's, Apple will struggle with it's own HW + SW issue for Smartphone's as well and will become a Appleophobic Phone in next couple of years.

WP7 will be the Windows for Smartphones. MS did it once again.

Nokia is just another Palm. WP7 will be ruling the mobile space for next couple of decades.

Nokia will be the New DELL for Mobile space.
0 Votes
+ -
nokia n8 wp7 possible or not
mvassu 25th May 2011
@C#2010

whether its possible for nokia n8 installing or upgrade this wp7 please give me answer my email: mvassu@live.com
0 Votes
+ -
@C#2010
i am using nokia n8 right now nokia are collaboration with microsoft whether possible upgrade WP7 please give the answer my email : mvassu@live.com thanku
0 Votes
+ -
WP7 only?
grimesdr 11th Feb 2011
Well it is a start for Nokia, but the CEO should have gone even further by opening up the phones to Android !!.

So now it looks like they are still going forward on MeeGo which is late.
0 Votes
+ -
Nah
Peter Perry 11th Feb 2011
@grimesdr Android would just be a me too approach for Nokia and they know that.

For MS this could be the modern day equivalent to the IBM deal and Apples worst nightmare.
"mee too" kind of thing. Apple is actually rejoicing right now, they could have gone with Android. Apple would much rather have two weak competitors than one strong one. You can bet that Steve Jobs broke out laughing when he heard this!!
@donnieboy I seriously doubt it, this gives new life to an old rival and Android is what Nokia worries about, not Apple.
0 Votes
+ -
Apple is hardly rejoicing, DB
John Zern 11th Feb 2011
and you know Google's ticked about it.

(I wonder how long before Google runs to the EU claiming This is unfair?)
0 Votes
+ -
Me too...
Solid Water 12th Feb 2011
@Peter Perry
How is WP7 me too is different from Android me too?
ton of cash, and is desperate to get a foothold in mobile, this may be exclusive for at least a period of time. In any case, I would not expect for Nokia to do anything with either MeeGo or Android for the short term, as the focus on rolling out WP7 phones.
I strongly agree.

For this to benefit Nokia in the LONG TERM, the agreement needs to have kept Novi Maps out of the hands of HTC, Samsung, and other companies who also have "strategic" relationships with MS (even if some of these companies have chosen to abandon WP7, at least temporarily).

Without a unique advantage, Nokia becomes like Palm in it's death throws: A hardware/software house with THREE different teams of software infighting. (At Palm, it was "legacy" PalmOS vs. "new" WebOS vs. Windows 6.x; at Nokia, it is now Maemo vs. Qt vs. WP7.) This creates a severe disadvantage against companies, present and future, which don't have the possibility of so much in-fighting-- AND WORSE, at Nokia, under bad management, sabotage between Maemo and Qt has become firmly entrenched, it's been going on for years. They HATE each other, because their jobs are at risk.

I see a gazillion people saying that Android would have "commoditized" Nokia; but obviously, unless MS screws their current "Strategic Partners", WP7 has the same result.

Nokia has failed, under previous management, to enforce cooperation between just TWO in-fighting teams. (Maemo == "us", Qt == "them".) Mr. Elop, in his intentionally leaked blog post, makes amazingly stupid errors of fact, writes like a teenager, and forgets to emphasize that his employees are valuable and work hard (but "under strategic choices which have not worked out".)

And so, except for (possibly) the one task of "negotiating" an MS agreement, I AM *MANIFESTLY* MORE QUALIFIED TO BE NOKIA'S CEO than this man. The blog post shows him to be in way over his head already. And so, if he doesn't kill Nokia's involvement in Qt (by handing it entirely to Intel, at any cost), I think that Nokia will ultimately fail.

Incidentally, anyone who thinks that they're simply "too big" needs to remember Compaq.
@grimesdr - WHY? Shipping Android would just have commoditized the Nokia phone OS.
0 Votes
+ -
The Internets
Cylon Centurion Updated - 11th Feb 2011
Will be a ****storm of haters today.

I fail to see why WP7 is so hated. Yes, it's an uphill battle, but this now means Microsoft has to be on their toes with the platform, and AGRESSIVELY, go after Apple and Google.

WP7 is a beauty once you really sit down with it.
@Cylon Centurion 0005
The **** storm happens because tech-people tend to have a predisposal towards defending "their" devices and chosen software.

As you correctly point out - people that have actually TRIED WP7, love it.
WP7. Obviously, with Nokia hardware, and MS investing anything and everything they can in WP7, this IS a big boost for WP7. The question is, how much money changed hands?
0 Votes
+ -
The sales show that, DB
John Zern 11th Feb 2011
in what way? That WP7's been out for 90 days on limited carriers, Android for 2 years on all carriers, and yet Goolge's worried enough to offer Nokia millions of dollars to go with Android.

those sales?
Champaign today at Apple. This is nothing but a big positive for Apple.
@DonnieBoy

Apple would have preferred Nokia to build both WP7 and Android phones instead of getting in tight with either of them. This way Nokia goes all in on WP7 and Apple will be casting a nervous eye towards this development. Once a few more WP7 releases are out, especially Mango (which Mary-Jo referred to as the entertainment-branch) and Nokia starts coming out with WP7 super phones things are going to get a lot more interesting.
@DonnieBoy were you there? Tell us about it.
0 Votes
+ -
RIGHT ON DB!!
Ron Bergundy 11th Feb 2011
just like google was busting out champaign all those times in the past eveytime M$ put something out!!!

the part that sucks is that they never got a reason to drink it!!!
@DonnieBoy
You know Apple is hardly rejoicing, yet you attempt to trivialize the issue by making claim that Apple is rejoicing, therby implying that "this is the worst possible thing Nokia could do"

Doubtless if they went with Android, you would make the claim that "Apple is incredibly upset at the news".

Logic would indicate that this upsets you to a great degree, that a storied and respected company like Noia weighed their options, and found Android lacking.

There is no champaign flowing except at Microsoft and Nokia.
Part of me is sad that it did not go to android, but it would have been just another maker there.
As Microsoft get a great navigation and camera, hopefully they will use Nokia as their preferred manufacture.

Also, how good would it be if Nokia goes full-in with the mobile gaming to create an xbox mobile type phone. Android and sony have their playsation phone, so this could be just what the doctor ordered for the xbox.
you can bet that HTC, Motorola, and Samsung, are celebrating, as they will not have to compete against Nokia for Android. They would much rather compete against Nokia WP7 phones than Nokia Android phones.
0 Votes
+ -
they might be!
Peter Perry 11th Feb 2011
@DonnieBoy they might be celebrating but Android is still kicking the not out of iPhone so I doubt they are happy about a rejuvinated Microsoft!
0 Votes
+ -
...but caution. So far WP7 has been selling on more or less the same hardware as Android, yet the latter has taken off and the former is desperately trying to get off the ground.
I somehow don't see this marriage as benefiting Nokia as much as it might help MS.
Let me explain: MS can use the Nokia brand, that has many fans worldwide, to increase its share. What's in it for Nokia? Its share (market and mind) has been decreasing as Android's been basically eating it's lunch, despite what many here claim is superior hardware.
We'll just have to wait until at least november 2012 to see how this marriage of convenience works out.
November 2012 for this to play out. It will take Nokia some time to switch over to WP7 on all models, and then see how it goes. The only thing for sure is that it will increase the sales of WP7. The big question is how much money exchanged hands here?
0 Votes
+ -
even though iphone was on one carrier in the us while android was on all of them?

i wonder - whose lunch will be eaten now that both at&t AND verizon are selling the iphone!
0 Votes
+ -
Finally, sound reason prevails!!!
anay3000 11th Feb 2011
Nokia smartphone running Windows Phone 7 = 7th heaven!!!
I think this is going be awesome. I only wish the fruits of their collaboration could be available now but it?s going to take a while.
0 Votes
+ -
Matthew, you're not alone
UseYourHead 11th Feb 2011
There are lots of people out there loving WP7. Many of them put off buying WP7 devices because either holding a wait-and-see attitude as WP7 is young or waiting for great hardware. Current WP7 devices are mediocre to say the least.
0 Votes
+ -
@UseYourHead
I ask because that was a bold statement on your part full of confidence so I assume you have some facts and figures to back it up with. Please provide....

Pagan jim
0 Votes
+ -
My prayers are answerd
Moe2511 11th Feb 2011
I'm a wp7 and a nokia fan, who are in my view the best phone software and the best phone hardware out there.
The only reason I don't have a wp7 or a nokia is for their lack of each other, i hate to chose between them, i want it all.
Microsoft
A beautiful operating system with a solid integration of all services i love and use (office, FB, Live, the cloude etc.), some nice apps for other services and a hope for a better future (with Microsoft's investments in this platform and how important it is for them makes me confident in wp7).
Nokia
Monster hardware where it counts, hardware that truly covers the need of other gadgets on the go not only a dual core of whatever.
a navigator that can compete with a true navigator,
a camera that can compete with a true camera,
a radio and music player that can compete with a true mp3 player,
FM transmitter, hdmi-out, usb-on the go, a screen that works outdoor, battery that holds more than one day, best reception etc.
There are no apps for those things, only nokia hardware.

ps. Mango update for WP7 is; Microsoft and Nokia GO.
0 Votes
+ -
why should we be happy
Quebec-french 11th Feb 2011
it will end up bad for nokia one way or they other
If it goes well microsoft will buy nokia .... its bad
If its goes bad nokia will loose a truck load of credibility ..... so its a loose loose situation for nokia.

we all know what happen when microsoft get it attention on you .... Its allways end up bad for you .. novell anybody.

BTW its not hate its just a nice look its ms road map
0 Votes
+ -
Why in the world would...
wolf_z 11th Feb 2011
@Quebec-french

...MS buy Nokia?

MS is a (primarily) software company. Yes, they make a great gaming console and they make nice keyboards and mice (outsourcing mfg) but smartphones are *computers*.

Seen that way MS would no more buy Nokia than they'd buy HP or Dell. Not to mention the antitrust headaches that would cause.
0 Votes
+ -
why simple cash cow
Quebec-french 11th Feb 2011
@wolf_z
If MS nokia work well they can kill everything in matter of month , Think about it ms could control everything from one side to the end side .
App
hardware
support

Remember if there one thing that MS does its learn .... why apple is the top dog now they offer a complete experience .
MS have a huge cash flow and need to do something about it . apple is becoming a huge monster that will cause major shadow to MS . if ms dont react .... they will have to face criticizes from the investor , board, bla blab bal .

as for anti thrust is easy you also offer android or something else ..... i just enter the market of hardware cell market and i offer both platform .

you make 2 line the xperience wp7 sexy and sleek and all link up email word database and the kitchen sink . and you do the bulky ugly unsupported android .


well apple have the largest market in cell phone and there no anti trust there rim was there tooo .....
0 Votes
+ -
I take pleasure in you sharing this internet site content.A large nfl jersey number of many thanks However once more. Sustain making.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix