Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

Summary: The T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is definitely not a small pocketable device, but more of a portable computer with functions those in the business field may appreciate. The hardware is quite good, but I was left with the feeling that Android would have been much more enjoyable on it. As I wrote last week I went all in with T-Mobile and as a result had a line with full upgrade eligibility. I planned to wait until this week and purchase my own Touch Pro2, but left the store with a new Merlot myTouch 3G so let's go through the device and see why I didn't stick to my original plan.

SHARE:

The unlocked HTC Touch Pro2 had been out for a short while and we posted some first impressions of that device after spending about a week with it. I've been using the HTC Touch Pro2 from T-Mobile USA for just over a week now and have a few more thoughts to share. It is definitely not a small pocketable device, but more of a portable computer with functions those in the business field may appreciate. The hardware is quite good, but I was left with the feeling that Android would have been much more enjoyable on it. As I wrote last week I went all in with T-Mobile and as a result had a line with full upgrade eligibility. I planned to wait until this week and purchase my own Touch Pro2 (I may still not be able to resist), but left the store with a new Merlot myTouch 3G so let's go through the device and see why I didn't stick to my original plan. You can check out several photos of the T-Mobile Touch Pro2 in my image gallery.

UPDATE: After a reader comment I called up T-Mobile twice and both reps told me that the 2-year price is $279.99! I need to get official T-Mobile confirmation and then will update my headline because at this price I will go buy one today. The T-Mobile website now has it up and shows the $349.99 price. I will try a store myself when they open in 45 minutes. Confirmed in store that the price is $349.99 with 2 year contract.


Image Gallery: Check out photos of the T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2. Image Gallery: Retail packaging Image Gallery: Close up of the left side of the QWERTY keyboard

The last Windows Mobile touch screen device from T-Mobile was the rather anemic Wing. The Wing had a very nice form factor and design (blue rubberized finish), but the 200 MHz processor and limited RAM kept it from being a device I would recommend anyone purchase. The HTC Touch Pro2 has improved vastly over the Wing and should appeal to quite a few folks looking for one of the best QWERTY devices available. HTC focused on making the Touch Pro2 a conference calling machine and there are a few key components optimized for this functionality. I personally make very few calls on my mobile phones and am a data hound so even though the speakerphone/conference calling capability is present, it wasn't something I was looking for myself so it did not have much impact on my purchase decision.

Specifications

The T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is priced at $349.99 with a two-year contract, required plan, and instant rebate. This makes the Touch Pro2 one of the highest priced subsidized smartphones available, but at least the hardware feels like it is worth that price. Then again, the resistive display kind of hampers the overall experience and the device doesn't scream like it really should. One thing I found out last week when I bought my myTouch 3G is that almost all T-Mobile rebates (particularly phones with required data plans) are instant and eventually there should be no more mail-in rebates, which is another awesome customer service feature being provided by T-Mobile. The full, non-contract price of the Touch Pro2 will be $549.99.

Specifications include:

  • 3.6 inch 480x800 WVGA resistive touch screen display
  • Windows Mobile Professional 6.1
  • 528 MHz Qualcomm 7200A processor
  • 256MB RAM
  • 512MB ROM
  • Bluetooth 2.1 + EDR
  • 802.11 b/g WiFi
  • Quad band GSM (850/900/1800/1900 MHz)
  • Dual band UMTS/HSDPA (1700/2100 MHz)
  • Integrated GPS receiver
  • Accelerometer
  • HTC TouchFLO 3D interface
  • 3.2 megapixel auto focus camera (no flash)
  • microSD card slot
  • 1500 mAh battery
  • Dimensions: 4.57 in x 2.33 in x 0.68 in
  • Weight: 6.61 ounces

The Touch Pro2 supports myFaves and there is a special TouchFLO 3D tab for this functionality. Unfortunately, there is still no UMA support and I was actually a bit surprised since the T-Mobile Shadow that was released a few months ago had it and I assumed that all future higher end Windows Mobile devices would support this technology.

As you can see the device has very good specifications. I do think it could have been even better with a faster processor, some amount of integrated flash memory, and a better camera. This is a premium device available at a premium price and should have all the latest and greatest specifications with fast, solid performance. It is also a bit tough to buy a new expensive Windows Mobile device at this time with WM 6.5 just around the corner and availability of updates for specific devices an unknown at the moment. The Pharos Traveler 137 that I am still evaluating (due to recent updates) has been confirmed as a device that will get this WM 6.5 update and also supports T-Mobile 3G so you may want to consider that device.

In the box

The T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 comes in a fairly standard T-Mobile package with an upper flap that contains a pocket for the manuals, screen protector, and CD. The device is then set in a bed of protective foam with the rest of the contents placed below this platform. Under the device you will find a wired stereo headset, audio/charging adapter (lets you use 2.5mm or 3.5mm headsets), USB cable, charging adapter, and carrying case. The leather carrying case secures with a magnet and is designed to provide some scratch and minor bump protection for the Touch Pro2 as you place it in your bag.

Walk around the hardware

The mocha color with yellow highlights is very attractive and for some reason the T-Mobile Touch Pro2 feels better in my hand than the unlocked model. It must be the curves and the layout of the back panel. I also found the screen hinge to be rock solid with the ability for you to prop it up from 0 to about 40 degrees as you like. The unlocked model I had must have been a bit defective because it flopped around quite a bit.

The hardware is the same as the unlocked Touch Pro2 I checked out before and even the keyboard is virtually the same. The leaked photos of the AT&T model show numbers in a phone keypad layout rather than the full top number row. I enter punctuation more than numbers so would rather have seen this layout on the T-Mobile model. I wanted to see a shortcut for the Start menu and it isn't there so you have to bounce back and forth between the touching the display and tapping on the keyboard and this just isn't an experience I enjoy.

We have also seen leaked photos of the CDMA Touch Pro2 with a 3.5mm headset jack on the bottom next to the ExtUSB port and I wish HTC would have done the same here.

As I mentioned earlier, the Touch Pro2 is optimized for the speakerphone/conference calling experience and two assymmetric speakers are found on the upper back. They are actually located on either side of the camera and I have to admit I was surprised by how closely they were located to each other. They are pretty loud though and the speakerphone is usable in a fast moving vehicle. There is also a mic with advanced noise suppression and duplex acoustics to help with the overall experience. If you make a lot of conference calls then this device may be just what you are looking for. I would actually be quite interested in knowing if HTC's market analysis showed there was a real need for such capability since it seems that the device was highly optimized to support this.

I know this won't really affect many folks, but I do have to mention that the SIM card on the Touch Pro2 is one of the toughest to remove I have ever experienced. The SIM card slot is located below the battery and then down in a slot that is protected by a small metal piece. The image shows you press down on the metal piece and then slide the SIM back up over it, yet you have to do this in a space of 1/4 inch. I discovered the only way I could get the SIM card out (I wanted to use my own T-Mobile SIM for real life testing) was to use a paperclip to lift up on one end of the SIM while pressing down on the metal piece and then using a finger to slide the SIM over. Whew, I guess you won't have to worry about your SIM ever popping out of this device.

Software

Speaking of the conference calling capability, HTC and T-Mobile have a dialer optimized for this with a slider to switch between a standard call and conference call. If you switch to conference call your contacts then appear with open boxes to the right of their names. You simply tap the two contacts you want to call and then tap Conference to setup the call. You then tap each person, one at a time, and hold a conference call. This is very slick and for those business users on the road making conference calls it doesn't get any easier than this. The software/dialer even lets you take notes and email the contacts as well and is quite feature packed.

The T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a Windows Mobile Professional 6.1 device with all the standard features you would expect in the device. T-Mobile also includes their myFaves utility, My Account utility, slick scientific calculator (when in landscape mode), Teeter game, JBlend Java client, Google Maps, Windows Live Search, Opera Mobile browser, and TeleNav GPS Navigator. I was a bit disappointed that the excellent WorldCard Mobile business card capture software was not present.

HTC has implemented their TouchFLO 3D UI so that many users can "live" in this user environment. You can access all your Programs from there, but you do need to dive in to the standard Windows Mobile settings for many settings not found on the TouchFLO 3D panels.

Even though I like to tweak and mess with my devices, even I am starting to tire of the long and deep menus of the operating system. For some things you have to scroll up and down through multiple displays to perform an action and I just don't want to do that as much anymore.

I think the notifications on the Google Android and Palm Pre are the best in the mobile space and was hoping to see HTC add that functionality to a device like this. I know they are working with Windows Mobile and maybe the OS is limiting how much they can do with notifications. The notifications on the Touch Pro2 are better than they were on previous HTC Windows Mobile devices and one level has been eliminated.

While the email panel looks slick and shows you a bit of your email, IMHO it is a bit of a pain to use since flipping through them has no effect on read/unread status and you have to dive into the standard Windows Mobile email client and then try to figure out how to navigate around to switch accounts and perform actions.

The month calendar is useless and just shows you the days on a month view. With the screen real estate wasted by top and bottom task and status bars they could show your day's appointments scrolling by or something. Screen real estate is wasted quite a bit in Windows Mobile.

Experiences and final thoughts

The T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro is definitely a two-handed device and the keyboard really cannot be used with a single hand. That said, it isn't too wide that entering text is uncomfortable, but I still find I am much faster on my T-Mobile G1. I love the layout of the standard keys and think this is just about one of the best large QWERTY keyboards on a phone.

The display is beautiful, however I don't think HTC has optimized their devices for movie playing as the videos I tested were still a bit choppy at times. It is a shame given the display on the Touch Pro2 has amazing resolution.

TouchFLO 3D was pretty responsive, but I did experience some lagging and I hated seeing the spinning beach ball when launching an application. At this time, there really is no reason that these high end phones should lag with the technology and processors we have available.

The display is resistive and HTC has made the targets a bit larger to make the experience closer to capacitive, but it still can't compare to the displays found on the Pre, Google Android, and iPhone devices. Again, people are expecting response from touch displays like we see on these devices and may be disappointed with the Touch Pro2 display response.

You can multitask with the Touch Pro2 and this is something that should appeal to those looking to get a lot done at once. I personally consider myself quite a power user and like to push my devices so the Touch Pro2 does appeal to me on one level. Then again, my usage and needs seem to be changing over time and I am less and less likely to carry a device of this size with me all the time. The new T-Mobile myTouch 3G fits easily into my front pants pocket and gives me much of the same capability at almost half the cost. If I bought the Touch Pro2 I can easily see looking for something trimmer and slimmer to carry around since I don't spend hours and hours trying to be productive with heavy text entry and browsing on a resistive display device with a stylus is just not as fun or easy as a capacitive display device.

Microsoft and Windows Mobile are in need of an overhaul that we won't see in Windows Mobile 6.5. I think HTC is pushing Windows Mobile as far as it can go and Windows Mobile fans may really like the Touch Pro2. However, as time goes by the numbers show there are less and less Windows Mobile fans out there so Microsoft has to pick up the pace or be left behind.

Other reviews

I always recommend reading reviews from lots of sources before making a purchase decision and you can find other reviews on the Touch Pro2 here. I am actually surprised that my review sounds a bit harsh compared to most all these other ones and I am not sure if it is because as a Windows Mobile fan I am expecting more from Microsoft or if I am just too enamored by the Google Android platform.

infoSync WOrld Mobile Tech Review PC Magazine Engadget Mobile Gizmodo CNET

Topics: Mobility, Hardware, HTC, Mobile OS, Operating Systems, Software, Wi-Fi, Windows

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

13 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Price change

    At the eleventh hour T-Mo changed the price (due to howls over the $350 two year contract price).

    Two year contract: $279

    One year: $329

    Much more attractive prices.

    And don't forget California purchasers (even existing customers upgrading), you have 30 days to try out the phone. Don't like it, send it back.
    SanFranciscoCA
    • Seriously? My T-Mobile contact hasn't given me that

      Hmm, I will get in touch with my T-Mobile PR rep and find out what is going on. I will update my review if that is true and at that price then I think this is an excellent deal!
      palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)
  • RE: Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

    I plan on using the one year upgrade option since I tend to buy a new phone every year, or even less sometimes.

    The TP2 is definitely a phone I will be testing out over 30 days with an eye on sending it back if I don't like it.

    I have a G1 running the Hero OS. That is one sweet device and I may like it so much as to not be able to go backward to the old WinMo days (better hurry up MS and get 6.5, then 7 out).

    But I like the TP2 for its functionality in the professional setting. A netbook on the belt kind of thing.

    I hear that WinMO 7 and Microsoft's "market" will be the same as the Android experience, so that may cause me to keep this phone long term. But if they delay and don't come out with it, I doubt I will stay with the outdated Window Mobile OS.

    And who knows, since this is an HTC phone, maybe the folks over at XDA will come out with a Hero hack for it. Now this phone with Hero, OMG that would be the coolest phone on the planet.
    SanFranciscoCA
  • Hello

    The calender is viewable on he home tab aswell under the clock, atleast it is on all the other touch flo devices I have seen.

    To be fair i think your faults with the touch pro 2 were just niggles, and they are the same for any platform.
    For example a friend of mine at work has the g1 which he now hates mainly because of a flurry of bugs with the device and the build quality on his atleast seems pretty poor.

    Maybe you just dont use your phone in the same way anymore.
    jdbukis@...
  • RE: Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

    wirefly.com has the touch pro2 for 199.99
    229.99 for upgrades....
    tmobile is crazy selling this for $350!
    ar40430
  • Another nail in the coffin for Windows Mobile

    Matthew: I recall that earlier this year, after seeing it at trade show, you were *definitely* sold on this device as being your next main WinMo phone. But now, after seeing it in the flesh and at its actual price, you passed on buying it.

    This does not bode well for the future of Windows Mobile. This was shaping up to be an iPhone-killer, but instead, it feels overpriced and underpowered. I've been waiting for a phone like this to come out ever since the HTC Advantage, but now that its here I'm completely underwhelmed. The price is outrageous.

    I've been a Windows Mobile user for about 10 years, ever since the Cassiopeia E100, but now I'm switching to Android.
    scott@...
  • Removing the SIM card

    I'm in the process of reviewing a Touch Pro2 (an unlocked Euro version) and I had the same impression about the SIM card. Then I noticed that there's a tiny slot by the rear of the card that fits the tip of the stylus. You can use the stylus to push the SIM card out a bit and then it's easy to remove.

    I haven't seen the T-Mobile version, so it may lack that slot. But if it's there, it takes care of the SIM card removal problem.

    dbrebel
  • RE: Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

    I picked up the HTC Touch Pro2 yesterday (upgraded from a 2-y.o. Curve). You can't really talk about the price of a phone separate from the cost of the monthly service. My monthly bill with my BB (unlimited calls, email, internet service & 400 texts) with taxes & fees was $89. With the HTC it will go up by $5 ($10 if you want unlimited texts). And the customer service with T-mobile is excellent. The same package from AT&T for the iphone is about $140 so I'll make up the price difference of the handset in 4-5 months. I am self-employed and need seamless synching between my smartphone and Outlook on my laptop, something I have never been able to get with an Apple product (and yes, I tried to synch my BB with a macbook for 18 months before going back to a Windows machine). Most of my business colleagues who have iPhones also carry BB's. My purse is heavy enough. The only thing right now that I am missing is the ability to forward an SMS as an email, which a BB can do and the HTC cannot.
    NYCKay
  • not available

    Four days after the rollout and the local T-Mobile store here in West Los Angeles still doesn't have a display model that you can look at; they have 3 models for purchase, but nothing you can hold or test or otherwise check out. Can't be good for sales.
    jklee333
  • Wrong points of comparison on screen

    The only better performance of an iPhone screen over a resistive one is the occasional missed button. However, the much higher resolution and the ability to WRITE on the Windows Mobile phone screen makes it far superior.

    Of course if you need to fingerpaint...

    ;-)

    tonymcs@...
  • RE: Review: T-Mobile HTC Touch Pro2 is a hefty device with a price to match

    I always wonder how much time reviewers spend with a unit before a review is written. Case in point with Matthew's comments re: email. Once you set up an email account, you receive an "email tips" email. If Matt were to have read it, he would have learned that you can switch between email accounts and text messages by swiping your finger left to right or right to left across once you are in a particular account. This saves a bunch of taps. One thing not mentioned is that the screen is very difficult to read a bright/direct sunlight, a problem that I did not have on my BB Curve. I'm a power user, and I'm glad that I bought it.
    NYCKay
  • more bias

    wow another anti-windows mobile biased review maldito desgraciado cretino imb?cil.windows mobile is no less capable than android or webOS.
    Eric12341
  • HTC EVPO CASES

    This is a unique carrying leather case for the HTC Evo, its not as boring as the other leather cases because it features elegant red dots decoration.Not many HTC Evo Cases are available today, since the phone was oly recently announced, The Amzer clear case for HTC Evo is one of the first available, and for an affordable price too!A sparkling green HTC EVO case made of a quality rubber.a fashionable case that is made to fit your Htc Evo, cases like these are usually top sellers and last for many years.This invisible shield for your HTC evo device that is seamless to the eye thereby showing off the true design and beauty of your mobile device.
    <a href="http://htc-evo-cases.org/">HTC EVPO CASES</a>
    stephanycolumbus