ie8 fix
madison

Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now

By | March 28, 2011, 2:10am PDT

Summary: It was extremely difficult to come up with just a top 10 list for smartphones this year as the market explodes. Interestingly, seven of my top 10 are Android device. What is your favorite so far this year?

Now that CES, MWC, and CTIA are all wrapped up I thought it would be appropriate to go through what I think are the top 10 smartphones for the first half of 2011. My top 10 smartphones of 2010 article was very popular and readers seem to like these types of comparison articles. I will follow up in a month or so with an article listing some of the top smartphones per carrier. As I sat down to go through all of the amazing devices that were announced or released, my list started at about 20 so it was extremely difficult to pare my list down to just 10. When the devices were close, I gave a bit more credit to those that are available or that have more definite release dates for the US market.

It is likely that a new iPhone will be announced sometime this summer and there are sure to be many more Android devices released throughout 2011. As you will see, some of the top 10 I listed do not yet have pricing or solid release dates, but I trust that they will be released since the manufacturers and carriers providing them are reliable. You can check out several product photos of these top 10 devices in my image gallery, but I also highly recommend you visit your carrier store or local electronics retailer to get some hands-on time with a device before you make a huge monthly commitment.


Image Gallery: Check out photos of my top 10 smartphones of 2011… for now. Image Gallery: Galaxy S II Image Gallery: Droid Bionic

The prices you will see in this article are from the carrier, when available. If you are new to a carrier or adding another line you will find excellent prices on Amazon.com and other online vendors like Wirefly. So you know where my personal perspective is coming from I am a long time (about 10 years) T-Mobile subscriber with five phones on a family plan and just signed up for a Verizon account with the HTC Thunderbolt. I had an AT&T account (mainly used only with data) for a couple of years and was a Sprint subscriber for about a year with devices like the HTC EVO 4G. I do have some experiences with each of the four major US wireless carriers and have also been purchasing SIM-unlocked smartphones for over 6 years. I personally will switch and pay the ETF to get a new device and jump to a carrier that offers me more for my money, but will most likely never try leaving T-Mobile with my family plan again (AT&T failed me big time when I tried that and my wife almost killed me due to the constant dropped calls).

Each carrier is different for all of us and is highly dependent on where you live, work, and play. I recommend you figure out which carrier works best for you before buying a device you won’t be happy with because of the carrier. There are many excellent smartphone options today and you honestly can’t really go wrong with any of the available choices. Like carriers, different smartphone operating systems work for different people because of their different strengths and weaknesses, 3rd party applications, and available form factors.

Enough about the disclaimers and warnings, let’s take a look at my list of Top 10 Smartphones of 2011 … for now.

Number 1: Samsung Galaxy S II

The Samsung Galaxy S line of smartphones had variants on all four major US wireless carriers, and on several regional carriers, and is an extremely successful line. The Samsung Galaxy S II takes the best of the Galaxy S line and improves it with an amazing 4.3 inch Super AMOLED Plus display, dual-core 1 GHz processor, 8.49mm form factor, 21 Mbps HSPA+ support, Android 2.3 (Gingerbread) OS, 8 megapixel camera, integrated memory and microSD card, 802.11 a/b/g/n WiFi, Bluetooth 3.0, and more.

The amazing Samsung display itself might be a reason to buy this device and if it comes to T-Mobile then I will likely be buying one for myself. You won’t have to worry about an OS upgrade since the Galaxy S II launches with Gingerbread already loaded too.

Number 2: Motorola Droid Bionic on Verizon

Verizon’s LTE network is the only network in the US that can seriously be considered a 4G network and the upcoming Droid Bionic may just be the best smartphone on the nation’s fastest network. The Droid Bionic sports a high resolution (540×960 pixels) 4.3 inch display, dual-core 1GHz processor, 8 megapixel camera, large capacity 1930 mAh battery, integrated 16GB of memory and microSD card slot, and support for the LTE network.

The device is scheduled to launch this quarter for an undisclosed price. It will likely launch with Android 2.2, but hopefully gets an update to 2.3 (Gingerbread) soon after release.

Number 3: T-Mobile LG G2X

LG really hasn’t focused on the high end Android smartphone market, but this year they will be offering several compelling candidates. One of the first ones that we should see will launch on T-Mobile as the LG G2x. This is the US model of the LG Optimus 2X and is a dual-core NVIDIA Tegra 2 processor smartphone running Android 2.2 with support for T-Mobile’s fast HSPA+ network. It will include an 8 megapixel camera, 4 inch display, enhanced audio technologies, front facing 1.3 megapixel camera, and 1080p recording capability.

T-Mobile has a high powered lineup of Android devices and the G2X looks to be at the top of the heap.

Let’s check out numbers 4 through 7 »

Matthew Miller started using a Pilot 1000 in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since.

Disclosure

Matthew Miller

Matthew is a professional naval architect by day and a mobile gadget freak at all other times. He purchases his own devices and then sells them on eBay or Craigslist to buy more. Many other devices are sent for review on a 30-day loaner basis and then returned to the carrier or manufacturer. If any are provided as “long term loaner units” this will be clearly disclosed in his reviews.

Biography

Matthew Miller

Matthew Miller started using a mobile devices in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since. He is a co-host with GigaOM's Kevin Tofel on the MobileTechRoundup podcast and an author of three Wiley Companion series books. Matthew started using mobile devices with a US Robotics Pilot 1000 and has owned over 125 different devices running Palm, Linux, Symbian, Newton, BlackBerry, iOS, Android, webOS, Windows Mobile, and Windows Phone operating systems. His current collection includes an HTC Radar 4G, Dell Venue Pro, Apple iPad 2, HTC Flyer, Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Nokia N9, Apple iPhone 4S, MacBook Pro, and many more, along with tons of accessories and classic devices like the Apple Newton MessagePad 2100 and Sony CLIE UX50. Matthew can be found on various discussion forums under the user name of "palmsolo".
204
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

Awesome Mobile App-Now Get Rewarded for Window Shopping
nishanth123 15th May
I've been a fan of the MintM Mobile Application.. It is a loyalty based reward system which rewards points even for window shopping and can redeem these points in big and fancy outlets.. Awesome app.. Just reviewed this app.. thought of sharing it with you people..
its free downloadable from

http://www.mintmapp.com/smartphone


Works best in android and Blackberry.. Enjoy happy
0 Votes
+ -
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder . . . as are the top 10 phones wink
0 Votes
+ -
Matt: by not declaring the iPhone as the indisputable #1 phone, you are asking for trouble. The hordes of crapplebots will rally and start throwing insults at you.
0 Votes
+ -
on this list by 2:1 or more and has a higher customer satisfaction rating than any other phone on the market. Why would you want to make it the number one phone? Oh, wait. I forgot. Because some idiot would come along and call you an Apple Tool.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Rick_K Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@nomorebs
The hordes of crapplebots will rally and start throwing insults at you.

Nice going there mr. (mrs/ms.) Apple hater. You should just admit that youre a Certified member of the Apple Haters Club. You can try and deny it, but your posts tell the real story.
@nomorebs: ... it also has IPS technology and all of its screen layers are glued together to fight parasitic refraction (Samsung has limited production of such technology with screens it names with "Super-").

Also, iPhone 4 has better battery life, is thinner, and it is not plasticky (better dissipates warmth), and it's antenna performance is vastly superior to possibilities of other phones (-122dB against -114dB for Android phones; of course, left lower corner should be treated with care).

Also, iPhone 4 has the biggest media resource library, biggest applications library, the only source of super-quality Retina class applications, AirPlay and AirPrint capabilities.

The only thing that it does not have it 4G/LTE, but there could not be other way since its tiny test-mode network would be dead in one day if Apple would support it now. Also, this 4G network is basically useless since it has so little coverage, and since Wi-Fi is working much faster, free of charge in very same places as this test mode was announced. Work, home, restaurants, hotels, airports -- Wi-Fi is everywhere.
0 Votes
+ -
@nomorebs

I'm currently a droid owner and after 9 months of use I kick myself every day for not buying the iPhone. The Droid is not worth the bugs and glitches. Apple with out a doubt has the best phone OS available at present.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
evilkillerwhale@... 28th Mar 2011
@nomorebs

Good troll.

As for the people who responded:
iPhone 4 is:
slower, less hearty, less reliable, less customizable, less connected (no Flash, less support from Google and social networks).

Personally, been there, done that, junked it, bought the Droid Incredible.

For the guy comparing the original Droid to the iPhone 4: You're comparing a 3 year old piece of crap to the current iPhone. Try comparing your Droid to the iPhone 3GS. Right. Droid wins in every single column.

Best screen resolution, you say? Did you notice that SEVERAL phones have the SAME or in a couple cases BETTER resolution? Right, iPhone loses again. Especially since it's been shown that the POS screen cracks like mad.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
worldbfree4me 28th Mar 2011
@denisrs
What about that tiny touch screen? Sure its high def, but It's like having 1440p on a 20 inch screen compared to the others! Oh and no flash either. When you go to say ESPN, you have to be re-directed to an IOS friendly link. If YouTube did not exist, video would not exist on IPhone/iPad !
0 Votes
+ -
@nomorebs
I want the one with the bigger GB's
0 Votes
+ -
@evilkillerwhales. iPhone less reliable? LMAO
Also, resolution is relative - how would you like 540x960 on a 32inch monitor? Of course that's an exaggeration, but my point is pixel density is what makes screen clearer and no one can touch iPhone 4 at the moment.
0 Votes
+ -
@denisrs. The "tiny" screen is fine...for now. Sure, it'll be nice if it's slightly larger...about 4". I wouldn't want it to be too large, though. As for flash, I have skyfire browser app which enables me to view flash, but honestly I've only used it about 3 times the whole year(2010-2011). There aren't much sites that "require" flash anymore. Due to the proliferation of iOS devices, most sites are iOS friendly.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Copyu Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@nomorebs
No choice...no contest...it HAS to be iPhone when you don't live in an English-speaking country. Android phones could offer a million free apps, but would it let me use the English language, if served by a Japanese carrier such as KDDI or DoCoMo? "Umm...maybe...it has full 'Roman alphabet' capability!" Not quite what I want or need. 'Smart-phones' can act pretty stupidly outside of the USA! Capitalization, hyphenation, auto-correction (etc, etc,) for the 'world language'...It was a no-brainer, easy choice for me! May not be the 'best', but it's the ONLY choice for a couple of million foreigners in Japan...and we're happy, long-term, repeat customers! NO CONTEST!
0 Votes
+ -
iPhone dumbest
haugens Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@nomorebs
Until Apple updates the iOS to allow transfer of files over the bluetooth interface, it is the dumbest of the smart phones. Even the Motorola RAZR could swap ringtones and photos over bluetooth.
The iPhone can't be considered a smart phone without basic functionality of its hardware.
0 Votes
+ -
@nomorebs Thats why its got 20% vote becaues all the fanboys are voting.
0 Votes
+ -
@nomorebs You expressed my sentiments so eloquently!
0 Votes
+ -
@evilkillerwhale You do realize that the Droid came out less than 9 months before the iPhone 4 didn't it? Not sure where you were coming up with 3 years. Doesn't really matter though because you seem to have a clear bias against Apple and are too immature to realize that one size doesn't fit all. The iPhone doesn't fit your needs/wants, so what, you have other choices and I hope you are happy with the one you made. Other's are happy with going iPhone so get over yourself and you might realize what you think doesn't apply to everyone else.
0 Votes
+ -
@denisrs LTE will be in every major metropolitan are in the USA by the end of July and 40% of the population will have access to it.

There will be tons of 4G android phones on the market as the final cities go live.
0 Votes
+ -
As a iPhone user...
MacNewton 29th Jun
@nomorebs

The phone looks good and has nice features and I like it, but just like a person that spots an oil painting reproduction of the Mona Lisa , the base DNA is still an Apple ripoff.

No one is going to forget that!
0 Votes
+ -
@Kabcock

Ummm.... except for Windows Phone 7. It's absolutely the best mobile OS out atm. Apple is just the consumer preference atm. Android is buggy as hell, but I didn't find iOS to be significantly better. Windows phone 7 phones on the whole are solid, the OS is *rock* solid, and they took a lesson from apple and made all the phones the same screen size, which makes it easier to develop a consistent experience (not that you actually need it since it has SVG support, but it's nice that they went there). It's also just a better development experience on the whole, objective-c is unnecessarily like pulling teeth.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
JimboNobody 28th Mar 2011
@ptorning
Please give 4G results for a market where all the vendors have 4G. After saying that AT&T speed was pitiful, you note in passing that they only have 3G service in Seattle.
0 Votes
+ -
I like the Samsung Galaxy S II. Though it could do with a better UI.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 28th Mar 2011
@ctsrajan How So?
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
jhughesy Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@Peter Android UI is really bad design. Inconsistent and laggy.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 31st Mar 2011
@jhughesy WTF are you talking about? This allows each phone to have a unique look... The back end is 100% compatible within revisions.

As far as laggy goes, My Incredible was a better phone than the iPhone 4... Not only did it do everything the Apple could do it did some things the Apple couldn't do... Oh and my Amoled Screen is actually better than Apple.

Now I have the Thunderbolt and guess what? It is even faster than the incredible and the UI has a few more options but it is 100% Uniform with the incredible.

Ultimately, the iPhone 4 was mostly old tech when it came out as others were already solid in the areas it improved in but now it is about to be throttled by a storm of new phones and the Thunderbolt / Atrix just fired the first shots of this next wave.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
non-biased Updated - 31st Mar 2011
@Peter Perry Ultimately, the iPhone * was mostly old tech when it came out as others were already solid in the areas it improved in but now it is about to be throttled by a storm of new phones...

We have heard this year after year now but the iPhone still outsells all the other comparible phones.
0 Votes
+ -
@non-biased Apparently you have not seen the latest stats...

IPhone 4 is being handily out sold by the Thunderbolt...

I know what you're going to say... Don't forget about At&t... to which, I reply... Then we might as well add the EVO to this mix as well seeing the differences between the Thunderbolt and EVO are pretty much the same differences between the two iPhones.
0 Votes
+ -
Im wondering how a phone which has problems with basic reception when being held in hand gets into the top 10 phones...? You couldn't make it up if you tried! :-P
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 28th Mar 2011
@jhughesy The Death Grip is not as easy to reproduce on the Verizon Model, I was trying and I needed two fingers to even come close to the effects of the AT&T Model.
0 Votes
+ -
@Peter Perry I'm sure that works out great for right handed users. Those of us that are lefties will still have the meat of our palms covering the antenna.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 31st Mar 2011
@hungryjoe From what I had seen and tried myself I was unable to replicate the results of the iPhone on AT&T period.
0 Votes
+ -
@jhughesy Take it back to your bridge! The "death grip" isn't as horrible as most iPhone haters make it out to be. When a simple bumper or a case fixes the problem (something you should have on your phone anyway), then I don't really consider it a problem. I would much rather have a phone with a easily fixable reception issue, then an entire platform/OS (Android that is) that had a vital text issue (Remember that little problem?) that needed to be fixed via an update. I am not an Android hater by any means, there phones and the OS are amazing, but stop bashing a phone for an old flaw that really isn't a concern anymore.
0 Votes
+ -
@Bates_ It is a concern. My colleague just bought one in Europe and the signal gets blocked when he holds it without a case on it.

Stop being an apologist for poor design. The concern is real, its here and its now. Only Apple could fool the populace enough to get away with this.
0 Votes
+ -
@jhughesy
fr_gough 28th Mar 2011
when you start ripping motorola and other phones with the exact same issue just as vehemently as you are ripping Apple, then we'll listen to you. Until then, you're nothing more than an ideologue on a rant.
0 Votes
+ -
@Bates_ Still in denial I see. We have many phones here in the office. None of them experience this problem except iPhone 4.

No point in arguing with an Apple loon tbh.
0 Votes
+ -
@Bates_ the death grip is just the worst case issue. Most smartphones, made by actual mobile phone companies, have at least 2-way diversity antennas. So whether its your hand blocking the signal, your body attenuating it, or just the orientation of the phone to the cell tower, two antennas are the nrom, and much better than one.
0 Votes
+ -
You need a case to fix a design flaw?
archangel9999 28th Mar 2011
@Bates_ Then presumably you also update the physical specs of the iPhone (weight, width, height, depth) for the presence of the case? So it's no longer as light, nor as thin, nor as...

And why "should" everyone have a case on their phone? Not everyone's phone has a design flaw a case needs to cover for nor is as easily damaged? My phone's extremely durable out of the box, gorilla glass, high impact, etc.

Case? We don't need no stinking case... happy
0 Votes
+ -
any number of other phones out there.

The whole thing was just a nice little witch hunt whipped up be people who don't like Apple for whatever reason.
0 Votes
+ -
@frgough@... It a fact that many other phones dont have this issue. I have experienced it first hand. No other phones in our office experience it.

You guys just love the Apple marketing stuff dont you. Jeez. Get a grip!
0 Votes
+ -
@jhughesy

"It a fact that many other phones dont have this issue. I have experienced it first hand. No other phones in our office experience it. "

Not quite. NO other phone has the same issue as the iPhone4. None.

It's true that you can effect the signal of many phones by holding it in various ways, or smothering it, but that is a COMPLETELY different issue from "death grip". The iPhone can be affected by the same things that other phones can plus the death grip.

You have to go back to the 80s retractable antenna models to find exposed bare metal antennas, and no other phone has ever had a bare-metal antenna built into the handle. It's inexcusably bad design.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 31st Mar 2011
@frgough@... Really? According to Consumer Reports it wasn't a major issue with other phones but you guys never believe the truth with the Blue Fruit Blinders On!
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Rick_K Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@jhughesy
Im wondering how a phone which has problems with basic reception when being held in hand gets into the top 10 phones?

Maybe because it only affects 2%, to at most 4%, of the users? I tried to replicate it on several AT&T and Verizon iPhones, sadly I was unable t replicate it. I have also seen other phone lose signal when they were held in a seemingly normal way. These phones were the Palm Treo Pro, and the HTC Touch Pro. Neither one was made by Apple, so maybe they really didnt have that problem? Maybe those dropped calls were just my imagination (as well as the person on the other end)? Or is the problem not specific to one phone?
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Xander_Crews Updated - 28th Mar 2011
@Rick_K
Not from my experience. I work with four people who have iPhones, and all four have the antenna issue. They had to either get cases or band-aid stickers to put over the offending area.
Where did you pull your 2%-4% number?
From my experience, more people have the issue than don't have the issue.
Personally, I've owned half a dozen different cell phones in my day...and I never lost signal because of how I held it. And that includes my Google G1 and now my Droid2.
0 Votes
+ -
@Xander_Crews The key point in your comment is the "Not from my experience." portion of it. I have heard the 2%-4% figure a few times but nobody really knows. In my experience I have yet to find anybody I know with an iPhone 4 that has this issue. So in my experience 0% are affected but my experience is no more fact to the overall percentage affected than yours. If it was even half as bad as the haters would like to make it out to be then the return rate on iPhone 4s would be significant, obviously they aren't. You even said that you work with four people that had iPhones who experience this issue but apparently it wasn't an issue that overshadowed what they liked about the phone so they kept it. I would say that's far more telling that the fact you supposedly know 4 people that have the issue.
0 Votes
+ -
@Rick_K 100% of AT&T iPhone 4's have this issue... I had a friend who made the same claim as you and I had his signal nonexistant in under a minute.
0 Votes
+ -
@jhughesy
16,000,000 units sold in the last quarter...
0 Votes
+ -
@Hasam1991 It is the same old trap as in the 80's and you guys still don't get it, the hardware vendor is irrelevant as the Android phones sold 27.5 Million last quarter and they're showing no signs of slowing down yet!
0 Votes
+ -
iPhone 4 Antenna
50thJumper 28th Mar 2011
@jhughesy The antenna is a non issue. Apple provided a very well made bumper for the phone free of charge and I haven't had a problem since. Even without the bumper I had few problems. However, my Android users call me (IT Dept.) quite often to setup their email after the device quits responding and has to be reset. I rarely have to reboot my iPhone and have never had to do any sort of a hard reset. Apple is not without flaws but comes closer to hitting the mark than anything else out there.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Xander_Crews 28th Mar 2011
@50thJumper
You're missing the point. It is still an issue, but Apple is hiding it by providing a "very well made bumper"...lol.
They shouldn't have to provide anything...except a replacement phone with redesigned hardware...which won't happen.
And if I had an iPhone, I wouldn't want to cover up that slick design with a flipping bumper. The iPhone looks cool, why in the hell would you want to cover it up with a piece of rubber or plastic?
Apple fail.
I'll leave you with this...
I have to reboot my computer every now and then, but I never have to reboot my daughter's See N' Say. Simple minded devices for simple minded folks tend to not need a lot of maintenance.
0 Votes
+ -
@Xander_Crews So your saying that your daughter is simple minded, not a very proud father are you :-o
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 ... for now
Peter Perry 28th Mar 2011
The only thing I disagree with is the placement of the iPhone as the phone seems a bit dated compared to most on this list and the Original EVO whooped it in most reviews so I cannot see the 3D falling behind and the Thunderbolt is essentially a Better EVO on Verizon.

I do understand the phones placement in the Top 10 as the Cameras and the screen should put it there.
I've been a fan of the MintM Mobile Application.. It is a loyalty based reward system which rewards points even for window shopping and can redeem these points in big and fancy outlets.. Awesome app.. Just reviewed this app.. thought of sharing it with you people..
its free downloadable from

http://www.mintmapp.com/smartphone


Works best in android and Blackberry.. Enjoy happy

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix