ie8 fix
madison

Top 10 smartphones of 2011 (Holiday Gift Guide)

By | November 1, 2011, 4:10am PDT

Summary: Apple’s iOS and Google Android are the two clear leaders in the smartphone market here in the U.S. so it was easy to pick the top two devices from these platforms. The next eight were not as easy in such a competitive market.

The beginning of the year always starts with a bang with smartphones being revealed at CES, Mobile World Congress and CTIA. I created a preliminary top 10 smartphones list in March and now that we have all the major anticipated announcements for the year I thought it was fitting to post my top 10 smartphones for the year 2011. Many of the phones I had on that list are present in this new list, but now that I have had hands-on time with some my perspective has changed. Some have yet to be released, but should be coming before the holidays so I included them as well. There are some great devices coming in 2012, but since it is likely we won’t see them this year I couldn’t include them in this list.

Last year I posted my top 10 smartphones of 2010 article in May, but Apple pushed back their iPhone 4S announcement from the traditional summer time frame. Google and Microsoft also made major announcements just this month. It is getting a bit easier to pick top platforms as iOS and Android are the clear leaders with Windows Phone on the move up and BlackBerry on the way down. BlackBerry devices are still 3rd in U.S. market share, but their OS is getting dated and we won’t see much excitement for the platform until QNX-based devices hit the streets. webOS is non-existent and out of the picture while Symbian is rare to find here in the U.S.

I was at Nokia World last week and saw the solid Nokia 710 and 800 devices and initially had the 800 planned for 3rd place, but since we are unlikely to see either of them here in the U.S. until early 2012 I had to take them off the list.

You can check out several product photos of these top 10 devices in my image gallery, but I also highly recommend you visit your carrier store or local electronics retailer to get some hands-on time with a device before you make your purchase decision. Also, check out online reviews from multiple sites to get a good feel for the devices.


Image Gallery: Check out photos of my top 10 smartphones of 2011. Image Gallery: iPhone 4S Image Gallery: Nokia N9

The prices you will see in this article are from the carrier, when available. If you are new to a carrier or adding another line you will find excellent prices on Amazon.com and other online vendors like Wirefly. Each carrier is different for all of us and performance is highly dependent on where you live, work, and play. I recommend you figure out which carrier works best for you before buying a device you won’t be happy with because of the carrier. There are many excellent smartphone options today and you honestly can’t really go wrong with any of the available choices. Like carriers, different smartphone operating systems work for different people because of their different strengths and weaknesses, 3rd party applications, and available form factors.

Enough about the disclaimers and warnings, let’s take a look at my list of Top 10 Smartphones of 2011. I hope you find this helpful as we head into the holiday buying season.

Number 1: Apple iPhone 4S

I participated in the ZDNet Great Debate for the Apple iPhone 4S, but readers overwhelmingly voted against it and many in the tech press stated it was not much of an upgrade. However, consumers responded in a big way and Apple had record opening weekend sales exceeding 4 million devices.

I became an iPhone owner again with the iPhone 4S on Verizon and am very happy with the device. The internals were bumped up with a dual-core processor, updated antenna design, and 8 megapixel camera. The Siri artificial intelligence utility is excellent and even in beta demonstrates a new way to interact with your device. I love that I can make appointments and set alarms with a few short words and the iPhone 4S is changing the way I use my smartphone. You can also SIM unlock the Verizon iPhone 4S for true world phone usage with Sprint and AT&T having slightly different policies. I used my iPhone 4S with my Truphone SIM in London and it worked very well.

The Apple iPhone 4S is available on AT&T, Verizon, and Sprint for $199 (16GB), $299 (32GB), and $399 (64GB) with a two-year contract. The unsubsidized, no-contract prices range from $649 (16GB) to $849 (64GB), depending on your carrier.

Number 2: Samsung Galaxy Nexus

Google rolled out the Nexus One back in January 2010 as their flagship device that supports the latest Android operating system. The Nexus S was released last year and just last week Google and Samsung announced the Galaxy Nexus that will be coming to the U.S. with Verizon confirmed to get the device first before the end of this year.

Unlike the previous Nexus devices, there is really nothing missing in this latest device, including the latest wireless radios. The Galaxy Nexus sports a 4.65 inch 1280×720 Super AMOLED HD display, LTE and HSPA+ pentaband support, Android 4.0 (Ice Cream Sandwich), NFC, barometer, 1080p HD video camera, 1750 mAh battery and more. I have regularly ranted on this blog about the lack of pentaband 3G data support that currently only Nokia provides in true world phone fashion with support for frequencies in all ranges. Thankfully, the new Galaxy Nexus is a pentaband phone, with support for the 21 Mbps HSPA+ data network so it is highly likely I will be picking one up to use with T-Mobile USA.

There is no pricing or availability yet and it sounds like it will roll out in Europe and other countries first with a Verizon LTE model coming before the end of 2011. It’s not clear if we will see one launching on AT&T or T-Mobile here in the U.S.

Number 3: HTC Titan

Readers know I am a major Windows Phone fan and I know it hasn’t yet been adopted by a large number of Americans, but it really is fantastic and everyone I know that tries it out likes it. I was going to put one of the new Nokia Windows Phone devices here in 3rd, but none are coming to the U.S. this year so I am throwing in the HTC Titan that is coming to AT&T soon, likely in November. I finally had a chance to try out the HTC Titan this week and even though the display is huge, it is quite thin and extremely well made.

The HTC Titan has a massive 4.7 inch Super LCD display at the same standard 800×480 resolution that still looks crisp and clear. It has a 1.5 GHz processor, 16GB integrated storage, 512MB RAM, 1600 mAh battery, HSPA+ radio (up to 14.4 Mbps downloads), and 8 megapixel camera. HTC had done work with their cameras and it is actually quite good.

There is no pricing yet for AT&T, but Microsoft recently showed it off and it is coming to the carrier soon.

Let’s check out numbers 4 through 7 »

Matthew Miller started using a Pilot 1000 in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since.

Disclosure

Matthew Miller

Matthew is a professional naval architect by day and a mobile gadget freak at all other times. He purchases his own devices and then sells them on eBay or Craigslist to buy more. Many other devices are sent for review on a 30-day loaner basis and then returned to the carrier or manufacturer. If any are provided as “long term loaner units” this will be clearly disclosed in his reviews.

Biography

Matthew Miller

Matthew Miller started using a mobile devices in 1997 and has been writing news, reviews, and opinion pieces ever since. He is a co-host with GigaOM's Kevin Tofel on the MobileTechRoundup podcast and an author of three Wiley Companion series books. Matthew started using mobile devices with a US Robotics Pilot 1000 and has owned over 125 different devices running Palm, Linux, Symbian, Newton, BlackBerry, iOS, Android, webOS, Windows Mobile, and Windows Phone operating systems. His current collection includes an HTC Radar 4G, Dell Venue Pro, Apple iPad 2, HTC Flyer, Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Nokia N9, Apple iPhone 4S, MacBook Pro, and many more, along with tons of accessories and classic devices like the Apple Newton MessagePad 2100 and Sony CLIE UX50. Matthew can be found on various discussion forums under the user name of "palmsolo".
64
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Top 10 smartphones of 2011 (Holiday Gift Guide)
tub2224 15th Feb
the fact that the new Nokia super-phones is not available in the US shouldn't be the reason for the exclusion, Nokia N8; 12Megapixel cam too good. the newer models are absolutely great, i prefer them 2 any other phone


http://www.dongyecrafts.com
0 Votes
+ -
Nokia Windows Phones?
SpinachConvention 1st Nov
Matt, where do the Nokia WP phones figure in this? Are they outside your top 10, or not on the list because they aren't released in the US this year? I'm on the look out for a new phone and want to make sure I'm not backing the wrong horse! (Again!)
0 Votes
+ -
Master Joe Says...Read
MasterJoe 1st Nov
@SpinachConvention Look in the HTC Titan description. As Matt says, these phones will nto be available until sometime early in 2012, which is why he chose the Titan instead of one of them. Since this is being pushed as a "Holiday Guide," the late arrival of the Nokia WP7 phones exclude them from the list, rather than being excluded because they don't belong there.

--Master Joe
@MasterJoe
And yet he includes the Nokia N9, saying that while it won't be available in the US, it's a great device that warrants attention, blah blah blah.
So it DOES beg the question, "where's the Lumia 800?!"
Here in France, the Lumia 800 is the TOP selling phone this week, outselling iPhone 4s and Galaxy II S.
And the Lumia is only in pre-order. Wait till it makes to market!
http://www.phonehouse.fr/top_50_ventes.php
0 Votes
+ -
Turd Burger
LLisa80 Updated - 30th Nov
@SpinachConvention Argh a windows phone, no thank you
Typical, iPhone 4s is at the top with little details as to why... Of course the glaring bit that stands out is that. You own one. That is an average consumers view, "my phone is the best because i own it".

The iPhone 4s is a decent phone but for every great thing about it there is something that isn't so great.
0 Votes
+ -
Master Joe Says...Trade Off
MasterJoe 1st Nov
@Peter Perry They fixed teh antenna, and broke the battery life longjevity, one of the major selling points of many Apple devices. I don't believe anyone should have to choose between good signal and good battery life. But, the difference between the iPhone 4 and 4S is just that. Go figure.

--Master Joe
@Peter Perry Agreed. I would have bet everything in my checking account (admittedly not that much) that the 4S was going to be at the top of this list before I even clicked the link.

Sales were so good because based on last querter's iPhone sales, people were holding out for the iPhone 5 and when it didn't materialize, they settled for the 4S. The release is a total disappointment. If the galaxy nexus was similarly hobbled, the tech bloggers would be saying that Android was dead.
@redhaven The release of iPhone 4S was a disappointment to who? No one settled on getting the new phone. Also, there was no such thing as iPhone 5. You've fell into the hype that everyone was saying about a product no one knew nothing about.
@Keonidas

Uh, that was his point?
Where is the Samsung Focus S?. This phone should be better than all those crappy androids out there....
@owlnet
Exactly...
@owlnet

+1 that the Samsung Focus S should be included in the list somewhere (possibly in place of the HTC Titan).

While the HTC Titan has a slightly larger display (4.7"), the Samsung Focus S has a 4.3" Super AMOLED Plus, and is thinner (8.4mm vs 9.9mm) and lighter (111g vs 160g). Both front and rear camera specs are the same (8MP & 1.3MP), although comparisons of picture quality are yet to be seen. The Focus S has a slightly slower processor clock at 1.4GHz vs the Titan at 1.5GHz, but that's likely unnoticeable with WP 7.5.

Personally, I'll wait until comparison reviews are available, but on paper it looks like the Focus S edges out the Titan.
@owlnet
Couldn't agree more. I had an HTC Infuse 4G droid phone for a week before I traded it in on a Samsung Focus Win7 phone. Couldn't be happier. I also played with an iPhone 3GS for a couple of weeks before getting the droid phone and far prefer Win7 over Android and iOS...
@owlnet i'd say the Focus S is at least in the 5th or 6th position, i mean cmon, it's the WP version of the SGS2!

in any case, any 2nd gen wp (focus flash, radar, lumia 800) can easily stack up to these steroid-induced android phones.
0 Votes
+ -
Nokia Smart
nblazer Updated - 1st Nov
the fact that the new Nokia super-phones is not available in the US shouldn't be the reason for the exclusion, Nokia N8; 12Megapixel cam too good. the newer models are absolutely great, i prefer them 2 any other phone
0 Votes
+ -
International...
wright_is 1st Nov
It would be good if you could include the international names for the phones, I assume (looking at the pictures), that the Amaze, for instance, is the Sensation?

The American market is a bit baffling, looking in, from the outside. Each carrier seems to take the same handset, but call it something different.

Personally, I select the phone I want, then see what sort of deal the carriers will give me.

I have the Sensation, as well as a Mozart and a 3GS, so I chose the Galaxy Nexus as the phone I'd want... Although I am happy with the Sensation and Mozart (home and work phones) and have no plans to upgrade, yet.

I had to sort out an iPhone 4S the other day, and have to say, I prefer the way the htc 'phones feel in the hand. The iPhone 4/S feels "wrong" somehow.

And given the reliability problems (one user has had 5 replacement iPhone 4s since May!), I wouldn't rate the iPhone highly at the moment...
@wright_is
To some degree you are correct. We have GSM carriers (AT&T and T-Mobile but with different frequencies) and CDMA phones (Verizon and Sprint, maybe also with different frequencies, I am not sure). This requires different transceviers and causes many phones to be different, at least from a radio perspective. Since it's America, it can't be simple ! wink
I don't have any issues of 3D on LG Thrill, but I see EVO 3D as solid and robust phone than LG Thrill. I own both, I traded by Atrix 4G and got LG Thrill recently because of 3D camera.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@Rama.NET I have to agree. I tested both the LG Thrill 3G and the HTC EVO 3D and found the Thrill to be more glitchy but offers better battery life than the Evo 3D. The Thrill is a better deal if you really want a 3D phone (prefer its 3D effects to the HTC) but the Evo 3D was the more stable device of the two.
0 Votes
+ -
I think if someone
NoAxToGrind 1st Nov
I think if someone ruined my holidays by giving me one of those time wasters they would be wearing it in an orfice NOT designed for it. wink
can't believe the Galaxy II is so far down your list? Such a crackin' phone.... Apple bias? PC Pro rate it as their best smart phone yet you have it lying very far down the list...
0 Votes
+ -
Deplore the Order but
rhonin 1st Nov
At least most of the top ones are included.

Hate to say it, but if you are basing the number 1 spot on sales, ......... you get my point. That's like saying the Toyota Camry is the best car over all because it is the best seller in the US.....

Weighted review but not bad.
@rhonin Bingo!
0 Votes
+ -
No Sonyericsson Xperia Play?
cromanillos@... 1st Nov
Where's the Xperia Play in this list? none of the other phones have gaming controls like this one, and that is a BIG plus.
0 Votes
+ -
Xperia
batvette 1st Nov
@cromanillos@... So much potential, dropped the ball. I'm with you on the controls, but my friend had nothing but troubles with the network,games not downloading. Lots of voices out there of disappointment.
Whatever you do at this time do not get anyone a Galaxy S II Epic 4G Touch, the Sprint phone is bad. Plagued by a loss of service bug that will render the phone useless until you power it off and on again, and to further worsen the issue while it is in this bugged state it burns through your battery life drastically, actually gets very warm in your pocket... http://community.sprint.com/baw/thread/76962?start=0&tstart=0
0 Votes
+ -
I beg my pardon...
Solid Water Updated - 1st Nov
@mrbdye

No problem with mine. Using it every day for a month - yet to see any problem.

1800mA battery and SAMOLED+ also helps.

YMMV

Just followed the link... 405 posts... Am I lucky or what?
0 Votes
+ -
@mrbdye
It's the Sprint network that sucks. My son defected from AT&T to Sprint and a new iPhone 4S. The Sprint network was so slow (he said it was like having dialup Internet access) that he brought the phone back, got his money back, and went back to his 3G with AT&T. He's now on the waiting list for a 4S with them... Stay away from Sprint. There's a reason Sprint offers unlimited everything for $79/month.....
I am correct that there is only 1 QWERTY on this list and that is a Blackberry ? It would seem that an Android QWERTY option would be a hit, at least to some. Any thoughts on the best one of those ?
@jkohut I hated touchscreens until I figured out:
landscape mode! doubles the keypad size, who knew? and always touch left.
I wouldn't want a phone at least twice as thick and more trouble prone from moving parts, which it would require- but I do miss full qwerty.
@batvette
Thank you for your input. I have a 10" Android tablet and even on that size of screen, find that touch type on on-screen keyboard isn't very productive (I can type fairly well on my Nokie E71 with QWERTY as I can use both thumbs to save time without having to move much).
@batvette
Have you tried SWYPE on screen keyboard?
It is seriously good!
After using Swype you won't miss the physical keyboard.
Hey I gotta chime in for the impoverished here, two bits for unlimited texting, messaging and web, 300 minutes talk. If the welfare/unemployment/recycling check is late, not a dime in penalties, I just restart my month when I get the funds.
Virgin Mobile Motorola Triumph. $270.
Cheap. It's the new "cool".
So basically as it stands now 58% of the people that voted, voted for an Android OS powered phone. happy
0 Votes
+ -
Knows little about phones...
hechizero 1st Nov
This guy must be on a number of xmas card lists at MS and Apple. This site is becoming the Fox News of tech. This is a totally lame list with pretty meaningless specs listed. Subjective waffle.
I want a phone that doesn't feel as if I am holding an Etch-a-Sketch up to my ear...what's with the huge screens? Fully one half of smart phone users are women whose smaller hands want smaller phones. I've heard many both men and women choose iPhones because they find the current crop of Android phones just too ridiculously large. I want 4G, but I'm hanging on to my Incredible for physical comfort's sake.
0 Votes
+ -
LMAO!!!!
rhonin 1st Nov
@gamebird
One big misconception on size; have then use a larger screen phone (anything 4"+) for a month then go to an iPhone 4 or 4S.

Good functionality or not the iphone screen just looks small - kind of like going from a Sonata to an Accent ..... you feel cramped and a bit cheated.
@rhonin - it's about holding the phone - what feels good in your hand!! And those big screens - although a joy to look at - are not a joy to hold. And what about the makeup shmear, girls? That monster phone rubbing your face acquiring layers of blush?
@gamebird
Seems to me that is the beauty of Android (and other OSes/phones allowing for size/feature choice other than Apple). You can use those others if you want to fit within the constraints of what Jobs/Apple thought was a nice compromise, but if you want something different, you gotta go elsewhere.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@gamebird I have really small hands (adult size XS gloves for women are too big sometimes) and yet I have no problems using my phone with a 4.5-inch screen. Besides it's great for my poor eyesight... Who wants to have to squint to see what's on your phone when there are larger options around?

On the makeup issue, I guess it helps I hardly get voice calls as I use my phone mostly for texting/data so I don't usually hold my phone up to my face. I think most people use wired or Bluetooth headsets and cover their phones with screen protectors so there are workarounds.

Most people who see me with my phone tend to be shocked then envious of the size of the awesome display. Many even go so far as to say they need to upgrade from their iPhone to an Android device just for the larger screen!
Strange that you list it way down the pecking order when it obviously has been edging ahead of the iPhone 4S for months. Then again, just because you have a 4S makes it the best phone... grow a set.
@ptoner

Aren't we all kind of prone to favor the device we use--whatever that is? Opinions, especially in the mobile phone debate, are like...you know the rest.
0 Votes
+ -
@ptoner
"when it obviously has been edging ahead of the iPhone 4S for MONTHS". You are kidding right? The 4S has been on the street for WEEKS now not MONTHS....
0 Votes
+ -
You must be smoking pots or something to put the High Potential Galaxy S2... just check the Poll Result at the end of the article...
@mmacwan83

The Galaxy S2 is a nice-enough phone for now, but it will be surpassed by the Galaxy Nexus when that comes out.
Because I have to wait until prices came down. I have Chosen the HTC Sensation. I don't think this is a mistake. Read many great reports.. Seems some are disappointed because the Audio don't equal a Boom Box.. I am sight impaired and motorcycle Deaf.. So I feel this Phone will fit me after I learn the 250 pages of the Manual to enjoy all the features.. The 8 meg Camera beats the tar out of my older 6 meg Box camera from a few years ago...
0 Votes
+ -
Of the top 10 smartphones listed:
the Samsung Galaxy Nexus is not available in the US
the HTC Titan *may* be coming to AT&T
the Nokia N9 is not available in the US
the Motorola Droid RAZR is coming in November to Verison

Some choices. How about the top 10 that are available NOW, in the United States?
@tomjw217

This is a holiday gift guide, not a "now" gift guide. And the US is not the world.
@tomjw217
Well, the author did advertise this as a Holiday 'Gift Guide' so some of these phones may be available here before the Holidays...
There was an option missing from "what is your vote for the best phone". It was "none of the above". I would have voted for the Motorola Photon.
the fact that the new Nokia super-phones is not available in the US shouldn't be the reason for the exclusion, Nokia N8; 12Megapixel cam too good. the newer models are absolutely great, i prefer them 2 any other phone


http://www.dongyecrafts.com

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix