A Chrome Notebook is on the way - and so is a new approach to 1:1

A Chrome Notebook is on the way - and so is a new approach to 1:1

Summary: Christmas is coming early to the Dawson household - A Chrome notebook is on its way and my number 1 task is to evaluate just how well (or how poorly) it meets educational needs.

SHARE:

Well apparently that old adage about "ask and ye shall have" is right. At least when it comes to bloggers getting Chrome notebooks. Larry Dignan already got his, but it looks like mine will be coming in the mail later this week. Unfortunately, I don't get to be in the pilot program, but that was a crapshoot anyway. Now I just get to blog to my heart's content about the notebook and its position in all of the markets it can touch.

Google is especially bullish about the notebooks in the enterprise and education. The latter is where my real interest lies. As I wrote last night over on the Google blog,

My first thought? This is how 1:1 student computing is going to look for schools that don’t decide to go the tablet route. Combined with Google Apps for Education (a free version of Google Apps for educational institutions), the notebooks stand to be priced and featured in ways that scream for schools to adopt this as a platform.

Tablets are great and I'm all about finding ways to co-opt kids' phones. Thin clients work well and save money using any number of underlying technologies. However, a computer with a full-sized keyboard, a decent-sized screen, no access to the inner workings of the computer, and complete leveraging of the cloud to ensure that dogs can never again eat homework sounds like a machine made for schools.

Just think: No more reimaging. No more backups or disaster recovery. No more Office licensing. No more, "Sorry the Internet's down - put away your computers" (100MB a month of Verizon 3G is included for emergencies or times when Wifi isn't available. And all those great sites for collaboration, social learning, and student-teacher interaction? Just post links to them on a Google Site and kids are right there.

Of course, this also means that schools won't be installing Photoshop or Autocad on these machines. Desktop applications, whether Windows, Mac, or Linux won't be happening. There will always be places where more flexibility is needed and specialized computer labs or standard notebooks aren't going away.

However, as I discussed with a reader tonight, hardware and software applications are becoming far less important in educational technology, while the "platform" becomes critical. Whether that platform is Google Apps, a great LMS, a well-designed wiki farm, or a fully integrated SIS (or some combination thereof), all you really need is the Web.

Chrome delivers that.

What remains to be seen is how these machines will be managed (at least in terms of what little management needs to be done), how users will respond to a new interface (both physical and on-screen), and whether critical skills for students can be fully addressed in only a web browser. Do students need to know how to use a word processor? What if their college or future place of business isn't running business applications in the cloud?

It looks like Citrix will be stepping up and providing Windows application virtualization compatible with Chrome OS, so some of these questions might be moot. I'm inclined to believe that all our students need to know how to do is think, seek out information, synthesize and process it, and then use it, preferably with their peers.

A long-term test of the Chrome Notebook (fingers crossed that it will be here tomorrow), working its way through my kids and their teachers, librarians, techs, and other edu-geeks, will give us a clearer picture of what, if anything, students might be missing by relying on 1:1 devices for the cloud. Where will specialized labs need to fill in gaps? How strong is the value proposition and how do web apps evolve for use in the classroom? We'll find out over the next several months.

And any schools/teachers who manage to make it into the pilot, make sure to share your experiences!

Topics: Hardware, Browser, Laptops, Mobility

Christopher Dawson

About Christopher Dawson

Chris Dawson is a freelance writer, consultant, and policy advocate with 20 years of experience in education, technology, and the intersection of the two.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

8 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Desktop applications

    <blockquote>Desktop applications, whether Windows, Mac, or Linux won?t be happening.</blockquote>

    So Chrome won't support Java? That's the only way to prevent Java "applets" that are effectively full-up desktop applications invoked from a website. Or perhaps Chrome won't cache anything, making it prohibitively slow to load nontrivial Java.

    All in all, I don't see a way to simultaneously provide a useful cloud client while preventing useful local computing.
    Yagotta B. Kidding
    • I was expecting a version of the Javik VM for ChromeOS, but, Oracle

      rattling their sabers over Java, and, the native client coming, might just about kill Java on Chrome, and maybe even on Android eventually. You should read about how Google is finally figuring out how to make C/C++ code a whole lot safer, and give it intermediate code that makes it cross platform.
      DonnieBoy
  • i'm sorry, the web runs primarilly on 3 things

    web coding (HTML,php,ask,etc.), Java and Flash. Any computer OS, ANY OS period, needs to have the capability to run these three things. Its not that hard, flash is out for android, java's been around for mobile apps forever, there's no reason why anyone, including chrome, shouldn't be making all of these available.
    KBot
  • RE: A Chrome Notebook is on the way - and so is a new approach to 1:1

    I hope mine is on the way - I have been moving my freshman tech class to web apps and would really like to see what this machine does.
    By the way - if you really do need all of the power for specific programs (video production) use this machine for fun!
    kgorman@...
  • RE: A Chrome Notebook is on the way - and so is a new approach to 1:1

    I applied for a Chrome notebook a couple days ago. I haven't been selected, I guess.

    Can you monitor the 3g usage?

    And what do you mean by "a new approach to 1:1?" What is 1:1?
    ron.cleaver@...
    • What is 1:1?? First, where have you been??? Second, have you heard of this

      thing called SEARCH???? Go ahead and try it, available at google.com.
      DonnieBoy
  • Actually, I really like the idea of Native Client. The more I hear, the

    more I like it. It seems that Google is the first to really try to do a cross-platform, sandboxed, intermediate code, C/C++ environment. Being a C/C++ programmer, this gets me a lot more excited than Java. Combined with Oracle's recent Java moves, I just really have no desire any more to write any more Java code.
    DonnieBoy
  • Chris: Google could put their weight behind Gimp, and created a native

    client version for ChromeOS. They could even make parts of Gimp work on the cloud instead of locally. This is part of what native client is all about.
    DonnieBoy