Employer demands Facebook login credentials during interview
Summary: Officer Robert Collins tells the story of how the Maryland Division of Corrections demanded his Facebook login credentials during a recertification interview.
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has taken up the cause of Officer Robert Collins, a Maryland man who was forced to hand over his Facebook login credentials during a recertification interview with the Maryland Division of Corrections (DOC). Collins took the time to describe what happened in his specific case in a video on YouTube.
On January 25, the ACLU of Maryland sent a letter (PDF) to Public Safety Secretary Gary Maynard on behalf of Collins, concerning the DOC's blanket requirement that applicants for employment, as well as current employees undergoing recertification, provide the government with their social network account usernames and passwords for use in employee background checks. It has been three weeks, and they have still not heard back.
"The demand for Facebook login information is not only a gross breach of privacy for Officer Collins and his friends, it raises significant legal concerns under the Federal Stored Communications Act and Maryland state law, which protect privacy rights and extend protections to electronic communications," an ACLU spokesperson said in a statement. "As many of us begin to rely on sites like Facebook to stay connected to our friends and family, it's important for employers and the government to keep in mind that, for most users, Facebook is a medium for private communications."
It's important to note that this is not equivalent to checking what a job applicant has posted publicly on the Internet. Collins emphasized that his Facebook account has the highest privacy settings employed, meaning that all of his messages are private. This is more like the government agency going through his personal mail.
"I was subjected to a customary usual background investigation," Collins said. "What was not customary usual was a request or to me, rather a demand, which was the insinuation for my Facebook e-mail and login information, my personal login information. Here I am, a US citizen who hasn't broken any laws, who hasn't committed any crime, and I have an employer looking at my personal communications, my personal posts, my personal my pictures, you know looking at my personally identifiable information... you know, where my religious, my political beliefs, my sexuality; all of these things are possibly disclosed on this page. It's an absolute total invasion, and an overreach, and overstep of their power."
Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.
Talkback
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Similar questions need to be raised in other contexts, including those involving jurors, where the audience is broader, and the protections are potentially murkier. The problem is also broader than any individual social networking site. What about other sites, dating sites, community fora, religious institutions?
I discussed some of these questions in "Colliding Worlds: Juries in the World of Pervasive Connectivity and Social Media", accessible at: http://www.rlgsc.com/blog/ruminations/colliding-worlds-juries-connectivity.html
I had similarly discussed some of the issues surrounding micro-blogging and its disclosure of information in: "Micro-blogging and Personal Self-Surveillance" at http://www.rlgsc.com/blog/ruminations/micro-blogging-and-personal-information.html
- Bob Gezelter, http://www.rlgsc.com
www.retardedemployer.com
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Remember, Maryland is the same state that decided it was appropriate to invade the home of a MD Air National Guardsman because he posted video of a traffic stop on YouTube. Maryland's views of personal rights correlate pretty closely to some governments of the late 1930's.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/06/15/AR2010061505556.html
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
I am ashamed today to state that I was born in Maryland.
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Illegal request
Before the can view the data, they must legally obtain the consent of every single person on the friends list not just the employee. Since access to private data, photos and info was given only to the account holder, not some random person. Access by any other person (without a warrant) constitute a violation of privacy laws and possibly illegal wiretapping laws.
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
hottest fashions for your spring
50% Discount fashion :Sandle,t-shirt,caps,jerseys,handbag and brand watches!!!
$30 Air Jordan shoes,shox,tn,LV shoes
$33 True Religion jeans, Ed Hardy jeans,LV,Affliction jeans
$15 Ed Hardy ,LV ,Bikini
$15 Polo, Ed Hardy, LV, Lacoste T-shirts
$25 Coach,LV,Prada,Juicy,Chanel handbag,
$10 Ed Hardy sunglasses
$9 New Era caps.
lol
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
There'd be nothing they could do.
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Also, maybe this is an area where Diaspora with its aspects can bring something innovative?
http://facebook.com/inlevelNet
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Against Facebook's terms of use
So that settles it I guess :)
Time for a New Business Model
RE: Employer demands Facebook login credentials
Last fall I wrote a white paper on the subject of "social screening," which relates to this post. It's called, "Social Screening: Employees - and Organizations - Beware." It can be accessed via http://tiny.cc/SocialScreening.... I wrote a follow-up blog post entitled, "Social Screening: The Expanded Discussion," which can be accessed via http://tiny.cc/SocialScreening....
Finding the right approach to social media policies is critically important, and many organizations are guilty of overreaching. A couple of weeks ago, for example, the NLRB settled its "Facebook case" with an employer (AMR), and one of key terms of the settlement was that the employer agreed to revise its "overbroad" policy. I wrote about this case both when the complaint was filed and after it was settled. Here are links to each piece: http://tiny.cc/SMinOrgsNLRBpos... and http://tiny.cc/SMinOrgsNLRBset....
This week I'll be publishing a post on social media policies that addresses the issue in a more holistic way. This is an important issue that requires a thoughtful, balanced approach.
Courtney Hunt
Founder, Social Media in Organizations (SMinOrgs) Community
At least they bothered to ask him for it
Just more proof...
You would have a point if....
And what value...
Hmmmm
If the state wasn't so lazy, they can easily find out about you.
Ignorant legislators