The ToyBox

Ricardo Bilton & Gloria Sin

Some iPhone 4 orders being canceled by Apple, AT&T

By | June 20, 2010, 6:05am PDT

Summary: Reports are surfacing that Apple and AT&T are randomly canceling iPhone 4 pre-orders placed last week.

It’s no secret that Apple, AT&T and anyone else who were offering pre-orders for the iPhone 4 last week suffered from site malfunctions, extended downtime and other problems.

But now it looks like even some of the customers who managed to get through the traffic and pre-order the fourth-gen iPhone online weren’t actually successful as reports are surfacing of randomly canceled orders.

Several tech sites are reporting canceled orders on the part of either AT&T and Apple for a variety of reasons, including unverifiable information, an incomplete authorization process, or sometimes no reason at all.  We haven’t seen notes like this from Best Buy yet, but let us know if that happens to you. In these cases, credit cards shouldn’t be charged. But still, talk about completely frustrating.

If you pre-order an iPhone 4 and aren’t so sure about your order status now, check your receipts and call the customer service number of the company you ordered it with just to be sure. And if you haven’t ordered one yet but want one soon (instead of waiting for weeks to get one in the mail), maybe it would be best just to clear your schedule and camp out at your local Apple or AT&T store next weekend.

Related coverage on ZDNet:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Rachel King is a staff writer for ZDNet based in San Francisco.

Disclosure

Rachel King

Rachel King has no business relationships, affiliations, investments, or other potential conflicts of interest relating to the content posted in this blog.

Biography

Rachel King

Rachel King is a staff writer for CBS Interactive in San Francisco. Before serving as a contributing editor at ZDNet in New York City for two years, she previously worked for The Business Insider, FastCompany.com, CNN's San Francisco bureau and the U.S. Department of State. Rachel has also written for MainStreet.com, Irish America Magazine and the New York Daily News, among others. Rachel has a B.A. in Mass Communications and History from the University of California, Berkeley and a M.S. in Journalism from Columbia University, where she served as art director for the student magazine, Plated.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
33
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Some iPhone 4 orders being canceled by Apple, AT&T
shandel 25th Jun 2010
0 Votes
+ -
business is too good
mstrsfty 20th Jun 2010
Business is so good that they have to cancel orders. I guess they really don't want these customers.
0 Votes
+ -
Apple/ATT business model allows this
Uralbas 20th Jun 2010
They tell their customers what they should have and shouldn't. Their customers love it that way, its the Apple ATT experience!
@mstrsfty
Sounds more like the data replication/fix from their continuity plan with server meltdowns is having an issue.
Wonder what other faux paus they are going to treat us with ?
0 Votes
+ -
@zenwalker
This time the problem isnt with at&t
manufacturing of retina displays is having failure rate of 500% above normal therefore only half the displays can be made.
retina displays manufacturring problem explained
* displays r manf on wafers. each wafer has fixed number of displays.
* normally the failure rate is less then 10%
* retina display failure rate is 55%
* root cause of the problem is in the design.
* it is normal to have problems on the first run.
* it can be fixed by analysing the problem in the lab. and pin point the spots.
* new design and new masks need to be made.
*displays need to remanufactured
* it should take 4 months to fix
  • Flagged
0 Votes
+ -
@snoonw
I agree with you and also see the pipeline issue with the screens.
This however does not explain the issue with the "cancaled" orders from both the Apple and ATT side. That is strictly a data problem casued or compounded by the server and congestion issues on both sides.
What I find really interesting is the lack "so far" of issues from Best Buy orders.
I am one of the affected confirmed-then-cancelled pre-orders. It is very frustrating after spending hours and hours earlier this week trying to place my order, to see a vague cancellation notice days later.

I've been on the phone with reps all morning now, and both AT&T and Apple are playing the blame game. Now it seemingly boils down to random chance. Unfortunately they picked the wrong gal to cancel -- I've been saving to buy a 2 Macbook Pros soon. But not anymore I won't!
@cathrynx
both AT&T and Apple are playing the blame game

We are told time and time again that Apple doesn't play the blame game, they take responsibility for everything because they, and I quote the Apple zealots: sell the whole enchilada. Huh. I guess those Apple zealots were lying.

Cue the double standards...
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Some iPhone 4 orders being canceled by Apple, AT&T
damato300 Updated - 20th Jun 2010
I am another affected. Ordered Tuesday at 6:30 EDT received confirmations a few minutes later for my 3 iPhones. Saturday evening received cancellation notice in my email. This what the email says:

"Dear Customer,

We were unable to complete the authorization process for your iPhone
order. As a result, we had to cancel your iPhone order. To complete the
purchase of your iPhone, please visit an Apple Retail Store or an AT&T
company-owned retail store.

To locate an Apple Retail Store near you, please visit
.

We apologize for this inconvenience.

Sincerely,
Apple Online Store Team"

I called Apple first since I ordered them through Apples website. They told me it was AT&T fault and told me to call them. So I called AT&T, Guess what AT&T said? It is Apples fault. Imagine that.

Thanks Apple/AT&T for such a wonderful experience!
@damato300 I wonder if your order cancellation had something to do with them limiting 1 per customer as I have read a few places.
@mjr5.0 I thought that as well. But no where does it say on AT&T website or Apples website that there is only one per customer for pre-orders. I have 3 iPhones that we have been eligible for upgrade and patiently waiting the release. Now the release is here and we are going to have to wait again. I have been a loyal AT&T customer for 14 years now, and an iPhone customer since initial launch in 2007. It is real hard to deal with such poor customer service from 2 companies I have spent alot of money on.
@damato300 I did find this on Apple's web site.

"How do I buy multiple iPhones?

Pick up your first iPhone at an Apple Retail Store and an Apple Retail associate can help you purchase additional iPhones."
0 Votes
+ -
Canceled? Who knows....
jblack213 20th Jun 2010
I received an email from AT&T saying that my order was canceled and that my credit card was not charged. It suggested I go to the store I ordered the phone from for more information. AT&T Wireless's website also stated that my order was canceled when I looked up the order number. So I went to the store to get more information. They looked it up and said that my order was not canceled. Seems I won't know if it was really canceled until they either do or do not deliver the phone. This makes me wonder if I am making the right choice switching from Verizon.
This is the way business should be. They should only make what they are capable of making regardless of what the reality may turn out to be. Far too long, we over serve the public appetite only to overproduce to the point of waste as well as endangering the company to financially overextend itself to the point where it may collapse because the public has changed its mind. I would rather Apple piss off some journalists but survive serving within its financial and manufacturing means.
@shennet
Great point, though I think Apple is one of the very few companies that never seems to have that problem. It only takes a shortage of a single component to jam things up, in this case, it's the new Retina Displays. You can bet a lot of companies had Apple's woes. I can't get over peoples impatience, will waiting a month more really be that terrible. Everyone new demand was going to be extremely high and should have anticipated these problems. It happened with the 3G, 3GS and the iPad. Even with the power of the Chinese Industrial Machine, they can only make so many. Don't forget, they're building these things to Apple's quality specifications, so I'm sure they can't run their assembly lines as quickly as they would for something like an Android phone. Quality is pretty crappy on those things.
0 Votes
+ -
@gtdworak
its manufacturing problem. The retina displays r failing at 500% higher then normal. it will take till nov b4 they fix this
@gtdworak I have had zero problems with my Android phone and I have dropped it more times than I can count and remember. Try seeing how long you iphone lasts after a few drops from 3 feet on to something other than carpet.
I am affected and miffed and frankly I'm switching to the EVO on Sprint. It's a better phone, cheaper plan and better coverage. Adios AT&T.
0 Votes
+ -
apple
mrfrankrier@... 20th Jun 2010
Frankly, why anyone would offer themselves for abasement to these unappreciative apple hucksters is beyond me. Brand up children, and choose products that work at fair prices and companies that appreciate your money.
0 Votes
+ -
What confuses me
Palmetto_CharlieSpencer 21st Jun 2010
is the mad rush for a device most users are going to discard in two years.
0 Votes
+ -
Order Cancelled by Apple
StonePhone 20th Jun 2010
On Jun 15, after trying for a long time, I succeeded at placing order for an iPhone 4. Yesterday, I got two identical emails from Apple saying my order was cancelled due to authorization problems.
This is nonsense. My account is eligible and credit card was pre-authorized and eligibility was confirmed.
Today, I called Apple, being on hold for 40 minutes. The rep did not know much either, he tried to shift the problem on AT&T saying my line is not eligible.
I told him this is complete BS. Essentially, he said that Apple does not know what is going on. Too many orders, too many problems, and he told me to go to AT&T store. He said that might mean getting my iPhone way later than June 24. I am sure if I go to AT&T, they will say it's Apple's fault.
Sucks! Sucks being a customer between two gigantic companies who point fingers at each other and leave just hanging there on your own.
I agree with gtdworak.
I waited to get my 3g, and I certainly can wait for the 4 (I am even thinking grabbing the 3gs as it is cheaper).

We knew that demand will be high. And a little patience never killed anyone. After all, it is just a phone/pda, not a survival kit that is needed right the second...
0 Votes
+ -
@sb9 Due to manufacturing problems with the retina display the failure rate is 500% above normal. Therefore it will take 4 months to fix. The delays will last for 4 months. only half the displays can be made
go see cnet for this story
looks like the fun and games are commencing early this release.

Popcorn please......
0 Votes
+ -
retina displays manufacturring problem explained
snoonw Updated - 20th Jun 2010
* displays r manf on wafers. each wafer has fixed number of displays.
* normally the failure rate is less then 10%
* retina display failure rate is 55%
* root cause of the problem is in the design.
* it is normal to have problems on the first run.
* it can be fixed by analysing the problem in the lab. and pin point the spots.
* new design and new masks need to be made.
*displays need to remanufactured
* it should take 4 months to fix
@snoonw I agree with you and also see the pipeline issue with the screens.

This however does not explain the issue with the "canceled" orders from both the Apple and ATT side. That is strictly a data problem caused or compounded by the server and congestion issues on both sides.

What I find really interesting is the lack "so far" of issues from Best Buy orders.

Wonder what else we will see and how frustrated customers get when they are actually delivered.

While I think the 4 is a great phone, I'll wait and really liking the Android phones coming out.
0 Votes
+ -
Orderus interruptus
Userama 20th Jun 2010
Bummer.
Oredred my iPhone 4 on June 15 at Apple online store, but my order was randomly cancelled by Apple for no reason:
---------------------
Dear Customer,

We were unable to complete the authorization process for your iPhone
order. As a result, we had to cancel your iPhone order. To complete the
purchase of your iPhone, please visit an Apple Retail Store or an AT&T
company-owned retail store.

To locate an Apple Retail Store near you, please visit
.

We apologize for this inconvenience.

Sincerely,
Apple Online Store Team
---------------------------------
Today I called Apple, waited almost an hour, a rep told me that that I need to go to a retail AT&T store to sort it out. So I went to AT&T store. A rep there told me that since I placed my order with Apple and Apple cancelled it, AT&T can't help me as they have no idea why the order was cancelled, and that I should go back to Apple. Here goes down the drain my father's day.
The two mega-corporations are footballing me back and forth, forcing me to waste more of my time. Meanwhile, Apple's pre-authorization on my credit card has been keeping over $300 frozen. Go figure...
@roubenhw
Not if you are one of the poor folk listed here who is scheduled for delivery....

No delivery now....
ouch!
I pre-ordered and clicked pick it up at the store. I called today to verify and they had no record of it. Guess I will be standing in line.
0 Votes
+ -
LOL...it was only a matter of time
SonofaSailor 20th Jun 2010
Don't be surprised that this elitist company is cancelling pre-orders...did you all really think you were good enough for the ilk of Lord Jobs?

First, Apple says "we won't honor your warranty if you're a smoker"

Second, Apple says...Consumers - want an app that's racy in content, be it adult, off-color humor, non-mainstream literature? sorry, you only get what we approve. And developers, we haven't forgotten about you...not only does your app only get released after our approval, but you must adhere to our guidelines (meaning, you can't play nice with our competitors)

now, thirdly, You want one of our new phones? Are you a high profile candidate? hmmm, "we apologize for any inconvenience"

And before any of you mactards offer up some kind of apologist rebuttal, tell me the name of any high profile musician, actor, writer, etc. that had their pre-order cancelled.

thought so.

You macidiots bought in to this whole "ecosystem", don't be surprised that the company running it...that turns their nose up to collaborative efforts with other software companies (and publicly criticizes them), and restricts content to it's own customer base (pretty much telling you you're too stupid to know what content you do and don't need)... suddenly decides to start cancelling hardware orders at their whim.
0 Votes
+ -
@SonofaSailor
First, Apple says "we won't honor your warranty if you're a smoker"
Of course, if you just happen to put your ashtray directly under the air intake so you can use your iMac as a chimney, we'll be perfectly happy to grunge through all that tar and troubleshoot your machine. Oh! Look here! All that tar is WHY your machine is acting up! No warranty here.

Second: ...(meaning, you can't play nice with our competitors)...
Meaning, we made the hardware, we made the OS. Build to our OS and you're fine. Build to someone else's, don't expect it to work on ours.

now, thirdly, You want one of our new phones? Are you a high profile candidate? hmmm, "we apologize for any inconvenience"
So you're telling me there are 600,000 high-profile candidates? I don't think so. On the other hand, considering that even the iPad took a month to sell a million units (which means about 300,000 per week) then having two weeks worth ordered in one day is extraordinary by any standard. Show me ANY non-Apple product that has seen that kind of sales. The closest I can recall are the Harry Potter books by J.K.Rowling, and those are only books, not functional electronic devices.
Meanwhile, how about proving that none of those 'high profile candidates' have had their order cancelled.
0 Votes
+ -
The price some pay to be early adopters...
Snooki_smoosh_smoosh 22nd Jun 2010
Grant it, some would hope that this process would be smoother, however, I prefer to wait for the feeding frenzy to dissipate, and buy products like this once things have calmed down. There will always be issues when consumers make something in such high demand, that it makes it difficult to keep up with the demand, but then again that is the price of being a early adopter.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix