Google Places merges may be hazardous to your business

Google Places merges may be hazardous to your business

Summary: An automatic merge of two Google Places listings almost killed a small Florida-based law firm.

SHARE:
TOPICS: Google
35

Google Places, the local business listing service behind Google Maps, has its share of fans amongst small business owners. After all, if you've done your homework as far as search engine optimization (SEO), Google Places has the demonstrable power to connect potential customers with the goods and services they're looking for.

But what happens if you wake up one day to find that Google Places automatically changed your listing, giving customers a competitor's phone number? And worse - what if you were told that it would take up to six months for Google to fix the problem?

That's what happened to Morris Law Firm, P.A., a St. Petersburg, Florida-based law firm with only one practicing attorney. Melinda Morris, the attorney in question, and Seth Shapiro, Morris' husband and the firm's operations manager, rely heavily on Google Places to drive new business.

But out of nowhere, the Place page for the firm changed to have the phone number and picture for Jason Mayberry, another attorney who recently moved into the same office building. The phone went silent. Naturally, Shapiro says he suspected foul play immediately, but upon discussion with the other law firm, it was revealed that both businesses were affected.

There was no phone number to call, and using the "Report a Problem" link Google Places provides garnered no immediate response. Some things put themselves right over the course of a few days, but the critical phone number remained incorrect.

After much research on the official help forums, Shapiro turned up the culprit: Google Places automatically merges what it figures to be duplicate listings. Multiple attorneys in one building were deemed to be the same business and combined.

The Google Places forums are full of people reporting the same issue, and many find themselves getting frustrated with the lack of support from Google. And some users reported that it took up to six months for Google to respond to their problems.

"Because Google Places is a free service, there is no customer support.  No one to call.  No human being to interact with as your small business is punished because of Google's inaccurate algorithms.  Just a silent phone to remind you that Google can very quickly and with no remorse kill your small business," Shapiro wrote to me.

And it only takes a quick Google search to see that this kind of merging is only one of the problems that businesses face when dealing with Google Places: the New York Times recently ran a much-cited report on the service mistakenly listing businesses as "permanently closed," though Google claims to have addressed that specific issue.

When made aware of the Morris Law Firm's difficulties with Google Places, a Google spokesperson promised to look into it, and issued the following statement:

"The business listings in Google Maps, part of our local search offering, come from a combination of sources. We work with third-party & publicly available Yellow Page directories, and we also look for business information from our web search results. Users are able to edit and contribute business information to help keep Google Maps up-to-date, and business owners can use Google Places to verify and maintain their own listing. Google Maps is a very popular source for local data, but we recognize that with millions of listings, there will be an occasional error. We encourage users to update listings themselves if they know the correct information - more on that process here - or flag something as incorrect using our 'Report a Problem' button, found at the bottom right corner of the map. A business owner can use Google Places, found at www.google.com/places, to oversee the information in his/her listing."

At the time of writing, the Morris Law Firm's entry is still at least partially conflated with Jason Mayberry's, and at least two user reviews are expressing confusion about which attorney it belongs to. And Shapiro indicates that the business is seriously ailing as a result, as the issue enters its second week.

This issue is especially troublesome because a business doesn't really choose to be on Google Places - the search giant's mission to organize all of the world's information means that you're on there whether you want it or not.

But if you're not wary, your business profile can lead potential customers to a competitor, and you may never know it. The only way to be sure is constant vigilance over your Google Places page. And even then, a problem may take months to address, thanks to Google's limited support structure for Places.

Topic: Google

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

35 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Problem Would Seem To Be...

    ...search-engine users ascribing a level of quality to the results that they do not possess.
    ldo17
  • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

    ...and bypassing your spell-checker may be hazardous to the credibility of your websites front page.
    Joe_Raby
    • +1

      @Joe_Raby
      Too bad there is no "like" in this commenting system.
      davebarnes
      • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

        @davebarnes

        I like that thought...
        mlashinsky@...
    • yours too

      @Joe_Raby the word is "website's" as the word is a posessive.
      AtlantaTerry
  • Bad business plan

    If a law firm relies heavily on Google Places to drive their business, they have a bigger problem than Google Places messing up their listing. Have they never heard the expression "Don't place all your eggs in one basket"? If they need business, they should be producing flyers, getting a Yellow Page listing, chasing ambulances like all the other lawyers do............;-)
    Rexxrally
    • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

      @Rexxrally the point is that the business isn't necessarily relying on it, they are there anyway. It's like Yellow pages putting a competitor's phone number in your free listing.
      keithc
      • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

        @keithc The article said the business was "ailing" which suggest that they are over reliant of Google Places.

        To me this does not sound realistic for a law firm anyway, but either this is a poorly research article or the firm is poorly run and over reliant on Google or the law firm was exaggerating the trouble they are in, to try and get the sympathy vote and to see if Google change there details quicker.
        Knowles2
      • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

        @keithc

        Yes, exactly. They never asked to be listed, and certainly do not want to be listed wrong.
        mlashinsky@...
      • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

        @keithc ... better check your stats and reread the post! Apples and oranges.
        tom@...
    • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

      @Rexxrally It never ceases to disturb me when apologists jump in to defend something for which there is no defense by trying to put the blame on the victim.
      Liam SWz
      • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

        @darkmoonman

        Not to place blame on the victim but the original poster is right... Its hard to imagine that Google Places could cause teir phones to "go silent". Of course, nobody wants a free listing if its going to give your competitors phone number and Google needs to fix it or shut it down (It's a law suit waiting to happen) but I think the problem is being dramatized a bit in the article.
        techadmin.cc@...
    • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

      @Rexxrally

      AAmen! +1
      tom@...
  • google's lack of personnel depth

    do i remember correctly that google has only a few thousand employees worldwide? if true, who is going to respond to a problem?
    dick@...
    • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

      @dick@... I keep this in mind all the time. Of Google's services, I only use gmail, and fortunately I have had no complaints at all. But if I do, I know there is no help desk to appeal to.
      mlashinsky@...
  • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

    I do not see how a law firm, where cases can take weeks, months or even years to resolve, can be ailing after two weeks.

    I spent six months working for one, an I was dealing with cases and receiving checks for cases that have been going on for 5 years. An that was a 3 man operation as well, two lawyers and me.
    Knowles2
    • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

      @Knowles2 It depends on the firm. What if you primarily handle living wills, incorporation, no-contest divorce, or other "quickie" legal matters. Not every legal matter is a long, drawn out court case.
      jred
  • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

    You can correct most of this yourself by using mapmaker.
    www.google.com/mapmaker or mapmaker.google.com
    SteveObe
  • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

    "many find themselves getting frustrated with the lack of support from Google." As Google heads into the more "traditional IT companies" turf, this seems to be an ever increasing issue for them. Sometimes totally out of their control - like the Android phone with Google on it... if it's crap or has issues people say "Google"...not HTC. I have always said their support (or lack of it) is their Achilles heel. We have enterprise licenses here and it's painful a lot of times getting help from them....even when we are wanting to spend money. That arrogance of theirs need to come down a few pegs...
    ItsTheBottomLine
  • RE: Google Places merges may be hazardous to your buisness

    Well, if one depends 100% on the 'net for ANYTHING they are making a huge mistake and need to wise up quick!
    tom@...