ie8 fix
Click Here

Googling Google

Christopher Dawson

Is Google replacing our memory?

By | July 14, 2011, 3:02pm PDT

A Columbia University study has found that Google and other search engines are literally changing the way our brains process and retain information.

The research was conducted by Columbia psychologist Betsy Sparrow and presented in a paper Science magazine published entitled “Google Effects on Memory: Cognitive Consequences of Having Information at Our Fingertips.”

In that paper, Sparrow makes the case that rather than remembering things, we now simply retain the knowledge of how to find the information we need when we need it. In other words, the Internet as a whole has become what a major example of what psychologists refer to as “transactive memory.”

The Columbia press release has some nitty-gritty details of the study. But essentially, participants were asked to answer a series of difficult trivia questions, followed immediately by testing response times to color-coded words. The participants had much shorter reaction times for words like “Google” and “Yahoo,” indicating that the search engines were already being processed as ways to find the answers to these questions.

Then, the trivia questions were rephrased as statements, and tested for recall when they believed that the statements were available for later retrieval - like a saved search query - and when they believed it was not. When they thought they would be able to review the statement again later, recall was much lower.

Third, participants were presented with the same trivia statements, which were either saved in a particular spot or erased, and again, any statement which was erased had a higher rate of recall. Finally, participants were more able to remember the folders where information was being kept than they were the information itself.

The implications of this research are still being explored. But it could have vast application to teaching and training fields.

And honestly, who among Google’s billion-plus visitors can honestly say that they’ve never  skimped out on memorization (of directions, of phone numbers, of important dates, et cetera) when they knew that the search giant was keeping track of it for us?

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

Matthew has written about consumer and personal technology for The New York Daily News and comic book culture for ComicMix.com.

Disclosure

Matt Weinberger

Matt Weinberger has no financial investments in the companies he covers.

Biography

Matt Weinberger

Matthew also covers software as a service (SaaS), cloud computing and recurring revenue models for the IT channel at TalkinCloud.com and MSPmentor.net. He has written about consumer and personal technology for The New York Daily News and comic book culture for ComicMix.com. Matthew is a graduate of the Stony Brook University School of Journalism.
60
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
baconman84 21st Feb
@tonymcs@... This study seems to signal that we are adapting to the need to remember more by developing greater contextual memories for where the information can be found later. This reminds me a lot of Memolane.com - which is basically a tool for aggregating personal social media history. The more often I view my lane, the stronger the relationship in my recall for the contextual cues for the actual memories themselves. I can recognize a familiar tweet, but then I see my lane and am given the location for it based on a Foursquare check-in, and a photo of the room I made it in from a Picasa image, etc. plumber seattle | landscaping houston
0 Votes
+ -
google is making us smarter
Linux Geek 14th Jul
unlike others peddling proprietary software that makes our mind numb.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
alasiri Updated - 19th Aug
@Linux Geek Will so m eone please make a list of things I am supposed to remember? I bet nobody can crea te one without referencing Google.
0 Votes
+ -
@alasiri
Another great read. These articles and short informative pieces are always a delight to read and keep me coming back for more.
Las Vegas chiropractor San Jose chiropractor Sacramento chiropractor San Francisco chiropractor Minneapolis chiropractor Indianapolis chiropractor
0 Votes
+ -
@alasiri
I understand the brain is very lazy muscle so for something that is available free why should it work.
Isint it something like the dictionary.


tires for sale
0 Votes
+ -
Very interesting, evolution at work
LiquidLearner 14th Jul
This is good and bad. Learning how to find answers is far, far superior to learning answers for the most part. You can't remember everything but if you know how to look you can always find your answer. As knowledge becomes more prevelant we will see our school systems change more rapidly to adapt to the vast amount of data humankind has amassed. Which will allow children to learn more quickly. 10 years from now a child graduating high school will know how to leverage the insane amounts of knowledge out there.

Then there is the downside. As technology becomes integrated into our lives at this level, to a point where it becomes an extension of ourselves, we become much more vulnerable. If a major disaster did happen and much of mankind, infrastructure and data systems were all suddenly wiped out people could could be in trouble. We won't know how to do anything.

So, Google could be helping mankind on the path to enlightenment, or it could be helping be the final nail in the eventual human coffin.
0 Votes
+ -
@LiquidLearner

+1!

I've been thinking pretty much the same thing for a long time. Actually, it started with this episode of Outer Limits, which aired more than 14 years ago:

http://www.tv.com/episode/21470/summary.html

I agree with everyone else who said that knowing how to find it is better than knowing it, whether it be online or in books. I do hope that they continue teaching kids library skills, just in case it does eventually become necessary to revert to the "old fashioned" method of finding information.
0 Votes
+ -
@rcnut
This was a really interesting read and one that I would suggest to friends. I will be sure to check back in the future to see if any more related content is added. Boston Chiropractor
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
preciolandia 27th Sep
@rcnut I don't think human memory is replaced by Google, but enhanced by it.
me encantar??a comprar Blackberry en venezuela . Me han dicho que hay ofertas y precios bajos espectaculares en Celular Nokia , tambi??n que es incre??ble el bajo precio de un Samsung liberado . Por supuesto que lo m??s buscando por dise??o y tecnolog??a es un Iphone 4 de Apple con todo el factor cool, y la confiabilidad de los cell phones Motorola nunca se pierde.
Y despu??s est??n todas las otras marcas importantes como la coreana LG , los increibles nuevos celulares liberados HTC , y perdiendo un poco la carrera tecnologica los Sony Ericsson . Como marcas Chinas, est??n Huawei , Alcatel , y tambien de Korea, Kyocera.
0 Votes
+ -
@Masson Connie Dr Steven J White Reviews
Dr Sharon Packer Reviews
Dr Sydney Coleman Reviews
0 Votes
+ -
@LiquidLearner Before the internet, we'd search in dictionaries or call people for answers, now we just search for it in seconds, it's a good evolution but it does make most people kind of lazy

posted via my archos 80 g9 tablet
0 Votes
+ -
I was worried, until I heard it was psychology. Have a degree in it, no respect for it (except the small hard science part) and I'll put this with all the other psych studies no-one could replicate or falsified.

I also can't seem to find how many participants were in the study and if they were part of the usual "random" population - that is, university students.
0 Votes
+ -
Agree
lass23 16th Jul
@tonymcs@...
Yes, most of psychologies don't understand basic scientific principles.
The most common example is when testing on children ability they don't control for genetics because it would be politically incorrect as if reality cares about what is politically correct or not.
0 Votes
+ -
@tonymcs@... This study seems to signal that we are adapting to the need to remember more by developing greater contextual memories for where the information can be found later. This reminds me a lot of Memolane.com - which is basically a tool for aggregating personal social media history. The more often I view my lane, the stronger the relationship in my recall for the contextual cues for the actual memories themselves. I can recognize a familiar tweet, but then I see my lane and am given the location for it based on a Foursquare check-in, and a photo of the room I made it in from a Picasa image, etc. plumber seattle | landscaping houston
as I do not see how this differs from what has come before: rather than remembering things, we now simply retain the knowledge of how to find the information we need when we need it, when obtaining it from books.

The only thing that has changed is that instead of relooking up the information in a book, or from notes, people just relook up information from the internet, or bookedmarked pages.
plain
0 Votes
+ -
@Mister Spock Exactly. I've been doing it since way before there was an internet or search.
0 Votes
+ -
@Mister Spock
Exactly. Researchers are forgetting keys things, like the fact that we've had information at our fingertips for thousands of years since humans learned to write. Now, I'd even venture to say we have to remember more, because before, there were just books, now there are books, and web sites. Now we have to remember the web addresses for all of the information we need, as well as remembering places *not* to go for information.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
WordpressGuy 13th Sep
@Liath.WW Never mind memory Google is replacing all manor of things books, shops etc etc. Google is replacing life itself happy
Wordpress Training./h1
0 Votes
+ -
@Mister Spock Correct...this is nothing new or exciting. Books, grandma, father, friends and remember those buildings called libraries? WHy are you wasting time writing about this? Nothing has changed except we can do it all from our desks...sitting down, getting fatter and out of shape...that's the big thing to write about
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
mikeabundo Updated - 15th Jul
Remember when people started storing information in cave paintings instead of their brains? Yup, our memory's just been going downhill ever since.

Blame those kids and their newfangled cave paintings.
0 Votes
+ -
Coping to remember more data
Coffee +1 15th Jul
Perhaps it is mentioned in the original study, but this article makes no reference to the fact that we now have so much more information floating around in our daily environments to remember. This study seems to signal that we are adapting to the need to remember more by developing greater contextual memories for where the information can be found later. This reminds me a lot of Memolane.com - which is basically a tool for aggregating personal social media history. The more often I view my lane, the stronger the relationship in my recall for the contextual cues for the actual memories themselves. I can recognize a familiar tweet, but then I see my lane and am given the location for it based on a Foursquare check-in, and a photo of the room I made it in from a Picasa image, etc.
If you read the summary of Sparrow's research (http://news.columbia.edu/research/2490), you'll see that she finds evidence that we take advantage of externally-stored information to create optimal strategies for remembering location rather than detail.

But there is no evidence at hand that the fundamental way that memory works is changing, or that any of the "the way our brains process and retain information" is changing. That would be sensationalist journalism at play. happy
0 Votes
+ -
This seems like an inevitable process. Look at the difference in memory of oral and book based cultures. The google effect just extends this from only needing to remember references or snippets to just remembering search terms etc.
0 Votes
+ -
I once read an account -- probably apocryphal -- of an Egyptian philosopher who ranted against the advent of papyrus. It was so inexpensive and easier to use than clay tablets that he feared that people would lose their ability to remember information.

The interesting point is that we'll never know if he was right. Technology is a double-edged sword.

Alfred Poor
HDTV Almanac
0 Votes
+ -
This is a good thing. Hell, it's the basis of most of the things we learn in school: it's better to know how to find the answer rather than just knowing the answer.
0 Votes
+ -
I was going to comment but forgot what the article was about.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
crewr@... Updated - 15th Jul
We don't have to make our own fire to cook food, generate our own electricity to power our devices, produce our own content for entertainment, remembers phone numbers of family and friends, calculate figures by hand, and the list goes on. This is the world we've made and we have to live in it. It's not bad, it just is what it is. Google is just the start. Eventually we will be "jacked in" to the "Googleplex" in such a way that the computer can provide answers simply by our thinking of the questions. We will then look back on the "good old days" when you needed a PC to look up information or a library to read a book.
0 Votes
+ -
Google is putting our BRAINS in the CLOUD!
0 Votes
+ -
Google isn't replacing our memory, just the trips to the library and having to look things up. As previous posters have said, we have much more to remember now, so we need a much more efficient retreival system.
0 Votes
+ -
How about the calculator? The address book on your phone?
0 Votes
+ -
Let google or the internet or the cloud or a computer or someone else remember the mundane things in my life. I'll keep my memory for actual memories and for working on important things.
0 Votes
+ -
This should make Winston Smith's job a bit easier.
0 Votes
+ -
...my modus operandi a long time before Google. I started playing in technology in the mid 1970s...I'd need about sixty brain cases to store every hardware and software manual and theoretical work I've dealt with over the decades.

Google merely replaced what I'd already been doing with paper and e-documents and databases...lollll...removing changing addresses and hard drive failures from the list of reasons why I can periodically become unproductive.
0 Votes
+ -
I realized in my pre-teen years.... (early '60's) that it was stupid to concentrate on remembering facts and figures.. that what mattered was knowing how to find information when I needed it. This philosophy hurt me in school performance in some respects (were memorization was important), and helped me in others where the big picture mattered. I aced tests where understanding mattered, and did poorly where specific detail was important. In adult life, the abilities I had developed... the ability to "pull the string", and find the information I needed quickly, the habit of documenting resources, expanding the search geometrically, and connecting intelligently with resource people and using them to spring board to others, leapfrogging to the heart of my inquiry served me very well, but ran up rather large phone bills when I was interested in things. Google has changed this to some extent, and in fact while it has been an asset where shallow knowledge is needed, it has made it if anything more difficult to go to the heart of things. Sorting the proverbial wheat from the chaff has become a huge task in many respects, an often means making direct personal contact with people as before if one wants to get into the ratified zone of truly knowledgeable people on the bleeding edge. The most valuable skills I learned in school were the ability to pursue knowledge, including the ability to communicate a passion and a personal knowledge to go with it, which elicits cooperation from those who really are on the bleeding edge. Google has it's place, but it does NOT take the place of real pursuit of knowledge, and those of us with this passion know where Google falls short.
Howard
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
linlturner@... 16th Jul
when somebody said i knew the answer to a lot of questions i stated "I don't know everything but i know where to look for the answers" and i wasn't just refering to the internet, books and more knowledgable people have been around for a long time. we have so much to remember now that it makes sense to store how to find information instead of the information itself. i love having the great world of information at my fingertips
0 Votes
+ -
GOOGLE YOUR MIND
arolnick 16th Jul
I am happy to share that I am the owner of a pending patent named

Google your mind

Here are some elements of the patent:

According to the present invention, there is provided a system for
receiving, storing, analyzing and disseminating a multitude of thoughts
and ideas from each user.

The invention may have many applications, for example from "personal
information management" to "preserving the memory and knowledge" in case
of a person's illness or death, to personal/professional consulting to
the user.

Thus, the new system may use the ubiquitous cellular phone, which, to
many people, is one of the most accessible devices. Alternately, people
may use the regular phone to connect to the system.

The system allows people to easily enter their thoughts or ideas therein,
by using speech recognition technologies. Thus, a user may just talk to
the system to convey his/her feelings or thoughts of the moment; the
system records such messages and transforms them to digital messages
which are subsequently processed in the system.

The system can then act intelligently on the messages. Such actions may
be adapted to each user's needs and requirements

The system may store a plurality of thoughts and ideas for each person.
The items in storage are indexed and organized for easy access.
A personality tank can thus be formed.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
BitsNpcs Updated - 17th Jul
Sorry submitted this twice.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
BitsNpcs Updated - 17th Jul
Hmm. Referring to documentation may be increasingly more popular than remembering things. But consider this.

If you remember how to do 70% of your job and are sitting beside someone doing the same job, but knows 95% without checking reference sources. Who will get the most work done? Who will therefore get a pay rise first? Who will get offered a promotion first? etc... etc.

In other words it pays to have both of a good memory of facts, and a good memory of where to find facts. Not just either one.
0 Votes
+ -
Will someone please make a list of things I am supposed to remember? I bet nobody can create one without referencing Google.
0 Votes
+ -
attent
Firat31 15th Aug
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari
sohbet kanallari ? radyo dinle ? radyo dinle ?
mirc ? cet ? dul sohbet ? chat odalari ? chat odalari ?
sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? sohbet odalari ? cet ? cet
sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari turk chat - turk chat - cet
odalari islami sohbet
dini sohbet
sohbet odalari
sohbet odalari
Beni takip edenin gotune koyim =)gf
0 Votes
+ -
That is just how our brains work. If a person has the confidence that they will find the same info, the brain does not try to remember the info itself, but rather the path to find that info again.
Internet Marketing Services
0 Votes
+ -
Wow. I never thought of this before but it makes perfect sense. It's strange how much something like the Internet can change humanity.
barska scopes
0 Votes
+ -
Good news! If you?re an Android developer yilmazlar et living in Brazil, Canada, kemik kesme Russia, or 17 other kemik testeresi countries you can cancel the movers because Google kofte makinasi will now let you sell Android apps in the hamburger makinasi Market. Likewise, you folks epoksi zemin kaplama in India, Singapore, and 16 other epoksi boya places can stay right where you are dugun mekanlari because in a istanbul dugun salonlari couple of weeks you?ll be able nikah salonlari to pay for those apps. That?s right, Google sunnet salonlari announced a large expansion to nisan salonlari the Android Market today when it dugun salonlari fiyatlari added 20 new countries where developers koy web sitesi of paid apps can live and ilgaz 18 more places where web tasarim consumers of those kartal evden eve nakliyat apps can live. However the number kusbasi dograma makinasi still falls far short of the total number of countries cam balkon fiyatlari in the world. Here?s cam balkon a copy of the email acilir cati they sent out to cam balkon registered cam balkon developers.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Is Google replacing our memory?
DeLi_Cocuk Updated - 4th Sep
Sohbet Sohbet Odalari Mynet Sohbet | Sohbet Odalari | islami sohbet | islami chat | islami radyo | Sohbet Odalari | sohbet siteleri | chat | chat siteleri | Chat | Chat Sohbet | Chat Siteleri | canakkale sohbet | canakkale chat | Sohbet Odalari | yemek tarifleri | yemektarifleri | oktay usta yemek tarifleri | resimli yemek tarifleri | Pasta Tarifleri | Kurabiye Tarifleri | Kolay Yemek Tarifleri |
tatli tarifleri | ankara sohbet | ankara chat
news ankara sohbet odalari | kamerali sohbet | kamerali sohbet odalari ankara chat studies sex izle |
sex seyret |
sex hikayeleri |
Canli Chat | Ankara Chat | Chat | Sohbet | Ankara Sohbet | Ankara Chat | Chat Siteleri | peynir cesitleri | peynir | sUt UrUnleri | ezine peyniri | bartin sohbet odalari bartin sohbet siteleri | ardahan sohbet odalari
izmir sohbet odalari
antalya sohbet odalari
face sohbet odalari | facebook sohbet odalari

Canakkale
0 Votes
+ -
This is an excellent article. The following publish supplies genuinely high quality info. My spouse and i?meters bound to check in it. Truly extremely helpful points are given listed here. Many thanks a great deal. Carry on favorable functions. vintage snapback hats best solid state drive
0 Votes
+ -
This is a really good read for me. Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I have ever read. Thanks for posting this informative article. baby gifts for boys baby gifts for girls
0 Votes
+ -
I like the article you wrote here; it is very informative and useful for the internet users like me. I will come back to read more blog posts on your website and I have bookmarked your website as well Thank You know style clothing store girls clothing stores online
0 Votes
+ -
I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate! nccma cooler
0 Votes
+ -
I used to be more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post. this thread is amazing i like your work and i appreciate you that you have share a useful stuff thanks for sharing the i shop abatwa
0 Votes
+ -
This is an interesting article and a great read. Some really good points made in here and
something that I would really be interested in researching more.

Austin Chiropractor

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix