Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

Summary: I've been spending my days in mobile-land. And I like it there.

Please, no! Stop the flamethrowers! Enough already! You haven't even read my post and the talkbacks are already flying from your fingers!

I'm kidding. Sort of. But after spending the last several days completely immersed in the land of Android and really becoming attached to my new Motorola Xoom, I can't help but understand why Microsoft watchers point to decreasing market share for Windows 7. As InfoWorld points out,

Between July 1, 2010, and April 22, 2011 -- a period of 275 days -- Microsoft sold 0.67 Windows 7 licenses for each PC sold: 175 million Windows 7 licenses, and 260 million new PCs.

To turn the numbers the other way around, in the past nine months, more than one-third of all new PCs sold didn't have Windows 7.

There are lots of reasons for this, ranging from XP downgrades to volume licensing deals to OS X to Linux. What really matters to me, though, is that every time I switch from my phone or my tablets to a Windows 7 PC (an OS that I actually like, mind you, and respect for its general snappiness and software compatibility), I feel like I'm...sloooowwwiiiiinnnggg......dooooooowwwwwnnnnn. The same could actually be said for any of the modern mobile operating systems (including Windows Phone 7) compared to the latest desktop OS from the folks in Redmond.

Clicking that start button (I know it's just an icon now, but it will always be a start button to me) and navigating through applications or fussing with desktop shortcuts vs. file clutter feels awkward and very 1998. My wife will tell you that I'm not an organized person (at least not in the traditional place for everything and everything in its place sort of way). And yet swiping through clusters of generally related apps gives me access to the features I need with an efficiency that used to take a command line.

Next: Is it just me? »

Maybe it's just me. We all have different ways of working, learning, and thinking. Android, particularly Honeycomb, just feels organic. My 1-year old swipes her finger across the tablet screen or across my phone when she wants different music playing or another video queued. I can't see her just yet navigating through menus. iOS users will tell you that Apple's mobile OS is so organic that it makes Android look like Monsanto soybeans. They might be right. Regardless, there is an almost thoughtless ease to moving among apps and consuming content on the two dominant mobile operating systems that I find it increasingly painful to go back to a desktop OS.

Android knows what I mean. I can speak it (those years of free GOOG-411 service have really paid off) and Android does it. Again, with Android 3.0, it's nearly unflappable. I can type on the on-screen keyboard (which I do very poorly) and Android usually knows the word for which I'm aiming. I can use Swype and really start to pick up the pace. It capitalizes for me, punctuates for me, and lets me focus on finding what I need, saying what I want, and connecting as needed.

Can the same be said of Windows? It can barely be said of OS X; Ubuntu's Unity interface is getting there in terms of isolating the user from all but the essentials, but the speech recognition, flawless touch interface, and predictive text still aren't there.

My next investment will be a Bluetooth keyboard or some slick docking accessory; add a good keyboard to Android as a UI and I'm going to be a happy guy. My Mac isn't going away, of course. I still need Adobe Creative Suite and I don't see that coming to Android anytime soon. My Windows desktops will be around, too, since there remain useful bits of software that just run better (or simply run) on Windows. Flash still isn't what it should be either; the mobile OSs are hardly the Holy Grail of personal computing.

But I can feel myself inching closer (OK, walking quickly towards) the day when Android will be my OS of choice rather than Windows, OS X, or Ubuntu. The move won't be for everyone, but the call of the modern mobile OS is strong. It's, well, modern. And it's intuitive in ways that Windows just isn't, even for a power user. Perhaps Windows 8 will be a radical departure and bring the efficiencies of a mobile, touch-oriented OS to the desktop PC. If it is, count me in as an early adopter. Until then, I'll be seeing just how far I can get without reaching any important limitations on [insert mobile OS of choice here to avoid any further flame wars since we acknowledge that both Android and iOS have significant merits].

Topics: Operating Systems, Hardware, Microsoft, Mobility, Software, Windows

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

64 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

    I think you're comparing apples to oranges; phones and tablets are by design quick and light, but lack the power of a pc. I love the Windows Phone OS on my HTC, but I need the brawn of my PC for Photoshop. Two different creatures. Now if you were to compare a Win7 tablet to an iPad, or Android tablet I'd agree with you that Windows 7 drags on that platform. I don't think we'll see any quickness and light until Windows 8.
    thomg57
    • re: is it me...

      @thomg57 and you are sure about win 8 being awesome how?
      tatiGmail
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @tatiGmail Oooh, very nice! Snagging. Thanks :D <a href="http://www.chanelhandbagsreplica.org">chanel bags replica</a> <a href="http://www.chanelhandbagsreplica.org">chanel replica bags</a> <a href="http://www.chanelhandbagsreplica.org">replica chanel bags</a>
        3shao
    • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

      @thomg57 - regarding current tablets, you're absolutely right - iPad and Android have Windows completely beat. For now.

      I am willing to bet that in 12-18 months time, when Win8 is released, that it will sport a new UI for tablet scenarios that takes the best elements of Windows Phone's Metro UI along with a bunch of new and improved features including voice recognition (which is already well served via Windows and improved upon by Windows Phone 7), touch and gestures (from WinPhone and Surface) and a host of other improvements born from IE, Silverlight, XNA, etc.

      Since we've already seen early builds of Win8 running on credit-card sized ARM boards, I also expect that Win8 will be available on a wide variety of slim, sleek, fast but power-frugal ARM-based tablets and phones.

      Microsoft is already hard at work making sure Office (and many of its other products) support ARM and Windows8 specifically.

      Remember what happened with netbooks? I fully expect that when MS ships Win8 on tablets, that a similar thing will happen to the tablet/slate market.

      Put it this way: If Microsoft was to ship (either itself or through partners) tablet devices that last 10 hours on a single charge and offer a great touch experience and yet are able to run full MS Office, Lync/Communicator/Messenger, any WinPhone app/game and sports a "tablet mode" UI with dockable live tiles as it's primary "home" experience, I'll be delighted.
      bitcrazed
  • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

    Using your reasoning EVERY desktop OS will feel sluggish. And like thomg57 pointed out, try running Photoshop or Visual Studio on your mobile device. Good luck with that.
    statuskwo5
    • Can Photoshop and VS be run via Citrix/RDP?

      @statuskwo5 (or anyone else) - has anyone played with remoting these apps onto a tablet? What does the experience turn out like?

      I'm seriously wondering to what degree tablets could replace PCs via such an approach - move specific apps to a server, remote them. Especially when you consider adding a BT keyboard and allowing output to a larger screen, as needed.
      daboochmeister
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @daboochmeister visual studio does work over remote desktop, though network connections need to be fast enough to really do some programming. Also the touch screen doesn't translate directly over remote desktop, so a keyboard and mouse would be needed for finer detail work.
        grayknight-22253692004129760887070084760051
  • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

    Windows 8 is going to shock and awe all the naysayers out there!!
    jatbains
    • Shock and awe in what sense?

      Or is it that it (Win8) will provoke yawning and drooling?
      ego.sum.stig
      • The same story has been told for decades

        The next product from MS is going to fix all your issues with the current version. Inexperience is required to still believe it.
        Richard Flude
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @ego.sum.stig@...

        I am looking-forward to Windows version 1,376. Perhaps by then we'll stop hearing about how everything will be so much better in the next version ;-)
        Restricted_access
      • Just like Apple, right Richy

        @ego.sum.stig@...
        The next product from Apple is going to fix all your issues with the current version. Inexperience is required to still believe it, and Apple counts on it to survive!
        Will Farrell
      • ptorning, that's the part I don't understand

        @ego.sum.stig@...
        Why does Apple put out [b]so[/b] many new versions of OS X, and iOS?

        Is there something missing in the current version I have? They promised me thier stuff is the best, but keep selling upgraded "new and improved" OS's.
        I guess that's all the proof we need to see that Apple's been lying to us all along.
        Will Farrell
      • Here's an explanation you should understand

        @Will Farrell [b]

        Why does Apple put out so many new versions of OS X, and iOS?[/b]

        Mostly due to jailbreakers... the major updates add new features but the incremental updates (i.e. 4.2 to 4.3) are introduced as attempts to restrict jailbreaing.[b]

        Is there something missing in the current version I have? They promised me thier stuff is the best, but keep selling upgraded "new and improved" OS's.
        I guess that's all the proof we need to see that Apple's been lying to us all along.[/b]

        Not lying... the answer is above. Apple is controlling but here's the thing - ALL of them say that the newest version is the "new and improved" OS no matter WHAT OS it is. Calling out Apple for lying about their current iOS being the new and improved until the next one is a bit hypocritical if you don't call out every single software manufacturer for the same... your scenario does not take into account evolution in hardware or how software works.
        athynz
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @Will Farrel,

        Nothing new there. Margarine companies have been claiming since before WW II every year that this year, their margarine finally tastes "Like Real Butter". It's not Microsoft or Apple, it's a set of false claims that are inherent in marketers.

        It's never going away, and never stopping. If Ubuntu goes fully commercial, then they will do it too.
        YetAnotherBob
      • athynz and YetAnotherBob

        Sorry I was being sarcastic, just throwing ptorning's words back in his face because he spoke without thinking.
        (I think he forgot that Apple works the same way)

        I agree there is marketing, but there is advancement, too. Like anything, as technology is discovered, or created to be affordable for all, it will be used. It doesn't matter what product it is, things will allways be replaced by an updated version of that product in the future.

        The marketing part is getting people to buy the product today, instead of waiting for the updated one. :)
        Will Farrell
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @athynz

        To you and others, you missed my point. I was being sarcastic to jatbains. So athynz, supposedly throwing my words in my face did nothing. You missed. What I said could apply to any OS, indeed, any device or just about anything in life . . . As for speaking without thinking, I knew exactly what I was saying and I even included what I consider to be an appropriate emoticon. Pity you didn't do the same. The last thing that I look forward to is that day that nothing can be improved because that is the day that there will be nothing more to look-forward to . . .
        Restricted_access
  • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

    I think it's just you.
    jeremychappell
    • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

      @jeremychappell

      I got tired of the Windows 7 interface 5 years ago while it was still the latest bling in Linux. At least Microsoft never did the spinning cube.

      Semi-transparent windows are not a really good idea. They distract from the content. It's another example of the triumph of "cool" over "useful".

      Microsoft should have left that nonsense up to Apple. Their fans don't really know what "useful" is.
      YetAnotherBob
      • RE: Is it just me, or does Windows 7 feel a bit long in the tooth compared to Android?

        @YetAnotherBob

        <I>Semi-transparent windows are not a really good idea. They distract from the content. It's another example of the triumph of "cool" over "useful". </I>

        I have yet to see anyone distracted by the AERO theme.
        The one and only, Cylon Centurion