ie8 fix

Will shoddy products tarnish the cult of Steve Jobs?

By | July 13, 2010, 7:28am PDT

Summary: When Consumer Reports says you need to put a strip of duct tape on the product to make it work, that’s shoddy.

Oh, man! When Consumer Reports, the most-trusted name in consumer product evaluations, pans your flagship product, you know you’re in trouble.

When a federal court judge drops the gavel on a class action lawsuit that could collapse your predatory (and universally hated) business model, you know you’re in trouble.

Or do you?

Consumer Reports actually recommended against buying the new iPhone 4 because, well, it doesn’t really work as a phone (unless you stick some duct tape on the side).

A federal court is now seriously looking at the question of whether the AT&T lock-in (and a bunch of ancillary aspects of the cellular phone business model) is kosher.

Does anyone think Steve Jobs will learn any lessons from this? Does anyone think he cares at all?

Of course not. Apple has billions in the bank and Steve himself is worth billions more.

To Steve and his Apple Dumpling Gang, the complainers are just mere bumblers trying to edge in on Apple’s good fortune, hard work, and its employees’ good looks.

Will these attacks break Apple?

Of course not. To millions of customers, Steve is Jesus. The iPhone, as imperfect as it is, is Excalibur and the Holy Grail all rolled up in bonded black and silver. It seems almost, that to the Apple faithful, merely touching the iPhone lets them touch an aspect of the deity and is truly a religious experience.

But it’s not a religious experience.

Apple is a giant, multi-national company trading off its reputation and the love of its strangely brainwashed masses. It’s a company that shipped a product that fails (we can forgive that) and refuses to admit it (this is the unforgivable sin). Apple is a company that is not putting its customers first.

It’s a shame, really. The iPhone 4, like most of Apple’s new products, is breakthrough engineering. Unfortunately, the company doesn’t label these breakthrough products as “beta”.

As a result, millions of gullible, trusting consumers are being duped into buying products that don’t perform their primary function and then, when they’re told they’re simply too stupid to hold it right, they turn towards Cupertino, bow their heads, and repeat in a monotone: “Thank you Steve for all thou hath given us.”

Don’t be goin’ off about the word “shoddy” in this article’s title. When Consumer Reports says you need to put a strip of duct tape on the product to make it work, that’s shoddy. Oh, what the heck. Let it rip.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

David Gewirtz, Distinguished Lecturer at CBS Interactive, is an author, U.S. policy advisor, and computer scientist. He is featured in The History Channel special The President's Book of Secrets.

Disclosure

David Gewirtz

At various times during his adult life, David has voted for both Democrats and Republicans, and has been disappointed by both. He is deeply disturbed by how partisanship has come before patriotism in America, which gives him the freedom to pick on both sides.

David is a frequent guest on TV and radio stations across America and can usually be heard or seen on-the-air at least once a week. He writes weekly commentary and analysis for CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360 and has been interviewed by Fox News, CNN, various ABC and NBC affiliates, and Canada’s Global TV. He has been a featured guest on National Public Radio and has also been featured on Voice of America, Radio Free Europe, and Radio Liberty where his commentaries on technology, industry, and emerging nations have been broadcast into 46 countries (all in their own unique translations).

David is the executive director of U.S. Strategic Perspective Institute, a nonprofit research and policy organization. He is the Cyberterrorism Advisor for the International Association for Counterterrorism & Security Professionals, a columnist for The Journal of Counterterrorism and Homeland Security and a special contributor to Frontline Security Magazine. He is a member of the FBI’s InfraGard program, the security partnership between the FBI and industry. David is also a member of the U.S. Naval Institute and the National Defense Industrial Association, the leading defense industry association promoting national security.

David is an advisory board member for the Technical Communications and Management Certificate program at the University of California, Berkeley extension. He is also a member of the instructional faculty at the University of California, Berkeley extension.

David’s “day job” is as publisher and editor-in-chief of ZATZ publishing, an online publisher of technical magazines. Other than than his ownership stake in Component Enterprises, Inc. (the parent company of ZATZ), David has no additional industry investments.

ZATZ has many advertisers who do, in part, provide for David’s lush income and extravagant lifestyle. Most of them are IBM and Lotus aftermarket suppliers, some of them make goodies for Microsoft Outlook, and a few make all sorts of strange mobile devices and add-on products. David has been a regular judge of the IBM Awards, but has no formal financial interest in or with IBM.

Because the ZATZ online magazines often review products, David and ZATZ are sent an overwhelming stream of unsolicited, silly, and often useless products to review. Because they’re such a pain to track and ship back, these products often wind up in a dumpster or fill up the corner of a large closet. Although David has no plans to review products in connection to his ZDNet blog, if he does do a product review, he will disclose any relationship completely in that posting.

Both through ZATZ and independently, David derives a small income through various advertising and sales relationships with Amazon.com and Google. These are minor relationships and they will not impede his willingness or ability to chastise either company should they deserve it.

David has many other business relationships, but none of them relate to anything he covers in his ZDNet blog. David does have a bit of the sales-guy bug and if he’s not doing a sales deal with someone at least once a month, he goes through withdrawal. He has a number of consulting clients, but none of them relate to anything he covers for ZDNet (and if they ever do, he will either disclose that fact, or decline to write about them).

Back in the 1980s, David held the unusual title of “Godfather” at Apple. He has written and published 40 incredibly simplistic applications for Apple’s iPhone.

Although David is forbidden to disclose the terms of his iPhone developer agreement, he isn’t drinking the Apple Kool Aid, will never be confused with a metrosexual, and feels free to mock Apple, and Apple users, any time the occasion permits, on alternate Tuesdays, or if he’s bored.

Biography

David Gewirtz

In addition to hosting the ZDNet Government and ZDNet DIY-IT blogs, CBS Interactive's Distinguished Lecturer David Gewirtz is an author, U.S. policy advisor, and computer scientist. He is featured in The History Channel special The President's Book of Secrets, is one of America's foremost cyber-security experts, and is a top expert on saving and creating jobs. He is also director of the U.S. Strategic Perspective Institute as well as the founder of ZATZ Publishing.

David is a member of FBI InfraGard, the Cyberwarfare Advisor for the International Association for Counterterrorism & Security Professionals, a columnist for The Journal of Counterterrorism and Homeland Security, and has been a regular CNN contributor, and a guest commentator for the Nieman Watchdog of the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University. He is the author of Where Have All the Emails Gone?, the definitive study of email in the White House, as well as How To Save Jobs and The Flexible Enterprise, the classic book that served as a foundation for today's agile business movement.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
193
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Will shoddy products tarnish the cult of Steve Jobs?
rfpower 1st Sep 2010
Consult an RF engineer and the fud will disappear!
Agreed. Oh the double standards that permeate everyday life. Microsoft or Android pull something like this they would be hanging from the gallows.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Will shoddy products tarnish the cult of Steve Jobs?
Feldwebel Wolfenstool 13th Jul 2010
@tbensen@... Bring back the Gibbet.
0 Votes
+ -
You have that backwards
zd-crap 13th Jul 2010
@tbensen@...

Actually, you have that backwards. Microsoft (Kin, Windows CE) and Android (HTC Magic, HTC Tattoo, HTC Lancaster, Motorola Droid, etc., too many to list), do this all the time and get away with it. They just keep rolling more phones out so you forget about their prior failures.

The iPhone is better than any of them, but gets no slack because of it. That's the double standard you were looking for.
0 Votes
+ -
@zd-crap Agreed. Apple is held to a ridiculous standard. Microsoft has been releasing crap products for 20 years and deserves all the hate.
0 Votes
+ -
@zd-crap

Not exactly. Apple fanboys "set" the standards and woe to any non-fanboy who dares to question the perceived quality of anything Apple produces. It's irrelevant whether it's hardware or software. If Apple makes it, it's the bestest.

It's a rare fanboy who will point and say that the Emperor has no clothes. And he's immediately excoriated by the True Believers for his apostasy. I offer Jason D. O'Grady as evidence of this--every time he points out a worm in the Apple, his oh-so-faithful readers do their best to rip him a new one.
@zd-crap What? Where was this failing with the Droid? I have one of these and the phone is great! In case you didn't know it was out selling the 3Gs until other Android phones hit the market.

As for Apple being held to an incredibly high standard, that's BS! They hand their manufacturing to Foxconn and they keep getting burned on it... Look up the iMac display issues, the 17" Display issue, the Macbook wifi issue (should I go on?) and you'll see that this isn't an isolated incident! Crud, this is probably the first time Apple customers didn't have to litigate to get their problems resolved!

Believe me, I build my machines and I don't use Foxconn products so guess what? My hardware never dies on me and if something like a hard drive does die, I just go back to the vender and they replace it (3 to 5 years is a typical warranty for many parts).

Anyway, I think you get the idea that Apple isn't being held to a standard, by their faithful, and they're still failing to deliver all the time.
0 Votes
+ -
@zd-crap As much as I love my iPhone - dude Android didn't have too many failures... lots of obnoxious fanbois but no real failures unless you count the whole Nexus One tech support fiasco. WM... yeah I'm with you on that one. Kin... yeah that one was a fail from the beginning - there were simply too many other and better offerings out there both Android and iOS based.
@tbensen@...

To put it another way: if the MS Kin had *antenna issues, would anyone give a sh8t (including MS)?

*Alleged issues, I own one, I can't reproduce it; and I don't read Consumer Reports for the hard science.
0 Votes
+ -
Hmm, interesting...
Peter Perry 18th Jul 2010
@zd-crap That's what a friend of mine said as well regarding his iPhone 4... I reproduced it for him in under 20 seconds, did you want to bring your phone over and I'll show you that the flaw is by design and you will see it without some type of insulation?
@tbensen@... On the contrary, there were a lot of problems in Android devices too, but invariably people said that it could only improve and be great. And I remember Page comments about multitasking problems on Android devices. Basically that he did not care at all.
@atari_z

Not to mention the Nokia N97 - which would not do anything once you had used a few of the features - because the Multitasking chewed up all the RAM and refused to launch the next one.

So Did Nokia stop selling their phones? No!!!

Did anyone scream about Nokia having a 'Shoddy' product? No!!!

Was this a real problem for the users - Yes!!!

So the double standard is alive and well here.
0 Votes
+ -
The irony of this...
nix_hed Updated - 13th Jul 2010
is that Apple is getting sued over the American cell phone market business model. You notice that there are dozens of other exclusive-to-the-carrier phones (BlackBerry Storm, Motorola Droid, dozens of HTC phones, the HTC Google phones on T-Mobile) and yet the lawsuit is going after AT&T and Apple. I'm sure that if Apple could have signed a shorter exclusivity deal than 5 years, they would have. However, AT&T had the foresight to see that the iPhone was going to become THE phone that the mass market wanted. The only reason why the me-too phones are selling is because of this deal. However, had Apple released the iPhone -

- On Verizon's network, the App Store wouldn't be nearly as varied as it is today.

- On T-Mobile's American network, coverage would blow and 3G data would perform even worse than it already does.

- On Sprint's 3G network, Sprint wouldn't exist because of iPhone users leaving for a network that actually works the way it should (back in 2007, Sprint didn't even work properly in it's home town).

- And Apple would still be in a lawsuit over the iPhone if there was an exclusivity deal!

The lawsuit isn't so much about iPhone as it is unfair marketing practices. If you want to sue the correct parties, you should be going after the major cell phone carriers and not the manufacturers, in order to reshape the American cell phone market to be more like the one in most of Europe (open and unlocked).
0 Votes
+ -
@nix_hed I'm glad someone else saw this... but sure, APPLE is the bad guy for doing a lock in just like everyone else...
0 Votes
+ -
@tbensen@...

I just laugh at you people - where do you all get off.

This story is actually based on a series of lies.

The iPhone 4 does by all accounts work as a phone with or without any tape.

Find evidence otherwise - then this story makes some sense.

But even then the issue is not universal from all reports.

And the issue is still awaiting a possible software fix.

So it's too early to call as 100% in Apple's favour - but it is way off being shoddy and a product requiring tape to work.

The real question still is - why do the Microsoft and Android cheer squads write so much garbage, and so many lies to knock down Apple!!!

No - this is not a fanboy comment - this is based on the available evidence not matching up with the articles written and the blog posts.

I am more than prepared to accept that Apple may turn out to have a real issue with the iPhone 4 - they have stuffed up before with a simple 'nice' feature resulting in the product failing - but on the available evidence now this appears to be a simple software issue misleading the user into panic about the level.

Do consumer reports have the tools to measure the actual signal level inside the phone? I bet they don't, and I bet they didn't do that.

This is as bad as the myth perpetuated about Objective-C and the iTunes store being the only way to get apps onto the iPhone. The journo's here perpetuated that, then suddenly when Google releases a web App - they discuss the relative merits of Web Apps - and even then make wild incorrect statements.

But it all gets you Apple haters posting and creating page impressions which make ad revenue for ZDNet - so the journo's get paid well for keeping the hate fires burning. Truth would not help their cause at all.

And plenty of Apple haters eager to use the opportunity to try to destroy.

So I will be going off about the use of the word shoddy - and quite frankly that is what the purpose of this article is:

Oh, what the heck. Let it rip.

@David Gewirtz

And we have - and so you will get paid for writing lies that in my country would possibly get you sued.
0 Votes
+ -
You Are Sooooo Scary...
Steve@... 14th Jul 2010
@richardw66
Your statements about there being no proof there is a problem are so insanely stupid. This is a nuclear text bubble over your head that screams "I honestly think people can ignore the mountains and oceans of evidence, and believe me when I blatantly lie to them"
Oh My God Gomer Pyle !
Consumer Reports doesn't need to measure the signal level inside the phone !!!!! When they hold the phone like Homo Sapiens hold telephones, the signal dies and the call is dis-connected !!!!!!!
What part of that do you and the rest of the koolaide kids think you can get intelligent people confused about ???????
Oh My God Gomer Pyle !!!!!!!!
Every one of you who defend the i4, and say "mine doesn't do it, so this is a lie" are accusing 500,000 people of lying ??????
Oh, damn, I'm sorry, you're probably not bright enough to do any math other than repeating "apple sold 1.5 million iPhone 4s in one week..."
You and your brother fan boys may not be able to read, write or count, but when you don't drink the apple koolaide, it's really easy to add up the problems and accept that they're real.
Quit shaming yourself...
@richardw66
How much is Apple paying you write such crap?
@tbensen@...

Steve is safe, as long as he issues a recall and says "My bad." That is what I read he is going to do.

Well, is Apple going to recall the iPhone4 or not? According to this article, the decision has been made.

Read this article, it is hysterical.

Apple Recalls iPhone 4?Very Fondly; Announces It Will Apply Same Rigorous Standards to Four New Product Launches

VERY FUNNY.

http://www.dailygoat.com/?p=1491
@pchrun
Yes, that was funny.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Will shoddy products tarnish the cult of Steve Jobs?
GENESIS667@... Updated - 13th Jul 2010
@tbensen@...
Funny, I distinctly remember the Evo having a problem with the screen separating and HTC said it was a "minor" annoyance, then there was the
non-responsive touch screen issue, then there was the yellow vertical line issue, then there was the latest clusterfluck where the users phones were bricked during a software update...I don't see hardly a mention about any of that...There's plenty about it on the web, but it's suspiciously missing from the media...But I guess you android fanbois consider those things "perks" since you're so used to sub-standard crap from MS...
@GENESIS667@... what does Android have to do with substandard crap from MS?
0 Votes
+ -
@sokmonkey67
rtk 14th Jul 2010
"what does Android have to do with substandard crap from MS? "

Not a thing, it's just the deflect part of the iCult's defend, deny, deflect shill.
0 Votes
+ -
What?
Peter Perry 18th Jul 2010
@GENESIS667@... HTC said the lines and the separating were part of the compound settling on the phones display and that the problems would disipate over time... Guess what? They were right, the problems did in fact go away on their own but this iPhone 4 issue isn't going away on its own!
0 Votes
+ -
@ David Gewirtz

What a bunch of histrionic drivel.

Seriously, it's as though you write for a jouvenile delinquent soap-opera!

There is absolutely nothing intelligent, reasoned, or even thought provoking about your childish rant.

Grow up.
The time is now apple. Admit you knew about this prior to launch, fired everyone up the chain who made the decision to launch anyway instead of fixing it first, and recall all these defective units and replace them for FREE with redesigned ones that work properly! your reputation is at stake and you've got way more than enough cash in the bank to do it without even making a dent.
@Johnny Vegas

HAHAHAHA - very funny - nice spin - complete garbage

The phones are not by all reports faulty!!!!

The signal level indicator is scaled oddly - and the users are panicking.

The bloggers and journos are having a field day misrepresenting the issue.

You have joined in with the lie.

Did you believe this rubbish you are writing?
0 Votes
+ -
Yes
becabill 13th Jul 2010
@richardw66
Yes
@richardw66
I love it when fanboys claim to not be fan boys - like a naked man running across the football field claiming he's not a streaker...

Frankly, Apple's software claim doesn't add up. The phone woudn't register a change at all unless:
1) the phone MAGICALLY knows when you touch a NON-SENSITIVE portion of the device, or...
2) there is a LEGITIMATE signal attenuation occuring when the antenna is being blocked.

Likewise, if the issue was software, adding a piece of tape would REALLY not have an effect.

The real shame is not that there is a flaw in an otherwise good device (since every engineered device has some flaw), but rather that Apple has choosen to spin the problem to avoid looking bad after over-hyping themselves(a la Microsoft circa late 90's).

I'll put it even more clearly: Apple has a vested interest in looking good and spinning their response. Consumer Reports, as a well respected and prestigeous publication, has a vested interest in being RIGHT.

Sorry, but as an engineer and a software dev, I'll believe CR over Apple.
0 Votes
+ -
@richardw66 Do you believe this rubbish you're writing?
0 Votes
+ -
If I understand correctly
becabill 13th Jul 2010
@Johnny Vegas
...the antenna is part of the frame. This would be a tough thing to fix in a recall. In-warranty unit replacement with a redesigned antenna seems like the only real answer.
0 Votes
+ -
@Johnny Vegas Except that nobody knows what is the extent of the problem, or even if there is really a problem at all, except from the faulty indication on the screen.

I have an iPhone 4, which has better reception that my previous iPhone 3GS, I have a friend who have an iPhone 4, with a better reception than it's previous HTC smartphone. I know nobody having this phone having detected this over-hyped problem. Which does not mean that it does not exist, but just that it is much more elusive than people want to shout on websites.

Plus it appears that "scientific" reports are not scientific at all
0 Votes
+ -
I'm giddy with excitement!!
NonZealot 13th Jul 2010
Apple is finally, for the first time ever, not being given a pass by the blogosphere. I LOVE IT!!!!

Squirm Apple zealots, squirm!!! happy
@NonZealot

Many people made a substantial emotional investment in this product and they are suffering now. Please pause a moment to consider how they are feeling now and show some sympathy.

Anyway, something like this was bound to happen anytime. Steve Jobs should have known that the moment Apple got bigger than Microsoft meant no more free passes.

Steve can try to boost the power on the Reality Distortion Field as much as he like, it will not work this time.
0 Votes
+ -
Sympathy? Not a Chance
trickytom2 13th Jul 2010
@OS Reload For years people like me have suffered at the feet of the iFans. PC users were looked down on by these snobs.

Screw 'em. Let them taste their own medicine!
0 Votes
+ -
Oh yes it will!
DougPetrosky 13th Jul 2010
@OS Reload
The problem is that only half the story appears to be getting out. Consumer Reports didn't show the phone dropping any more calls than any other phone. All they said was that if reception was already bad, touching this spot "could" drop a call.

What they didn't report is exactly what Ars noted, which is that the phone holds on to calls very well and that some other phones would not have reception at all in the hypothetical location, where a call could be dropped.

This phone is working in the real world, so thus far all Apple has lost is the Media War, and I think Steve can ramp it up.
@OS Reload No way. People are "suffering" because they're too stupid to actually wait for reviews of their phones, for bug reports, for things any reasonable person would research before buying extremely expensive kit? These peoplare are SUFFERING now?

No. They're stupid. If they're suffering, they deserve to suffer.
@trickytom2: If you want the truth, it's attitudes like yours that cause people to look down on you. I personally can't stand people who have to talk down everybody for no legitimate reason. You, and 99% of the other anti-Apple zealots have my pity, but not my respect.
@OS Reload

Sorry - but the reality distortion field is not where you think it is.

The best reality distortion field is the one that makes you think the reality distortion field is somewhere else.

The iPhone 4 has sold in the millions - and how many people have been unhappy enough to return it?

And how many people are really happy with it?

And how much has a signal indicator problem been misrepresented as a fatal flaw by the press and by people such as yourself?

And where is this reality distortion field exactly?
0 Votes
+ -
@OS Reload Difference is AAPL got bigger through honest market competition, not illegal monopolist behavior. Apple should continue to get a free pass.
0 Votes
+ -
Not true
Peter Perry 18th Jul 2010
@DougPetrosky

Consumer Reports did say they tested 10 AT&T phones and the only product to exhibit the problem with poor signal strength and dropped calls was the iPhone 4! They basically said, hey, guess what? AT&T isn't to blame here!
0 Votes
+ -
Do you really believe that?
Peter Perry 18th Jul 2010
@MSFTWorshipper

They leveraged their iTunes and continuously locked out the competition every time they had their devices connecting to iTunes. Now they're doing the same thing with the iPad and several of their applications.

Basically, it's the same thing Microsoft was guilty of doing.
0 Votes
+ -
@NonZealot While I may not agree with enthusiasm, it is refreshing to see that the "Perfect Apple" that so many people cram down throats has a few bruises or worms (as any company/product). However, I said it years ago...as Apple gets more popular and it's ranks grow - so will the criticism and to date I have been correct. The larger market does not wear the knee-pads as faithfully as the smaller market did nor will they have the patience. Maybe I will be a lottery ticket
@ItsTheBottomLine

It's the Apple hating Zealots who cram 'Perfect Apple' down people's throats.

Anyone who has used Apple products knows they are not perfect.

And I have not seen any Apple users claiming Apple is perfect. I have not even seen Apple claiming to be perfect.

I have seen a lot of people such as you claiming this 'Perfect Apple' straw man though!!!

Apple is not perfect!!!!

Apple has had products that died out due to a flaw.

This is really not looking like that though, as much as the haters are hoping this is a faulty product - it apparently isn't.

There are a lot of bloggers who are going to be disappointed that their lies do not kill the product.

They were after all declaring the iPhone 3G dead before it was launched, the iPhone 3GS also, the iPad and the iPhone 4 before launch.

The number of blogs about missing features - that turned out to be in the product were amazing.

So nothing has changed.

Millions of sales, how many returns?

And millions more sales to come.

The IT industry no longer owns the customer base. The decision makers are no longer readers of this garbage.
@NonZealot

Yeah - you enjoy others hurting don't you!!!

And you still know this is in fact a lie.
I don't know where you M$ lovers have been, but Microsoft's mobile phones are a disaster. I changed to an iPhone after two seriously flawed Windows Mobile phones and will NEVER look back.
0 Votes
+ -
What does this have to do with MS?
NonZealot 13th Jul 2010
@Whack!
Focus. This is about Apple and only about Apple.
@NonZealot
Thank you! I have had quite a few Windows mobile phones and have had nothing short of a near perfect experience (as your going to get w/any cellular device) as I could have hoped for. Perfectly satisfied w/Win 6.5.
But - as you said - this story is not about MS! Focus all!

Now - back to the bad apple in the bottom of the basket, I wondered why there were so many flies around this summer?
@NonZealot thank you! This is one of the few times I agree with you, this IS only about Apple. However has it occurred to you that you will never hear from the millions of users who don't have a problem? I usually just chuckle to myself when I read your mostly specious arguments and carry on enjoying the banter that goes on between MS and Apple haters (on both sides). In my case, I just upgraded from an original iPhone to iPhone 4. I find that it does everything I expected it to, with better battery life than I expected, good reception, and no dropped calls. That is not to say you are wrong, or right, just that MY experience is not what YOU are repeating. And as I doubt that YOU actually have an iPhone 4, I would suggest that my opinion based on actual usage and experience carries somewhat more weight.
0 Votes
+ -
Why focus?.
becabill 13th Jul 2010
@NonZealot Is the intent of this discussion to maximize Apple's embarrassment or to help publicize what needs to be improved?
@NonZealot

I agree - with a Windows mobile phone it is not about Windows or MS.

I believe Windows runs alongside the baseband radio system and MS does not design the hardware at all. So I doubt that Windows is involved in signal issues.

Apple on the other hand is building the device and the software including the baseband radio system. So Apple is relevant to the signal issues of an iPhone.

But what is relevant about Whack!'s comment is that he has used windows mobile phones which were still a phone product and had issues with them - and he has used an iPhone and had a good experience. This is perfectly relevant.

It is important to judge a product by not only are there any issues, but are there any satisfied customers.

The antenna issue - if it is an antenna issue - may be only affecting a few people, or it may be affecting millions. Any comment that helps to judge the reach of the issue is helpful and relevant.

Also it is reasonable to put this in perspective against other similar products.

@ NCIronMan

And similarly you are reporting that you have been happy with the other products - this is also important for the same reason of balance.

@aidux

And exactly right - I also agreed with NonZealot about the risks of buying a product at release time.

I disagreed with him that it is stupid or crazy in this case - but it is risky.

But since any unhappy customer can return their iPhone to Apple then the risk is somewhat mitigated by the way Apple is behaving most ethically about this - What more can you do than offer a money back guarantee.

Since there is so far no evidence that the problem is universal, in fact quite the opposite, there are at least some people out there who are happy that they did buy the iPhone 4, and that have done well by their purchase.

The question yet to be answered is - does the antenna issue exist - or is it as currently diagnosed a signal indicator software issue?

The second question to be answered is - does the sensitivity to coverage of the antenna gap happen in only some of the phones? Is it somehow more sensitive in some due to differences in the way it was assembled, some manufacturing tolerance issue, that increases the effect.

There is no doubt that the way you hold a phone will change the signal, and this is true of all phones. The doubt is what is the impact of that change? And is the degree of change consistent across all of the iPhones out there?

There are something over 2 million of these devices already - if all of these were affected then I think we would be seeing a much larger effect - most of what is going on is overblown reporting, combined with blogging from those who have no experience of the product but wish to bring down Apple for reasons of their own.

And ZDNet continues to write stupid, stupid things - Like 'Shares Tanked' - that's just ridiculous - they went down by a small amount, nothing unusual - then back up again.

And as for shoddy - that implies bad workmanship - which would imply that FoxConn is doing bad work in assembling them - and there is no evidence in that at all.

There is also evidence so far that the issue is a software scaling issue - and if you apply this logic to Windows - what would you say about it? Or to any other software that has a bug on release?
@Whack!

Now it's Apple's turn: same sin, same punishment.

It's only fair.
Consult an RF engineer and the fud will disappear!

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix