Can Microsoft build a tablet that people will want to buy?

Can Microsoft build a tablet that people will want to buy?

Summary: Microsoft and Barnes & Noble have a lot of content available to offer, in the form of music, books, games, apps, movies, magazines and so on. A tablet could be just the convergence device to focus all this into one place. But everything has to be right.


There is increasing speculation that Microsoft will use today's event at Los Angeles to showcase a tablet developed and built in conjunction with Barnes & Noble.

But can Microsoft build a sexy tablet that people will want to buy?

In the invitation sent out to the press, Microsoft called this a "major" announcement and one that "you will not want to miss". This sets the bar quite high in terms of expectation and has led some to speculate that this would be a Windows RT or Windows 8 tablet announcement.

I find this hard to believe given that Windows 8 and Windows RT is still months away, and Microsoft's OEM partners wouldn't be happy if the Redmond giant had entered into some strategic alliance with a third-party at this state to pre-announce a Windows tablet before anyone else.

So this likely isn't about Windows.

The whispers that this is related to Microsoft's strategic partnership with Barnes & Noble makes a lot more sense. Here are my thoughts; partly based on speculation, and partly based on rumors and chatter I'm hearing.

There is likely to be new hardware announced today. More than likely this hardware will be a tablet, given that Barnes & Noble already has a tablet product on market enjoying modest success.

But a tablet can only part of the equation. As companies such as RIM, Motorola, and HP have demonstrated in the past, coming out with a tablet does not guarantee that said tablet would be a success. In fact, if history is anything to go by, unless you're Apple --- or to a lesser extent, Amazon or Samsung --- tablets are an almost sure-fire way to lose money.

In order to succeed in the tablet market, you need much more than a physical tablet.

This is where content comes into play. Hardware is nice, but content is king, and as Apple and Amazon have demonstrated, it can make the difference between success and failure.

Between them, Microsoft and Barnes & Noble have a lot of content available to offer, in the form of music, books, games, apps, movies, magazines and so on. A tablet could be just the convergence device to focus all this into one place.

But everything has to be right.

First, the price has to be right. The $199 price point that the Amazon Kindle Fire and Barnes & Noble NOOK tablets have carved for themselves seems to work, but dropping the price to around the $150 mark would certainly sweeten the deal and make people more likely to take a risk. There's significant wriggle room with a device that's designed primarily as a content consumption device to subsidize the price significantly without hitting the bottom line.

Don't expect any tablet announced today to complete with the iPad. The target here is likely to be Amazon and the Kindle Fire.

Also, the content has to be right. There can't be a situation where there are big gaps in the content on offer, and the content available has to be priced right. Also it has to be, to the maximum extent possible, a one-stop-shop for digital media. Consumers aren't going to take a chance on buying into a new ecosystem when then can buy into broader and far more established digital content ecosystems such as those offered by Amazon and Apple.

The way people access the content also has to be right. It has to be quick, easy and streamlined. How this needs to work has already been well established by devices such as the iPad or Kindle Fire. Consumers who are used to a one-click world won't take well to having to click twice.

Pricing also has to be right. And by right, I mean simple. One of the biggest complains I hear leveled against the Xbox Live concept is Microsoft's insistence in pricing based on Xbox 'points' rather than just pricing content in local currency.

People just want to know how much things cost, and not have to currency convert into as weird and arbitrary points system.

Integration also has to strike the right balance. Whatever product or service Microsoft comes out with today needs to integrate with, but at the same time not rely on, Microsoft's existing ecosystem. Here I'm thinking specifically about Windows and Xbox.

While I don't believe that Microsoft is going to announce an Xbox gaming tablet today, I expect there to be some leveraging of the Xbox ecosystem. After all, Xbox is Microsoft's second-largest ecosystem, after Windows, and now that Microsoft has subtly shifted the Xbox platform away from being purely a console and more towards being an entertainment hub, it would make sense that any device announced today would leverage this ecosystem.

That said, it cannot and should not rely too heavily on the Xbox, the hardware, platform or brand. The reason I say this is that when you look at the diverse nature of people buying tablets such as the Kindle Fire, Nook and iPad, the majority of them aren't likely to own an Xbox or ever want to. Launching a tablet that relied on the Xbox would mean certain death of the tablet.

Finally, Microsoft and Barnes & Noble need to get the differentiation factor right. Quite simply, there needs to be a clear and well-defined reasons why people should take a chance on it, and these need to go beyond way beyond the fact that this tablet has anything to do with Microsoft.

If Microsoft can't succinctly answer the "why should I buy this over a Kindle or an iPad?" question, it's doomed from the start.

That's a lot for Microsoft to get right, but if it can be done, then this could be interesting.

Image credit: Wikimedia Commons, CC.


Topics: Hardware, Laptops, Microsoft, Mobility, Tablets

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Yes They Can!!!

    If the price is rigjt, MS just served notice and even Apple had better take this thing seriously! Windows 8 can work on a tablet very well and that cover is way better than anything out there.

    Here I was thinking a Windows RT Nook tablet!
    • Hope not

      I really like my Nook and don't want it ruined with Windows.
      • Ditto for the Nook Simple Touch.

        It's a beautifully simple little gem of an e-reader. Don't touch it, Microsoft!
      • IF they make a new Nook with Windows

        Then DO NOT BUY IT! It's just that simple.
      • Nook is a sweet product.

        Microsoft will only ruin it. Obviously in an effort to make their OS the one that rules them all.

        Watch out Nokia! You should have never gotten into bed with MS!
        The Danger is Microsoft
    • Funny how they didn't mention price.

      or [/b]resolution or battery life[/b].
    • Peter, you are absolutely right

      I think this is one of the few times I agree with you honestly. The Apple Innovation for this year isn't that great and I think they should take Microsoft Surface seriously. MSFT just showcased how Win8 can work on a tablet and extend it as a serious laptop with that touch cover. Apple should seriously think about the Macbook Air and iPad line.
      Ram U
  • The problem with secrecy and hype... that the expectations before the event tend to get so wildly inflated that it's VERY difficult to live up to them. Apple has had this problem. We'll see how Microsoft does this afternoon.
    • I think alot of people understand it's more the news entity

      over reaching, and aren't shocked or excited about anything anymore.
      William Farrel
  • Can Microsoft build a tablet that people will want to buy?

    Yes they can! Anything with Microsoft Windows on it is going to sell pretty darn well. Not only that but Microsoft is known to distribute some pretty darn good hardware as well. Just look at the Microsoft natural ergonomic keyboard, mice, Xbox, and Kinect. All are winners. To even question Microsoft on if they can sell a tablet is absurd!
    Loverock Davidson-
    • Hmm

      Nokia phones and the Zune excluded I am sure!
      • Why exclude them?

        Nokia was #1 selling phone on Amazon and AT&T.
        Loverock Davidson-
      • Zune is a great piece of hardware

        that people never heard about. That doesn't take from the fact that they do indeed make good hardware.
        Sure XBox had had it's hardware issues, not unlike alot of other products on the market.
        Overall, if they really let people know about the product, then thats half teh battle, so to speak.
        William Farrel
      • And the Kin

        And every other Microsoft tablet (hundreds) that has gone before. And Plays for Sure.
      • Umm

        William Farrell,

        I never said it wasn't good hardware... I merely challenged his assertion that everything running Windows sold well, when that clearly isn't true. I still feel that MS makes the best mice and keyboards in the game.
      • Nice try but...

        Nice try Loverock but, AT&t's number one selling phone is the iPhone.
    • I still find your posts on tablets amusing

      considering you've called them a fad since the first iPad came out. Is this a change of heart?
      • No

        They are still a fad, I've always maintained that position.
        Loverock Davidson-
  • Doomed I tell you ...

    AKH master of disaster, king Chroom of Doom ...
  • No

    Outside of computers, things with Windows on them sell poorly.

    Look at Windows Mobile. Fail.
    Turned that into Windows Phone and another Fail.

    So no people really don't want Windows. They only sell it in the computer space because people think there are no alternatives. As Apple has shown (with increasing Mac sales while PC sales are level or on the decline) when people are aware of an alternative to Windows they will jump ship.

    Same thing happened with GM from the 60s and 70s. As soon as a viable competitor came along people jumped ship.