Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

Summary: Ugh, here we go again. The iPad 2 hasn't been out four months yet, but that doesn't stop yet more rumors that a new iPad will be hitting Apple Stores this fall.

SHARE:
TOPICS: iPad, Mobility
8

Ugh, here we go again. The iPad 2 hasn't been out four months yet, but that doesn't stop yet more rumors that a new iPad will be hitting Apple Stores this fall.

Note: Those of you with good memories will undoubtedly remember earlier iPad 3 rumors.

It's a well-known fact in tech journalism that the summer represents a dry period for news. Everyone - press, public and tech industry alike - is caught up thinking about vacations, BBQs, catching some rays and other 'summer' related activities. Because of this there's a certain pressure on outlets to fill this vacuum. A good target for these 'rumors' is Apple, and the Apple rumor du jour seems to be that Apple is planning on releasing the iPad 3 (or iPad HD as it's being called by some) this fall.

This latest rumor comes in via former Engadget editor-in-chief Joshua Topolsky on his new site thisismynext.com.

Our sources are saying that not only will there be a newly designed iPhone coming in the fall, but there is going to be a new entry into the iPad family as well. As hard as it might be to believe, the new tablet is said to sport a double resolution screen (2048 x 1536), and will be dubbed the "iPad HD." The idea behind the product is apparently that it will be a "pro" device aimed at a higher end market - folks who work in video and photo production possibly - and will be introduced alongside something like an iPad version of Final Cut or Aperture. This product is specifically said to not be the iPad 3, rather a complimentary piece of the iPad 2 line. Think MacBook and MacBook Pro.

OK, let's put the whole 'our sources' bit on one side for a moment and just focus on the technical points. This iPad 3 (or iPad HD as Topolsky calls it) sporting a 2048 x 1536 display is not a new rumor. There seems to be some mention of this screen resolution in the iOS SDK related to the new Twitter and Newsstand .framework. I dismissed this rumor back in June with the following points:

  1. Why release another iPad within months of the iPad 2? I'd understand this knee-jerk move if Apple was under pressure from other tablets in the market, but it's not.
  2. Why restrict the high-resolution 'Retina Display' to certain aspects of iOS (like Twitter and Newsstand) rather than making it available across the whole OS?
  3. Supply chain contacts say that there is no iPad 3 incoming any time soon.
  4. It's not the first time that people have used 'evidence' gathered from the iOS SDK to convince themselves that a 'Retina Display' iPad is imminent. Remember all the speculation before the iPad 2 was released?
  5. A 'Retina Display' panel the size of the iPad's would be a serious number of pixels to move about and it would need some serious hardware. The cost doesn't justify the benefit. Yes, sure, a 'Retina Display' panel might be nice and 'cool' but what's the point when HD movies would run windowed or need upscaling?
  6. How do you explain this?

I think that these points are just as valid now as they were last month.

But in this latest 'rumor' Topolsky takes this high-resolution ‘Retina Display’ iPad rumor and repackages it as 'a "pro" device aimed at a higher end market.'

OK, where do we start tearing this idea apart?

  1. Where is the need for Apple to introduce a new 'pro' iPad? Apple is targeting the mass market with the iPad (both in terms of price and functionality) and the idea that Apple feels the need to introduce a niche product aimed at 'folks who work in video and photo production possibly' doesn't make sense. Apple can sell iPads faster than it can make them, it makes no sense whatsoever for the company to take a risk releasing something aimed at a subset of the tablet market.
  2. Apple already has products aimed at 'folks who work in video and photo production possibly' - they're called the MacBook Pro and MacPro! Take a look in the Apple Store - they're there!
  3. What price does Topolsky think that this 'pro' iPad will sell for? Apple's priced the iPad competitively, and companies that have tried to sell a 'premium' tablet product have failed. Why would Apple go there?
  4. At the same time that Apple is backing away from certain pro market (as shown by Final Cut Pro X compared to Final Cut Pro 7, and how Apple discontinued the Xserve line), why would Apple be thinking about a 'pro' tablet? Apple is targeting the bigger 'mass' markets as opposed to fringe 'pro' or enterprise users. The big money is in the mass market. Apple knows this. I'm surprised Topolsky doesn't.
  5. Resolution aside, what does this 'iPad HD' offer over the iPad? What about it makes it 'higher end'?

Nothing about this rumor makes sense. Sure, it's bound to drive the fanboys wild with anticipation, but as for being based on reality, I don't think so.

Before I end this piece, let's go back to Topolsky's casual throwing in of that phrase 'our sources.' There's no doubt that Topolsky, like most other people in this industry, has his contacts and well-placed sources, but there have been many examples of where Topolsky has been adamant about things that have turned out to be completely wrong. Only a few weeks ago he was adamant that there would not be any iCloud web apps, and going as far as to claim that he'd had this confirmed by Apple PR (if you want to follow this you need to keep up with Topolsky's podcast). A few days later Apple released a statement making it clear that iCloud would indeed have web apps. Then the Apple TV rumor. There are more examples, but I don't need to hammer the point home, do I?

I'm pretty sure that there are HD-capable iPads floating around Cupertino, and that there are people who have seem them, but this doesn't mean that there are new HD iPads incoming any time soon.

2011 will be the year of the iPad 2.

Thoughts?

Topics: iPad, Mobility

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

8 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • 100% agree.

    At 12MB/screen not counting any off screen stores and UI backing stores, a Retina display based iPad, while being sweet, is not in the cards. You need to goto 1GB of RAM just to take care of the extra memory requirements for graphics.

    No with 1GB and a future Apple A6 that is 543MP4 based or Rouge series 6... Maybe then.

    Many of the Apple supplied apps already have <i>@2x.png</i> rendered graphics so it is coming at some point.
    Bruizer
  • RE: Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

    That's interesting considering apple just made their beta program http://adf.ly/21TOf open to the public.
    jen364
  • If I had a nickel for every Apple rumor I've read...

    I would easily be able to afford their products.
    Mac Hosehead
  • RE: Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

    Nice to see someone NOT drinking the "iPad 3 in 2011" kool-aid. I've said it once and I'll say it again... There is *ZERO* incentive for Apple to release a brand new version of a product so soon after the current version, when the current version is doing EXTREMELY well.<br><br>Apple THRIVES on the excitement and fervor caused by almost every hardware product they release. Why would they "waste" excitement they could integrate into their upcoming 2012 product time-line by throwing so many new core products out before the end of 2011? It's stupid to assume they would throw so many cards on the table all at once when they could theoretically extend even *just* the products rumored so far for 2011, all the way through 2012! Though I don't doubt some of them are definitely coming, with the new Mac hardware being the most likely to come the soonest.<br><br>I also don't buy the rumor that the iPad 3 is viable just because of iOS 5. There is PLENTY that the current iPad will already be able to utilize from iOS 5, and any other unused features can be left for the 2012 iPad 3 release.<br><br>What I DO agree on, is that the next iPad, whenever it arrives, WILL have to increase the current resolution. I don't know if the 250ppi that I'm hearing is realistic given current hardware constraints, but certainly at LEAST a bump up to 1280x800, and hopefully 1680x1050. If not to claim Full HD resolution for video content, at least to saddle up with the iPhone on sharpness and text legibility. Resolution is really the only thing keeping me from an iPad for the time being, I just don't like seeing pixels that large at the close distance I hold the thing. It's actually a distraction to me.
    Playdrv4me
    • RE: Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

      @Playdrv4me

      I disagree with one of your opinions (that Apple would have "zero incentive" for a 2011 iPad 3) while finding your other opinions on this subject well thought out.

      For the sake of argument, let's call this rumored tablet an iPad 2.5 since posted rumors all point to just an increase in display resolution as the distinguishing hardware feature and not an improvement in SoC components .. which is to say, the rumored iPad 2.5 will retain the current A5 chip set.

      If I may speculate about this rumored "professional level" iPad - as some online bloggers have categorized it - then I might be inclined to believe it could have a "Thunderbolt" port at the sacrifice of some battery life duration as well.

      If indeed the rumored iPad product will be host to professional apps (some have speculated that Final Cut Pro X and Aperture are being ported to the iOS ecosystem) than Apple would have incentive enough to introduce this product.

      Think about it for a second. This would give Apple an excellent "try out" for an HD iPad display .. a display that would probably be in relatively short supply before manufacturing facilities can ramp up production for inclusion into mainstream iPad products scheduled for release in 2012 .. and /or a Thunderbolt equipped tablet.

      Speaking of those anticipated 2012 products, they will, in all likelihood, incorporate a different (and likely more powerful) SoC and perhaps NFC tech.

      Since these are all rumors and speculation at this time, why not have some fun and join in on the "what if" game?
      kenosha77a
  • Without these rumors...

    how would pundits be able to slam Apple for delays of unannounced products?
    msalzberg
  • RE: Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

    expover microsoft internet working at sites with the
    - and <a href="http://www.balimsohbet.com" title="sohbet odalari" target="_blank">sohbet odalari</a> - and <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="Mynet" target="_blank">mynet</a> - <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="Mynet sohbet" target="_blank">mynet sohbet</a> -
    turkey the microsoft is a good format is also <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="face" target="_blank">face</a> -
    - <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp" target="_blank">metin2 pvp</a> -
    operiation <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com/">facebok</a> - <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/">twitter</a>
    Behaviour of desdek bigger role in these sites <a href="http://www.sohbetix.net/">sohbet</a> Microsoft A network connection to the game s dada gubve unwanted surprises
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverlar" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverlar</a> -
    <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="facesohbet" target="_blank">facesohbet</a> -
    and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/yonja-sohbet" title="yonja" target="_blank">yonja</a> - and <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com" title="facebok" target="_blank">facebok</a> -<a href="http://www.sexsohbeti.org" title="sex sohbet" target="_blank">sex sohbet</a> - <a href="http://www.sexmuhabbet.net" title="sex hikayeleri" target="_blank">sex hikayeleri</a> - and- and <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="facebook" target="_blank">facebook</a> - and <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="fesbuk" target="_blank">fesbuk</a> - and <a href="http://www.balimsohbet.com" title="sohbet" target="_blank">sohbet</a> - and <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="cet" target="_blank">cet</a> - - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/indir" title="metin2 indir" target="_blank">metin2 indir</a> - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/resimleri" title="metin2 resimleri" target="_blank">metin2 resimleri</a> - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/metin2-kaydol" title="metin2 kaydol" target="_blank">metin2 kaydol</a> - ang <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a> -

    <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com/tag/fesbok-giris" title="fesbok giris" target="_blank">fesbok giris</a>
    room turkey
    twitter sohbet portallari <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/netlog/" title="netlog" target="_blank">netlog</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/twitter-turkce/" title="twitter turkce" target="_blank">twitter t?rkce</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/twitter-giris/" title="twitter giris" target="_blank">twitter giris</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/" title="twitter kaydol" target="_blank">twitter kaydol</a>
    <a href="http://facesohbet.net/modules/news/index.php?storytopic=41-fesbuk-videolar" title="fesbuk" target="_blank">fesbuk</a>

    turkiye mt2, metin2 online games serverlar
    and and and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="mt2 pvp server" target="_blank">mt2 pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp server" target="_blank">metin2 pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="pvp server" target="_blank">pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverlar" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverlar</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverler" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverler</a> and
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="pvp serverler" target="_blank">pvp serverler</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="pvp serverlar" target="_blank">pvp serverlar</a>



    <a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet odasi" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet odasi</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet odalar?</a>


    <a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet" target="_blank">ankara sohbet</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">ankara sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">ankara sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet odas?" target="_blank">ankara sohbet odas?</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet" target="_blank">izmir sohbet</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">izmir sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">izmir sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet chat" target="_blank">izmir sohbet chat</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet" target="_blank">bursa sohbet</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">bursa sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet siteleri" target="_blank">bursa sohbet siteleri</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet odasi" target="_blank">bursa sohbet odasi</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet odalari" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet siteleri" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet siteleri</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet kanallar?" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet kanalalr?</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/yonja-sohbet" title="yonja" target="_blank">yonja</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/netlog/" title="netlog" target="_blank">netlog</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/" title="twitter" target="_blank">twitter</a><a href="http://www.faceara.com" title="face" target="_blank">face</a><a href="http://www.faceara.com" title="facebook" target="_blank">facebook</a><a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp, metin2 pvp server, mt2 server," target="_blank">pvp</a>


    Bunu mu demek istediniz? Cok guzel bir oyun be?eni ile oynuyorum ama bunun metin2
    Metin veya web sitesi adresi yaz?n ya da bir dok?man? ?evirin.
    ?ptal
    Dinleyin
    Fonetik olarak okuyun
    T?rk?e dilinden ?ngilizce diline ?eviri
    I play a game with very nice, but it <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a>
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp" target="_blank">metin2 pvp</a>
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverler" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverler</a>

    and install servers by lara s depending on the tour game bilrisiniz

    <a href="http://www.tuztanem.com" title="tuztanem" target="_blank">tuztanem</a>
    <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="manolyam" target="_blank">manolyam</a>
    zafer12
  • RE: Friday Rant: The 'iPad 3/HD coming this fall' is the zombie rumor that refuses to die!

    Hull have announced that Richard Agar will be John Kear's assistant for the 2005 and 2006 Super League seasons.
    The 32-year-old has had a successful year at National League Two side York City Knights<a href="http://www.jigoloekspres.com">jigolo</a> <a href="http://www.medyumanna.net">medyum</a> <a href="http://www.cihanhacihan.com">web tasarim</a> <a href="http://www.duvarkagidim.com">duvar kagidi</a> <a href="http://www.fobsam.com">ofis mobilyalari</a> <a href="http://www.fobsam.com">buro mobilyalari</a> <a href="http://www.kolcularltd.com">Hava Perdeleri</a> <a href="http://www.kolcularltd.com">Hava Perdesi Fiyatlari</a> <a href="http://www.kolcularltd.com">Hava Perdesi</a> <a href="http://www.nivahavaperdesi.com">Hava Perdesi Fiyatlari</a> <a href="http://www.nivahavaperdesi.com">Hava Perdesi</a> <a href="http://www.nivahavaperdesi.com">Hava Perdeleri</a> <a href="http://www.sosyal-medyam.com">sosyal medya</a> <a href="http://www.bezcantalarim.com">bez canta</a> and reached Grand Finals as a player for Dewsbury and Widnes.
    "He's a coach of undoubted potential as his record already indicates," said Kear, who takes over from Shaun <br><a href="http://www.ukeducation.com.tr">ingilterede dil egitimi</a> <a href="http://www.ukeducation.com.tr">ingilterede ingilizce</a> <a href="http://www.ukeducation.com.tr">ingilterede dil okullari</a> <a href="http://www.ukeducation.com.tr">Londra dil okullari</a> <a href="http://www.ukeducation.com.tr">ingilterede sertifika programlari</a>
    <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede master</a> <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede yuksek lisans</a> <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede egitim</a> <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede universite</a> <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede mba</a> <a href="http://www.britisheducation.com.tr">ingilterede sertifika programlari</a>McRae as Hull's head coach next season.
    "He's a great thinker of the game who shows tremendous innovation."
    iceberg34