ie8 fix
madison

Hardware 2.0

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary

By | June 7, 2010, 1:53pm PDT

Summary: OK, so I’ve sat through the WWDC 2010 keynote speech, sifted through the tech specs and checked out the hot sheets to see what others are making of Apple’s latest creation. Time for a verdict …

OK, so I’ve sat through the WWDC 2010 keynote speech, sifted through the tech specs and checked out the hot sheets to see what others are making of Apple’s latest creation. Time for a verdict …

Evolutionary, not revolutionary.

Yeah.

Let’s begin by stating the obvious. The iPhone 4 is a nice bit of kit. Visually it’s different to the older iPhone lines, which in some way makes the older devices obsolete from a “cool” perspective. The iPhone 4 will redefine in people’s minds what the iPhone looks like. In one fell swoop, Apple knocked aside the older iPhones and created a whole new strata of “coolness” for those to whom such things matter have to aspire to (and pay up).

There are some neat new features in the iPhone 4 too. The improved camera and better screen are certainly nice, but a phone with a camera on it is nothing new, and a slightly better screen is nothing more than the result of the technology getting better. That said, the 326 pixels per inch is certainly an engineering feat and I’m sure will look stunning (until users slap a screen protector on it, or get it covered in fingerprints).

Poll

What do you think of the iPhone 4?

Then there are those metal bands on the case acting as antennas. Sure, it’s cool and geeky, but it’s performance that will matter. Unless Apple can put numbers to the actual signal improvements that this change creates, it’s little more than a gimmick.

The better battery is certainly much needed, but I’m sure that it won’t be enough for folks on the move. Battery life never is.

Then there’s the A4 processor. It’ll make the iPhone 4 faster, but just how much faster remains to be seen.

Then there’s the gyroscope, adding a new dimension to the iPhone’s ability to detect movement. This will see application within games, but probably not much beyond that.

HD video and editing … nice, but hardly ground breaking or essential.

Video calling, again is interesting, but nothing new, and on the iPhone 4 it’s currently crippled to WiFi only and that alone makes the feature feel unfinished and sort of rushed.

Oh, and it’s thinner …

More than anything I see the iPhone 4 as being a tool not only to invigorate those who haven’t yet bought an iPhone to do so, but to also re-invigorate those already on a 3G, 3G or even 3GS handset to step up to the plate and buy into the new iPhone.

I’ve no doubt that the iPhone 4 will be a huge success for Apple, with the company selling millions of them. I’m also pretty sure that, despite having been around for years, that the iPhone 4 will do to video calling what the original iPhone did to mobile browsing.

In all honesty, Apple didn’t need to do anything that revolutionary with the iPhone 4. The company is selling millions of iPhones (and iPads) as it is and this latest handset is little more than a stepping stone.

Put simply, it’s all Apple needs to maintain forward momentum.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

More from “Hardware 2.0”

Topics

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes is an internationally published technology author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology.

Disclosure

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

All opinions expressed on Hardware 2.0 are those of Adrian Kingsley-Hughes. Every effort is made to ensure that the information posted is accurate. If you have any comments, queries or corrections, please contact Adrian via the email link here. Any possible conflicts of interest will be posted below. [Updated: February 23, 2010] - Adrian Kingsley-Hughes has no business relationships, affiliations, investments, or other actual/potential conflicts of interest relating to the content posted so far on this blog.

Biography

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes

Adrian Kingsley-Hughes is an internationally published technology author who has devoted over a decade to helping users get the most from technology -- whether that be by learning to program, building a PC from a pile of parts, or helping them get the most from their new MP3 player or digital camera.

Adrian has authored/co-authored technical books on a variety of topics, ranging from programming to building and maintaining PCs. His most recent books include "Build the Ultimate Custom PC", "Beginning Programming" and "The PC Doctor's Fix It Yourself Guide". He has also written training manuals that have been used by a number of Fortune 500 companies.

Adrian also runs a popular blog under the name The PC Doctor, where he covers a range of computer-related topics -- from security to repairing and upgrading.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
55
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

The anti-Apple fanboys
rstexas 9th Jun 2010
Are even worse than the Apple fanboys. This isn't a football game. They are companies making phones. Stop acting like you're better because you're on the winning "team." The iPhone 4 looks fantastic, despite the snide remarks in this review (sight unseen). The EVO looks fantastic too. To each his own.
0 Votes
+ -
another 3 axis accelerometer a gyroscope to make it sound more impressive?
You must be traumatized by the amazing new iPhone, while, WP7 is still months away at the soonest, and we are still not sure about cut and paste.
I thought it an honest question, seeing what a Gyroscope is, and curious as to what a gyroscope would be doing in a cell phone, considering that even though it is a measurement device, it is more commonlly used as an alignment device.

Yet your outright fear of MS had you (once again) bring up MS as if that was some sort of answer to my question.

Your really are a simpleton, DB.
feature. Let me guess, you tried to find more using Bing, and got nothing. I will give you a clue: use Google!!

http://www.zdnet.com/blog/btl/wwdc-video-iphone-4s-new-gyroscope-feature/35580
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
Rama.NET Updated - 7th Jun 2010
@DonnieBoy
Oh my God, Microsoft is making you pee in the pants, isn't it DonnieBoy. You are worried that Microsoft would topple Google from its position like they did it for Lotus, Netscape... Come late to the party and steal the thunder. Yes, you would say why you wouldn't get scared blah, blah, blah, but your posts day by day are telling the fear, uncertainty you are under about Microsoft's products. Get a life. there is plenty of good air outside. Your choice of technology is your choice, but don't force it on our throats by making clueless comments about competition.
--Ram--
0 Votes
+ -
@DonnieBoy

By definition a gyroscope means the phone has moving, mechanical parts. I guess we will have to wait to see what the durability is on these as well as the shock tolerance (i.e. what happens if you drop the phone while it's turned on and the gyro is spinning). Other questions as well such as is the gyro spinning all the time or does it only spin up when needed? If it only spins up when needed, how long does that take and how responsive is that?.

Overall I'd have to say that moving parts would be a big negative unless you are doing somthing important that really needs it.
0 Votes
+ -
Exactly what I was thinking Kingsley. Well said!
0 Votes
+ -
Attention all iCult members
OS Reload Updated - 7th Jun 2010
Your membership in the iCool chapter of the cult will be suspended until full payment for an iPhone 4 is received.
0 Votes
+ -
Not just good for fanboys
Schoolboy Bob 8th Jun 2010
@OS Reload
I'm not much of an Apple fan (overpriced computers and they ruined the music industry - my phone was jailbroken day one) but it's been a good week for me. I get to replace my 3G earlier than expected (it should sell well on ebay) and I get the cheaper data plan I've been wanting (I've never used more than 200MB on mine). The iphone 4 should fix my two biggest issues - CPU slowness and battery. The new data plan is cheap enough to allow me to buy a couple more iPhones for my envious family members.
0 Votes
+ -
@Schoolboy Bob I get to replace my 3G earlier than expected (it should sell well on ebay) and I get the cheaper data plan I've been wanting (I've never used more than 200MB on mine).

Good luck with that, I'm guessing you're going to have heavy competiton. And your potential customers are those who don't want to or can't be cool enough to buy the 4.
0 Votes
+ -
Much bigger news would have been...
ubiquitous one 9th Jun 2010
...an iPhone 3 released for Verizon instead of the iPhone 4
Each of improvement taken separate might not look as it, but all together the iPhone is all-new, revolutionary product -- comparing to earlier iPhone.

Almost everything is changed -- from inside to outside, including UI (with iOS 4) and functionality
0 Votes
+ -
Your comments about battery life or the antennas make me think about people comments on announced battery life on iPad. They thought that it what Apple announced was a bit exaggerated. it turned out that it was even better that they announced.
0 Votes
+ -
Fair enough - evolutionary it is. But you make it sound like these features are not useful, or substandard or something!
There you're wrong! Show me another phone with the capabilities of the iPhone 4 that has the speed and battery life that it does.
This is a really nice package deal.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
rikasa Updated - 7th Jun 2010
@rossdav@...
Can you personally attest to the battery & speed improvements? Nope - no one can as yet. While this definitely is a solid evolutionary step for the iPhone, there are competing devices out there with compelling features not yet available in the iOS4... wireless AP functionality in the Nexus One + Froyo anyone? Regardless; the increase in competition this will bring to the market is all good news for all smart phone users.
0 Votes
+ -
I wouldn't tout that WAP feature too loudly
Snooki_smoosh_smoosh 9th Jun 2010
@rikasa... Sure it is great if you really need it, but then again your paying the carrier $60+ a month for it.
0 Votes
+ -
@rossdav@...

I'm gonna have to wait and see on your claims.
I use a 3GS currently and it's battery life leaves a lot be desired. Most days I have to dock by midafternoon or earlier.
With the new shape and extra internal space I would hope the battery life would improve.

FYI: this is normal. My wife's 3GS (lighter user but avid reader - kindle) is docked by early evening at the latest.
0 Votes
+ -
Side Question
matt@... 7th Jun 2010
I thinking maybe Apple has gotten off balance because it all iOS4 and Ipad (I still use a Mac and a Windows PC) and they haven't release an update to iLife and iWork this year! It not like they don't have the money it maybe lack of talent? Thoughts?
0 Votes
+ -
@matt@...do they need an update?
0 Votes
+ -
iLife/iWork is on a 2 year cycle.
Bruizer Updated - 7th Jun 2010
@matt@...

Has been for a few releases.
0 Votes
+ -
Minus the screen.

Okay, just kidding, but really, the world has moved on. The iPhone has never been about functionality (MMS anyone?) but about cool. Now, Android is cool: despite being clunky and ugly, it has plenty of apps and more functionality than any other phone out there. Still, I'm sure Apple will sell millions of these things, but they aren't going to be the envy of all anymore. That ship has sailed.

If only we could get Symbian's speed and battery life powering a WebOS handset with Apple's ecosystem, Google's latest toys for Android, and Blackberry Connect on some kick-butt hardware, we'd really have something! (Sorry Microsoft, not sure what you still bring to the table. I love Windows 7, though!)
0 Votes
+ -
@jdakula
Hm, I don't know about you, but my Nexus One isn't clunky or ugly. Maybe you're thinking of a different phone.

Yawn. Nothing revolutionary here. Video conferencing... hmm... let's see how often regular people use this.

Other than that, they barely kept pace with Android 2.1, let alone 2.2. Oh wait, the Evo already has the front facing camera, and it's already out. I guess iOS hasn't outpaced ANYTHING.
0 Votes
+ -
@Droid101
But the music and video player on Android can't beat iPhone or iPod anytime sooner.
--Ram--
0 Votes
+ -
@Droid101 write on!!!!!!
0 Votes
+ -
No, but the Droid Incredible...
Bruizer 7th Jun 2010
@Droid101

And EVO. Two ugliest phones released in the last 2 years. Nexus One is pretty clean. Moto Droid is clunky but OK.

As for "Video conferencing... hmm... let's see how often regular people use this." much more than Google Goggles, cell phone navigation and dozens of other mostly worthless Android Features.

With this release, iOS/iPhone 4 easily passed Froyo on integration, usability, polish, battery and many other features that are used daily by many people.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
Pete "athynz" Athens 7th Jun 2010
Taken separately the features are okay but together they make for a pretty nifty package IMHO. Does this mean I plan on rushing out and buying one or pre-ordering one?

Nope.

I like the new phone - the features and the looks are pretty sweet but I was expecting a bit more in the way of internal storage - where's the 64GB version? The iPod touch 3rd gen has 64GB, why couldn't they have squeezed in a 64GB drive or made it a bit thicker and put in more storage? Or better yet instead add SD card capability. When they do one or the other - or preferably BOTH - then I'll get the iPhone 4. Until then I'll stick with my tried and true trusty 3G (and wait to upgrade to iOS4 when the jailbreak is out for it).
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
Rama.NET Updated - 7th Jun 2010
@athynz
Exactly. I am constantly on the move and I carry my movies on iPhone. I am also expecting a larger internal storage. I would like to leave iPod Touch at home and take iPhone and WinMo with me. After having 6 movies on the phone, the iPhone becomes full (16 GB 3G). I am expecting 64 GB, so that I could take my movies and TV Serials with me to watch while flying. I think I have to live with 32GB version.
--Ram--
The new iPhone has four times the pixels and four times the contrast ratio of the previous phone, (shoot it has 78% of the pixels of the much larger iPad) and that's described as "SLIGHTLY better screen".... ??

happy
@Davewrite
For 3 years, the Apple zealots have been apologizing for the iPhone's woefully inadequate screen resolution saying it was perfect as is and scoffing at the idea that those of us with phones that have far better resolution are lying that there is any noticeable difference. Today, your leader stood up and called you all LIARS .

The iPhone screen resolution has SUCKED for 3 years now. Pathetic, horrible, terrible, lousy screen resolution and Jobs said as much today.

A BIG congratulations to Apple for the new iPhone. I agree with you Davewrite, this isn't a slightly better screen, this is a vastly improved screen over what was undeniably the iPhone's WORST hardware flaw.
@NonZealot

Stevie J is a marketing genius!

(looks like they changed the article to 'better screen' from 'slightly better'.)
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
Pete "athynz" Athens 8th Jun 2010
@NonZealot I'm not an Apple Zealot and I've never apologized for the iPhone's display... Nor do I recall anyone else doing such.

Jobs never said the displays on the older model iPhones sucked... that might be YOUR interpretation but he never said that or alluded to it. There is always room for improvement in any and all devices as the technology and innovation moves forward.
0 Votes
+ -
Nor do I recall anyone else doing such.

When I got my HTC Touch Diamond a year and a half ago and I told the Apple zealots how much better a higher resolution screen was, they screamed and frothed and howled about how on devices this small, you simply couldn't tell the difference between 480*320 (iPhone) and 640*480 (Diamond). Now watch, I'm sure I'll be berated for having a phone with such a lousy resolution. wink

Jobs never said the displays on the older model iPhones sucked..

Of course he did. By saying that you could never go back to a low resolution screen after seeing a high resolution screen (funny, that is exactly what I've been saying for a year and a half), he was essentially saying that after seeing iPhone 4, you couldn't stand to look at any of the previous iPhone screens, that's how bad they suck.

There is always room for improvement in any and all devices as the technology and innovation moves forward

On this I will agree. The sad thing for the iPhone is that it was behind when it came out. To wait 3 years to improve it is sad. To see the apologists apologize for it is downright embarrassing. But Jobs does this, it is part of his business plan to sell more iPhones. Leave out basic features that everyone else has so you can "innovate" them in the next release and force everyone to pay for an upgrade. You can't upgrade the resolution of the iPhone 3GS with a free software patch. Get your wallet out iPhone owners, time to upgrade!
0 Votes
+ -
what a load of bs
banned from zdnet 8th Jun 2010
@NonZealot
besides you no one ever said that the iphone screen sucked. to the contrary most people found it to be an awesome display. (remember outside of your little geeky bubble people don't care about dpi or screen resolution numbers).
0 Votes
+ -
@banned
NonZealot 8th Jun 2010
remember outside of your little geeky bubble people don't care about dpi or screen resolution numbers

Tell that to Jobs, he went on for quite a while talking about dpi and screen resolution. I agree with Jobs 100 percent when he says that once you've used a high resolution screen, you simply won't be able to stand the ugliness of a low resolution screen like the one in the iPhone V1-V3. BTW, I have a high resolution phone. You don't. happy
@NonZealot Its just a damn screen!
0 Votes
+ -
Notice that...
ubiquitous one 9th Jun 2010
...the more successful Apple becomes, the more hostile @NonZealot gets

lol... grin
0 Votes
+ -
what the iphone has:
hd video , sexy look , cool and usable UI
but that's it
0 Votes
+ -
@seanson71
Have you ever tried to take HD video on this small of a device without image stability control? chuckle.

What I am curious is did they improve the lens (hope so) and 5mp for HD is laughable! Maybe not for playback on an iphone but on a big monitor if flatscreen tv? Poor.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: iPhone 4 - Evolutionary, not revolutionary
Rama.NET Updated - 7th Jun 2010
One thing is definitely a killer in iPhone, the display resolution. Having said that I would definitely see the same in the competition in the coming months especially the ones from HTC.
--Ram--
0 Votes
+ -
@Rama.NET
I agree on competitor playing catch up but will the resolution do to all the existing apps?

Will the majority even be usable without updates?
0 Votes
+ -
Difficult decisions ahead
keebaud@... 8th Jun 2010
I currently own an iPhone 3G and am eagerly anticipating the opportunity to upgrade, but I am faced with some difficult choices.
Do I sell my phone whilst it still has some value, namely ?150 or wait until the new phone is released and risk losing a chunk of that cash value, bearing in mind that the 3G is now officially end-of-line?
Do I update the firmware to iOS4 or leave it as-is with the thought to selling it as a Jailbreakable phone on eBay? Certainly iOS4 isn't going to offer me much in the interim.
iPhone 4 is in my immediate future, but the decisions I have to make need to be made now. Any thoughts?
0 Votes
+ -
iPhone 3Gs is dropping to $99...
DevJonny 8th Jun 2010
@keebaud@...

...so you are unlikely to get 150 for for your 3G. IMO upgrade to iOS4 when you can, then sell it as cheap alternative to cover some of the cost of a iPhone 4.

Just a thought...
@DevJonny
Most of them are complete morons. Just look on this site for confirmation of that. happy
  • Flagged
This is a serious question and not a sarcastic comment.
I had heard you really aren't supposed to have your bare hands touch cell phone and other radio antennas when they are in use. The new iPhone basically uses the metal surrounding the phone as an antenna. Is it o.k.? Has new research come out saying it doesn't matter if you touch the antennas or not? Just curious.
0 Votes
+ -
Huh??
Scubajrr 8th Jun 2010
That wasn't a complaint. It was a valid question. Is there an actual Gyroscope (a Physical spinning mass) or a second, more accurate accelerometer. Both have advantages. Accelerometers use less power and are less succeptable to damage due to shock. Gyroscopes are more accurate but consume more power and are a "moving part", therefore more succeptable to wear and damage. You're the only one bring up MS, Cut and paste, or anything negative.
0 Votes
+ -
Big YAWN!
Gradius2 8th Jun 2010
Still too expensive.
0 Votes
+ -
Oh, that gimmicky Apple and their tricky marketing department claiming that a new processor, battery, os and display is something new. Its all just a result of the technology evolving on its own. Plus, that thing will look like cr4p once its all covered with chocolate finger prints. Now, back to my Commodore 64. Im still waiting on that technology to magically evolve.
0 Votes
+ -
Gyroscope
jhoward@... 8th Jun 2010
If the gyroscope plus accerleomters are sensitive enough, then there is a lot more utility in them than just for gamers. Inertial / dead-reckoning navigation through outages of GPS or cell-tower triangulation (inside buildings, etc.) becomes possible. All kinds of instrumentation becomes possible, for cars, private planes, motorcycles, bicycles, white-water rafting, sailing, etc. I'm sure others will come up with many more uses!
0 Votes
+ -
While the hardware/software discussions are raging, the one thing that I'm looking at is the package itself. I would be very happy to replace my old, cracked (several places in the back) 3G with a sleek stainless steel and aluminosilicate glass front and back. Supposed to be better chemically resistant...does that equate to fewer fingerprints? If they've treated the glass properly it should last a long time (defined as 2 years in cellphone-speak) without breaking. A question: is the introduction of aluminosilicate glass the reason that screen protective films were removed from the Apple Store? Hmmm...
0 Votes
+ -
The anti-Apple fanboys
rstexas 9th Jun 2010
Are even worse than the Apple fanboys. This isn't a football game. They are companies making phones. Stop acting like you're better because you're on the winning "team." The iPhone 4 looks fantastic, despite the snide remarks in this review (sight unseen). The EVO looks fantastic too. To each his own.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
Click Here
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix