Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

Summary: Facebook ads are notoriously and comically off-base. But even when they pique our interest, in today's multi-option environment they are likely to sell something for a competitor.

SHARE:
17

Facebook ads might work, but not how they think[Updated 9/22/10 with a clarification from Facebook re ad clicks.]

I've been reading the latest in The Wall Street Journal's excellent What They Know series (further post to come on that front), and pondering online advertising.  Companies are doing their darnedest to figure out who we are and what we want so they can serve us relevant ads that might relate to a real need (or strong wish), and lead to a purchase.  But the system is hopelessly broken, and seems to get more, not less, so as online advertisers learn ever more about us.

Case in point:  this strange photo of a woman applying a camouflage print to her eyelid was to the right of my Facebook profile the other day, along with text having something to do with "free samples."  The weirdness of it made me curious, so the ad had at least caught my interest.  In the world of Facebook and its advertisers, that means I probably clicked the ad to learn more, and maybe bought a product or took part in a promotion they were offering.

In the real world, that's not even close to what happened.  The last thing I want to do is give my information to some promotional outfit in exchange for "free" samples.  So of course I didn't click the ad.  (Does anyone?)  [Update 9/22:  Facebook wrote in to clarify it gives no personally identifiable information to advertisers without a user's knowledge, and that if I had clicked the ad, the advertiser wouldn't have gotten any personal information about me unless I had chosen to enter it on the advertiser's site.  My assumption though was that such information would have to be voluntarily provided by me at some point in order for an ad for "free samples" to have any payoff.] But I did want to know just what that thing was, it had me curious.  (Halloween is on the horizon, after all, and one could build a whole costume around that eye.)  So I Googled "camo eyeshadow."  The fourth result was the company responsible for the product featured in the Facebook ad.  I clicked through the search result, got the company's name, ColorOn, and the name of the product.

Not so bad for Facebook and its advertising clients, so far, even if not precisely how they expect things to work.  While I didn't click the ad next to my profile, seeing the ad still got me to the site where the product was for sale.  But did I buy it there?  Of course not.

As an Amazon Prime member, Amazon is always where I look if I'm in a buying mode.  So off I went to Amazon with the company and product names, and searched there.  The product was there, but as no Prime (free) shipping was available, any notion I might have been entertaining to buy that particular product evaporated.  Instead, I went back to being merely curious about this weird new world of stick-on/peel off eyeshadow, something I'd never seen before and found sort of academically intriguing.  An Amazon search for the manufacturer's name pulled up several related results -- including a similar product from ColorOn's competitor, Avon.  Since those were far cheaper on Amazon (shipping included), and since my curiosity was sufficient to justify the few dollars it would take to satisfy it, I bought the Avon product from Amazon.

Thus did a Facebook ad lead straight to a result no Facebook advertiser wants:  a completed sale for a competitor.  Maybe such an advertiser might take a philosophical "rising tide floats all boats" approach to my anecdote, but I'd be surprised.

Am I that unusual, or a pretty standard modern-day customer?  Do online ads affect your behavior at all, and if so, do you behave in ways the advertisers expect?  If you have anecdotes like mine or even more convoluted ones, I'd love to hear them.

[poll id="9"]

Topic: Social Enterprise

Denise Howell

About Denise Howell

Denise Howell is an appellate, intellectual property and technology lawyer who enjoys broad industry recognition for her expertise on the intersection of emerging technologies and law.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

17 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Well they've graduated to spam

    Now I'm getting "facebook" notifications for Viagris and other pills. Yes I know it's not Facebook, but I'm sure a lot won't.

    While I'm sure there are a small minority (probably posters here) that ignore ads in Facebook, most of humanity is in the "oooh pretty, I wnat to touch it" camp and will happily click away. They're probably the same audience that farmville is hoping to fleece.

    Never underestimate the stupidity of your audience.

    "Against stupidity the gods themselves contend in vain"
    tonymcs@...
  • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

    Adblock. Always.
    txscott
    • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

      @shollomon Agree, but think only very savvy users do this. Do any browsers come with adblocking on as the default? If advertising and targeting worked as advertisers hoped, a good number of people would actually want to see ads I suppose.
      Denise Howell
      • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

        @Denise Howell

        Wasn't that the theory behind iAd? I've never clicked on one of those, either.
        Real World
    • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

      @shollomon

      Completely agree. And if it somehow squeaks thorough Ad Block, I kill it at the firewall.
      Real World
  • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

    Not to be all elitist, but you and your audience (including me) probably have a higher Int score that most of Facebook's customers. While we might research a product as you did, most of their customers are blissful enough to simply click on the ad. They're the ones the ad is aimed at and I imagine the ad companies are quite successful with their hit rate.
    Caermon
  • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

    Adblock : Always !!!
    BUT : Without those ads , are we willing to pay to be on FB ?
    curiousgeorge1940
    • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

      @curiousgeorge13@... I don't even want to be on Facebook, I just do it to have those "connections" with friends, but no status or photo sharing. Just having their profile picture and a feature to message them is enough.
      ctxppc
      • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

        @ctxppc <a href="http://www.theessay.co.uk/essay-help.asp">Essay Help</a>
        <a href="http://www.thecoursework.co.uk/">Coursework Help</a>
        <a href="http://www.theassignments.co.uk/">Assignment Help</a>
        rainnwilson94
      • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

        @ctxppc <a href="http://www.thedissertation.co.uk/">Dissertation Help</a>
        <a href="http://www.theonlinethesis.co.uk/">Thesis Help</a>
        rainnwilson94
  • RE: Facebook ads might work, but not how they think

    expover microsoft internet working at sites with the
    - and <a href="http://www.balimsohbet.com" title="sohbet odalari" target="_blank">sohbet odalari</a> - and <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="Mynet" target="_blank">mynet</a> - <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="Mynet sohbet" target="_blank">mynet sohbet</a> -
    turkey the microsoft is a good format is also <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="face" target="_blank">face</a> -
    - <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp" target="_blank">metin2 pvp</a> -
    operiation <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com/">facebok</a> - <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/">twitter</a>
    Behaviour of desdek bigger role in these sites <a href="http://www.sohbetix.net/">sohbet</a> Microsoft A network connection to the game s dada gubve unwanted surprises
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverlar" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverlar</a> -
    <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="facesohbet" target="_blank">facesohbet</a> -
    and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/yonja-sohbet" title="yonja" target="_blank">yonja</a> - and <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com" title="facebok" target="_blank">facebok</a> -<a href="http://www.sexsohbeti.org" title="sex sohbet" target="_blank">sex sohbet</a> - <a href="http://www.sexmuhabbet.net" title="sex hikayeleri" target="_blank">sex hikayeleri</a> - and- and <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="facebook" target="_blank">facebook</a> - and <a href="http://www.facesohbet.net" title="fesbuk" target="_blank">fesbuk</a> - and <a href="http://www.balimsohbet.com" title="sohbet" target="_blank">sohbet</a> - and <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="cet" target="_blank">cet</a> - - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/indir" title="metin2 indir" target="_blank">metin2 indir</a> - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/resimleri" title="metin2 resimleri" target="_blank">metin2 resimleri</a> - and <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/metin2-kaydol" title="metin2 kaydol" target="_blank">metin2 kaydol</a> - ang <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org/" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a> -

    <a href="http://www.faceboksohbet.com/tag/fesbok-giris" title="fesbok giris" target="_blank">fesbok giris</a>
    room turkey
    twitter sohbet portallari <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/netlog/" title="netlog" target="_blank">netlog</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/twitter-turkce/" title="twitter turkce" target="_blank">twitter t?rkce</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/twitter-giris/" title="twitter giris" target="_blank">twitter giris</a> and <a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/" title="twitter kaydol" target="_blank">twitter kaydol</a>
    <a href="http://facesohbet.net/modules/news/index.php?storytopic=41-fesbuk-videolar" title="fesbuk" target="_blank">fesbuk</a>

    turkiye mt2, metin2 online games serverlar
    and and and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="mt2 pvp server" target="_blank">mt2 pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp server" target="_blank">metin2 pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="pvp server" target="_blank">pvp server</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverlar" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverlar</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverler" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverler</a> and
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="pvp serverler" target="_blank">pvp serverler</a> and <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="pvp serverlar" target="_blank">pvp serverlar</a>



    <a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet odasi" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet odasi</a><a href="http://www.istanbulsohbetodasi.net" title="istanbul sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">istanbul sohbet odalar?</a>


    <a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet" target="_blank">ankara sohbet</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">ankara sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">ankara sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.ankarasohbetodalari.org" title="ankara sohbet odas?" target="_blank">ankara sohbet odas?</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet" target="_blank">izmir sohbet</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">izmir sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet sitesi" target="_blank">izmir sohbet sitesi</a><a href="http://www.izmirsohbetodalari.org" title="izmir sohbet chat" target="_blank">izmir sohbet chat</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet" target="_blank">bursa sohbet</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet odalar?" target="_blank">bursa sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet siteleri" target="_blank">bursa sohbet siteleri</a><a href="http://www.bursasohbetodalari.com" title="bursa sohbet odasi" target="_blank">bursa sohbet odasi</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet odalari" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet odalar?</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet siteleri" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet siteleri</a><a href="http://www.seviyelisohbetodalari.com" title="seviyeli sohbet kanallar?" target="_blank">seviyeli sohbet kanalalr?</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/yonja-sohbet" title="yonja" target="_blank">yonja</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/netlog/" title="netlog" target="_blank">netlog</a><a href="http://www.twittersohbet.com/" title="twitter" target="_blank">twitter</a><a href="http://www.faceara.com" title="face" target="_blank">face</a><a href="http://www.faceara.com" title="facebook" target="_blank">facebook</a><a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp, metin2 pvp server, mt2 server," target="_blank">pvp</a>


    Bunu mu demek istediniz? Cok guzel bir oyun be?eni ile oynuyorum ama bunun metin2
    Metin veya web sitesi adresi yaz?n ya da bir dok?man? ?evirin.
    ?ptal
    Dinleyin
    Fonetik olarak okuyun
    T?rk?e dilinden ?ngilizce diline ?eviri
    I play a game with very nice, but it <a href="http://www.metin2oyunu.org" title="metin2" target="_blank">metin2</a>
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserver.net" title="metin2 pvp" target="_blank">metin2 pvp</a>
    <a href="http://www.metin2pvpserverlar.com" title="metin2 pvp serverler" target="_blank">metin2 pvp serverler</a>

    and install servers by lara s depending on the tour game bilrisiniz

    <a href="http://www.tuztanem.com" title="tuztanem" target="_blank">tuztanem</a>
    <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="manolyam" target="_blank">manolyam</a>
    <a href="http://www.manolyam.net" title="manolya" target="_blank">manolya</a>
    zafer12
  • Great job

    Took a lot of time to read but I really found this very interesting and informative, thank you buddy for sharing.

    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/" title="Logo Design">Logo Design</a><br/>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/" title="Custom Logo Design">Custom Logo Design</a><br/>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/stationary-design-services/" title="Stationary Design Services">Stationary Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/website-design-services/" title="Website Design Services">Website Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/banner-design-services/" title="Banner Design Services">Banner Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/brochure-design-services/" title="Brochure Design Services">Brochure Design Services</a>
    Brenda345
  • brenda

    Took a lot of time to read but I really found this very interesting and informative, thank you buddy for sharing.


    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/" title="Custom Logo Design">Custom Logo Design</a><br/>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/stationary-design-services/" title="Stationary Design Services">Stationary Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/website-design-services/" title="Website Design Services">Website Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/banner-design-services/" title="Banner Design Services">Banner Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/brochure-design-services/" title="Brochure Design Services">Brochure Design Services</a>
    Brenda345
  • Great work

    Took a lot of time to read but I really found this very interesting and informative, thank you buddy for sharing.

    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/stationary-design-services/" title="Stationary Design Services">Stationary Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/website-design-services/" title="Website Design Services">Website Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/banner-design-services/" title="Banner Design Services">Banner Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/brochure-design-services/" title="Brochure Design Services">Brochure Design Services</a>
    <a href="http://www.logovilla.com/" title="Cheap Logo Design">Cheap Logo Design</a><br/>
    jaycutler
  • Good One

    Took a lot of time to get on it, but I really found this very interesting and informative, thank you buddy for sharing.

    [url=http://www.bestresearchpaper.co.uk]buy research papers[/url]
    mathewstuart
  • Difficult to get rid off.

    Its really difficult to get rid of itbut a little research is what we need I have gone through the same situations but still dont know how to tackle with the same with finding the solution.
    Michelle Alter
  • hope

    hope we find it someday but
    research is what we need
    Michelle Alter