Students try to bring down Facebook

Students try to bring down Facebook

Summary: A little off topic I'll admit, but it still contains "students" and "technology", which to me justifies this post. I'm not one to make harsh and unsubstantiated comments about something or someone, but this calls for an exception.


facebook0.pngA little off topic I'll admit, but it still contains "students" and "technology", which to me justifies this post. I'm not one to make harsh and unsubstantiated comments about something or someone, but this calls for an exception.

Facebook is a difficult one to judge in terms of privacy; most people see the word “privacy” and presume it’s about keeping yourself to yourself. In the computing world, it means “how much you are giving away about you”. The point of Facebook is to share information and details about yourself, connect with those you already know and sometimes with those you don’t. There has long been heated debate about privacy with social networking websites; MySpace, Facebook, Bebo, Live Spaces etc. This time, smartarse Canadian idiots law students decided to take on one of the biggest websites in the United States, probably to try and further their impending careers, and they are going to fail miserably no doubt. Spenser who wrote on the Neowin forums seems to agree:

"They're law students and now they think they can do whatever they want. It's like they think that these privacy concerns haven't been looked at or brought up by any real lawyers yet."

The BBC reported that the basis of the complaint “states that Facebook collects sensitive information about its users and shares it without their permission.” Again, the UK perspective but it’s one that I know well. Under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000, this allows only the UK intelligence services (MI5, SIS, GCHQ) to intercept and monitor, collect and disseminate personal details and sensitive information, whether it is used in a court of law or not. A similar act(s) apply for the United States, but it only allows certain national security based Government departments to collect information on you.

Now, last time I checked, there address wasn't*, so they are well and truly out of the Government's reach. But have you any idea what risks are involved in doing these things if you're a private company? There may only be 300 employees at Facebook, but I can guarantee that at least one of them will realise that something isn't right and get in touch with the relevant authorities if this was the case, but as they haven't, it leads me to believe that there is no misconduct on the part of Facebook.

Missing out parts of a privacy policy or withholding information about the data being collected is a criminal offence in most places in the world. An organisation as small but having an impact so large such as Facebook isn't likely to screw around with these technicalities and start missing bits out, because if it did then they'd be facing huge fines, lack of customer support and faith in the service and potential (and as a result, likely) bankruptcy.

I looked over the privacy policy with a couple of IT experts and bloggers and came to a sound conclusion. Facebook uses contextual advertising which picks out words from a web page and displays an advertisement in relation to that. If you were on a recipe website, you may well get recipe or ingredients advertisements being displayed. Even this website has a whole load of technology related advertisements using contextual advertising; it benefits the publisher and the advertising companies to display relevant content dependant on the content you are viewing. The Facebook privacy policy clearly states:

"Facebook may use information in your profile without identifying you as an individual to third parties. We do this for purposes such as aggregating how many people in a network like a band or movie and personalizing advertisements and promotions so that we can provide you Facebook. We believe this benefits you.

And it can do! Some people don't mind advertisements, and after all, this is how most of the Internet stays free. If Facebook didn't have advertisements on it, you'd have to pay an arm and a leg for the services and web sites you use. Just look at how Windows Live survives - it's the only real way of doing it without getting the people who use the service to pay for it.

"You can know more about the world around you and, where there are advertisements, they're more likely to be interesting to you. For example, if you put a favorite movie in your profile, we might serve you an advertisement highlighting a screening of a similar one in your town. But we don't tell the movie company who you are."

Just one more point on this privacy policy which should be noted:

"We share your information with third parties only in limited circumstances where we believe such sharing is 1) reasonably necessary to offer the service, 2) legally required or, 3) permitted by you."

If anything, you should be more concerned about the applications which are written for Facebook, as they seem to jeopardise your privacy on a whole new level. With a few clicks of the button, you can easily change your privacy settings; some argue this should be shown first before you use the service, and maybe so. But whenever you give out information on the Internet, even through a secure channel when buying something, you still run the risk of human error taking over and causing a slip up with your data. If you don't want to use the service for whatever reason, just stop using it.

facebook11.pngOn a similar but separate note, even though Facebook is designed to share information about yourself, content which you have written to "give" to others, you have a huge variety of options to conceal which information is shown and hidden, and to who. I’ve been looking through my Facebook privacy settings, and I’ve never seen such a comprehensive and intelligent way of altering your settings to restrict information reaching a set of people, an entire network or even individual people.

With a few clicks of my mouse, I can alter even the more complicated privacy settings. I may want to show a photo gallery of me and my friends pulling pranks around campus, getting sloshed off our faces and getting up to general mischief - however I may not particularly want my parents finding out. I can open up my photo gallery to everyone on my friends list, or limit it to "friends and network" - so anyone on the Kent Uni. network can see my photos, but say my parents' cannot be part of (as they don't have a network specific email address to authenticate them) thus cannot see their son getting up to no good; nothing but a good thing considering they're paying around £8,000 ($16,000) a year for me to be here.

facebook2.pngI can hide my email addresses, my friends list, my work information, my education details; I can select who see's what on my profile, whether it be in the same network, a friend of a friend, even my own friends or individual contacts. It's all very easy to understand as well - a little padlock appears when something is being locked out to someone or something, enabling the user to easily see what is being protected and who from.

The ability to share and hide data is immensely easy to do, simple to understand and secure. From a brief look at some of the other social networking websites, in my expert opinion it is far more wide-ranging when it comes to users being in control of their own data.

facebook51.pngI set out on this blog to show the view of technology in students. It seems the high majority of students and younger people love Facebook for the inter-connecting and communication features it has. However a small minority want to use it as a suspect in a court of law. Students of this planet, gather round as I tell you something. If you want to change the world, start off small and have a half-decent argument first, before trying to take on the biggest and the best

I finish one word which sums all this up perfectly – “lawyers...”.

Topics: Social Enterprise, Browser, Software Development

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.


Log in or register to join the discussion
  • Have you herd of Corporatism

    This is the correct form of modern FASIM and so called ?social web sights? such as Facebook are promoting this type of environment.

    Facebook was created for the express purpose of collecting ones date and then selling it to corporations so that they may both target market products to people more effectively whether desired or not and second to effetely price discriminate to those willing to pay a premium for a product. There is some value in sharing info/photos with your family & friends and so mail was developed for that purpose which acquired an electronic form through email. Although email is a more efficient means of sharing info most people are aware not as secure a method as traditional mail.

    The question now becomes are people really aware of the true nature of these types of ?social web sights? and the long term implications to our society when personal information no longer remains personal? Effetely that may mean the choice to share no longer exists or to a great extent may become marginalized.

    If we want to maintain are freedom of choices which are forefathers died for and layers codified so that tyrants cannot find easy ways to avoid abiding by them, let us be aware of the true cost to our ?social freedoms,? that is to our desire to opt in if we desire by protecting that option. Therefore the only way to due so is to hold accountable corporations such as Facebook with deceptively take that option away.

    Thank God for lawyers without them Habeas corpus would be relegated to that ?dame piece of paper? Bush and his administration has refereed to as.
    • R.O.F.L, you must have a trial lawyer in the family

      R.O.F.L, you must have a trial lawyer in the family
      SO.CAL Guy
  • Canadian Privacy Law

    It seems to escape you that the case will be tried in CANADA, not in the UK or the US. You seem to be quite unaware of canadian privacy laws, and you calling them idiots without knowing about this law is pretty uncalled for. These laws apply to corporations that operate in Canada, not only to governemental institutions.

    Whether or not Privacy can be expected from this american company (which, btw, is not small, but owned by a large american corporation), and if shrink-wrap contracts are legal, will have to be decided by the courts. I am not qualified to make that determination. However, I think they might have a case.
  • RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

    I thought everybody had spell check now days...
    • RE: RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

      Did I misspell something in the post? I write in UK English rather than US English... partly because I'm British... :-)
      • Crazy Brits....

        act like they invented the English language or something. :D

        Edit: I still haven't noticed a mis-spelling, or even a "British spelling" of a word in the article, so perhaps the spelling check comment refers to post #1?
        • RE: Crazy Brits....

          I hope so - I've had enough of spelling mistake criticism... seems to be the highlight of my first week here. I'm doing the best I can :-)
          • Spelling's Fine

            I noticed the following, though...

            [i]Now, last time I checked, [b]there[/b] address wasn?t*, so they are well and truly out of the Government?s reach.[/i]

            It should say [b]their[/b], instead. It's a common mistake, though, and the article was definitely written better than much of the feedback that you'll receive, I'm sure.
  • RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

    Ads are annoying & i hate how on facebook they say one my friends or myself recommended someone check out something when infact we didnt recommend anything. Ya its nice I guess that the ads are more geared toward whats on my page or some other users page but they are still annoying. No matter what ad they put on a page im on I just try to ignore them best of my ablity and NEVER click on them. Plus u never know if its a bad link that contains a tracker or bug or something to it that could infect your pc. I understand companies need to make money but still. As far as privacy is concerned I think Facebook isnt doing enough to ptotect our privacy. I dont mind my fav book being told or fav band but when facebook starts letting companies and others see my photo email addy and other personal identifiable info thats crap esp letting apps on facebook have our contact info. in order for us to use the app and add it. I dont need to be spammed by the apps. I should be to use the app and add it without it having to have my contact info. And one thing i hate about facebook besides whats mentioned in article and comment is there limit on how many msgs, invites and friends requests. Lol okay ive ranted/vented and rambled on enough.
  • RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

    Wow, as a Canadian and UofT Alum, I'm somewhat embarrassed. I don't recall anyone from Facebook forcing me to sign up nor pressuring me to give up any information. In fact, I'm pretty sure that I was the one who voluntarily typed and provided my <personal> information.

    Anyone who goes on the internet believing that 'privacy' really exists is beyond naive. Technology today tracks and records IP addresses and activity, and <GASP!> this information is used for the sake of making an almighty dollar. Welcome to the real world. I'd lean towards calling them donkeys but am afraid I'll end up with some defamatory lawsuit on my hands from anti-Facebook UofT law students. What's next? Targeting Starbucks for their menacing coffee cards that can track how many grande lattes I had last month?? Come'on...
  • RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

    The best way to stay anonym on the internet is not using it. But this is not a real solution is it.
    So the second option is, to lie about who you are. And only use our boss computer to update our page.

    This story is about the back side information that is used. What the most people don?t care about is that not only your friends are looking at the page but also colleges and or (future) employer.

    so watch out and think about what info you leave on the web.
    • RE: Students try to bring down Facebook

      Not only that, but they can also keep track of your potential illegal activities...,1000000189,39389297,00.htm

      Makes for an interesting read ;)