The pros and cons of social media classrooms

The pros and cons of social media classrooms

Summary: How social media platforms can be used as a learning tool - and what some of the advantages and disadvantages are.

SHARE:

The debate surrounding social media as a learning tool is unlikely to abate any time soon. Is it just a distraction, or do the interactive educational tools available outweigh any disadvantages?

Social media platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter, are becoming steadily more integrated within a variety of apps targeted at learning. Real-time news feeds and instant accessibility make them a tool that can be used quickly and efficiently -- but due to its changeable nature, it can be difficult for school systems to keep up and compensate.

What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of using social media in the classroom?

The pros of social media as a learning tool.

1.) It is a familiar tool.

Most of your students are on social networking platforms, and these services are already tools that students are generally comfortable with -- and they can probably show you a thing or two in return.

2.) Improve your own knowledge and skills as an educator.

By learning how to use these platforms as a teacher, you are making yourself more aware of issues surrounding students today. If a student tells you a classmate is harassing them over Twitter -- doing something called 'tweeting', how can you investigate the situation unless you know how to search profiles and send messages yourself?

3.) Resource availability.

From current news feeds, following public figures, learning a new language or improving software skills, there is an endless range of free resources available through social media -- both linked and hosted. If you are looking for a debate, a video or commentary based on a recent news report, Facebook and Twitter's search functions make them a valuable and free set of tools.

4.) Improvement of research skills.

Being able to find information online is a skill that is now important in the workplace -- and one that can be taught through lessons designed around social media platforms.

5.) The improvement of communication.

If conducted within a controlled environment, then social media can be a way for students and teachers to communicate effectively. This could include sending out reminders, posting homework notes and organizing projects or events such as revision classes.

6.) Relevant, real-life learning.

Teaching students how to use social media in order to improve their job prospects can be extremely valuable. How do you find a job through Twitter? Who do you follow? Why do I need a LinkedIn profile?

7.) The promotion of digital citizenship.

Students have to learn about how to conduct themselves appropriately online. Not only do they have to face the consequences if they behave in ways that are considered cyberbulling, but it is also necessary for them to understand privacy policies and the transfer of data online. By using online platforms, these lessons can be integrated within a more traditional school curriculum.

8.) Engaging your students.

Gen-Y and younger generations are stereotypically portrayed as being glued to their gadgets, and are known for using such devices for social networking, games and entertainment purposes. Use this to your advantage.

9.) The ability to share learning material.

Social media sites including Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest are full of user-generated content, links and shared items. This can be used to your classes' advantage. Why not create a Facebook group dedicated to your class, or set a task to research something across these networks?

10.) The potential to appeal to different learning styles.

Whether a learner naturally prefers kinetic, audio or visual learning, the varied types of media and information found on sites such as Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn can appeal to a wide range of learner styles.

11.) Ease of access.

Social networking requires no expensive equipment or modern upgrades -- all you need is a computer or mobile device with an Internet connection.

12.) Assisting shy students.

There are some students that find social interaction or contribution difficult -- and engaging students through an online project can make this easier for them.

The cons of social media as a learning tool.

1.) The gimmick factor.

Unless the use of sites such as Facebook and Twitter are incorporated into a class plan in order to contribute towards an objective lesson aim, then it could become nothing more than a waste of time.

2.) Distractions.

Unless teachers properly supervise their students -- and maintain control if the novelty of YouTube makes them too excited -- it can be difficult to follow through with a lesson based on Internet research.

3.) The risk of cyberbullying.

Cyberbullying is rampant on social networks, and it is something teachers need to be aware of. Social media projects may not be confined to a classroom -- and if this is the case, teachers (and potentially parents) need to monitor student activity for any signs of bullying.

4.) Limiting face-to-face communication.

If a balance is not maintained, then too much technological input can have a detrimental effect on social skills that children need to learn.

5.) The need for schools to research, understand and implement.

Educational establishments are slowly making their presence known on social media for advertising and information-based purposes. However, it requires a good level of technical understanding to use and maintain social media effectively.

6.) Continual social media change.

There are constant changes to platforms themselves and their security settings -- of which schools and teachers must keep up to date with and act accordingly.

7.) The need to manage multiple sites and keep updated.

If schools decide to make use of these platforms, pages and profiles should be updated in order to prevent them becoming stagnant.

8.) The possibility of malware infections or phishing scams.

Social networks are now a breeding ground for scam artists to lure both children and adults to exchange personal information or in order to gain access to a computer network. Educational establishments need to be aware of this risk and monitor their usage accordingly.

9.) The need to filter and plan.

Schools have a duty of care to their students, and as such, the use of social media platforms has to be planned and executed appropriately in order to protect children from inappropriate communication, images or video. Several options are available, such as YouTube for Schools.

10.) Inappropriate content sharing or exposure.

It is important for children in school to be protected from inappropriate content; but it is also necessary for teachers to monitor what they are sharing between themselves. It is not only a matter of duty to students -- but protecting yourself as the teacher responsible for them.

11.) Controlling device use in class.

Teachers have to grow eyes in the back of their heads -- and when mobile devices are used in class, the need for continual monitoring and regulation increases.

12.) Exposing the 'haves' and 'have nots'.

Once you introduce social media use in to a classroom, then unless the school has the facilities to supply each student, it is sometimes the case that students are asked to bring their own device. This in turn can highlight divides between students who can afford certain devices, and those that cannot.

Image credit: Brad Flickinger

Related:

Topics: Browser, Banking, CXO, Data Centers, Enterprise Software, Software, Software Development, Social Enterprise

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily email newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Talkback

4 comments
Log in or register to join the discussion
  • there's also the notion of trust in social media

    Seriously, one of the overlook topic and idea is that somehow, we are supposed to trust these social medias. I'm sorry but they dont have the well being of their users in mind. But rather, they only care about the well being of their corporation only. period. all of these companies are out to mine, mine, and mine their user's data - both private and public to their gains.

    And really, we, as a society, need to look at this overhyped-overshared mindset that everyone has right now regarding social network. I'm sorry, I dont want to know about every single moment of your live. Nor do I want you to know every single moment of MY life either. And that certain goes with the corporation behind these social networks.
    JJ_z
  • Another example of the spoiled Western students...

    More technology does not equate to more learning without discipline and work ethics. Chinese and Indian students have far less technology in their classrooms but yet they can still score better than the US students?
    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-12-07/teens-in-u-s-rank-25th-on-math-test-trail-in-science-reading.html
    And social media will help US students learn when laptops, calculators, smart boards, etc. are not enough, while the Chinese and Indian students are happy with chalkboards and old textbooks?
    ArquitectoInstruccional
  • equating apples and oranges

    I doubt that. "Western" is a big place. Maybe what is being said is a comparison of "American" or "Canadian" to Indian and Chinese. First, education is a REQUIREMENT in Canada and the USA. It is illegal to NOT send a kid to primary school. Show me how you would enforce that in China and India. I have been to the latter place, where nine-year-olds make a living by sitting all day on a concrete floor, carving statues out of soapstone to sell to tourists. Factor these into your statistics, then tell me how much better the Chinese kids who grow rice and the Indian kids who carve statues, do in school.

    I agree that in India their middle-income bracket is about the same size as the entire US population. So let's do the same thing in the US, and conveniently ignore the lower economic strata, then look at the scholastic performance of the remaining segment. I suspect that the numbers will look a lot better.
    tavent
  • Pro Social Media in Classrooms!

    Social Media goes beyond facebook/twitter. It not only allows students to start networking for their future, but have access to a variety of information for their education. I am a huge supporter and encourager of social media in the classroom. Not only has it helped me through my high school and college career, but my social life. I think students entering the workforce to can not only search for job openings but more in depth information regarding that job and company. How else can you find out certain details that one may never know with out social media? Check out the latest @ http://gsearchmarketing.com/our-story/social-media-education-for-teachers/
    bmarshall3