ie8 fix
madison

The Mobile Gadgeteer

Matthew Miller & Joel Evans

Review: 5 reasons the new Nook is the best dedicated ebook reader

By | July 1, 2011, 4:07am PDT

Summary: The iPad is a decent ebook reading device, but you just can’t beat a dedicated eInk device for the most immersive ebook experience and the all-new Nook is THE one to beat.

95% of my reading is now done on ebook readers and after using them for several years, starting with the Sony Reader, then a couple of Kindles, and a couple of Nooks, I have now found the ultimate ebook reader in the new Barnes & Noble Nook. I bought my Nook 1st Edition in 2009 and still use it every now and then. Back in early 2009 I wrote why ebooks were best for reading and now a couple years later after trying to read on the iPad, big screen smartphones, and other connected devices I have decided that nothing can beat a dedicated ebook device with eInk and limited connectivity for the near-book experience.

I read ebooks on my iPad and HTC Flyer, but notifications, the urge to check email or browse the web, and other distractions take away from the book experience. My eyes are not really bothered by color displays, but after reading ebooks on my new Nook the past couple of weeks there really is nothing that can beat eInk for reading.

In my opinion, the all-new Nook, also referred to as the Simple Touch Reader, offers the BEST ebook experience through the same size screen as others, the best eInk technology, an amazingly long battery life, support for standard ebook formats, access to a bookstore with over 2 million titles, small form factor without a keyboard or other unnecessary extras, functional touch screen, and software optimized for the reading experience. It is available for a very reasonable $139 and if you are an ebook fan then this is THE ebook reader to purchase.

I also took a few product photos that you can find in my image gallery where I compare the new Nook with the 1st Edition Nook. I also captured a video below of the Nook in action and included my top 5 reasons why I think it is the best current dedicated ebook reader.


Image Gallery: A walk around the new Barnes & Noble Nook ebook reader device and the screens available. Image Gallery: Old and new Nooks width= Image Gallery: Changing button functions

5 reasons the all-new Nook is the best ebook reader

Each of us has our own personal preferences and I can’t tell you that any device is the very best for all of us. However, I sincerely believe there are several reasons that the all-new Nook is the best and offer the following 5 reasons for you to consider.

Reason #1: Form factor

Before this current Nook, my favorite ebook reader, in terms of form factor, was the Sony Reader 505. While the Kindle has a great ecosystem and has many strengths, I rarely ever used the QWERTY keyboard and found that having a hardware one that was always present and taking up valuable real estate was a major waste of space. The original Nook that I still own has a color touchscreen band at the bottom so there are reasons for using it, but it was a bit clunky and I often could be found tapping on the eInk display rather than the color band.

The all-new Nook has the same display size as the other ebook readers at 6 inches, yet there is nothing else to the device but a small bezel around the display so you can hold it in your hand. It seems a bit chunky, but is the same width as the first generation Nook and the shortness of it makes it seem a bit wide.

The Nook is also covered on the front bezel and complete back with soft touch material so it is easy to hold and presents you with a surface that is not slippery. It also only weighs 7.48 ounces and compared to the newest Kindle (8.5 ounces), Kobo Reader (7.8 ounces), and Nook Color (15.8 ounces) it is the lightest currently available.

Reason #2: Touchscreen interface

I tried touchscreen Sony Reader devices in the past and Sony did get better every generation so that the latest PRS-650 Touch Edition used the same infrared technology that we see on the Nook. However, their previous strategy was to place a touchscreen layer on top of the eInk display and thus they were always taking something away from the eInk reading experience. I believe that the eInk display is one of the most important aspects of device because without a crystal clear display you won’t enjoy your reading experience. The upcoming Kobo Touch also offers an infrared touchscreen display so that your finger position is picked up by IR sensors embedded around the sides of the Nook bezel.

When I heard it was based on infrared I thought I would see lots of deadspots and lag, but so far I am amazed by the responsiveness of the display and if I didn’t know that it was powered by IR I would swear that the actual display had a touchscreen layer on top of it.

The touchscreen user interface feels very natural and swiping or tapping on the display to turn pages is intuitive. The pop-up QWERTY keyboard works well too.

Reason #3: eInk display

The all-new Nook uses the latest Pearl eInk technology and the 6-inch 800×600 display looks fantastic. The contrast and clarity is amazing and I am able to even easily read books in low light and direct sunlight conditions.

Barnes & Noble has a new functionality, called Fast Page, where page turns are near instantaneous and you will only see page refreshes every 6 pages. The page turns are so fast that reading is completely unencumbered on the new Nook.

Reason #4: Battery life

I purchased my new Nook a month ago and charged it as soon as it arrived, but haven’t put it on a charger since then and still have 25% battery life left. I have finished half of Tom Clancy’s Dead or Alive and spent time creating notes, adding bookmarks, putting in highlights, and browsing the store. I did have WiFi off for the majority of the time, since you only need it for shopping or for delivery of your daily newspaper selection.

Barnes & Noble advertises that you can go 2 months with WiFi off and 3 weeks with WiFi on. It is so refreshing to have an ebook reader where I never have to even think about charging the battery and can just focus on reading books.

Reason #5: Content

There are over 2 million titles in the Barnes & Noble ebookstore, compared to the 950,000 titles in the Amazon ebookstore. In addition, you can transfer over DRM and non-DRM EPUB files through a USB connection or Adobe Digital Editions. This functionality let me bring over all of the books in my Sony Reader library and also check out ebooks from my local public library.

The original Nook let ebook readers who had books from Peanut Press read them on the device, but PDB formats are no longer supported. For those enthusiasts who still own these books I am sure they can figure out how to use Calibre to get these titles on their new device too.

Let’s check out the specs and functionality details »

Topics

Matthew Miller is an avid mobile device enthusiast who works during the day as a professional naval architect in Seattle.

Disclosure

Matthew Miller

Matthew is a professional naval architect by day and a mobile gadget freak at all other times. He purchases most of his devices and then sells them on eBay or Craigslist to buy more. Many other devices are sent for review on a 30-day loaner basis and then returned to the carrier or manufacturer. If any are provided as “keeper” or “long term loaner units” this will be clearly disclosed in his reviews.

Biography

Matthew Miller

Matthew Miller is an avid mobile device enthusiast who works during the day as a professional naval architect in Seattle. He is one of three hosts on the MobileTechRoundup podcast and runs the Nokia Experts website. Matthew started using mobile devices in 1997 with a US Robotics Pilot 1000 and has owned over 90 different devices running Palm, Linux, Symbian, Newton, BlackBerry, Mac OS X (iPhone), Google Android, and Windows Mobile operating systems. His current collection includes a Nokia N85, Nokia E71, Nokia 5800, Nokia N810, Apple iPhone, HTC Advantage, T-Mobile G1, Palm Treo Pro, HTC Fuze, MSI Wind, MacBook Pro, and many more, along with tons of accessories and classic devices like the Apple Newton MessagePad 2100 and Sony CLIE UX50. Matthew co-authored Master Visually Windows Mobile 2003, was a member of the Nokia Nseries Blogger relations program, and is a member of the invite-only Microsoft Mobius mobile device evangelist group. He can be found on various discussion forums under the user name of "palmsolo".

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
89
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

re: blakepedersen
blakepedersen 29th Dec
Scarborough Ontario Canada forms the eastern part of the city of Toronto, Canada. It was named for it's resemblance to the white cliffs in England. http://www.scarboroughhouses.ca/

Scrapbooking is known to be a popular hobby that is growing fast today. It is a mixture of photos, memorabilia and stories created in a scrapbook style album. http://www.scrapbookingideas.ca/

Imagine being able to actually see all the features of a potential house you wish to buy without dealing with the headaches of talking to a realtor or even traveling to the house to walk through it. http://www.seehouses.ca/
Great review Matt. As a frequent flyer and avid reader I have owned a both of the first two Kindles and have Kindle software on both my smartphones, my iPad and the HTC Flyer. I've not gone back to a dedicated e-reader for over a year, but your review has me reconsidering. A question, how does a dedicated e-reader interfere with the evolution of e-books into multimedia experiences? I really enjoy the embedded videos and expandable pics/graphs in the Wall Street Journal on iPad and Android.
@lichmd The problem of freezing on THE NEW KOOK; I just got done talking to a supervisor today with B&N named Audrey about the problem with THE NEW NOOK, we have gone thru 2 new NOOKS with the same problem in the last 3 weeks. I took her there was a software problem and asked when it was going to be fixed and are they going to make a RE-CALL on THE NEW NOOK. She put me on hold for about 4 min. and came back and said they don't know yet when the software problem is going to be fixed, I stopped her and said "then you do admit there is a software problem with THE NEW KOONS" she responded I guess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and I have it recorded
We are getting a FULL REFUND, they don't work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And B&N admits to it.
Unlike the author, I use the keyboard quite a lot, and the Kindle allows one to simply start typing from whereever you are at. Reading a book and want to refresh one's memory about a character...just start typing. Shopping and want to see all of an author's offerings...just start typing.
Although the Nook is shorter and about 1 ounce lighter, it is also wider and thicker than the Kindle.
But the biggest issue is no 3G. For me, that's a dealbreaker.
@dprozzo The problem of freezing on THE NEW KOOK; I just got done talking to a supervisor today with B&N named Audrey about the problem with THE NEW NOOK, we have gone thru 2 new NOOKS with the same problem in the last 3 weeks. I took her there was a software problem and asked when it was going to be fixed and are they going to make a RE-CALL on THE NEW NOOK. She put me on hold for about 4 min. and came back and said they don't know yet when the software problem is going to be fixed, I stopped her and said "then you do admit there is a software problem with THE NEW KOONS" she responded I guess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and I have it recorded
We are getting a FULL REFUND, they don't work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And B&N admits to it.
0 Votes
+ -
re: blakepedersen
blakepedersen 29th Dec
Scarborough Ontario Canada forms the eastern part of the city of Toronto, Canada. It was named for it's resemblance to the white cliffs in England. http://www.scarboroughhouses.ca/

Scrapbooking is known to be a popular hobby that is growing fast today. It is a mixture of photos, memorabilia and stories created in a scrapbook style album. http://www.scrapbookingideas.ca/

Imagine being able to actually see all the features of a potential house you wish to buy without dealing with the headaches of talking to a realtor or even traveling to the house to walk through it. http://www.seehouses.ca/
The Nook is good as long as you don't have to read it in the sun or bright day light. Try to read it in broad day light and you'll struggle to see anything on that screen.
@edifeldman Er, what? It's an eInk display, you can see fine in the daylight. You must be thinking of the nook COLOR, which uses an LCD.
@Aerowind From what I understand one can change the screen to the "night" setting on the Nook Color and be able to read in full sunlight - I have yet to test this but on my beach trip in a couple of weeks I'll see for myself if this works...
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Wrong, it is even better in full sunlight
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 1st Jul
@edifeldman This new Nook looks FANTASTIC in full sun and is perfect for taking to the beach this summer.
@edifeldman
You have OBVIOUSLY never used a Nook, or any EInk reader for that matter.
0 Votes
+ -
Some questions
wolf_z 1st Jul
How easy is it to transfer books from your original Nook to the new one? I'm talking about DRM'ed books, not ones from places like Project Gutenburg.

Second, how does the screen size of the new one compare to the screen size of the old one? I get the Pearl part (which is *nice*) but what about the actual screen real-estate? My eyes aren't what they were so I use a larger font, which already increases my page turns.

Also, do you have to swipe or does the bezel still have page turn buttons?
@wolf_z The problem of freezing on THE NEW KOOK; I just got done talking to a supervisor today with B&N named Audrey about the problem with THE NEW NOOK, we have gone thru 2 new NOOKS with the same problem in the last 3 weeks. I took her there was a software problem and asked when it was going to be fixed and are they going to make a RE-CALL on THE NEW NOOK. She put me on hold for about 4 min. and came back and said they don't know yet when the software problem is going to be fixed, I stopped her and said "then you do admit there is a software problem with THE NEW KOONS" she responded I guess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and I have it recorded
We are getting a FULL REFUND, they don't work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And B&N admits to it.
Have you even looked at the new Kobo Touch?
It's hard to beat.....
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Not yet, but I will try to get one soon
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) Updated - 1st Jul
@drmawyer@... I like the original Kobo and am sure the Kobo Touch will be a good alternative too. The specs look the same with a slightly lighter weight and lower price on the Kobo Touch. I may have to call a new winner happy
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)

I've picked up a Kobo Touch to replace my original Kobo. Slightly smaller and lighter than the Nook Touch (6.5 x 4.5 x .4, 7.05 ounces). Same Pearl display which I find doesn't look much better on text but does look better on the book covers and illustrations. Same ability to set the full display refresh delay which does speed up page turns on the average.

I've noticed some issues with the touch screen and books that were not from the Kobo bookstore. Some of the issues disappeared after I ran the problem books through Sigil and cleaned up the errors that the FlightCrew validator located.

I can't speak to using the Pearl screen in bright sunlight but I'm almost certain Vancouver will have a sunny weekend in the next month or two.

In Vancouver, you don't tan, you rust.
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) The problem of freezing on THE NEW KOOK; I just got done talking to a supervisor today with B&N named Audrey about the problem with THE NEW NOOK, we have gone thru 2 new NOOKS with the same problem in the last 3 weeks. I took her there was a software problem and asked when it was going to be fixed and are they going to make a RE-CALL on THE NEW NOOK. She put me on hold for about 4 min. and came back and said they don't know yet when the software problem is going to be fixed, I stopped her and said "then you do admit there is a software problem with THE NEW KOONS" she responded I guess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and I have it recorded
We are getting a FULL REFUND, they don't work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And B&N admits to it.
Good review, except for the last item about the number of books available at B&N and Amazon. B&N counts public domain titles in their count, Amazon does not. So B&N's number is actually meaningless.
0 Votes
+ -
So?
wolf_z 1st Jul
@srichard3817

Why do public domain titles render the numbers meaningless? A lot of really good books are in the public domain you know. happy
0 Votes
+ -
@wolf_z The comment was about the fact that it is an unfair comparison in terms of numbers of books, if one bookstore counts the public domain ones and the other doesn't. Amazon has massive numbers of public domain books too (probably the same ones!), so a fair comparison would show either just priced books, or priced+public books for both stores.
I would add that the choice of an ereader depends also on the overall "ecosystem" of the provider of the ebooks. Amazon consistently has more popular titles available (as well as more books for sale than B&N), and also searching for new books to sample is much easier on Amazon's website. They have much better systems in place to suggest titles that I might be interested in, a better system for ranking books, and a more robust community of reviewers that give feedback on the books they sell. I would much rather shop for ebooks on Amazon than Barnes and Noble.
@srichard3817 The problem of freezing on THE NEW KOOK; I just got done talking to a supervisor today with B&N named Audrey about the problem with THE NEW NOOK, we have gone thru 2 new NOOKS with the same problem in the last 3 weeks. I took her there was a software problem and asked when it was going to be fixed and are they going to make a RE-CALL on THE NEW NOOK. She put me on hold for about 4 min. and came back and said they don't know yet when the software problem is going to be fixed, I stopped her and said "then you do admit there is a software problem with THE NEW KOONS" she responded I guess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and I have it recorded
We are getting a FULL REFUND, they don't work !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! And B&N admits to it.
My wife & I are in a book club. I don't want to pay for two e-books, one for her iPad and one for my Nook [which I don't have yet]. How do I pay only once and yet both of us can read it at our leisure on our own device of choice? Thanks.
@spaine
Use amazon and Kindle. Use a single account and both have access to books. Can sync books on up to 6 devices.
@Redhooker
Don't know enought about ereaders to understand. Are you saying not to use the Nook, but get a Kindle instead and both of us have a single Amazon acct?
@spaine You create an account with B&N - and that is what you register your Nook to. You would then have the Nook App on your iPad and register that to the same account. Then any purchases you make onto that account are mirrored onto both devices. It is the same with Amazon: your account is valid on up to six devices. So you can also register your Nook App on your computer and your smartphone, etc....
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Just login with the same account
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 1st Jul
@spaine You can simple setup one account and login and download books from multiple devices. I have the Nook app on my iPad and Android phones and download my library on each with no problem. I am not sure what the limit is on devices, but I haven't hit it yet and use quite a few.
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) No offense, not trying to dissuade anyone, but the entire discussion above is precisely WHY I will never get an eReader or even get sucked into eReader apps. The fact that you have to sit there and consider "how many devices" you can use is appalling.

eBooks are a boon... for publishers. It takes a fraction of the cost of printing traditional books, then they turn around and sell them, with DRM, for the same price as they do their paper counterparts that actually require materials, labor, shipping, et cetera. They are completely manipulating market economics instead of passing off the reduced cost to the customer. And then, once you have your book, you have to make sure you have devices registered properly, make sure you have your account in good standing, and then when you're done with it you get one choice: save it or delete it. No other option. Can't donate it to a library, can't resell it, can't share it without extreme limitations.

They market it as a convenience and it most assuredly is: A convenience for THEM. They ditch almost all of the factors of production then charge you as if they still existed, all while destroying your Fair Use and First Sale Doctrine rights.

Such convenience!
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Ha, you sound just like my daughter
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 1st Jul
@Captiosus My oldest daughter is an avid book reader and feels the same way. She shuns me when she sees me reading on my ebook reader. As a commuter and frequent business traveler, ebook readers are awesome and convenient for me. I understand the concerns with DRM and limits, but I have learned to just accept them in my life.

I do think ebooks should be a lot cheaper, but as an author I understand writers get dirt for their efforts so I don't mind paying a bit.
@Captiosus
That's why so far I have limited my eBook experience to books with no DRM that I can use wherever I want. I buy the new books I want in paper form generally, but there are a lot of older or less famous books available without DRM attached.

I haven't gotten a dedicated eReader to this point. I've been looking over the PocketBook eReaders a bit recently. They don't have Pearl screens yet, but they have lots of flexibility for book format, and you don't have to sign up for an account to use one.
@spaine install the nook/B&N reader app on your iPad.
0 Votes
+ -
it is just the way that Barnes and Noble does their accounting. Barnes and Noble counts all of the Public Domain books in their totals but Amazon does not count Public Domain books in their totals. I have not found any book on Barnes and Noble that was not available at Amazon!
@lichmd Call me "old," but to answer the question, " how does a dedicated e-reader interfere with the evolution of e-books into multimedia experiences?" It doesn't. My iPad is a "viewer" and this is a "reader." I view a video, I read a book. I hope they evolve in parallel, just as my physical bookshelf and DVD player do.
0 Votes
+ -
With a Kindle I can purchase books anywhere in the world. You can only use a US server to purchase B&N books. I don't need the hastle of using a VPN every time I travel outside the US to buy or download content!
@rjsarles
Could you elaborate further on that? I have no e-book experience,but am thinking seriously of purchasing one for my wife and I.Living in France,we no longer have access to the local library.
You did not state that when the battery dies and will not charge that unless its under warrenty you might as well pitch it in the trash because you have to buy a new one.
@brelove2@... Given how absurdly long even one charge lasts, I think you can afford a new one.
@Aerowind It doesn't matter how long a charge lasts! One of the L-ion battery negatives is that--even sitting on a shelf unused--life span is only about 3-3.5 years, though some newer types are pushing that up.
I never comment on these things but the Kobo Touch edition is great much like the Nook and it is only $129. It is attached to borders.com which could be problematic in the future but Kobo also seems to be able to stand alone. I am not saying that the Kobo is better than the Nook but you should look at both.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
Thanks, I will try to take a look at it too
palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) 1st Jul
@cdaveygo The Kobo Touch does look very similar to this new Nook and is lighter. I would like to test the page turn speeds since it looks like everything else is the same. Nice to see choices like these at fairly low prices too.
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller)

I understand the Kobo Touch also supports a few more file formats than the New Nook.
A basic question from a newbie kindle user, with no previous e-reading. Can one transfer the amz (or whatever the designation) files to Nook, or vice-versa? Or is each dedicated only to its base company?
@jpm007 You can if you use a conversion program like calibre and convert the AMZ to ePub (or vice versa) files. I have a Nook Color and converted a few ebooks I bought on Amazon to ePub using calibre.
Hmmm, I own a Kindle with 3G and wi-fi (free too). I agree with you in that I rarely use the keyboard and it may be a waste of space. A color screen would be nice but the Kindle's screen is good. Although it is hard to see if sunlight or any bright light shines on it. As for book choices; as many people have pointed out; B&N counts public domain books whereas Amazon does not. Besides, I have never been at a point where I can't find what I want to read on Amazon. And, at this point after being with Amazon for about a year or so now, I would be a bit nervous about attempting to transfer my library of books over to B&N. So, I think I'll stick with my Kindle for now. But may check later iterations of the Nook when it comes time to get a new ereader. I do like the idea of them in that they are a more eco-friendly way of reading.
@rickhal "I do like the idea of them in that they are a more eco-friendly way of reading."

No disrespect but I can't believe anyone buys into this.

Plastic, silicon, solder, and lithium-ion batteries which all require a lot of energy (not to mention petroleum) to create and will eventually end up contributing to our growing tech "trash" problem is more eco-friendly than a renewable resource like paper? Paper can be recycled and reused, is biodegradable and most paper processing plants operate tree farms which replace trees that are cut for paper manufacturing.
I don't see how you can address the review without discussing the book service. How many services does it have access to? just 1? The biggest issue I have with e-readers is the cost of the book. They are no cheaper than buying the book in the book store. They get a massive reduction in distribution costs an I get the shaft. No thanks! They need to offer competition on the book service.
@nanderto Ebooks are cheaper than their paper versions.
Matt, there is a browser built in tot he Nook Touch. Lots of YouTube video out showing how to access and drive. Appears to be the same browser as found on the earlier Nooks.
0 Votes
+ -
Contributr
@mryanaz ... but I don't want a browser on my ebook reader. The experience is lame and I want a full ebook experience without distractions while reading.
@palmsolo (aka Matthew Miller) I have a Nook Color and so far having apps and the browser on the device does not distract me from reading... and they are pretty convenient to have there if I want to do a quick web search.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix
ie8 fix