ie8 fix

Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn’t fit all

By | April 16, 2011, 8:55am PDT

Summary: Mobile technology, smartphones in particular, are very personal devices. The fact of the matter is that no matter how personal these phones become, there is no perfect device nor platform for everyone.

Mobile technology, smartphones in particular, are very personal devices. I suspect it’s because anything used repeatedly during the day, up close at that, invokes a very personal experience. The personal nature of smartphones is evident in any article on the web dealing with one phone or another. The comment section for such articles immediately becomes a shouting match over which platform is best. The fact of the matter is that no matter how personal these phones become, there is no perfect device nor platform for everyone.

Everybody uses smartphones differently, and how they use them determines which platform or phone is the best fit for them. Some folks primarily use smartphones for phone calls, if you can believe that. For those folks the smartphones that don’t do voice calls well, and there are more of those than there should be, don’t qualify as a good fit. It doesn’t matter how fancy a phone/platform may be, if the basic needs of the individual user aren’t being met then they fall short.

Case in point: my 17-year old stepson, a typical teenager in every respect, a kid who loves gadgetry, uses an old Nokia smartphone (I forget which one) by choice. He is in the unusual position of getting early exposure to nearly every top-of-the-line smartphone that comes into my office, and he is duly impressed by many of them. But when it comes to his choice of smartphone for everyday use, the old Nokia wins hands-down. Why is that? According to him because it does phone calls and text messaging very well. Those are his top two uses for a phone, and all of the fancy smartphones he’s tried fall short compared to that Nokia with its nice keyboard.

It is important for each individual to understand what uses of a phone are important to fit their lifestyle, and go with that no matter how public pressure tells them otherwise. It doesn’t matter if a particular smartphone is cool, or has state-of-the-art features; it only matters if it does what you need, and does it well.

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long.

Disclosure

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has no affiliations or relationships that need to be disclosed.

Biography

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long. Prior to joining ZDNet, James was the Founding Editor of jkOnTheRun, a CNET Top 100 Tech Blog that was acquired by GigaOM in 2008 and is now part of that prestigious tech network. James' writing has appeared in many print publications: Smartphone and Pocket PC Magazine, Information Week and Laptop Magazine to name a few. James' coverage of the mobile technology sector has regularly appeared in the New York Times, Salon.com and CNN/ Fortune online. Not just a writer, James has filmed numerous video reviews and how-tos that have garnered well over a million viewers. He has appeared on local news segments and been interviewed by the Associated Press on mobile technology topics. Additionally, James has been podcasting about mobile technology for years.

26
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn't fit all
FAULKNE 13th Oct
Good day to confirm this comment I would appreciate T h e b e s t o f Z D N e t d e l i v e r e d your website very nice to everyone Yes, Oracle is the only one with shared-disk architecture, but that is there advantage. It means you can add or remove nodes and the database lives on. In a shared nothing architecture, if you lose a node, you lose the system. I'm sure Oracle appreciates EMC highlighting their advantage.I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate Awesome post! Thank you very much || thanks for nice content this is really benefit to me.
My first smartphone was for work about 6 years ago when they were just hitting the market. We went through several platforms and manufacturers so I was exposed to many. The ones I like best have a physical keyboard as I tend to use my smartphone for alot of email, text, forums (using it now for this post), facebook, twitter etc. I have tried several platforms that are just touchscreen, but I just don't like that format. So when the original Motorola Droid came out I got it on launch day. Upgraded to the Droid 2 Global when it came out too. Really like this phone, it does everything well for me. Can't wait for the Droid 3. Just hope its 4G!
0 Votes
+ -
@tgschmidt

That goes for me to - very pleased with my Desire Z. Phone calls and texting are what I do most of so a proper qwerty keyboard and decent call quality are a must for my personal needs. I like having a touch screen but I would not wish to be dependent on one, hence phones like iPhone, Galaxy S, Desire HD, Mozart etc. would simply be no good for me - without my being in any way "tribal" in my attitudes towards iOS, Android or WP 7.
@FrederickLeeson

It is indeed refreshing to read an article where one device is not touted as "the best" and where the author understands that personal needs and usage styles are the primary consideration when deciding on which device to purchase. Well done!
0 Votes
+ -
True indeed
Economister 16th Apr 2011
And you can extend that to desktops, notebooks, netbooks, tablets or whatever. If it does what you need it to do, and does it well, you have found the right device for you. And that is the only thing that matters.

And all the fan boys can just shut up and go home.
Annoyance..... the picture of the smartphones is lame.
Show a real lineup including a large screen Android device or Windows device.....

Outside you are so right.
example: my daughter has an older iphone I gave her and while she likes the phone she prefers her old MotoQ because text/calls are her thing....
my son likes his Captivate better - it has swype and a bigger screen..

true - one size does not fit all happy
0 Votes
+ -
And "EVERY' smartphone is a compromise.
James Quinn 16th Apr 2011
It's just a matter of finding which set of compromises effects you personally the least negatively.

Pagan jim
Wow, what a refreshing breathe of fresh air. Now all you have to do is convince the other pundits of the fact that one size does not fit all.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn't fit all
Grayson Peddie Updated - 16th Apr 2011
To me, I like Windows Mobile (6.1, but wish I had 6.5) because of the ability to do Outlook sync. I primarily use my Pharos Traveler 619 for texting, but since it has Wi-Fi, it'd be nice to do Internet surfing, but not that much. Speaking of Outlook synchronizing, I like the fact that I can view tasks, calendar events, text messages, and any other things that I need, which is nice compared to that style of widgets in Android.

As for moving to Windows Phone 7, I really don't bother with that, even though Microsoft is taking a "one-size-fits-all" approach, which does not fit well with me, like not being able to side-load applications and a departure from Windows Mobile. Plus, I certainly don't like tiles, no matter how useful they are. So, I'd like to come to a conclusion that while Apple iPhone is more restrictive than Windows Phone 7, Windows Phone 7 is too restrictive for me.

If I want to go with Android, I'd rather have a very pure Android experience, which my first preference is Nexus S with a very large screen, but I'd like to have a slide-out keyboard with it; however, I can live with that. But if only I have the money to afford to buy the unlocked phone, as I spent about seventy dollars for Pharos Traveler 619 and that I'm using text message only service (400 message plan) from qwert (www.qwertcorp.com). Of course, I'll miss out in full Exchange sync capabilities, though, such as the ability to sync notes, tasks, and since I've tried the Android 2.1 emulator, I did miss out in folder hierarachy.

Anyway, that's it for smartphones. For mobile Internet capability, I use T-Mobile WebConnect 5GB Overage Free Plan with T-Mobile Rocket HSPA+ (I only get like HSDPA when I was in Orlando from Tallahassee, FL). I currently have Acer Aspire One AOA150 with Ubuntu 11.04 Beta 1 and I wiped out the Windows XP recovery partition. I'm currently holding on to my money and get a new tablet next year with AMD Fusion APU built-in (28nm manufacturing tech).

Oh, my first smartphone is an Alltel UTStarCom PPC-6700 Windows Mobile smartphone that I bought as of late 2005 and that platform is perfect for me, even before the pre-iPhone days. In my opinion, I still continue to like Windows Mobile more than Android. I really don't like manufacturers that stiffle my pure Android experience with custom themes and lots of crap in a smartphone. Call me an old folk, though. *sigh*
0 Votes
+ -
@Grayson Peddie

As someone who used Windows Mobile from the beginning on an O2 and after various updates to phones and to 6.5, I think I'd suggest you might reconsider WP7. My WP7 phone synchs with my Exchange server and all my outlook mail is there. Tiles are just better. It may take you a while to realise it, but having hubs and dynamic tiles work a whole lot better than a crowded desktop.

The only thing I miss from my Windows Mobile is the stylus and handwriting recognition, but for all other functions WP7 is vastly superior.
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn't fit all
Grayson Peddie Updated - 18th Apr 2011
@tonymcs@... Sure, if I can root a Windows Phone 7 phone and if I can replace the theme of Windows Phone 7 with Windows Mobile 6.5. Besides, I consider Windows Mobile 6.5 an upgrade from Windows Phone 7. I can try it as much as I can, but all I can say is that the graphical user interface is too bland for my taste.

I will wait for Windows Phone 8 with NO RESTRICTIONS WHATSOEVER FROM MICROSOFT (sorry for my yelling, but Windows Phone 7 is not like what Windows Mobile is all about...FREEDOM FROM RESTRICTIONS!!! happy Oh yes, I do cringe when I am suggested to get Windows Phone 7...restrictions, restrictions, restrictions... *sigh*
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn't fit all
Pete "athynz" Athens 16th Apr 2011
What? Are you out of your mind? EVERYONE knows iOSAndroidWP7 is the best and most perfect... the other guys all suck... /sarcasm and antifanboi rant.

Well written article! Well written indeed.
0 Votes
+ -
Are you out of your mind?
Economister 17th Apr 2011
@athynz

EVERYBODY knows that WebOS is the BEST wink
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Smartphone platform wars: One size doesn't fit all
rudraksha1 Updated - 17th Apr 2011
Smartphones have been an interesting gadget to be kept by anyone. There is true competition to retain customers. But still new things always make people like that.
http://www.ommrudraksha.com
0 Votes
+ -
Very good article and well written. Could you please update the picture with Original Palm, WP7 phone and WM6.5 phones also, then it would make it complete.
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
Return_of_the_jedi Updated - 19th Apr 2011
0 Votes
+ -
Message has been deleted.
Will Farrell Updated - 19th Apr 2011
  • Flagged
My first smartphone was the Motorola E680i. I loved it to death. It took the full size SD cards, had Real Player on it on top of a .ogg player I found for it. It had a AM/FM tuner, full touchscreen, and was built on a Linux OS. It was just an all around awesome phone, but eventually the batteries died out and didn't last very long. I still have the phone and it still works great!

After that I got my LG KF750 Secret (Slider phone). That thing was great. Carbon fiber backing, tempered glass, 5MP camera that took the best pictures, I haven't found a phone that takes better pictures of videos yet, plus a front facing camera, accelerometer, and even had an option to turn it into a full touch screen. Another wonderful phone that never saw distribution in this country.

After that I got my 3GS and my iPhone 4. I am hooked.
I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate! nccma cooler
I used to be more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post. this thread is amazing i like your work and i appreciate you that you have share a useful stuff thanks for sharing the i shop abatwa
I used to be more than happy to seek out this internet-site.I wanted to thanks in your time for this glorious read!! I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you weblog post.Bookmarking now thanks please consider a follow up post. power sa shop
I think the representation of this article is actually superb one. This is my first visit to your site. Thanks a lot and keep sharing the information. Keep updating the information for all of us. Thanks ZDNet Government was launched as the brand's first industry vertical, with a mission to cater to IT professionals in the public secto I agree with your post. However, do you have any sources I can cite for my paper wheel car com bury
Well welcome, hopefully you can become a vital member of the community and really help to push far ahead of google. Which Im sure the development team would love. This will of course earn you alot points too and get you on the leaders board. z d n e t t h a n k Im not sure i come to an agreement with you on every level, howevor it absolutely was a good posting, many thanks for taking the time to put up your ideas.
Thanks nice info z d n e t I really liked your current article write more..let me add you to its favorite The articles you have on zdnet s i t e are always so enjoyable to read. Good work and I bookmarked it.
Fantastic news about the new release.I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you b o o k m a r k e d to check out new stuff you weblog post.Im not sure i come to an agreement with you on every level, howevor it absolutely was a good posting, many thanks for taking the time to put up your ideas
Good day to confirm this comment I would appreciate T h e b e s t o f Z D N e t d e l i v e r e d your website very nice to everyone Yes, Oracle is the only one with shared-disk architecture, but that is there advantage. It means you can add or remove nodes and the database lives on. In a shared nothing architecture, if you lose a node, you lose the system. I'm sure Oracle appreciates EMC highlighting their advantage.I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. Thank you as soon as once again and maintain up the great operate Awesome post! Thank you very much || thanks for nice content this is really benefit to me.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix