ie8 fix
Click Here

Takeaway from the iPhone event: Solid phones, end of an era

By | October 4, 2011, 12:51pm PDT

Summary: The new iPhone 4S was announced today, and while a proper evolution of the smartphone from Apple, the event marked the end of an era.

The big Apple iPhone event went down in a lower key than usual, with new iPhones announced and Tim Cook taking over as Apple’s public front man. The presentation, which by all accounts was rather low-key, went off without a hitch as Cook ushered in both the next iPhone and a new era at Apple.

While the new iPhone line will surely set new sales records, the event was clearly the end of the era of exciting Steve Jobs presentations. It was an event that captivated millions as Apple launches tend to do, but with a very sad undertone that made it feel underwhelming at times, knowing that Jobs has for the most part left the building.

Folks are already bemoaning the new iPhone 4S as a disappointment, with little reason. While many hoped for a phone with a larger display, the fact is the current iPhone is the number one selling smartphone in the world. For Apple to greatly change it was not needed, instead an evolution of the iPhone was the proper avenue.

Sure there is a faster processor and better camera to update the technical specs of the iPhone 4S, but iPhone owners have never cared about that. They want the iPhone to do what they want nicely, and no doubt the iPhone 4S will serve their needs, better than the earlier model.

A bigger story on the iPhone line is the cheaper models that will appeal to new buyers. A $99 iPhone 4 is a big deal, and a free (on contract) iPhone 3G is huge. While Apple has enjoyed good sales numbers in the past, that will continue and likely grow given these cheap iPhones. The new iPhone 4S will do fine, and these older models will grab market share being vacated by RIM.

Another big story coming out of today’s event is the Siri software, the speech recognition technology that is integrated in the new iPhone. Featuring natural speech recognition, Siri is designed to make interaction with the iPhone 4S as easy as talking to the phone. While it remains to be seen how well this works in the real world, it has made the iPhone 4S the best handicapped-accessible smartphone on the planet. While the iPhone was already the best phone for the blind, the iPhone 4S just made the phone even better for them. This will revolutionize usage for the visually impaired, and in a big way.

The coming weeks will show how well Apple has nailed the market with these cheap iPhones and the new 4S. While some may bemoan the incremental update to the line, if it’s not broke don’t fix it. Expect to see iPhones flying off shelves as fast as ever, and probably in markets previously not substantial. Apple will continue to dominate the smartphone space for the foreseeable future, you can safely bet.

More:

Kick off your day with ZDNet's daily e-mail newsletter. It's the freshest tech news and opinion, served hot. Get it.

Topics

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long.

Disclosure

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has no affiliations or relationships that need to be disclosed.

Biography

James Kendrick

James Kendrick has been using mobile devices since they weighed 30 pounds, and has been sharing his insights on mobile technology for almost that long. Prior to joining ZDNet, James was the Founding Editor of jkOnTheRun, a CNET Top 100 Tech Blog that was acquired by GigaOM in 2008 and is now part of that prestigious tech network. James' writing has appeared in many print publications: Smartphone and Pocket PC Magazine, Information Week and Laptop Magazine to name a few. James' coverage of the mobile technology sector has regularly appeared in the New York Times, Salon.com and CNN/ Fortune online. Not just a writer, James has filmed numerous video reviews and how-tos that have garnered well over a million viewers. He has appeared on local news segments and been interviewed by the Associated Press on mobile technology topics. Additionally, James has been podcasting about mobile technology for years.

Related Discussions on TechRepublic

Did you know you can take part in these discussions with your ZDNet membership?
43
Comments

Join the conversation!

Just In

RE: Takeaway from the iPhone event: Solid phones, end of an era
maniashraf 27th Oct
Not sure that Siri is all that helpful for the blind, or at least the blind who might have foreign accents and/or know people that don't have standard Caucasian names. My mother hasn't been able to make a single successful call with Siri and the voice for Siri is different than that of the VoiceOver and often much lower. It also pronounces words differently than the VoiceOver - which just leads to confusion for someone who can't see. We're pretty disappointed so far, but hoping that maybe we're missing some trick to make it work better.
The Amazon fire has stolen the iPad's thunder from below. The Samsung Galaxy S IIs are stealing the iPhone thunder from above. Apple better up its game.
@chapelhillice Man you guys just spit it out. SG II does not have have iPhone sales. Fire hasn't been sold. I would like to see were you get hour number from. If you think apple will not sellypur sadly mistaken. Cheaper iPhone alone is going to put them so far ahead especially with the china mobile deal
@chapelhillice And the Kal-El phones aren't even here yet!
@chapelhillice
You're talking Apples and oranges. iPhone is a phone and you are comparing to tablets...
@chapelhillice Spoken like a true fandroid. BUT the Fire is not even in the wild yet and The Galaxy S II is stealing iPhone 4's thunder not iPhone 4S's... but don't let the facts spoil your attempt at FUD.
@Pete "athynz" Athens ... I'm certainly not interested in that.

I am interested in iPhones and iPads
0 Votes
+ -
RE: Takeaway from the iPhone event: Solid phones, end of an era
LoverockDavidson_-24231404894599612871915491754222 4th Oct
My takeaway was that was one boring event. A bunch of fudged numbers being thrown around and a disappointment of a new phone.
@LoverockDavidson_ I will agree that the event was boring overall but the iPhone 4 and Siri feature are super cool.

I know many people are disappointed because it wasn't re-designed but I love the horsepower underneath the phone.
@LoverockDavidson_
Point out and counter 1 fudged number.
@LoverockDavidson_ Yet even as a hater you watched it... Says something about where Apple is, doesn't it?
Windows Phone domination will start in 2012...
@owlnet
It does seem that Apple has upped their game, especially hardware-wise in exactly (one of?) the core area(s) where Nokia shines - the camera. I'll be interested to see how Sea Ray's photos compare to the new iPhone's.
@owlnet

Yep already has more integrated functions than Apple could dream of. Speech already works fine.
@chapelhillice
I was just checking out a Galaxy S II, What's so special about it? The screen is bigger and colors are over-saturated.. looks nice, but not much else.
@GSavage777: ... applications, has low resolution (yes, oversaturated, though bigger contrast due to SAMOLED+) display, worse, slower camera, lower battery life, less applications, no Siri, no Airplay, no iCloud; and it is plasticky.
@DeRSSS


I have to hand it to you ... you are one consistent cheerleader even if awfully transparent. A lot like Loverock but on the other side
@DeRSSS
First, I'm no Apple hater. I have a Macbook Air and an iMac. But I also have the Galaxy S II, and it's an awesome phone. I'm sure the new iPhone will be as well, but for screen size, battery life, speed, and--yes--voice commands, I'll take the S II.
About the "over-saturated" colors...you do know that there is a simple way to adjust that, don't you?
@GSavage777
The Galaxy S 2 is a Tamagotchi. It drives you insane.
http://www.mobilespoon.net/2011/08/android-is-just-like-tamagotchi.html
0 Votes
+ -
Resting on laurels...
daftkey 4th Oct
the fact is the current iPhone is the number one selling smartphone in the world. For Apple to greatly change it was not needed, instead an evolution of the iPhone was the proper avenue.

Here's an exercise for you: Change the date on your computer back to 2006, and re-write that same paragraph using "Blackberry" in place of "iPhone".

Then sit back and watch history repeat itself.
@daftkey

Except Apple is sitting back milking a "keyboard". Everyone is following Apple's lead, except trying to outspec them and how well is that strategy working?

Heck, unlike the entire mobile industry, Apple has made it easy and a no-brainer to upgrade your two year old phone to their newest operating system baby. Any can do it. For free. For a phone that came out in 2009.

No root. No pirate roms. All fully supported by the vendor.

When did RIM do this? When did anyone else?
@dhmccoy How about any Android phone? All you do is put in your SIM and it's automatic. Sorry, Apple failed and there is no getting around that.
@timspublic1@... I love it when misinformed fandroids try to spread FUD - it just warms the heart... LOL

How about any Android phone? All you do is put in your SIM and it's automatic.

LOL ANY Android based phone? Really? So then tell me WHY is it that there are still Android 2.1 and 2.3 devices being sold, why are the ones that came with 2.1 not able to be upgraded to 2.3 without a hack like they cyanogen mod?

Sorry, Apple failed and there is no getting around that.


How? By selling millions of devices and by being such a popular device it took an entire Android Army to outsell it? Please.
@dhmccoy - Windows Phone 7 Mango update. They don't go back two years, but they do go back more than 1. My arrive updated just find, fully supported with no root and no pirate roms. Granted they took their lead from Apple with the walled garden approach, but they did do it.
@daftkey Go back to 2006 and tell me when rim was making the money apple was doing or pushing out apples numbers.
0 Votes
+ -
That doesnfit
ThatIsMePetr 4th Oct
ow well Apple has nailed the market with these cheap iPhones
The Galaxy S2 is a lot better than iPhone 4S and that was released in April. It is effectively broken!

Siri is Apple's "Google Voice Me Too". Wow! So exciting.

iPhone 3G free! It better be, it's bloody old. Can you imagine Samsung, HTC or even RIM still trying to sell a phone that old as current?
Each year a new iPhone comes out, people come out saying it is a minor upgrade. I mean, without fail.

Yet, the 3GS guys are getting a great upgrade and it costs the same as the phone in there pocket. Or, they can sit back and upgrade just the iOS and see if that is enough.

Who else does this?
Don't worry Apple, at least you still have your health!
End of an era as Apple gives up high-end niche and goes after low-cost, old-generation mass-market. How do you keep your cache, your mystique, by pursuing the China market?

So now I take the $200 or so I budgeted for electronic toys this fall and go buy an Amazon Fire. And I am am looking to upgrade my iPhone with Android. No more, "Must have an Apple."
Something to think about... Apple seems to be out to change the world at least as much as they are out to win the market in any particular quarter. And what Apple just introduced follows the change their change the world strategy pretty well, while the world goes on trying to explain what they have done in tactical marketing terms.

What we saw Apple do today was primarily two things - if you are taking the "change the world" point of view. First, they used older models to expand their market coverage, enabling most anyone who can afford to support a smart phone to own an iPhone if they want. The second thing Apple did was to further differentiate their ecosystem, their view of what they think the world should change into, from the other products out there. With iCloud, Siri, Cards, and camera features, Apple has aimed, once again, to expand the definition of the phone. It isn't that they have done things that weren't available elsewhere. What they have done is to seamlessly incorporate these things into the experience we think of as the 'phone'.

If Apple succeeds in making more and more functionality part of what mainstream consumers think of as the 'phone' experience, they will continue to pull farther and farther ahead of their competition. And btw, if you don't think that functionality integration is what this is all about, just think back to when, just a very few years ago, talking was all you did on your phone...
@z2217 If Apple succeeds in making more and more functionality part of what mainstream consumers think of as the 'phone' experience, they will continue to pull farther and farther ahead of their competition.

The problem as I see it is that the iPhone has always been the "it's New, it's Amazing, ya just gotta have one of these magical high quality!" gadgets. With every new release, that would sell a lot of these phones. With the 4S, that's no longer the case. Most will see it as just another iPhone 4. The magic dust long since blown off, will get more consumers to see what else is available. Sure it's still a fine phone... but without the "WOW"... it's just another phone.
Watch that huge cash pile dwindle rapidly into more and more lawsuits. That seems to be the only thing Apple is capable of creating nowadays.
It has no physical buttons. It has no consistent menu structure that made sightless navigation possible. It has states where the entire content of the screen changes.

This is a TERRIBLE phone for the blind (and in fairness - the same can be said for all other touch-based smartphones).

Siri will definitely make it a better phone for blind people, but if it responds graphically, it had better have as good voice response (VoiceOver isn't that good).
0 Votes
+ -
Best for the blind?
han@... 4th Oct
Wait, what? A phone (mostly) without traditional keys on the outside is best for the blind? A pre-historic Nokia or Blackberry has buttons that you can actually feel when you want to dial a number or send a message!
@han@...

Yes and they will press all the wrong ones! Siri is revolutionary and truly is the best thing for the blind. In fact, it seems to be the most revolutionary phone feature in years!
Place your bet !!! Place your bet !!! How much unit these 4s will be sold in first month ? 1 million ? 10 million ? or 100.000 units ? or Apple to shame to announce it ?
I take the last one
@Voltus

I don't know the number... wouldn't want to guess. But I'd say plenty in the first month. 6 months down the road, probably not so much.
@Voltus

I am predicting instant sell out and shortages for the first 6 months or so due to high demand. Basically, you best pre-order the second it goes live on Friday or you may not get one...
" ...if its not broke dont fix it. Ah... The voice of mediocrity lives!! - And we thought Microsoft stymied innovation. Who knew?!
@The Rifleman

The only problem with your comment is that they DID fix it. In fact, it is almost a 100% new phone except for the outside case...
0 Votes
+ -
Apple's biggest mistake IMHO was the exclusive AT&T availability until this year. I liked the iPhone but must be on VZW so I went with Android in early 2010.

After using my Droid X for just a few months I decided it was better than the iPhone 4 based on battery life (the extra one in my pocket so I could hammer the phone all day with no worries about having to park the phone by an outlet), huge inexpensive SD card storage, excellent GPS, tethering, larger screen, hdmi output, fun with widgets, voice dialing and control, hardware buttons, alternative launchers and app parity. Now there are new Android phones coming out all the time with amazing screens, dual core processors in an array of form factors.

When the iPhone finally came to Verizon I wasn't interested in the least. I find it interesting that in our very busy local Verizon store there is almost no visibility for the iPhone.
Not sure that Siri is all that helpful for the blind, or at least the blind who might have foreign accents and/or know people that don't have standard Caucasian names. My mother hasn't been able to make a single successful call with Siri and the voice for Siri is different than that of the VoiceOver and often much lower. It also pronounces words differently than the VoiceOver - which just leads to confusion for someone who can't see. We're pretty disappointed so far, but hoping that maybe we're missing some trick to make it work better.

Join the conversation!

Formatting +
BB Codes - Note: HTML is not supported in forums
  • [b] Bold [/b]
  • [i] Italic [/i]
  • [u] Underline [/u]
  • [s] Strikethrough [/s]
  • [q] "Quote" [/q]
  • [ol][*] 1. Ordered List [/ol]
  • [ul][*] · Unordered List [/ul]
  • [pre] Preformat [/pre]
  • [quote] "Blockquote" [/quote]
ie8 fix

The best of ZDNet, delivered

ZDNet Newsletters

Get the best of ZDNet delivered straight to your inbox

Facebook Activity

White Papers, Webcasts, & Resources
ie8 fix